The remaining four students of LBC Star Academy 5 have just finished their final evaluation of the season.
Four of the students sang Umm Kulthoum's El Wardi Gamil and Nader sang a French song as usual.
They also had to do a sketch about family troubles and whatnots.
It's nice that all of them helped each other with their sketches and were very cooperative.
The first students to do the eval is Saad, he sang the song and did his sketch.
Saad did very well with the song, didn't forget any words, did hesitate and didn't screw up any notes.
Nader then sang the French song, which is not at the same difficulty level as El Wardi Gamil, but i have to hand it to him, it’s a difficult song and he did well!
Mohammad was next. It seems he was a bit afraid, so he screwed up a note or two at one point, nothing serious but i bet the teachers picked it up!
Shahinaz was the last to do her eval, she sang very well.
I'm not sure who's going to be nominated tomorrow ... especially that Abdallah left and the number of students is not not as planned! Is there a possibility that there won't be a nomination this week? We'll have to wait and see.
Videos of the evaluation will be online soon
comments
Waleg please post the videos i didn't get to see the whole thing. thanks
i think there still will a nomination cause they want to get rid of nader so they will nominate mohamed we nader i think.
Waleg , can you please or any one tell me where is abdulla , cause i didn't see him the evaulation..
thanks, nada
WHY DO THEY WANNA GET RID OF NADER ?
I SERIOUSLY LOVE HIM
ITS SO UNFAIR IF THEY NOMINATE HIM!
WHY WHY WHY ?!
I DONT GET U PPL..HES RLY ENTERTAINING
AND I ADORE HIM
ALOT OF PPL DONT ..I DNO WHYYYY ! =S
HE'S AMAZING
MIGHT NT HAVE THE BEST VOICE BUT STILL
R i agree with you, and inshallah Nader won't me nominee, cuz it would not be fair, cuz Mohamed and Saad messed up his mash7ad, 7aram wallah! I just wish that this week, will be no nominees, all those 4 to the finals. Inshallah nadour is not nominee, cuz he sang beautifully. It wld be nicer if there was no nominee!
N.A.D.O.U.R I.N.T.E.R.N.A.T.I.O.N.A.L S.T.A.R! Wallah 7aram if they nominate him! It wasn't his fault, it was his 'so called fellow student who were meant to be his friends' fault, they kept laughing!
yehh layla ... but he was lauhging too .. it wasnt only moe and saad..... nader couldnt even hold himself...nader wasnt even mad after..
Mo is a nominee and he is OUT this week ....
I hope that Moe isn't a nominee..... He deserves to win the star this year. Inshallah there will be no nominee's this week because Abdullah left Star Academy this week!
oh God why did Mohamed and Saad have to laugh in Nader's mashad, God no one cld hold themselves from laughing! They did it on prose, cuz they wanna nominate Nader! And becuz of this stupid thing, he will be nominee, la inshallah! What did nader ever do to them??? That is so unfair, doesn't mean he if sang well they had to mess his act up, he acted well in there scenes, that is just mean, wallah 7aram! Inshallah he isn't nominee!
ya rab inchllah mo nomine nadoura ystehel ykoun star
Ya Rab ma fi nomination this week!!!!! Ameeennn!!! It wld be much nicer if all those 4 went to the finals! 7alas, we had enough of panicking!!
Ya rab Nadour mish nominee, 3alashan 3ana kateer 7eluuu!!!!!! It wouldn't be fair if they made him nominee just cuz Mohamed and Saad started laughing!!!!
jojo.... nader was laughing aswell.. calm downn moe even laughed in his evall........
Mo and Saad didn't laugh on purpose. And Nader was laughing more than them. Plus Mo laughed in his scene as well which means that he didn't mean it.
Plus all of then screwed up in all the scenes and the 4 know it. They know that they all sang good but acted real bad.
