Did Tamer Hosny Steal 'Bent El Eh'?


mohammad al jibali tamer hosny

Tunisian singer Mohammad Al Jibali accused Tamer Hosny of stealing his song 'Ben El Eh'!
Al Jibali says that the song is in his album 'Yezzini' under the same title and with slightly different lyrics.

Al Jibali didn't go too far with the case because he says he's beyond such trivialities and wouldn't stoop low to make a big deal out of it.

I wonder what Tamer Hosny has to say about this!

What do you think?

20 Comments
  1. Heba [ EGYPT ] | May 12, 2009 12:08 PM | Reply

    Um. tamer hosny's song " bent el eih " is one year old now or more than one year old. why did he notice that now ?

    Heba [ EGYPT ]
  1. faroo7a | May 12, 2009 1:30 PM | Reply

    hell no. tamer does not need his songs nor does he need to steal them. song producers throw songs at him

    faroo7a
  1. ahmed | May 12, 2009 3:38 PM | Reply

    he have no word only steal Mohammad song what a pathetic Tamer is.

    I hope the Swallow eat him the tamer Elf.

    ahmed
  1. Yunis | May 12, 2009 3:52 PM | Reply

    But bint el eih tamer's song was one of the biggest hit in his songs. We know he is talented but we have to listen to the acusers song first before we decide. so please send us the song first.

    Yunis
  1. Mega | May 12, 2009 4:30 PM | Reply

    Possible. The song isn't really the perfect egyptian type, but what's the heck to wake up a year later to say it ?

    Mega
  1. sara | May 12, 2009 8:28 PM | Reply

    How could Tamer have stolen it, wasnt ya bent el ey from Tamers album that he writ in jail?! Plus y didnt this guy come forward before? Unless that guy was at the same jail as Tamer Hosny then I dont believe it

    sara
  1. ahmed | May 12, 2009 9:58 PM | Reply

    why don't you beileve it Sara?

    he did steal it. who you waiting to tell you. So, when he was in jail he only cleaning the flour and mesah the toilet not writing believe me that person is not true singer and a crap cleaner custodian.

    he should singing about the mop and the floor of how to clean!

    ahmed
  1. sara | May 12, 2009 11:10 PM | Reply

    LOl ok Ahmed and how do you know he stole it, what evidence do you have? Lets say he did steal it, why is the guy Mohamed that says its originally his jus saying now, if I wrote a song and find out someone else took it then Id go mad and naturally anyone would if you find out someone else took credit for your work!

    sara
  1. MASRI | May 12, 2009 11:16 PM | Reply

    People, please we must learn to be respectful to any singer even if we aren't their biggest fans.

    I mean, I'm not a huge fan of Tamer Hosny and I don't have much respect for him, but I can't say he stole it until I actually hear this other guys song and judge.

    But, I don't believe Tamer would have stole the song anyways. If we can get a link to the song, we can judge. But not from the words of a guy with no proof so far.

    Thank you.

    MASRI
  1. Hy-aah | May 13, 2009 12:35 AM | Reply

    I've listened to Mohamed's song... and, wow there isn't any similarity with Tamer's song !

    if u want to listen to mohamed' song, type on Dailymotion ' Jbali yezzini' ...

    Hy-aah
  1. Mariam | May 13, 2009 1:26 AM | Reply

    stupid accusations....im not a fan of Tamer but i hate it when people start these lame arguments..who cares if he has a similar song..its past and it already happened...........

    Mariam
  1. wadsou | May 13, 2009 12:25 PM | Reply

    some people on this form, have no respect whatsoever. If you think that you can write a better song, or mop the floor any better in jail then tamer, then go ahead.

    just remember, for everytime you say and do something bad to another, it will come back and hit you 3 times as hard.

    tamer has written, sung and composed all these songs, i don't think that he needs the song of a jealous nobody to steal to make a hit.

    wadsou
  1. khouloud | May 13, 2009 12:43 PM | Reply

    ppl mohammed talked about this years ago but whoever wrote this article is the one who woke up late so tamer possibely stole the title not the song

    khouloud
  1. ahmed | May 13, 2009 4:17 PM | Reply

    look who's written its wadso al will hit me 3 times hard. who will hit me is it you?.
    please pay attention and I will knock you're as hard until you get dizzy. Samer is harmful person cause he's been to jail. in that case he's only a bathroom cleaner. the only legend man is Malcolm X. when he was in Jail in 60's he read the Quran and learn Arabic during jail time.
    so Samer nothing he did... he's ignorant.

    ahmed
  1. nana | May 13, 2009 5:08 PM | Reply

    Tamer is not waiting for his words he is bigger than that!!!!

    nana
  1. MASRI | May 13, 2009 9:05 PM | Reply

    Actually Malcolm X was reading books about the Nation of Islam, not the Quran. Their is a HUGE difference between Islam and the Nation of Islam, Ahmed.

    Plus...what does this have to do with anything? And whats with your toilet obsession?

    MASRI
  1. hazem | May 14, 2009 5:07 AM | Reply

    who ever wrote this article has nothing to do in their life. The album is 2 years old and this has been discussed 2 years ago when the song came out and it was proven that its tamers song. Plus your speaking about tamer hosny here.... the most successful arabic singer today, you really think he would steal a song? come on.

    hazem
  1. wafa | May 14, 2009 4:13 PM | Reply

    i beleive mohamed el jbali. he is a very respectable singer and i'm sure that he is not lying.

    wafa
  1. wadsou | May 14, 2009 10:18 PM | Reply

    obviously ahmed you don't understand cliches very well. nobody is going to hit you, and i would certainly not waste my time on you, who are you in the first place.

    what i think is that you should go and do something more constructive then sit here and critise people.

    wadsou
  1. sandra | May 16, 2009 11:54 AM | Reply

    now 1 talk about tamer my lovar his the bestt

    sandra
Leave a comment




Get an icon next to your name by signing up for a free Gravatar



 
« Guess Who -53- | Main | Exclusive Photos From Roberto Cavalli Club Opening in Dubai »