star academy 2 was the worst yet...I hated that season. Then its star ac5, then 4, then 1 and 3 are tied for the best!!! I loved fady, joseph and bashar from S1.
Overall the show has become more of a dating show which is annoying. In the first season they would sit around in their pyjama's all day and now they sit and put on 6 pounds of make-up before anyone sees them...as if they forget that we can see them put on the make-up and we know that it is not natural. The worst part is that they look awful with all that make-up!

I couldn't agree more with you June about the makeup thing and the boring stupid dating drama stories .. ewewew ...

As for the worst season, i think its 2 and 5
the best are 1 and 4

so are w. june and cupcake and 4 me its the exact order:
star ac 2 was the wrost
then star ac 5
then star ac 4
and the 2 that tie equaly are star ac 3 and 1
star ac 3 had the students who u truely felt that there were friends and that they cared 4 each other.khalifah was funi. fadi was cute so was hany...joseph chayma,rakiya.maya hana, the al wer amazing and had amazing personalities as well.
star ac 1 had mohamad atieya who wasnt the best singer in the univers but was the funiest one of al the years and was a great actor
star ac 2 was so boring the only thing i noe of it is a saudi guy won and made dumb shows

Star academy 2 was the worst
best seasons are 1 & 4

STAR 2 AND 5 sooo much

next year the answer for this question will be starac 6 cos season after season it will more boring more kisses n hugs more unfairness towards students
so be prepared

If it was about talent...

5 - best
4
2
3
1 - worst

Other things...

2 - best
3
4
1
5 - worst

Star academy 2 was the worst, it was very boring, the est Star academy ever was 1 & then 3,4 & 5.

in my opinion staracademy 4 was the worst and it was realy boring.and the best is staracademy3 .

starac 5 is the worst with no competitor and starac 1 is th e best without thinking

i dont know why many ppl hated starac 2 although i loved it and enjoyed zizi katia .... maybe its problem was the assasination of El Hariry which made things terrible unstable and the live coverage was cute for over a week but overall it was a nice season but 5 is the worst i hated it

starac 2 was boooooooring the students were so dry!!!
the best to watch were 3 & 4......they were funny and entertaining.
the best voices were 4 & 5.

In the past 5 years and in allll the years to comee !! There will be no star academy ebtter than Star Academy oNe !!
no competition ..
everything was spontanuous .. Atteya and Bachar were HiLaRiOuS !! ahmed was amazing .. Sophias relationship with Bachar was real. Everyth was just naturally entertaining

and btw. dont put ur hopes up on 6 .. unless there is major changes

I think most of us will agree that Star Academy 1 was the BEST!!! It was a great group in general

I agree Ashmy...Star Academy ONE was the BEST one...in general it was an AMAZING group. They were funny and down to earth...I dont remember there being so much drama like the others. They also had the best voices too.

in my idea staracademy 4 was the worst one.i love staracademy 3 & 5, b/c of NADER MIRHAN REEM WAJDI.

i think that starac 2 was the worst there voices were bad and everything. i dont think that starac 1 was the best i think that 3 was the best and i like starac 5 i dont know y u dont like it.

i think star academy 1 was best and the rest was sh^t full stop. each year it gets worser and i think 4 was so sh^t and i aint talking about the winners coz some people seem they are saying its shit coz of the winner i hate hisham but 2nd season was better then seaseon 4 and 5 any day.

I LOVEDD ALL SEASONSSS !!

I LOVE STAR ACADEMY 1
becuz of mohammed attiya - bashar - sophia - ahmed al sherif

I LOVE STAR ACADEMY 2
becuz of bashar gazawi - zizi - kind of hisham

I LOVE STAR ACADEMY 3
becuz of joseph - hany - fady - chayma - maya - hanaa - rym - wajdii - khalifa

I LOVE STAR ACADEMY 4
becuz of tina - ahmed - mohammed k - marwa - emad - ali - sally - carlo

I LOVE STAR ACADEMY 5
becuz of nader - mirhan - saad - zaher - mustapha - abdulla - adnan - dia - amal b - amal m - chahinaz

SOO DO U SEE EVERY SEASON HAS SOMETHING SPECIAL AND NICE THAT MAKES YOU WANT TO WATCH IT !

and for me i like the people in star academy 5 moree

ALL STAR ACADEMY ROCKSS !!!

Because in the past years we had many doubts about what was going behind the screen and cutains in staracademy , this year ( the 5th year) we were able to know most of the dirty tricks in staracademy >>

why some are nominated and why others arent nominated ... that many things are planned in advance, regardless who you vote for >>

Mr. Fouad & Mm Roula proved without any doubt that this program isnt about who wins, its about how much money they make use of public emotions of students , whereby Rula decides how the acting should be >>>inorder to get the most votes ..

its beyond any doubts , that its one of the cheapests programs with the dirtiest style

