Mo #2 ???? What the heck? The teachers complain complain then complain, next they put him #2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

They are messing with him!!!!!!!!! But he deserves sormay/kondara 3ala rassooo

I don't have anything against this list but I can't understand why teachers praise Nader in the evaluations but when it comes to top 5 he is rarely included in it. Can anyone explain the reason for me?
And if it goes on like this, they will send all of the students with nader and Diaa to Italy.

Really i was shocked for Moustafa, this was unfair, this shows that this is a true game but we lebanese we do not have place between u Arabs, Moustapha was one of the best and freindly guy but at d last moment they betrayed him

Mustapha OUT! ! ! !

Mirhan got the votes and :

Badr, Abdalla & Saad voted for Mustapha, the rest voted for Amal!!!!!!!!

Wish it was Mo that was kicked out!!

Did anyone see how Mirhan pushed eveyone away from Mustapha to hug him and rub against him one more time... that girl needs some ;)

Im not Lebanese but I fully agree with you christy ... Mirhan should be out .... no voice and no ethics...

hey ahbal

im not trying to point u out of all ppl but y do u have so much hate for mohamad wat did he ever do to u

didnt u hear him in the prime today he was amazing

ur talking about how everyone voted for amel and u focus on talking bout how u want adam out

srry i wasnt going to say something in the beginning but we get it we dont need a reminding like y u keep mentioning him if u dont like him talk bout who u like

ADAM TOP STAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =]] lol

O.M.G! Are they going to take the whole academy with Nader??? That is soooooo stupid, what is wrong with Madam Rola, it won't feel special, if all of them go. Poor Nader that is awful! It is really stupid, wallah this woman has a problem with Nader, all of them do!!!!! Today he only sand half a song!!! When others got 2!!!

p.s I am soooooo annoyed why that idiotic Mirhan came back! Yeah don't forget Egypt is a BIG COUNTRY! And all the slutty men must have voted for her, to see more of her fatty blob shaking!!

Nader you are simply the best! < Soooo sweett!!!

oh gosh ...........!!!!
i really feel angry and astonished.
this is totally unfair , mustafa desreve to stay more.
it's also strange that the others didnt vote for him........!!!!!!!!!!!
i need to know why they wanna keep that shit namely " academy's angel"
sooooooo boring indeed.

REEMA I DNT KNOW WHERE THE HECK UR FROM ...BUT WATCH UR GODDAMN MOUTH..OKAY..IM EGYPTAIN AND ALL MEN ARE PERVERTS NOT ONLY EGYPTAINS OKAY..SO WATCH UR MOUTH BIATCH!!!

THANX FOR ALL STUDENTS TO VOTE FOR MUSTTYYY! AND THANX TO DA FANS AND I WILL MISS U ALOT MUSTY I REALLY LOVE U AND ITS ASHAME FOR MIRHAN NW COZ MUSTY HAS LEFT AND I JUST SOW HER ON STAR ACADMEY TV AND SHE WAS POUR CRYING! SHE REALLY LOVES HIM! I DONT KNW WHY THEY KEPT THE SHYT AMEL, SHE CANT EVEN SING OR NOTHING MAN! MUSTYYYYYYYYY U WILL BE MISSED BADLY! I LOVE U,I LOVE U,ILOVE U

I don't get why diaa is in the top 5?
Anyways... cannot believe that Mostapha left Mirhan should have left!!!!! Reema i do agree with you, Egypt is a big country!!!! It's population is massive!!!
All sleazy men over the world must have wanted to see her mouse face, and chubby body haha!!

Noooo Safo, is is soooo sweett!

P.s Saad got to go alone to Russia, but Nader gets 2 people with him!!! It is sooo obvious Rola has a thing for saad!!

why do use not LIKE MIRHAN wat has she done ?? SHE REALLY LIKED MUSTAFA SO DATS NT A BAD THING

shame on them , that's obviously hambug.
moustapha is the best and amal is sweet and mirhan should be out , no offense but he's out of standard.
love u moustapha , saad and nader

Why does everyone hate Diaa I don't get it? Is it because she is Moroccan? I don't understand the Moroccan students in StarAc are the least favorite?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I always get affended when people threat Moroccans differently!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By the way Rula did not send Diaa with Nader for the heck of it she too won top in case you forgot.

