LBC Star Academy 5 - Prime 10 LIVE

To kick off the tenth prime of Star Academy 5, Egyptian singer Angham sings one of her popular songs 'Kol Ma Ne2rab' and Shahinaz sings along.
The surprising thing is that Angham's performance wasn't impressive at all! Her voice seemed weak and the music was louder than her!

The 1st tableau if the night is totally Lebanese! Mohammad starts to sing as the rest of students do a bit of Dabkeh and sing in the background.
Then Saad comes in with a Rababah and sings 'Diggi Diggi Ya Rababah'.

The nominees enter the stage and the 1st to sing is Amal M., she sings something French.
I think she sings Entre Nous by Chimene Badi.
Then Mostafa sings 'Saalouni' by Wael Kfouri.
Mirhan sings last and she does a Haifa Wehbe song! I think it's 'Fakerni'.

It's time for Amel Bent to sing her 1st song of the night, she does her popular debut song 'Ma Philosophie'. Diaa sings along with her.

The second tableau is amazing! Three huge washing machines up there and on top are the students singing 'Ya Bent el Jeeran' by Rami Ayach. Oh! They're doing laundry too!
Abdallah goes first, then Mostafa takes over.

Angham sings again ... she performs her song 'Atmanalo el Kheir' with Shahinaz.

As for Friend of the week ... it's a girl this week ... it's Amal M. !

Mohammad appears from behind a huge screen! I thought it was another surprise guest!
He sings one of those patriotic songs by Wadih al Safi, i think it's entitled 'Yabni'.

Bader drops from the ceiling of the theater … beside him sits Shahinaz.
They sing Ibrahim al Hakami’s debut song ‘Ma Baddi Illak Shou Benni’.
The Academy's Angels are going to perform now!
Amal M. , Amal B. and Mirhan sing 'Ashteki Minno' by Nancy Ajram.

Amel Bent performs the legendary Rocky song Eye of the Tiger.
Joining her are Zaher and Diaa ...
Sorry, but if you know and love the original song, you won't like their performance at all!
I know it's remix, but it could have been better!

The 3rd tableau tonight is set in a bakery … YUMMY!
And Shahinaz sings ‘el hilwa di’ … the Dania al Khatib remix of the original song.
Amel Bent sings again … this time she sings her song Nouveau Francais alongside Nader and Amal B.
It seems it's Zaher's 21st B-day ... he gets a huge surprise! An unexpected visit from his best friend Raida! Happy B-day Zakzak!

To finish off the prime ... i mean just before announcing the voting results ... Angham sings another one of her songs.

As for the voting results, Mirhan gets 40.41% and thus is saved by the audience.
The choice is now between Mostafa and Amal M.
The students give the majority of their votes to Amal M. and Mostafa leaves the Academy! Hard Luck Mostafa!

Gosh! What a surprise! I thought his friends would give him a chance ... but those are the harsh rules of the game! And Amal M. has many friends inside the academy ... it must have been a difficult choice for the students.


Archived Comments ↓  Post a New Comment →

  1. zahretelsham
    zahretelsham

    Abdallah showed tonight that he can't sing and his voice is weak....he really deserves to be a nominee next week I dislike the guy verymuch

  1. Ahbal
    Ahbal

    loool el bent amal sang well :)

    the laundry tableau is funny, makes doing laundry seem fun :) I can't wait for MO's bahdaleh today :))))))

  1. zahretelsham
    zahretelsham

    wow Mohammad he's a true star......... regardless what he does

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    MOE rocks the PRIME.... he doesnt even need that song that was taken away from him.. MOE U ROCK good job in the mawal and song

  1. Ahbal
    Ahbal

    Mo the sicko is singing with his hand waving like an idiot. Moving the mic from one hand to the other. His shirt open and a necklace that has his serial number and his house information (just incase he forgot) ...loool

    Majnooon ebn majaneen :)

  1. roula
    roula

    wlek yo2borneh rabbak malla sot ya mohamad

  1. Ahbal
    Ahbal

    Mo the sicko is singing with his hand waving like an idiot. Moving the mic from one hand to the other. His shirt open and a necklace that has his serial number and his house information (just incase he forgot) ...loool

    Majnooon ebn majaneen :)

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    ahbal would u give it a rest.. its like ur living just to see moe getting tortured... get a life bro seriously u NEED to get another hobby

  1. dima
    dima

    mhamad ifg u werent starac 5 thenn sth is wrng int his world

  1. felicia
    felicia

    Ahbal...........jealous much?? LOL


    Is it just me or did amal bent totally outshine dia? It was as if dia wasnt even there.

