Tuesday night was a supposed to be an entertaining Broadway show night, but some of the contestants turned it into a bland show night!
The Top 6 performed great songs by famous composer Andrew Lloyd Webber.
The first to sing was Syesha Mercado and she did ‘One Rock n’Roll too Many’ from ‘Starlight Express’.
She tried her best, but it seemed to me that wasn’t good enough. On the other hand, the judges thought she did great and has a shot at a huge Broadway career. What do you think?

The second to sing was Jason Castro and he did ‘Memory’ from Cats.
That’s a tough song and needs a strong voice to give it was it deserves.
Jason didn’t do well! As Randy put it, it was a train wreck!

The third to sing was Brooke White and she did ‘You Must Love Me’ from Evita.
Brooke forgot the words in the beginning of the song and was brave enough to ask for a do-over! She stopped and said: “I’m sorry, Can we do that again?”
Paula told her that she’ll be very disappointed when she watches it back and I agree.

The fourth to sing was David Archuleta and he did ‘think of Me’ from ‘Phantom of the Opera’.
That’s a tough song, but little David made it his own and gave it a new identity! Randy and Paula thought he was great, while Simon though it was one of his weakest performances! What do you think?

The fifth to sing was Carly Smithson and she did ‘All I Ask of You’.
Carly shouted the song through! She tried her best though!
The unexpected thing was that Simon didn’t comment on her shouting, but said that she enjoyed it! What does that mean?

The last to sing was David Cook and he did ‘Music of the Night’.
David did great with the Phantom of the Opera song and his might be the best performance of the night!

Who wrote they’re ticket out? Maybe Brooke White?
We’ll reveal that in the Results article!