This week I think all the students were at the same level, except it was obvious that Mirhan had the weakest voice.
I just want to say what I thought of each student:

Mirhan – she sang it okay but overall her voice is week and I think she ruined the end of the song a bit.she’s a definite nominee.She acted well but ruined it by laughing.

Saad – he sang okay but sometimes I think that he listents to eveal song soo much that he does it EXACTLY like the singer, he should more original his acting is improving though.

Shahinaz – She sang well and with feeling and she acted well.

Abdullah – he didn’t sing the khaleeji song as well as I had expected. My mum knows the song he sang very well and she said that he sang it too quick. I think he got too confident when he got the song and then ruined it.
He acted a bit weird but sometimes I see him over exaggerating his character which is a mistake in acting.

Nader – he got a hard song but I think he rushed into it, the beginning part was meant to be slower. I think he did the chorus correctly though; his acting was a little disappointing. I don’t see him progressing much these days, his mind seems somewhere else…

Mohammad – I was a little worried when he got the khaleeji song but I think he really managed it. He’s very good with kahleeji songs. I think he sang it the way it was meant to be sang and even better than Abdullah. His acting was really good and hes improved.
I can’t believe Shahinaz told him he didn’t sing well and Nader told him he ruined the acting, but he stood up to them and told them he felt he sang good and said he didn’t ruin anything.
You can see how badly the students want Mohammad as a nominee. If he is one, then I feel sorry for the Mirhan because she will be gone..
I think the nominees are:
Mirhan
Nader

I love Mohammad and Merihan hope they are more close to each other.

Abdullah and shahy sucks in their behaviour

hey gurls does anyone think saad will b a nominee??

Nader sang well, and his acting was ok.. Mohamed didn't help him much , cuz he didn't let Nadour say his part in the eval.... but wut eva..

The nominee's it should BE Mirhan and Abudallah, Mohamed sang the Khaliji song better than him!!! I mean come on this show is about who can sing not who can act the best!
Mirhan--No voice..
Abudallah--didn't sing the song well..
But both these plp are good in acting!!! It is hard... let's just hope Nadour isn't nominee inshallah!

Ppl..i just watched the eval on waleg.
i actually LOVED nader..for the first time i really enjoy listening to him in the eval..maybe the sketch was a bit silly..but he was great..really :)
i enjoy it when he sings slow amazing songs..like when he sang with alessandro safina ... hes such a great singer..he could sing anything
just pray he wont be a nominee this week.. id love to see him sailing through the next round..i adore him

this weeks nominees are gonna be three:
1)nader
2)mirhan
3)saad

and two are leaving...

i hope nominees are'nt nader and mirhan...............

im trying to find out who is good in the academy?
no one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! oh shit
they r all actors
they r all backstabbers
they all talk abt others
if mohamad had problems i can say each one of the remaining have loads and loads of problems

I think we're in for a surprise this week. They all didn't do all that great in something or the other. Most of the singing was bad, even the stronger candidates like Chahinaz and Mohamed tipped up or went flat. Abdallah was terrible and Saad was flat. I think Nader did well, in spite of a bad start. Mirhan's scene might give her one more week, but if she's judged on singing alone, she's definitely on the chopping block again. It would be interesting if two of the students who have never been nominated are named this week.

Mohammad is an embarrassment to Arabs everywhere and should be nominated as soon as possible.
Anyone who is as arrogant, big-headed, filthy, as he is does not deserve the benefits of being a part of Starac

remember guys...dont attack each other's opinions....its not worth it to waste our energy being mad....put your enegry towards voting....In my opinion I think mirhan will be the next to leave, I think this is a great spot to leave, and made a good mark on the academy, she has a voice, but its not great, she can act and mashalah looks like model, and imagine she will be sucessfull after the show is over, the other option is Nader, i think he has an ok voice, he is a good performer no doubt and I think he will do well after the academy, but he is also weaker than some of the others....the other i think who might be a nominee is abdallah, yes he has a nice voice....but its only NICE, he has potential but needs some liveliness.......saad has potential he needs to put to work ASAP or he will find himself nominee...cuz he tends to sing things the same without making them his own...and saad has a wonderful voice i wish he would use it a little better, as for mohammad, I think mohammad does a great job, ya his stage presence needs improvent but i think he does well.......

I HOPE the nnominees are abdalla and nader.....mimaa did good this week and her sketch was awesome!!

It seems that this week Mirihan is a definite nominee.
If I have to choose between Nader and Abdallah to be nominees , I'd go with Abdallah because they definitely want Mirihan out by next week and I'm not so sure Nader is gonna be the one to oust her out of the competition.
I know there are a lot of Abdallah haters here (including me ) , but believe me if he's nominated this week , he'll definitely come back.

P.S: WALEG . why can't you allow readers to edit their posts or delete them ? Sometimes , I have to repost twice because of some mistakes.