At the end of the eval they were saying poor Gaby he must be furious
isaa nadoura msh nominee isaa
bs i think msh hyb2a fe nomination cuz abdallah is gone
may be the 4 for the final
dunno but i hope that nadoura is not a nominee he sang very well but for the scene really i couldnt stop laughing at them esp when kwider entered
gooooooooooo NADER u r the best
i think they should end the show this week. no NOMINATION... seriously last yr there was four standing in the finals...and now that abdallah left there is four left....the show is getting rele boring...and i cant wait to see mohammed out in the real world...im sure that by next yr hell have an album that the whole world will be in love with...
also i think that they announce the tourne this prime cuz last yr they announced it during the semi finals
Faiza, yes i know.... but like in Nader's eval all the teachers got soooo pissed, cuz they were all laughing like hell, and it all started cuz of Saad and Mohamed!!!! It was funny, but not when you know there is a nomination going on! And when Mohamed laughed in his eval u cld barely see it.. anyways... I just think they could have been nicer to Nadour! Ok... so they want him out.. but it doesn't have to be this way.. he is a really nice guy to both of them. Raban 3a3tii 3ala al niyaat!
The two who sang the best were Mohammad and Shahinaz...Nader and Saad were dispapointing and i swear to god when saad sang i didnt even notice his mouth or jaw even moving...after his eval, he heard the teachers say he didnt open his mouth well.
I think all their mashhads were disappointing.
Why the hell does everyone blame Mohammad for ruining everything?
Nader was the one that made both Saad and Mohammad laugh. Also mohammad acted the best in Shahinaz mashhad.
If Nader is a nomine tomorrow, its not because of Mohammad, its because he didnt sing well enough and mixed his words up.
I think all of them should be nominated and the three who get the most vote should stay. I think tomorrows nominees will be Saad and Nader. Thats just my opinion.
Jeeeeeeeeeeeeeez!
Stop blaming other people for Naders bad eval. Hes the one that started them laughing, i applaud Mohammad for being able to enter afterwards and sing better than all of them.
If you want to start pointing the finger at someone, point it at all of them since all three boys were laughing.
jojo ,, i know wat u mean,,, i like nader tooo and i felt bad for him... guess we'll see tomm... plus i didnt like anyone scene... it was all too long and boring.. nothing special...... they couldve acted wayyyyyyyyyyyy better...
Susan what are you saying??? Nader sang very well, Do you know how hard that song that he sang is? They give it to professionals in the Operas! Nothing like the Arabic song they had to sing... anyways he didn't mess up, u cld barely notice it, and the teachers said that its ok to mess up as long as u continue you normally! Plus, Nader sang beautifully!!! I really hope the show ends, and all 4 are nominees to the final!
Yeah Faiza i agree, lets just hope there is no nominee's this week! 7alas end the show!!!!! All 4 of them to the fianls!!!
If they had wanted to ressurect Naders scene, and had brains all they had to do is ...
since Moe was playing the part of the never do well brother, Nader could have told him ...
Get out are you high and or drunk, our father jsut died, so there was a way out but no one was focusing and thats just of the top of my head.
But they all laughed and we laughed along with them.
Sue, i heard the song for the first time and just said my opinion on how he sang in general. My opinion is that Nader sang the weakest out of the 4 of them...also a week ago Wadi3 told them that the evals are very importnat now and ANY mistake could cost them to be nominated.
I agree with what you said about 4 nominees to the final, the show needs to end.
Eum.. to those who are blaming Nader for laughing, shld go and check the eval again! I personally don't like to blame any student for another's nomination, but Saad and Mohamed burst out laughing and Nader then laughed along with them!!! everybody sucked in acting, Shahnaiz was ok... they all sang well! And if nader is nominee it is obvious to see why, cuz he sang wonderfully!!! Lets just hope there is no nomination this time...!!!
Strange i personally think, that Nader sang the best... cuz that song is way beyond his level, and he sang it very nicely... u never know u guys...its getting harder.. yeah i agree with everyone, the show has to end, and all 4 shld be nominated! And yeah, its not like Moe didn't make any mistakes!! Ya Rab Nadour and Moe mish nominee!!!!
there will be a nomination this week!!!!!! do you guys really think that they'll one whole week without making any money???!!!! i don't think so, so they will nominate two people so that people will vote and lbc makes money >>>>>> don;t forget it is a business and they will do what's best for the business not the students >>>>> they don't care about the students!!!!! or their fans.