This prime, I really like Moe, he should win tip one next week otherwise I'll be pissed. Shahinaz was great and I liked that she outshined Angham whom I don't care for.

Mirhan should've left and Mustapha should've had a second chance. By the way I think he did better than Abdallah in the Tableau.

Good Luck to All the Students :)

MOSTOFA LUV U EVERBODIES GONE MISS U LUV U SO MUCH AMELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL HATE HER SO MUCH SHE HAS NO VOICE I HATE HER BUT MOSTOFA LUV U NO ONEZ GONE EVER FORGET U YOULL BE IN EVERYBODIES HEARTZ LUV U HABEBEY LM GONE MISS U :(

I AM DEVESTARTED THAT MUSTAFA IS OUT

but to lina , ahbal and reema !! YOU'D BETTER WATCH YOUR MANNERS .. WHAT THE HEELL DO YOU THINK YOUR DOING? EAT YOUR HEARTS OUT MERIHAN STAYED .. how old are you ? 12? damn it .. behave yourselves i wonder how you look ? flawless i guess ?

for any1 who hates amal m i am soooooooooo happy she came back.........n sad coz safo left but dat doesnt mean u have to call her shit r u crazy amal m iz not some1 u can hate its not that she put a gun to their heads n demanded them to vote for her.she even told them dat it will be logical if they vote her out coz she got her chance but by the end of the day its their freakin wish......shes bak hahahahhaha IN UR FACE jerks

to ms independent and any way amel m has no voice shell be oyt by next week mate!!!!

we dont hate any1 coz we dont even knw dam! BUT WE ARE SAYING THAT SAFO SHOULD HAVE GOT A SECOND CHANCE COZ DATS amels second tym dats not fair on safo ok MS INDEPENDENT

TO AHBAL,

I got one thing to say for you, you are either extremely stupid and you dont read what you type or you just have some mental issues that make you hate people that much.
Anyway, you need help big time, to prove my point you called yourself ahbal, so what does that tell us, but anyway keep sending comments because thats probably your only way of contacting with people because i cant imagin you have any friends.

Lina....Diaa was the light of this prime & every prime.She deserves not only top 5 but top 1
Do u think Amal B ballout deserves top1 better?
Zaher & Nader betrayed Safo who was their best friend...that was unexpexted
the witch should have gone not Safo
Go Diaa & Saad...you are the best

MIRHAN I HATE U!!!!!!!!!!

7araaaam i cant believe Mustafa left :(
im glad amel stayed......but that cheap thing mirhan......she makes me sick, kteer sa2eeeeeleh ou tidala3 zyaadeh......ma 3anda wala zarret hadameh!

Tara,
I wouldn't say that. Nader is the only one to get top 5 more then once. I am just dissappointed he didn't sing Samo Zein's song today.

christy,
chill out. No one "betrayed" Mustafa and as it has been said mant times before he is not one of the best. And though I think Mirhan should have left, everyone voted as they should have. No one betrayed anyone.

Nader voted for the Tunisian just like Saad voted for the Lebnani.
Amel B. voted with the one closer to her.
Dia voted for the closest girl left to her.
Shahinaz was never close with Mustafa and thus voted for Amel.
Mohammad voted for the girl that treats him nicer then anyone.
Zaher voted for Amel because she and him were closer friends.

Moi,
Nader voted for his countrywoman. That's not betrayal. He voted for whom he should have voted for. Just like Saad voted for Mustafa even though they were never friends. That is not in any way betrayal. Nader did the right thing.
And if I recall correctly Mustafa did not invite Zaher on the outing, and he did not vote for Zaher either time he was nominee. Zaher voted for Amel because she is good to him.

mostafa voted 4 zaher with asma. ok i hate
zaher and all...............

i love u safoo......................

miss u safoooooo......................

marya..... loves...u mustafa......................

