The way I saw it Saad did the worst. I don't know who the nominee's will be though.

I wonder if Abdullah is really gone for good...?

Nader started off shaky but by the end was doing the best of all of them.

Mohammad did ok all the way through. No terrible part but nothing outstanding

Shahy sang it rather well. No big problems really, despite that I think she has the weakest voice of the candidates left.

PS. Who else thinks it would be great if Mohammad and Nader sang "Abdel Qader" together in the finale. It is a great arabic song they could both sing. Also, they should sing "Araby Liya", beause they both ing that well.

i think that everyone sang their songs really really well so i think that the acting will play a big role this time...if so then i am so afraid because naders scene got ruined by all the laughing the only one that didnt laugh in his scence was shainaz...ughhh i wish there was no nomination because they all deserve to stay till the finalsss!!!!!

now that abdulah is gone they should keep those 4 to the final, weren't they planning to keep 4 for the final anyways?????? they are all great......

love you moe

wow, abdullah left?
i just recognized that now!
thats sucks for him.
dude, the finals SHOULD be those four.
i think that they should NOT make nomination this week.

iam gonna vote this time.
ill vote for nade,shahy and mohamed.
i hope one of them win.

shahy:bent balady
mohamed:PERFECT VOICE AND LOOK.
nader:perfect english accent and feelings.

I MISS YOU MOSTAFA AND MIRHAN!!!!

where is abdallah?

Mohamed is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I don't care if he is nice or no.

He has the best voice.

all saudis left lebanon and close their embassy

Listen people,
If Nader and Qwaider are nominees!
Mostapha Diaa and Mirhan supporters vote for NADER!
1)Qwaider took all Mostaphas flags off his bed so he could sleep there 10 minutes after Mostapha left.
2)Qwaider almost hit diaa when she told him to stop singing while they were eating.
Plus,Saad supporters,
If Qwaider leaves Saad will have a better change to win.Lebanon needs him to win atleast something to make the people happy after whats going on.

Lebanon!!
Actually if they are nominees Qwaider will easily come back. Againts any of them he;ll easily come back.
Dont assume the fans of others will vote for only one person, there are egyptians who love mohammad and have promised to vote for him, there are lebanese who love Qwaider too, there are Algerians and Moroccans who also love qwaider, hes got the voice,some people are mature enough to vote for the person who deserves to stay.

Mohammad is the most talented out the four and should win.

Also this morning, Mary made Saad feel hes a nominee, she said hes the only one who doesnt open his mouth correctly and all of the teachers say he needs a lot of work, he should know at this stage.

To the person who called me "pathetic".Have some respect.Im just giving my opinion and what i see.You may or may not agree you can tell me that.But dont call people names.It isnt nice,i am open to hearing your opens but insults are not necessary.Im glad you believe prayer would lead to the end of the war but i just think we need something to be proud of after this.To be honest Saad isnt even my favorite!
*QwaiderStar*..What i wrote was adressed to only the mostapha and diaa supporters.Not to Qwaider fans.Yes people can make their own decision and i have the write in conveying my desicion just like your showing your support to qwaider.Which i appreciate you doing..

The eval was so pathetic that it was so funny,i couldn't stop laughing. I think the only one who is safe is shahinaz.

Hi everybody

The nominees I think it will be saad and nader. but it's gonna be mohammed and nader.
They wont or let saad be nominee they will will save saad for the final i'm sure.

But now abullah left( really i like his voice a lot it;s to bad that he left.)
Mohammed will be the star. And actually everyone deserve it off course but now abdullah is gone i hope mohammed will win this compettion.

And i want to say even i am a dia fan it doesn't mean that im stand behind saad, he is good guy and a good voice but he is not my favorite star.

and a lot of dia's Maroccains fan loves Mohammed.

Incha allah Mohammed will be win this compettion. Star 1 was one from egypt Star 2 one from KSA Star 3 one from Lebanon Star 4 one from Irak/Maroccain so Starac 5 Mohammed from Jordan wallah i hope so and he realy deserve it. And i will vote for him untill he win the Staracademy 5 im sure he win this.

Go Mohammed Rabi Ma3ak a ghoja.

Najoua (maroccain) from Holland.