  1. roula
    roula

    ahbal
    shou ra2yak trouh tomm halak
    3abeleh a3ref shou bye3jbak bi hal deneh
    eleh senten bo2ra ur posts w ma 3ejbak shi
    shou ra2yak tesh7at halak bi tari2a mhazbeh

  1. sage
    sage

    Mohammed has by far the most beautiful voices of the guys. The only thing that restricts him from winning it all is his attitude. I guarantee if he was as nice as Nader, everyone on here would be saying that he will win SA5. But his attitude has turned people off. I ope he can turn it around because if we base the winner strictly on their singing talent, he is the winner.

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    awwwwww bader looks totally cute sitting on that swing thing next to shahy .. he sang really well.. but he needs to move his hands a bit instead of being stiff..

    ahbal ur getting BORING...

  1. Tara
    Tara

    Maybe you can criticize Mohammad's personality and behavior but his voice is perfect.

  1. Yalie
    Yalie

    can someone explain why shahinaz is NOT in the top 5?! She did wonderfully last prime...

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    woooooooooohooooooooooooo mohammed is number 2 yaaaaaaaaaay ya rab e5aleek wa ti6la3 top 1 inshallah
    GO mooooooooe...
    mabrooook amal bashoosha she deserves it =) this weeks top 5 is fair but shahinaz should be their regardin her evaluation was the best ...

    and the singer amal is great mashallah.. shes really nice to look at and listen too shes light on the eyes and ears..
    this prime really turned out to be cool n fun unlike what i expected..

  1. cupcake
    cupcake

    Thank god the song in Rocky movie didn't have a chance to have Diaa's voice in .. otherwise, Rocky will never made it to be a legend and classic forever!

    Diaa's voice is .... well no voice, she is just screaming and needs to join the British council in morocco as soon as she is out of the academy!!

  1. layla
    layla

    im really sick of people always picking on dia they are other people in the academy who should have been gone a long time ago

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    another thing that shows how moe is being unfairly treated.. why does zaher and dia get surprises for their birthday.. not that i have anything against zaher and diaa.. i like both of them ... while moe got what??? punished in george's class... pffft... ..this treatment will drive anyone nuts... poor moe ya3ni he is a human being... and every person like to feel special atleast one day in a year which is on his birthday..coz its his day...
    btw its my birthday today 28th march =) my gift is seeing moe in the top 5 and seeing him sing well =)

  1. Jo
    Jo

    happy birthday BamBina!!!

    best of wishes:)

  1. layla
    layla

    let me just say that i am really sick of people throwing really bad comments about dia they are alot of people in the academy who really that good anyway.

  1. suzi
    suzi

    OMG MUSTFU WANT OUT HURRYA IAM HAPPY THAT HE WANT AND AMEL STAYED HAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY HE DOSNT HAVE A VOUCE ANYWAY LOL HAHAH

  1. felicia
    felicia

    Omg, all the girls are crying!

  1. suzi
    suzi

    OMG MUSTFU WANT OUT HURRYA IAM HAPPY THAT HE WANT AND AMEL STAYED HAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY HE DOSNT HAVE A VOUCE ANYWAY LOL HAHAH

  1. vanvoon
    vanvoon

    Noooooooooo i cant believe moustapha is out..that was totally not fair...amal m already got her chance...OMG i cant imagine the academy without him...I HATE THIS!

  1. daydreamer
    daydreamer

    what the hell they were thining of??
    it's not fair at all...safo deserved 2 stay as amal got her chance b4.....
    really i can't believe it...
    poooooooooooor safooooo

  1. Yalie
    Yalie

    AMAL M YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!

    7aram mostafa, why did Mirhan get the highest votes?