MIRHO go out save us from you

i think the nominees would be
1. NADER (ewwww hate him)
2. MIRHO ( hate her too)
and i think mirho would com back but i wish they both would get out

ASMA ASMA ASMA ASMA ASMA WE ALL MISS YOU HERE

ahbal ure ahbal!!!!!!!!!! u've alway hated moe.................

Jealous of MO? I don't think anyone on earth wants to be like MO. Wallah if anyone told me that I look like Mo or behave like him, I would shoot myself. Mo is alil Adab, Alil tirbay, bala zou2, bala akhla2, watti, 7aqeer, Mon7at our mareed nafsi. What is there to be jeolous of????

Lak watch him, do you people watch him? Everything about him is crzy. Lak the guy can't even complete a sentence to make any sense!!!!

PEOPLE !!! The guy has a mental retardation. He is not normal He cannot be normal. I feel bad that I abd mouth him instead of wishing him recovery He really should be in intensive recovery not star academy.

I can't wait till the show is over so I no longer have to see him or hear him!!! Allah yil3ano shu mo2rif!!!

Tfoo 3aleih or 3ala elly rabbah ta yitla3 heik.

I mean no offense, but I can't not conclude that anyone that likes Mo or approves of his behaviour is lacking as well. I mean for me to love him and repect what he does, I have to act like him and be like him!!! And if you are like that , you need help as well.

And for those who start pointing at how bad the other contestants are. THAT does not justify what Mo does. If the others are bad people that does NOT mean that Mo is OK and he can act that way!

Sure Abdalla is sick, Shahy is mental, Mirhan needs to close her legs, Nader is confused and Saad is bored with himself. Sure they all are freaks. But Mo is freakier and worse than them combined!!!!

Nothing justifies MO. Nothing.

In the evaluation Abdalla's acting was soooooooooooo GAY and silly and exaggerated. They could have come up with a better letter than O. i mean why didn they say 3ain mathalan and confused between 3omar and 3oud, insread of thier stupid OUD! and they were so happy about thier performance!

Mirhan's scene was so weak, problem is she loves her self so much that sheis to busy laughing at her own khiffet damm instead of carrying on with the scene, too much laughing, so immature

The best scene was mhammad and nader, they acted well althought it lacked a good finish.

I f i was Gaby i would jump off a building after seeing all the shabby acting the students did!

they all sang well except for mirhan whose voice is just muz3ij and Nader started off badly and only sang well at the very end

First of all
i agree with ahbal on one thing
ure allll saying that abdulla and everyone are really bad people for talking about moe w heke..they gossip alot true..but mohammad did LOTS of bad things..like lots..he finally realised he shouldnt be heke..and BTW
u say mohammad is the only one who isnt fake.. how could u say that ? men zamen he used to say that shou badkon fiyye im that guy ana 3anid w i dont know what.. and now he became better..so i think he now is fake and not being the true mo because he said it himself..the true him is the guy who used to fight with everyone over silly selfish reasons..
and i personally dont like abdula but why are u judging him if mohammad is getting on his nerves?? .. no one knows what moe did backstage so stop judging people..
and 7aram nader..only cuz he liked mirhan for a llilttle while u guys hate him now? u cant control ur feelings people..i just wish hes sfae this week
i love you naddoura (K)

shahi and abdallah gossip a lot behind the back of all and when peole mentioned that during the SMS night she lied and said noooo i didn't do that
what are your comments??????

To fond admirer of starac from USA,

Je te jure que tu es grave, mais c fou jai fait la meme remarque que toi y a pas un seul marocain sur terre (meme les analphabetes) qui ne sait pas ecrire casablanca correctement loool tu es genial

to loubna
we c'etait claire que c'est un message pour creer un conflit entre les marocains; meme un americain il aurait du ecrire correcetement casablanca.

j'ai aussi fait attetntion aux messages disons que les algerians ont vote mir+hoooe ;ce qui est impossible surtout que les algerians sont dure que les marocains ;je pense pas qu'ils vont gaspiller leurs argents pr voter a une danceuse de premiere categorie.

on est assez intelligent pour voir au clair les intentions de certaines personnes qui utilisent le conflits entre algerie et maroc pour atteindreleur buts.

on aime les algerians meme si'ls votent contre nous car on est frere de sang.

Vive Algerie

Salut Fati,

je te jure que quand j ai vu KASABLANKA j ai compris tout de suite le jeu, the is no 1 single morroccan who doen t khow how to spell it, it s obvious and we (Morooccans )are cleaver enough to know who is the the sender, did u get my point fati?

Dis moi, est ce que tu vis a casa?

hi fati,

am from casa, but i live in dubai. yes of course we will be with abboudi till the end. am voting since yesteday. inshallah he will be back, he deserves all the best.

Tu fais quoi dans la vie? etudiante?