Honestly you guys can be ridiculous sometimes,...if you actually watched the eval Nader started laughing first and then Saad and then Mohammad. Saad explained it later on, it was bcause of something funny that Nader said.
Also Mohammad sang the best out of all of them and those of you who say hes in danger because of his mashhad, EVERY single week he does the crappest most boring mashhad and Gaby and Elissar say his name and hes not nominated.
The nominees are Nader and Saad, but i can see they just adore Saad soo much that he may just slip out of the nomination...
Even if Nader's mashhad was perfect, he would be nominated because hes got the weakest voice out of all 4.
nader didnt mess up in his song !
mohammad did, what r u ppl talking about..
nader sang beautifully..now maybe they all laughed in the eval. but this doenst have to be the point where they make him a nominee
and lsn ppl.. why do the teachers want nader out.. who told u so ? u guys r making up SERIOUSLY
how on earth do u know what the teachers want..
and plus no way they want him out.. like the past 6 weeks..they kept saying that he has amazing carisma, alot of ppl love him and all that .. now they want him out..theres no reason they want him out
maybe fouad wants him but the rest..no
so stop making up things from ur damn heads
Even if Mohammad is a nominee.do you guys actually think he will go?lol, Mohammad can come back over any of those students left. His only competition was Abdullah's khaleeji votes and Abdullah has supposedly left.
With the amount of support Mohammad is getting, i wouldnt care if he's nominated because he would certainly come back.
And dont say Khaleeji will vote for another student who was friends with Abdullah because they wont, Khaleej only vote for Khaleej. Dont assume the whole of Khaleejo will now vote for just one person the same way they voted for Abdullah.
Nader the weakest voice??? Ha ha...no comment ... more like the strongest voice!
Nominees:
MOHAMMAD
NADER
Mohammad wil come back without a doubt....bye bye Nader.
PPL PLZ TELL ME .. WHERE THE HELL IS ABOUDI????? I CANT BELIEVE MY EYES, AM READING SOMETHING LIKE"HE LEFT THE ACADEMY"... WHAT HAPPEND PLLZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
yeaa true maria; they only vote for one another ;they will never vote for moe even if he got messages from khalej but its clear dat the messages are well made especially the last nigh sms.
almost all sms were to him while in each site or magazine there's an article talking about moe bad behaviors and bad reputation and many jordanians arent supporting him.
after aboudi left i guess he will win but he doesnt deserve it but this the situation of the arab world we always granted non respectfull people dats why we still ways away from being developped;we refuse to admit dat moe isnt good and only voice cant make a star.
1st nader is one of the strongest voices in the acdemy
they r all the same level no one in the acdemy has his stage presence or his sweet voice
guys be honest nader was the best one to sing his song is so much harder than el ward gamil and he did it great he was the best and he was the best in the prime too , so isa msh nominee
goooooooooooo nadoura u r the star
Nour, arabic is the dominant singing language for this show. When Nader sings arabic he is by far the weakest out fo the 4, that a fact. If i was watching starac france than Nader would defnatley have a strong voice.
It goe slike this:
Mohammad
Shahinaz
Saad
Nader
I have no sympathy for Nader getting a hard song like Nader fans say.
There have been times where the arabic singing students have recieved the hardest, most difficult songs that you cant even imagine them being able to sing while Nader gets an easy song.
Now its swtiched the other way round.
Also you have to accept that its enough of a negative that Nader cant sing good arabic so obviously hes not going to get the easiest french or english song, if hes unable to sing arabic, you have to set him big challenges.
In fact i have watch all these programs such as Pop Idol, Star academy France, fame academy etc... And i think that nader can make it, he can even actually sing as well as them, in the European world Nader would make it BIG! And he will after this show.. u guys wait and see.. this guy is international, and can sing Arabic so softly and delicately, with such emotion. He sang with the most strongest Opera voices in the world, not even plp in the European world can do that, very rarely! You telling me this guy isn't a Star.. rriiittteee..... no even gonna comment on that. Nadourrr can't wait for you album!!!