I can't honestly vote in this poll.. I believe that each Star Academy Season had that special thing that attracted ppl 2 watch..
Roula Saad had always been smart enough when it comes 2 choosing the candidates.. She chooses the ppl who have talent, voice, personality & humor..!
Like this what makes each season unique:
Star Academy 1:
Most Natural, most funny.. Mohamed Attieh had been the 100% Egyptian with the sense of humor, Bashar who will always b my favorite kuwaiti in Star Academy, Sofia (The sweetie), Cynthia, Bahaa.. They were amazing!
Star Academy 2:
I liked Zizi, Katia, Samer♥, Salma & Bashar who were so natural when it came 2 their love relationship..
Star Academy 3:
That was was the greatest.. I loved Fady,Hany,Maya,Khalifah,Rakya,Joseph,
Reem,Wajdi,Bahaa.. They simply defined true friendship 4 me.. All those funny moments & crazy stufff they did .!♥
Star Academy 4:
I liked Tina, Marwa,Ahmed, Sally, Kammah.. I hated the drama in this season Amal & Ahmad's mysterious love story that we never knew what the hell was it! But Shada won & she actually did deserve it yet Kammah did deserve it as well..
Star Academy 5;
I Love Love Love this season.. Nader, Meema,Zaher, Saad, Diaa, Mohamed .. All of these guyz they might NOT have been the most natural nor the most friendly wid each other yet they will stay special 4 me..♥

Waiting for the 6th season.. But I still think Roula will always b smart enough 2 choose the candidates that might attract the viewers & make it as special as all the previous 1s.. Though all the cheatings, scandals that were wid each season we kept watching it wid curiosity.. We loved the candidates & yet voted though all the cheatings! =)
xx!

each season had something special but i the best was star academy 5 bcz of nadoura he really rocks.i dont understand why many of you didin t like this season!!!
i think the worst season was star academy 4
it was very boring
nnnnnnnnnnaaaaaaaaadddddddddddddddeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrr

star academy 5 WORST!

I think that the best season is starac1 then starac 5 and 3. honestly i think that the worst one was starac 2 i just remember that the best voice was Amani from Tunisia.

i dont know y u guyz didnt like season 2 ?? hisham and ahmed hussein were rly funnyy

as for my favorite i guess its season 5 qwiader man rly did entertain us with all those fights, mema and zaher were funny and safo and nader were rlyy sweeeet! as for season 1,, i think ppl liked it cuz it was new+ bashar, a7med el shrif and mo7d attieh were funny

season 4 was sooooooooooooooooooooooo boring and i didnt like the ppl in season 3 except for joseph and fady and reem

In order from worst to best:
Starac 2- there was no one worth watching.... the only thing tha would hve made it good was if a good singer won (AMANI) but unfortunatly, she didnt ==> BORING WITH NO MEANING

Starac 4- There were some good people, but overall it wa boring.... Tina and amma7 story, and the amal marwa ahmad triangle... ma ken 2ilon ma3na...

Starac 5- It was alright, bas to much drama... all love stories w ta2 7anak, but there were alot of amazing talents, Im glad nader won.

Starac 1 and 3 were def th BEST, the whole seasons...
Starac 1 was so natural... they were so innocent and 3a tabi3ton... attieh w bashar balaweh... w ahmado jamel w sot... khalawi mahdoum... bruno w cynthia 2a7la joz.... miryam was the only person who made it boring

TOP 1 STARAC3!!!!!! JOOOOOSEEEPH W BAS! HAHA he def desereved to win, w the first starac contestant to fairly win... sot w charisma wjamel...
fady w maya w rakia khalifa chayma... theywere amazing... akkiiiid min doun tifkeer th best ever and to ever come =)

I agree with the voting it is similar

2nd was the worst season without any doubt
boring boring no talent except Amani not funny at all all pretend to act awful

then followed by 5th season it was horrible although talented students but veeeeeeeery booooooooooooring

then the 4th season was repetitive and nothing special except marwa shatha and amal

then 3rd although it was over but the stuedents were like a group and the primes were the best prim ever made

the best star academy ever is
Starc 1
not because it is the first seson but the group was a super group very talented and close they union the arab countries we enjoyed that part very much and knew a talent like BASHAR and others sofia , baha attia

in order the worst
2
5
4
3
1best

uh , well its kind of a hard question. i feel that each season has its good and bad sides ! but each season it seems that roulas game was about to be discovered especially starac 5 !
well in order its like this for me :
5 - 3 - 2 - 1 -4 !
well i like 5 because of BOCHBOCH <3
she made it the best especially her performances in the primes! i also liked every1 else and mirhans acting and the problems between shahinaz and mirhan they used to crack me up ! but at the end madame roula really screwed up : first amel beats dia, then dia beats amel the week after :S:S oh and nader loses against dia and then hes the star !:S:S:

3 was nice they were all a big family i like chayma the most ! they used to play tricks on the poor girl but it was funny!

2 was ok, i dont know y ppl dont like it! salma was hilarious !

1 was , well i dont know wat the big fuss was about, 0 talent and mhammad attiye made me sick honestly!

4 .... mmm well as much as i like it theres something about it that made me hate it ! its wat they did to amel al anbari! it was obvious they wanted to make money off her back,, poor girl i used to love her!!!

I definitely like Seasons 1, 3 & 4 the most...The people seemed kinder and much more supportive of each other. I think Season 5 was the worst.