  1. hey
    hey

    I HATE THIS SHIT OMG MUSTAFA IS OUT??? WTF ALL THE GIRLS COME ON GIVE HIM A f***N CHANCE WTF HE IS WAY BETTTER THEN AMAL I LOVE AMAL BUT COME ON HE DESERVES A CHANCEE OMG ALL THE TEACHERS LOVE MOSTAFA THEY ARE GONG TO FREAK AND COME ON NADER HE INVITED YOU TO THE TRIP WITH HIM WHAT BACKSTABERS OMG I HATE THIS I HATE STAR ACADEMY NOW THIS IS SOOO NOT FAIRRR


    MOSTAFA INTA STARR I LOVE YOUUU

  1. layla
    layla

    i miss the voting results who voted for each person

  1. Nadia
    Nadia

    All I can say is this is completely unfair! I'm so disappointed that Mustafa was the one to leave. I truly believe he deserved a second chance...Good luck Mustafa, you are already a star!!!!!!

  1. Yezen
    Yezen

    Well lets see,

    First of all I am dissappointed that Nader did not yet get to sing the arabic song he had planned. I wonder why they put it off still? He sounded great when he was practicing. He only got 1 part. Nader needs to sing more variety.
    Second, happy birthday to Zaher, but he did terrible in "Eye of the Tiger".
    Third, Shahinaz did well tonight but got too many parts. 4 parts? it's too much. One should have gone to Amel B. Mohammad did very well, Saad and Abdullah only had one part.

    I am very sorry to Mustafa, but that is the way things worked out.

    Lastly I'll have you all know I am very happy for Amel Ma7alawy. She came back by getting votes she deserved. Nader, Dia, and Amel B. were from il Maghreb and close to Amel M. so they all voted for her. Shahinaz is a much closer friend to Amel then Mustafa.

    Zaher and Mohammad were real men today and voted for the person who deserved their vote and who had stood with them instead of listening to the pressure from the audience.
    Congradulations Amel M.
    Mustafa, has done well and come far.
    Mirhan.... I don't understand why people vote for her but oh well. They will likely use her voting strength to take out Badr.

  1. nat
    nat

    I HATE THIS SHIT OMG MUSTAFA IS OUT??? WTF ALL THE GIRLS COME ON GIVE HIM A f***N CHANCE WTF HE IS WAY BETTTER THEN AMAL I LOVE AMAL BUT COME ON HE DESERVES A CHANCEE OMG ALL THE TEACHERS LOVE MOSTAFA THEY ARE GONG TO FREAK AND COME ON NADER HE INVITED YOU TO THE TRIP WITH HIM WHAT BACKSTABERS OMG I HATE THIS I HATE STAR ACADEMY NOW THIS IS SOOO NOT FAIRRR


    MOSTAFA INTA STARR I LOVE YOUUU

  1. ildivo
    ildivo

    ooooooooooh the prime was great and ithink the star of this prime is shahinaz she looks different right guys??!! she lost some pounds and with her new look she looks amazing,and ilove amal benttttttttt her voice is amazing,and im really sorry that mustafa is outttttttt ithought he will stay really he deserves it more than mirhan and im really shocked coz iwas sure that he will stay,ba ialso like amal m,and mohamed sang beautifully,and sure naderrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr,

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    thanks jo *not a flower but a bouquet of them for u*

    aww poor saffoo....i wanted mirhan to be out but... what to do...what im sure of is that she wont be in the finals ..so one or two more weeks of her wont kill me... =p.... GoOd LUCK mustafa...welcome back amal M......

    the prime finished fast.. its shorter than usual

  1. ms independent
    ms independent

    r u crazy so wat if amal got her chance......khalid was nominated 4 freakin times n zaher was nominated twice........n its their wish whoever they vote for..........i can say for sure dat amal m iz wayyyyyyyyyy more talented than safo cut her some slack

  1. maruoma
    maruoma

    mirhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan congrats babeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

  1. zizo
    zizo

    OMGGGGGGGGGGGG !!! I WUZZ RLYY CRYINGGG THAT MUSTAFA LEFTT!! NOO WAYYYYY 7AARRAAAMM AMAL GOT HER F*CKINGG CHANCEE !!! :@:@:@:@ II HATEE STARACADEMMYY! AND WTFFF MIRHANN STAYSSS AS WELL???? OMGGG I HATE MIRHANNN ALOOOTT AND AMALL M THAT B*TCHH I HATEE HERR!! :@:@:@ NOOO WAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYY

  1. Engy....from...egypt
    Engy....from...egypt

    OMGGGGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!! i cant believe it bgd!!!!!!steaf is oout!!!!!!!im totally shocked!!!!!
    n he got only 3 votes by his friends!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    im disappointed!!!!!!! its like a night mare!!!!anyway, its his fate!!!!!!!!!!!!i wish him the best of luck

  1. 100% Masreya
    100% Masreya

    I'm SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MAD!!! Mostapha deserved another chance! BEGAD 7ARAM! Amal needed to get out, hopefully she'll get out next week. Begad 7aram!!!! I'm gonna miss Mostapha and he had a beautiful voice. OMG, I HATE AMAL! First nees then Mostapha, I hate Star Academy NOW! And whats with Amal. B being top 1, Mohammed deserved Top 1 and Ahahinaz Top 2.

    Miss u Mostapha and Nees!!!

  1. Redd
    Redd

    Congratulations Mirhan and Amel M.!! I love them both!! I'm so glad that Amel M is back she deserves it soo much! I knew that she would get the majority of the friends votes, think about it:
    Mohammad- She calms him down after the fights.
    Zaher-Best friend, she also saved him last week.
    Amel B-Best Friend,
    Diaa-Best Friend
    Shahy-close Friend
    Nader- because she's from Tunis, his country

    Amel M is the friendliest girl in the academy, she won friend of the week twice in a row! Adn she has a better voice than Safo and Mirhan! Go Amel M!!!!!

  1. ildivo
    ildivo

    ooooooooooh the prime was great and ithink the star of this prime is shahinaz she looks different right guys??!! she lost some pounds and with her new look she looks amazing,and ilove amal benttttttttt her voice is amazing,and im really sorry that mustafa is outttttttt ithought he will stay really he deserves it more than mirhan and im really shocked coz iwas sure that he will stay,ba ialso like amal m,and mohamed sang beautifully,and sure naderrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr,and diaa sang beautifully specially the first song,its great songgggg ppl u should search for the lyrics because its great song specially for the girlsss

  1. kayy
    kayy

    THIS ISNTT FAIRR AT ALLLLL YOU ARE HONESTLY GOING TO SIT HERE AND TELL ME MUSTAPHA SHOULD OF LEFTT? II AM SOOOOOO DISSAPOINTED I CANT BELIEVE THIS HAPPENED AND I KNOW ALOT OF PEOPLE ARE GOING TO AGREE WITH MEE

    MUSTAPHAA YOU ARE THE STAR HABIBI WE LOVE YOU SOO MUCHH

  1. Tina
    Tina

    can some on pleaaasee tell me who voted for amal and who voted for mostada? pleaseeee

  1. steph
    steph

    okay

    shanaza - amal
    diaa- amal
    amel- amal
    nader- amal
    mohmad-amal
    zaher-amal
    bader-MOSTAFA:D
    SAAD-MOSTAFA:D

    dont get me wrong i like amal but mostafa deservers a second chance

  1. Nadia
    Nadia

    Mustafa plzzzzzz come back! This is so unfair! He deserved a second chance!!!!!!!!!

  1. kayy
    kayy

    THIS ISNTT FAIRR AT ALLLLL YOU ARE HONESTLY GOING TO SIT HERE AND TELL ME MUSTAPHA SHOULD OF LEFTT? II AM SOOOOOO DISSAPOINTED I CANT BELIEVE THIS HAPPENED AND I KNOW ALOT OF PEOPLE ARE GOING TO AGREE WITH MEE

    MUSTAPHAA YOU ARE THE STAR HABIBI WE LOVE YOU SOO MUCHH

  1. kimmycrew
    kimmycrew

    this prime was soooo boring!
    a part from Moe who did a very great job! he sings well during all the primes and he is always good during the eval, he should have been Top 1, but yallah, next week inch'allah!
    angham, keep away from any LIVE performance, u r just good to sing in studios not in front of an audience T.T
    i m going to miss sapho :( i whished he stayed and mirhan went out!
    i think that amel bent wasn't in her day, she usually sings better than that, i guess she was little afraid...