Mohammad can sing better than half the people signed with Rotana. Full Stop. thats a fact...and bullsh*t that he doesnt deserve to win, he does a much as any other student.
And any student will be hated and loved, none of them are exactly angels.
I can imagine some of you in a few years time sitting there listening to Mohammads album and saying how great his songs are.
This guys gonna make it big and you guys just cant admit that fact.
Waleg can you plzzzzzzzz post the evalsvideo's!!!! Thank's!!
Nour i never said Nader cant make it big...i said that his arabic singing is weak and the prime's dominant singing language is arabic. For weeks, the teachers have been telling him he needs to practice singing arabic.
if he can sing arabic then why sisnt he singing much arabic in the primes??
The guy is a star but not the star for this show.
yes reem i know, but he can't just sing Arabic like that.. he needs a teacher to listen to him or at least tell him how to make it better, but as we see, none of them have time, and they cldn't careless abt nader improving arabic, they are happy the way he is, and then shall blame him!!! ... so u can't blame the guy for not singing Arabic, cuz no one is helping him !!!
Nour, Michelle sat with him for a whole hour once with Mohammad and they were giving him advice on how to sing this arabic song that they wanted to give to him. The teachers havent ignored him.
Mohammad even sits with him sometimes to teach him how to sing arabic on the guitar.
That was like only one Arabic song.. and he sang it in the prime, after that.. they just left him..!! For example nader said that he wants to do an eval song in Arabic, but who on earth is gonna help him? everyone is occupied with themselves.. anyways there is less than a week left.. why care now, its not like he can't sing Arabic at all, i personally love the way he sings in Arabic, So touching! can some plz post the eval videos!!
WALEG when are you going to post the eval videos????? please !!!!! please :)
WALEG can u plllzzzzz post the eval videooossss!!!!!!!
Waleg when are u gonna post the eval, plz can u post it now!?!!
nader is disguisting he looks like a chip munk he is a trader he is a freak he is noy a real friend he didn't vote for mirhan when he was a ganst diaa and he didn't vote for mostafa AGAIN HE IS SO UGLY I HATE HIM!!!!SAAD STAR OO BASS AND I HATE NADER HE WAS TALKING ABOUT MIRHAN THAT SHE WAS DRUNK
leb lover your not the one to be talking, plz look at Saad himself before u comment on others students... thanx u!!!
There will be nominee, akeeed!
Mirhan + Abdullah are out it's already boring, it'll be worse for 2 weeks without nominee's and no competitions!
I guess only 3 in the finals.
uhmmmm what happened to abdulla where did he go?
I think any combination of nominees will include Chahinaz this time around and anyone of the three guys can give her the boot.
UR WRONG EMME
confused - Abdullah left today, check the latest thread or The one dedicated to him leaving for the details.
For everyone who say's Nader can't sing arabic:
He actually can, just not as well as english. We have heard him sing many arabic songs just fine in the academy. He sings "Araby Liya" just as well as Qwaider(I think they should sing it in a prime) and he has sung many others. Also he has sang "Sahrana Ma'ak el layla" rather well or average
But Nader CAN sing Rai songs. He sang "Youm wara Youm" in an earlier prime with Dia, he sang it PERFECTLY, does anyone remember it? he was sitting on a window in a medley?
Nader's strongest style is in french, english, etc. but Nader could also mix that in with Rai songs similar to "Aisha" or "Abdel Qader".
PS. I want to hear Nader and Mohammad sing "Abdel Qader" in the finals! They could both sing it perfectly. Who else agrees?
dandooushaa if it was mohamads fault believe me nader wouldnt be that calm abt it:) it was saad who laughed first at moe's sal3a he said it wen he went out but u always blame thngs on moe which isnt really nice:S! saad and nader were laughing uncontrolbly even wen moe left ! ya3ne come on:S this isnt nicee! he laughed in his own scene
Hey guys!
I hope that there are three nominees this week:
-Nader
-Saad
-Mohammad
And the person with the most votes goes against Shahinaz!