To be honest now that Abdulla is gone there isnt much of a competition.For many is kind of clear who is going to win now.But theyre might be a shocking result.Alot of Diaa's supporters are with Saad and Moe has a large number of fans.Shahinaz and Naders fate is also unpredictable.But this show is all planned out.I bet they chose who they want to win a long time before the final and use the nomination not only to get money but also to give the opportunity to the person who they want to win.We just have to wait and see,and hope that our favorite wins..!

sorry i know this is only for the evaluation comments but i have to send the followings:
first of all you are all mean just like the people you are talking about and you are ll should cool down
things look ugly because it happens infornt of you. just imagine if there were camers inside the academy.
for mirhan and if you are watching the program from the begining she has changed a lot even they way she dressess has been changed that's why i think she is fake
all the time she is wearing her highheels, hair down with full make up. it's really annoying
and all the kissing and hugging and no relationship with any of the other girls even m7lawi and bushosha. she is funny i agree but some people dont stand funny people to be funny all of the time.
and who told you that she loves mo7ammed no she thinks he is phsyco and he needs to see a shrink and she told abdallah about it. she knows that nader is having a crush on her but she did nothing to stop him even m7md started to join the hussing and kissing club although it was not in his nature. the girl is sexy and she plays with the card cleverly not for the boys of the academy but for her veiwers and voters.
Shahinaz she is talking too much but she is not that BAD and she is not a B..CH so back off.
Abdallah he is young and can not stand mohammed's behaviour which is outragous, he does not respect anyone not even his teachers and if they are aginest him he would have been nomintated long time ago and no one would have voted for him inside or outside and cuz the teachers khow that very well he is safe)
Saad is confused na di dont like his story
Diaa was not talking about mima she was just btfdfd to her friends about the stuff upseting her.
Nader is another story but he is not BAD.
every one of them has his/ her bads and goods just like the rest of you
and dont forget that they are behaving just like HUMAN BEINGS being locked up inside one place for 4 month ( i really would like to see all of you inside their shoes)

sarah how could u possible know what the teachers wanttt ?
like ino u said the teachers dont want saad out or they want naader out
..how could they ossibly want him out when they kept defending him all over the show?
so just stop saying things from ur head.
wait like 5 hours and figure out who r the nominees.. just stop making conclusions cuz u ppl are starting to piss me off..
and btw..if moe and shahinaz went to the final..it wont make a difference..because theyre like ALL singers.. strong voices, boring presence.. whereas, saad ..like ALL lebanese would be happy since jospeh's winning prime.. ya3ne each year same thing..and nader is unique ..hes different from alll students.. he could ing arabic in such sweet and soft passion and if he actually sings slow love songs, he could touch anyone's heart..

Its called an opinion. This is what I THINK the teachers want...just like you think Nader is unique, i think Shahinaz and Mohammad should make the final because they are interesting.
There has never been a voice like Mohammads in starac at all and he can sing ANY style.Every teacher always tells him hes the only onw who can do both high and low notoes perfectly. Even the teachers have said hes original and he truly is. Hes been told by Saber that his voice is amazing, Amal Hijazi wants to do a duet with him.

I think Mohammad will make a perfect star, hes honest, stubborn and if he wouldnt make a good star then he wouldnt still be in the show.
I like Nader but i dont see him as original as Mohammad is.

Im only saying my opinion,i respect your opinion but this is what i think.

Sarah,
Im glad your giving you opinion and you have the right to show your appreciation towards them!:D..

R,
I live in American and i tried looking for the numbers to vote.To you have any idea what the international numbers are?Ill vote for Nader like crazy!!nchalla hell not be and niminee and win!I dont know why but i have a feeling hes leaving this week!I dont want him to though!!!so vote vote vote vote lal prime!Oh and diaa had Asma's,Adnan's and Saad's supports including her own.Thats why she got so many,And she did have a nice voice!

Y was nader n all laughn? Can sum1 translate it for me,plz

I dont speak nor understand arabic,thnx!!!

Anyone please........

Sarah,
I understand.We should all be happy whoever wins!Because all of them are going to be successful whether he/she is the star or not.