  1. nooooo
    nooooo

    can u plz write the voiting result 4 each person

  1. nana
    nana

    wow, i'm shocked that mostafa is out! i thought one of the girls will leave but that's what you get when you are not friends with everyone!

    shahinaz and mohmad votes changes everything and they picked the one they loved the most!

    the prime was nice, shahinaz should've been top1 not amal b! she simply doesn't have a voice and can't act!! i don't know how the academy thinks but she deserve to be happy and go to italy so it's all cool!

    nader got a small part and he isn't in top5!! i think he's gonna be nominated soon sadly

    zaher needs to show himself more! they just give him a small part each prime and they expect him to improve! give the guy a break

    mohmad , classy voice and he was awesome tonight

  1. ildivo
    ildivo

    oooooh ma god waleg plzzzzz put clear password coiz ikeep resendin ma comment,anyway the prime was greatttttttt really no mistakes and ithink the star of this prime is shahinaz she looked pretty specially with her new look or haircut and she lost few pounds.....
    ilove amal bent she is great singer and ppl plz stop pickin on diaa she sang nicley specially the first song by the way ppl u should know the meaning of the lyrics specially the girls im sure u will love itttttttt,and mohamed sang beautifully,
    and sure naderrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr,
    ooh and im shocked iwas soooooooo sure that mustafa will return ba noo he is out im really sorry for hime he deserve to stay more than mirhan,im happy that amal m returned,and wow amal b prefered the travilin over 5000dolar greatttttt lool now she can see safina.

  1. shadi
    shadi

    I am lebanese but that doesnt effect my opinion, i like all 3 of them, amal m the most, she is soo nice and calm and talented. i wished if all 3 would stay but i was sure that mirhan was gonna get the votes and amal m the students votes. rola saad knew how to get rid of him, offcourse its her game, she knows how to get rid of the students. and now they will use mirhan as a weapon to take badr out, obvious, offcourse placing him with amal m, so amal comes again, then they're gonna use maybe nader or mohammad to get rid of merhan herself .....until a student last...i want amal boushousha or shahinaz to win.

    students to leave next are:
    badr
    zaher
    amal m
    nader
    mirhan

    the finalists:
    amal b
    shahinaz
    mohammad
    abdalla

    in between:
    dia
    saad


    i am really sad for mostapha he is a gr8 guy but am still happy for the girls.

    (2-0) for academy's angel and with zaher leaving soon, academy's angels would win!! and no academy brothers (last week adnan is out, this week mostapha, most probably zaher next week)

    GO Amal B, Shahinaz, Amal M, Dia

  1. moustafahayati
    moustafahayati

    first of all idk who suzi is but she needs to stfu because almost half the people on this show dunt know how to sing are UGLY and are asswholes and are still here. i cant believe he left the only reason i even watch this show is because of him and his beautiful smile. and wtf is wrong with zaher i cant believe he picked amal over moustafa idc that she voted for him that was her choice he dosent owe her anything because she did that. im so fuckin mad right now i cant believe habibii safo is gone. i feel like this is just a dream.

  1. WALEG
    WALEG

    First videos of the 10th prime are available on Waleg videos.

    Please no Capital letters and no loooOoong words
    Thank you.

  1. eve
    eve

    Oh, i started late and did not see saad perform at all so i am a bit disappointed but i am glad i did not miss mohammed’s solo. Damn, the guy can definitely sing! My sister who do not watch the show was like is he a student or guest? Angham did not do it for me, she looks really uncomfortable when she sang with shahinze. and bader did good i think. Zaher needs to go out asap, he really really can’t sing. Sorry to mustepha fans, the voting was so close, only 5 % or so difference and a big no unheard of for a Lebanese contestant. But i am happy to see amal m back. I hope she will not be a nomine next week. The star of the prime was mohammed ! but My star is saad.
    The students are back, they are like sad and staff...
    p.s guys don’t answer to ahbal ever, - just another attention seeker!

  1. Tara
    Tara

    Well don't try to say that Amal M. is more talented than Mustafa. It doesn't make any sense. He's a nice and friendly girl but when it comes to talent if Mustafa isn't more talented than her , at least they're the same but Mustafa has a distinguished presence on stage. He's a very charismatic person while Amal M. even can't smile easily on stage. Anyway Mustafa had not any chance to get to the finals and it's the same about Amal M. So being in the tour is the best thing they can achieve in this program. I think Mustafa will be treated like Wajdi and he'll be included in the tour besides Saad, Abdallah, Nader, Mohammad, Shahinaz,Diaa, Amal B and unfortunately Mirhane while Amal M. won't have this chance. She has not a lot of fans and most importantly she has nothing special to offer to the tour.

