Katie Holmes or Nicole Kidman for Vogue?

katie holmes vs. nicole kidman

If you could chose one to be on the December cover of Vogue Magazine, would you pick Katie Holmes or Nicole Kidman?
It seems, according to Star, that Vogue can't make up their minds on who to put on the next cover!
Both ladies have new movies coming out; Katie is excited about her 1st movie in a long time, Mad Money, while Nicole will be promoting her next movie, The Golden Compass, in December ... so, who's a better candidate?
What story will Vogue have on Nicole Kidman? Let's face it, she has a slow life now, only making a couple of movies & nothing much going on in her personal life!

But Katie ... well, she's on a roll! Trips all over Europe, she's the mommy of one of the cutest kids in Hollywood & her new movie! Oh! One more thing, she's also the one married to Tom Cruise now!

If you could pick, would you choose Katie or Nicole?

Related Posts with Thumbnails
9 Comments
  1. Faci | September 4, 2007 4:54 PM

    I would choose Katie, for several reasons. Beauty, age and a lot more.

    Faci
  1. Margie | September 4, 2007 6:44 PM

    I would pick Nicole....she is beautiful, elegant, and classy. I would be more interested in anything concerning Nicole instead of Katie Holmes! Age has nothing to do with it. The last pictures I've seen of KH, well, she looked awful. She's trying too hard to imitate Posh Beckham!

    Margie
  1. Jack | September 5, 2007 12:39 AM

    They are both beautiful, intelligent and gifted but I'd go with Katie.

    Jack
  1. Fenvid | September 5, 2007 7:40 AM

    Katie has a face of a natural beauty... Her face is classic and she's not afraid to face the world. You can see her without makeup, no frills, and she's gorgeous especially how she managed to take care of Suri so beautiful.

    Fenvid
  1. Hey | September 5, 2007 7:56 AM

    I think they should choose Nicole, a talented, glamorous and timeless sign of beauty and success and with two of her films, "Margot at the Wedding" and "The Golden Compass" getting serious oscar buzz for her. It also seems that her films are much larger and will be far more heavily advertised. Sorry (not) but Nicole will be chosen over Katie. At any rate Nicole is friends with Anna Wintour

    Hey
  1. Disgusted | September 5, 2007 4:24 PM

    It's disgusting that you're implying that Nicole's adopted daughter Isabella is unattractive.

    Disgusted
  1. Snacks | September 5, 2007 7:19 PM

    Nicole actually has many more decent movies under her belt--she's won an Oscar and is more of a star in her own right. Katie was starting to develop her own career but isn't really there yet.

    Snacks
  1. Rainmanshoe | September 5, 2007 11:51 PM

    Of Course Nicole.... When Nicole became a shinning star.... hello, where is Katie??? Maybe still in her diaper. Nicole is successful at her own right and KH is only been notice after she left her poor boy (Chris Klein) to marry TC. And for God Sake, if Vogue can't find anything to write about Nicole, they should write themselves off.

    Rainmanshoe
  1. Cole | September 10, 2007 7:31 AM

    Nicole. She has more essence. She has proven a lot after the Tom Cruise era, and i think it is more "intelligent" to have Nicole in Vogue than Katie who will only talk about her travel with TC, Tom Cruise, her house with TC, kid with TC, etc...all about Tom Cruise. Enough.

    Cole

 
« Who's The Beach Babe? | Main | The New Paris Hilton in ELLE UK »