I really miss the traditional finals, with only two people!
It will be the best finals if Shahinaz went against Mohammad!
Fingers crossed!
GO SAAD GO!!!!!
Your the best. And anyone who doesn't like Saad r jealous of him, he has charm and witt and a great voice, allahs gift. Come on Lebos vote SAAD, no matter how much they try to put us down we always rise to glory.
They are amazing singers!
But all the former stars are all the same.
We need something different this year.Nader is unique and thats what we need.He can always learn how to sing in arabic.I mean if he can sing high vocal english and french songs.Arabic would be a piece of cake.At the begining of his eval he messed up abit in the vocals but he mastered the rest.Guys remember its not only the eval.The performances in the prime are important too..!
mohammad and nader were practicing the arabic song that nader always sings, to sing in the prime.. but then the teachers didnt let them sing it in the prime
so u say its naders fault ?
maybe he isnt practicing, but its cause the teachers arent giving him arabic songs to sing in the prime!
and roula always said that this show is all about english and french AS MUCH as arabic..she kept arguing with fouad and everyone, and wadih and mary agreed.. ya3ne he had the chance to come to starac 5, and he sings french.. ya3ne if he sings french ya3ne he cant get into this singing world ? give him a slack people !
and whoever said that nader looks like a chimp and u hate him.. hes ugly because he didnt vote for mirhan and mustafa ? like come on..i really wanted him to vote for safo, basss ya3ne alot of other ppl didnt vote for him and u didnt eevn say a word..so its not naders fault..
and btw, dont say nader kept talking bull-sh-it when mirahn sent the msg..he was explaining, 7aram ! and if he really did talk about her backk he wouldnt have cared this much to explain it to her..he would have just let it go!
and remember, he to;d mirhan he had feelings for her, how could he talk about her back after 1 week of her leaving the show?
its just not logical.. so dont just depend on the sms, maybe its not mirhan after all who sent it..maybe its someone who hates nader and shahinaz and they want ppl to go agaisnt them..
R,
No one said that Nader cant get into the singing world because he cant sing arabic.
He can be an international star because hes got a good voice but in my opinion, this is an arabic singing show, the majority of the primes is the students singing arabic. Its good that Nader has reached this stage but no way should he win, that just wouldnt be right. The winner should be either Saad or Mohammad.
They'e not givig him arabic songs to sing because he cant sing properly in arabic!If he could, he would be singing arabic as much as other students. A lot of people keep saying he can sing arabic perfectly so then why isnt he singing in the primes?Its not because the teachers ignore him, they favour him more than ignore him, they give him like 3 solos each prime, thats good in itself.
Wadi3 is always testing him for arabic songs when a star is coming, when all th other boys go up and try an arabic song, Nader gets to as well. Wadi3 then tells him to prepare it and the only reason he doesnt get it is simply because hes not good enough to sing it.
i know hes not as good as the students right now..
im just saying that he sings arabic in such sweet soft passion..ya3ne AKID all of them can sing..
they al have the voice..in my opinion, this show isnt about who has the greatest voice
its about how they use it!
because their voices isnt something they produced, its a gift from good
so this show must be about who works the best and who has the star qualities..
everyone says that no way shahinaz or mohammas ykouno nominees.. WHY ! ya3ne ok they have strong nice voices, bas alot of singers out there do too.. so itshould be about their ability of what they can do by their voices..
And this show might be an arabic singing one, because its in the arab world..however ALOT ALOT of ppl enjoy listening to eng-french songs, he doesnt have to go to starac france to sing french.. and maybe he wont win, bas it'll be amazing to see him going to the finalss since hes has such great carisma and presence and a really tender voice..so i think alot of ppl would love it : )
God *
Susan..
The show is called STAR ACADEMY..not ARAB STAR or whatsoever.."STAR" means a person who can not only sing but someone who has stage presence and is able to communicate with his/her fans whilst on stage!Nader has those qualities!