  1. zena
    zena

    WHAT just happend today was unfair....

    is zaher better than moustafa
    is badr better than moustafa
    is mirhan better than moustafa
    is amal m better than moustafa
    NOOOOOOOOOOOOO WAY.....
    I hope that moustafa gose to that tour but that depends om madame rola.....

    Hate Sahinaz and Zaher for not woting for moustafa....

  1. Abdulaziz
    Abdulaziz

    As the nominees both Mirhan and Sally last year (15th prime) had the same song; it should be still available in clips online (Sally and Shada). In (this) comparison (even) Sally sounds like a star.

  1. ?
    ?

    MOUSTAFA WENT OUT ?! STUPID ZAHER FOR NOT VOTING OMG HE WAS THE BEST WHAT'S WRONG WITH THIS YEAR ?! THIS IS SO UNFAIR NEES GOES OUT OMAR JESSICA THIS DUDE HAS TO COME TO THE TOUR LIKE THEY DID WITH IMED !

    OMG SO THAT STUPID MIRHAN AND UGLY GORILLA AMEL STAYS IN ?

  1. asmi
    asmi

    Totally not fair!!! its ok mustafa you are better then them anywhys!

  1. Abdulaziz
    Abdulaziz

    As the nominees both Mirhan and Sally last year (15th prime) had the same song; it should be still available in clips online (Sally and Shada). In (this) comparison (even) Sally sounds like a star.

  1. observer
    observer

    Whichever way you see it mirhan is to blame for mustepha’s early dismissal.
    She distracted him so that he can’t concentrate
    All the girls are a little bit jealous of the attention she gets from the boys so to spite her they voted against him
    All the boys kind of like her so, they got read of competition specially zaher, he always liked her but couldn’t do anything about it because of mustepha.

  1. sousou
    sousou

    Wow I am surprised that Mima got the audiance, I thought Mustapha would. Oh well. I really like Moe, Shahinaz and Diaa this prime. Tableaus were fun :)
    I never heard Amel Bent before but now I am hooked, I think she is really good. Not a big fan of Angham I think Shahinaz outshined her. Good for you Shahinaz.
    Best of luck to all the students :)

  1. Zozo
    Zozo

    Ohh the prime was very cool tonight, i'm very sorry 4 safo but that's life. I mean ok he is cute and everything and even if Amal M had already 1 chanse before she deserved to stay, her voice is better , BUT even better than Mirhan's . Ohh I really felt sorry 4 Amal when all the people in the audience just scream mustafa , but why hate those who did't vote 4 Mustafa it's their choice . I also think that it was very strong from them I mean that they did't let the audience influence them.

  1. dalia
    dalia

    This prime was so shyt coz SAFO left am really angry and wish u all da best SAFO!
    MIRHAN wish u all da best with zaher coz use are ma fav nw after Safo left! I WILL MISS WATCHING U ON TV! LOVE U LOADSS HAYTIE XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

  1. nsreen men falasteen
    nsreen men falasteen

    kayy i definetly agree w/ u!!!! i thnk mirhan or amal m shuda left but not mostafa!!!!!! i lluuvvv mostafa he wuz da 1st person in da academy i had a crush on!!!! bes anjed he can sing way better den both dem grls!!!!!! thad iz nootttt fair!!!! i bet da teachers feel stupid now!!!! nd y did mahlawe get mre votes den him???? i am sssooo mad!!! bes we all luv u mostafa nd anjed i thnk u r da best!!!!!!!! i hate mahlawe now!

  1. Sage
    Sage

    Honestly, I too believe that everyone should get a second chance, and I feel bad that Mostafa was voted out, but realistically, we will never win. He had started to become a tad too arrogant for my likes and well, life will go on without him.

    Congrats to Amal for Top 1. I thought it should have come way sooner, but I'm glad she won today. She'll have a lot of fun in Italy with Diaa and Nader!

