Hasan Kharbash Leaves Arab Idol
Although last night's results episode of Arab Idol saw the departure of Tunisian contestant Hasan Kharbash, the night was a fun one filled with laughter and joy.
Hasan, who was known for his smile throughout the program, bid his friends farewell with a few tears and a lot of smiles.
He received the least number of votes after Friday's prime and was in the danger of zone along with Saudi Mohammad and Syrian Nadia.
The judging panel was divided as to whether the "save card" should go to Hasan or not; Both Ahlam and Hasan Al Shafii thought the card was better left for one of the remaining 5 finalists, but Ragheb Alamah felt that Hasan deserved it.
What do you think? Does Hasan deserve to leave at this point?
Should have Ahlam and Hasan given him the "save card" ?
Archived Comments ↓ Post a New Comment →
-
ya we are indeed sorry for hassan to leave. the probleme is in hassan shafii. he is really the biggest racist i have ever seen in my life. you can noticed that when he flatters carmen so much and when it comes to dounia he says nearly nothing.
-
You are absolutly right, but should not use the word "racist" ... Al Shafee is like almost all Egyptians - a bloody chauvinist ! Because of his overblown nationalism he's ready to sacrifice even his profesionalism and appear just as an average, dumb, prejudiced judge. He would never consider using the card for a Tunisian, or hardly anyone else. Actually these judges are rediculous; the worst in any show. The starac eliminations often look as cheating, but at least they are straightforward and there are no "judges" !
-
Nawal,
Bare in mind that Hassan did not choose Yehia when he was in the danger zone.
There is no need to generalize and say all EGYPTIANS..
-
I was about to say the same thing, why are you generalizing????
Tomorrow, two will be eliminated so it is best to use the card tomorrow, it is not his fault that people didn't vote enough for Hassan. The rest are better singers, but I wish the best for all of them.
-
Sallam.firstly it's impossible that nadia have vote more than hassan
secondly ahlem hate hassan and she did all her possibilities for geting hassan out
thirdly HASSAN stay for us the best because he is the only one who has a character ;a presentation and a spirit of a profitional artist adding to the sweatable voice
-
@ Shaza & Lebanon :
I did not say "all" but "almost all" = most of them; which is true. Lebanese are often attacked for their patriotism, but that is like the cat's whiskers when compared to the Egyptian national phanaticism !
You are right, Hassan did not choose Yehia ... but, I was refering to the Al Shafee's open chauvinism as the "judge" - as fatine sayed has noticed. Actually, all three are miserable as the judges. At first I thought the Najm al Khaleej judges were not good enough; and now, in comparison with these clowns, they seem to be great ! These are the worst pseudo judges that have been seen in any show of this kind ! This whole program is mediocre. The MBC has never been able to put out any descent music show - for instance, like the LBC. The starac primes have become really very good and in the absence of the SuperStar, the Starac remains the best show.
-
Ok u can't really call Hassan al Shafai racist. He just happens to lean towards people from his area of the middle east like Carman whose from Masr like him and Donya whose from the Meghrib. So maybe he's not the best but at least he's way better than Ahlam. That woman is lost! To me, Ragheb is the best judge and then comes Hassan and then Ahlam.
-
all what I can say that I will miss u hassan and I miss starac alot as it is better than arab idol million time.I miss waleg summary about the dailes and our comments and conversations about the candidates.
DO YOU THINK THAT STARAC IS BETTER THAN ARAB IDOL ???
Rawan
Feb 26, 2012
I love Hassan! I felt so bad when he left. Ahlam and Hassan al shafai were stupid not to use the save me card because Carman and Donya are already too good to ever be people with the lowest number of votes so they should've used the card on someone who is still good but has a weaker voice. Ragheb was right to use the save me card! And for that I love him too. I'm sorry Hassan! Don't worry to me you'll always be the best!!!