It would be great (If he becomes the star) because he can mix english and arabic songs together.It would be something completely different to the former stars!Saad and Moe arent unique they do have the voices but no sort of specific attraction.Nader and Diaa were one of a kind!They arent picking him to sing an arabic song mainly because he sounds better in English.Its not that he cant sing in arabic!If he can speak and read in arabic singing would be a piece of cake,i believe!
When you actually think about it if Nader leaves the number of viewers will decrease a great deal!I mean nothing is going on.The only they do is sleep now since Mirhan left!If Nader leaves thats it.Boredom 24/7!
to Nader!!!!(STAR)
i agree totally...
if mohammad or shahinaz won.. it would be so boring.. seriously, Chaza last year..and season 2 when i forgot whats her name was in the fianls
it was so expected.. ya3ne were bored of the same people..
they could make songs easily.. bas ino nader it would be amazing if he won,,, the problem here is that the countries@ they vote for the students that are from their countries..
ya3ne for once look at everything, about who deserves, or the way they produce their ability to do anything and all these things..
and i really would LOVE to see nader sailing through the finalss (K)
WE LOVE YOU NADER
Nader!!!(STAR)
I respect your opinion that Nader should win but in my opinion Mohammad should, after the teachers said he doesnt have stage presence, Wadi3 said last eval that Mohammad has proved in primes he does have stage presence. I personally see Mohammad as original, the teachers even think hes the most original. Every song he sings, he does it in his own way, he doesnt copy anyone.
In my opinion(and i think you will agree), all the four left now will be successful, it doesnt matter who wins because they ALL four will most likely end up singing.
I dont hate Nader and i hope he succeeds but id be happier if Mohammad wins rather then Nader.
Susan,
I do agree with you that all of them will certainly be sucessful in the music industry.But all the former stars are the same.If Nader wins itll be somthing different.
The teachers opinion doesnt really matter because they give they students positive points to motivate them.
I understand you prefer Mohamad over Nader and its your right to.Thank you for your opinion and whoevers deserves to win will win!Good luck for Qwaider:D
P.S.
do you have any idea how to vote internationally.I live in the states and all the numbers are locar arab countries.
Im not sure about international voting because im living in the UK but i've heard some people who have voted from the UK and the states. I dont know how.
To Nader!!!(STAR)
ill check the numbers today when i watch Lbc and ill try to tell u as soon as possible ..anyway lets just hope he isnt a nominee :p
and id like to add one thing
i think in this stage they should nominate the ones that arent working well in classes and thAT arent improving.. i really reALLY loved nader's song and how he performed it..
honestly, not just cuz im a fan but i just love it when he sings these kinds of songs..seriously amazing!
Oh god
NADERRRRRRRRRRRRRRR (K) hahaha
i never expected it to be this way
bas im glad
saad and nader.. U guys proved every one who isnt a fan..Wrong!!
u see people..its not about who has the strongest voice..its about who can use it the best
I LOVE U GUYS (K) GOODLUCK TO BOTH ( saad & Naderrr )
well.i am ver sad for mohammed he deserves to stay to the end he will may gpd be with him.
I ver glad ,happy that Abdullah is out khayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy this the best ever this year.
Plz ALL of the Star academy vote for Mohammed.
R,
Thank you.Appreciate it.Im not going to need the number this week though!lol!Next week for sure!Im so happy it went this way!I wonder what would have happened if Abdullah stayed!I felt so bad for Moe though he was in SHOCK!"Control,Control"..7aram!I think the eval was based on class involvement and the overall performances.But when watching the evals after the judges gave their opinions of Shaninaz and Moe you could tell they messed up abit.
Susan,
Sorry about Moe.I have to admit I was extremely shocked!I see.I'll try looking for the internation voting numbers on tv/online then.Thanks anyways.
please every one where can i find the number to vote, i live in usa and the numbers they put on the tv screen for voting outside the arabic world are so not clear, any help, i want to vote for muhammad
please every one where can i find the number to vote, i live in usa and the numbers they put on the tv screen for voting outside the arabic world are so not clear, any help, i want to vote for muhammad
why do you want to get rid of nader? i mean i really really love him, anyway who dosen't love him!!!??