YAAAAY!!! i cant believe mirhan is back yes iv been voting for her from tue thank goodness.. i told all of u mirhan haters tht shes gonna stya whether u like it or not.. MIRHAN I LOVE YOU U R THE STAR!!! but i totally agree tht amal m. should have left tht witch mustafa is waaay betta than her... i mean the students r soo dumb.... anyway im still relievd tht mirhan is backk....... mirhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan u rock!

i am soo sad and happy at the same time, coz i didnt wanna safo to leave, bt at sametime i wanted amal to come bk, y didnt mirhan leave ah man.

anywayz i am also soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo happy for amola b congrat at last thy gave the top 1to her, maybe she had better weeks that she could have taken the top 1 in other then this week, bt at least she did get to top 1for her hard work.

gooooooooo NADAR, AMAL B, amal m, saad, diaa, zaher and mohamed

by the wayy WALEG plllz post the prime becoz i didnt get to watch it.. i would really appreciate it. u guys r the best gooo waleg.. thank you

Thanks for being a helpful website!

to all who think that mirhan will be the star, aaah, well dont, cause, wtff, why would she be the star, when they got ppl like adam, or saad, or nader, or boodi, or diaa, or shahi, she will never be the star, even if she bought they academie, and for 2night, am gonna miss toofi so much, he was a sweet heart, AMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAL, wb sweety, tu es tres belle, je'taime, good luck for the others, and i hope moe is the star

sousou, I cannot agree more with you(although I don't hate Mirhan)!
What is it with people against Dia and pro Nader? I think Nader is good, but not excellent, and I agree with the teachers when they said he needs to start giving more! I think this is the first time Nader wasn't included. And it's a game people, don't get too mad when your favourite isn't included in the top 5, or leaves or doesn't win, etc...
When Hanaa lost to Joseph, did I (or other Moroccans or Hanaa-fans) start calling Joseph names? Some people really take things too seriously, really! It's a game, it's already calculated! Everything!
Congrats Amal B! You could've done better last prime, but you deserve it! I hope you'll have a good time in Italy with Nader and Dia(who deserved it as much as Nader!).
I'm really glad Amal M came back, but Mostapha good luck in your further life! Please graduate and Inchallah you'll have a good diplome and maybe we'll hear from you again?
Yezen, you wrote a great comment :)
Abdulaziz, go and check Dailies-page 50, I hope you can still use it!

maghrebi from belgium, Moi i agree with you both 100%, finally people who make perfectly good sense.

this top 5 thing is crap
what the hell is diaa doing in the top five.. dont u all think Shahinaz shud've been in the top 5 if not top 1... she sang like the entire prime and her evalu was great...
i dont get why they act this way... crapppy

im sooo shocked mostafa went out =[
im not sad that amel came bak
but im realllyyy upset mostafa went out
*
that stupid b**** rola planned all this 2 happen
I
HATE
HER
errrrrrggg..
x

i think that the top 5 was fair even though i think shahina shouldve been in there some where. Anyway to reema, y is it saad's fault that madme rula treats him like this? but i can tell u y: he deserves it!!! he treats everyone equally and he never causes problems he is always kind and tries to resolve problems that happen in the academy. btw abdullah is travelling or already traveled (im not sure) alone so y did u only hav to comment on Saad???
P.S amel shouldve left only because it was mustafa and mirhans's first time while it was her second, they at least deserve a second chance...
LUV U SAAS, NADER, AMAL B, and DIAA!!!

Wow Mohammed top2:::he really deserve it.. i hope next week top1

Slowly this competition is getting more and more fair.
Its a good thing that nader wasnt included much because like Madame Mary said he needs to work on his voice. I think Nader is mainly a performer which is okay for this show but voice is the main part and hes got one of the weakest voices. i think Dia has stronger voice in many ways and shes great to watch performing, she deserved to be in the top 5!Im really starting to like her performances.
I think Moustafa did better then Abdullah in the ya bint al jeerany and Abdullah didnt really have the best voice for it so Wadi3 shouldnt have removed Mohammed.
Mohamme did great and really proved to Madame Rula thats hes a real star, when he came out and sang he didnt even seem like he was one of the students because he was soo professional. I love how he gets into so many problems inside the academy but still manages to sign perfectly without forgetting lines!
I think Bader also did well, people usually underestimate tis guy but he has a better voice then Moustafa and Zaher so doesnt deserve to go at the moment.
I think Amal M and Moustafa were the ones who deserved to stay because Mirhan has teh weakest voice. But next weeks nominees will be something like this :
Mirhan - the teachers have alreayd said she has the weakest voice in the girls.
Zaher - he didnt do well in the prime and really has no voice at all.
Amal M - even though i love this girl, she has an average voice but still isnt good enough.

dalida...............then i guess zaher n khalid shdnt have stayed as long as they did...iz that wat u mean? amel m iz way more talented than zaher n khalid put together

in zaher's case he iz still in the academy

I HATE ZAHER VERY VERY VERY MUCH AND I HATE AMAL M AND MOAHMMED TOOO. I CAN'T BELIEVE THAT MOSTAFA IS OUT. OH MY GOD ITS UNFAIR. WE WILL HAVE MOSTAFA BACK AGAIN COZ HE DESERVE TO STAY.