Forever21,
Well apparently they started laughing for no reason i presume.All of them except Shahinaz!..Mohammad said he coulnt find work.Then Saad and Nader told him to go find work and Nader hit Qwaiders head.Which they found amusing and continued laughing uncontrollably.!:D
You watch Star Academy and dont understand Arabic?Thats cute!:D

Saad said later on that when Nader was saying how Mohammad has no work and always looks lost, Saad said he just looked at Mohammad and started laughing, he didnt know why, just everytime he looked at Qwaider he started laughing.

zizou, i did not realise that many moroccans like Mohammad...i used to always see comments from dia fans saying Mohammad is rude because they had that arguemnet. But its good you like Mohammad's voice!

A question for anyone who cares to answer: Does shahinaz have fans??? I'm just wondering coz i'd be surprised if she does have.

I think most of the peoples here and follow the staracademy have a diffenrent way about the maroccains.

Maroccains loves Dia and Saad of course. Maroccains Loves Nader shahi and aboudi.
And maroccain Loves Mohammed.

Not all the maroccains is with Saad because of dia. And not all the maroccains is with aboudi shahi or nader. And not all the maroccains are with Mohammed everbody has his own opinion and his favouriete star in morocco.

i am a maroccain girl from holland and i follow the staracademy mostly everyday.
At the beginning was Mohammed and Dia my favouriete stars.I really believe in them and still i have the trust in them, they gonna be a truely star.And i will always them biggest fan.

All the others student are quiet nice but not so much as Mohammed and Dia.

I think Mohammed and Dia are the same.(character) that's why i like them.

Mohammed about his mood and his attitude every one and everybody was against to him even the teachers. And everybody knows that he has a such a beautifull voice he can sing in many tunes high and low from jabal to soft songs from khalijiee songs to romantic songs folklore songs. Mohammed is unique singer that is what he is from me then ( my opinon_

Dia about her when she gets angry she is lilke mohammed. she can do it hard like mohammed in words if she is fighting with him. and i don't think dia hates mohammed no she realy respect mohammed as his own brother. She said to him sometimes you could be a sweetest man and so cute but sometime you could be so rude and she said to him that there character like much to each other he can be agressieve and she can also being agressieve.She can sing in so many songs in a different way she can rock she can singing the jazz and the blues, she can sing a 3 languages.

The last couple of weeks the become truly friends like a brother and sister.

they are truly both my stars

Go mohammed go dia I hope really hearing some things of you. keep on the good work

and for the other students good luck.

Dandoushaa are u sure about the nominees how do u know
why qwaider and shahi they are the strongest ones it doesnt sound right

Yesterday night shaniaz was tempted when Saad and nader were eating toast with cheese spread. And when she was aboout to have one they told her to remember what goerge said and made fun abt the whole thing. She then got pissed off and went. Nader and saad followed her to the bedroom and made her get back to the dining room with them. She then wanted to make some tea and offered them, they said okay. After that she deliberately put too much salt in their cups. saad spitted right away and they both stood up to pour water all over her. She wanted a big deal out of it and was laughing in a disgusting way. But later they went to the theatre room and locked the door behind them. They were not thrilled by her actions coz it was not funny and it was mean so saad went on playing the piano while nader was singing. After that they went to their rooms and she cleaned up the place while revealing half of her breasts. Poor shahy, she's a psycho! They say Moe is crazy but she's the worst.

qwiderstar
i heard it from a source in the lbc they r saying they r sure
but iam not sure
but shahy's eval wasnt good and qwider i dunno may be from the prob with abdallah or to get rid of shahy after all her probs

sarah r u sure??
cuz iam not sure ,, plzzzzzzzzzzzzz if that vote m7md iam egyptian but i will vote for m7md

aha ok thnxxx alot
plzzz vote m7md , shahinaz must leave

VOTE MOHAMMAD!

This doesnt mean he wont win...remember Shada was a nominee a week before the final

mabroooooooook nadoura 7biby el final
plzz vote m7md

congratulationssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss NADER the final .
really i'm very excited and hope you'll be the star 2008 .
and good luck for shahy and moe , i'm NOT going to vote this time ,i just want to wait and see the results .

goooooooooooooo nadour you can do it ,ya 2amar ya atyab alb

VOTE MOHAMEDDDD

If they took out the trash you would have been in the bin!!!!!