AMAL TOP 1!!! FINALLY!!!!

YOU DESERVE IT MY ANGEL (k)(k)(k)

Plz guys u cant blame zaher 4 not voting for Mostafa coz lastweek mostafa voted 4 Adnan coz he was his friend and we didnt say anything against Mostafa coz Adnan is his friend as well as Amal Mahalawi is Zahers best friend in the academy or Are u blind and havent been watching the same show that we r watching?since the very begining Zaher and Amal M had this wonderful frienship and they were always togother and if Mostafa was with somebody else Zaher would have voted for him coz Zaher is a real man ,white heart and respectful?why u didnt say a word against Shahinaz? I believe she also choze her Friend Mahalawi and it is her choice.
And for those who r saying ,why Zaher is still in the academy ? i will answer coz he has a sweet and romantic voice that we die for. all the girls that i know in different schools adore Zaher coz he is so cute ,best personality and so respectful .and if u want the real reason why Mostafa left is simply bez of Mirhan and do u know why coz all the time that poor Mostafa was tired from rejecting Mirhan and saying no to her and that he doesnt love her .she was all over him all the time and i feelt sorry fo.r him coz he was harrassad by Mirhan who is 25 years olds and have no shame so Mostafa in his mind was buzy all the time with Mirhan issue so wake up coz she is the one to blame.Zaher we love u and believe in u .Enough said.

nadia i have nothing against zaher i actually like him but i was making a point to dalida if u scroll up a bit u will know wat i am talkin abt
tc

i dont get wat u mean ms independent! we are all angry coz dats safoo first time dats all! and zaher is in the acadmey nt coz his voice but coz his look! i like zaher for dat dats all

MS independent basically what everybodie is sayin that ther so anoyed that safo went out thats all we get it that she didnt put a gun through ther heads and said pick me!

myyy goooddd ii hattteee AMALL M !! WTFF??? SHE GOT HER CHANNCEE!! THIS IS SOO NOT FAIIRR!! HE HAS A BETTER TALENT THAN HER! UHHH I HATE AMALL M SOO MUCHH!!! MIRHANN AS WELL! U SL*T !! DID U C WUT SHE WUZ WEARING AT THE PRIME ? THE SL*TTIEST CLOTHES OF ALL GIRLS AND SHE WUZ DANCING IN A SL*TTY WAY AS HAIFA AND SANG HER SONNG!!

GOO AMALLLL B MYY ANGELL U DESERVE TO BE NUMBER ONE FROM WEEK 1 !! AND ZAHHEERR II LUVVV UUU<3

I HATE AMAL M 2 !!! :@:@:@ SHEZZ SOO UGLYY WITHOUT MAKE UPP!! IN THE ACADEMMYY!! BUT IN THE PRIME WITH THE HELP OF MAKEUP SHE GLOWS!! OMMGG!! UGLLLYYY WH*RE !

noo mustaffaa 7abeebyyy ii luvv uu! i wish u all da best away frm those monsters that dnt respect u !

and amal boushousha i luvv uu more than any other candidate! u deserve everything!! ii luvvv uu<3 ii luvv her hair as well:P

gooo MUSTAFFAAA AND AMAL BOUSHOUSHA!<3

congratz amal b ur the star of staracademy 2008! u glow more than a star<3 peaple this comment place isnt for talking bout the nomination results its about top 5 !!

shame zaher!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shame moe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shame shahinaaz!!!!!!!!!!
sahame dia!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shame amel b!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shame nader!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

they all r jelous of mostafa coz he is muchmuch better thn all

may god bless him in future ..........

miss u mustafa always

unfiar star ac 5 sucks sucks

they dint give him a chance crying crying uch >>>>>>>>