  1. rana-lebanese
    rana-lebanese

    omg i cant believe mostafa left i keep thinking this is only a dream he is the best and he has the most amazing smile. it makes no sense he shouldnt have been nominee in the first place and its also not fair because everyone deserves a second chance and he never got his. mostafa even if ur not in staracademy we love u so much and we always will we will never forget u and ur still a star no matter what.
    I MISS U SAFOO :(

  1. Hanna
    Hanna

    I am sooooooooo worried about Nader if he has to face against Saudi or Jordan or any other country cuz soooooooo many here in Tunisian voted for Amal M. Please Nader work hard, if you are nominee once that means he will go out, and i will die!!!!!! :(

  1. rana-lebanese
    rana-lebanese

    omg i cant believe mostafa left i keep thinking this is only a dream he is the best and he has the most amazing smile. it makes no sense he shouldnt have been nominee in the first place and its also not fair because everyone deserves a second chance and he never got his. mostafa even if ur not in staracademy we love u so much and we always will we will never forget u and ur still a star no matter what.
    I MISS U SAFOO :(

  1. E
    E

    i'm happy for mirhan she is crying now let her fil the shit like what happen to asma wa adnan when she splite them .but i'm sad for mostafa good luck lebanon is proud of you.

  1. michelle
    michelle

    Mo was AMAZING tonight.

    Glad Amal M is back. shes gorgeous, charismatic, and has a sweet voice.
    btw- what did she win as friend of the week?

    I'll miss you Mustafaaaa

    Abdallah gets on my last nerve. He sings like he has potatoes stuck in his throat. Strong voice but not a nice one.
    He needs to leave. Seriously.
    Id rather see someone with a weak voice like Zaher or Badr win this thing than the sneaky donkey Abdallah.

  1. Kay
    Kay

    Thanks WALEG for the the summaries of the dailies and the videos.

    I'll give my 5 cents on the programe and the students, these are my personal thoughts. The prime today was ok, actually this season the primes are not that good, it's not the same without the Rahbani songs and Fairouz.

    As for the students:

    Saad- was one of my favourites but not anymore. His voice is boring and he is very sly.

    Zaher- seems like a nice guy but his voice is very weak.

    Dia- a very nice person although she seems to be going through depression. Her voice is nice but sometimes she shouts. I'm happy she isn't with Saad anymore.... and please don't tell me they are siblings!

    Amel M- what a pure heart she has. An ok voice.

    Mirhan- I feel bad for the girl, the programe is using her to create a new Haifa Wehbi. She is ok.

    Abdullah- my favourite voice in the academy. He has a lot of emotions when he sings. However I don't like his personality at all, he acts very childish. I do beleive he will be in the finals.

    Bader- ok voice, boring character. Enough said.

    Mohammed- a very nice voice, though not my fav. He is not being fake and that is why people hate him. I do admit sometimes he is annoying but that is how he is and you either accept him for who he is or not. However he should respect the teachers coz most of them are trying to teach him something new.

    Amel B- has lost her spark, she has an ok voice.

    Nader- a very very strong stage presence. I enjoy seing him on stage, but i don't like his voice and all the songs he sings sound the same. I don't think he will be successful outside the academy. His voice just doesn't do it for me.

    shahinaz- is not getting the credit she deserves. she will shine more and more in the coming primes.

    Mostapha- I was surprised that he left, I thought it would be Mirhan to go. His voice is very weak and he tends to shout alot while singing.

    This is definetly not the best season although there are better voices then all seasons. Well these are my thoughts, and thanks WALEG again.

  1. dalia
    dalia

    I REALLY WANT TO KNOW WHY EVERYONE DOSNT LIKE MIRHAN! WHAT HAS SHE DONE TO USE ? ANYONE ANSWER ME

    musty i wil miss u ! u are da BEST and the acadmey is shyt with out u

  1. zena
    zena

    Moustafa voted for dia (and gave her a chance) when she was nomine with khaled (and moustafa was closer to khaled) And now she votes for amal....
    Mirhan should have left
    I can understand the situation the student had but it was wrong to even put moustafa nomine at the first place when badr and zaher are weaker
    it´s all roulas faul, she plays wiht the student like shak how much money did she get for having badr left or zaher

  1. nessma
    nessma

    ah moustafa well he had to go anyways bas i thought not rite now it ws to early..... anyways go mima and i think amel was good and glad for both of them......... this mite sound stupid but still miss ahmed......k bie and go shahy love u so much and nader i thought he should have done that song in arabic i got goose bumps in the practice with mohameed!!!!!

  1. TO AHBAL AHBAL
    TO AHBAL AHBAL

    TO AHBAL,

    I got one thing to say for you, you are either extremely stupid and you dont read what you type or you just have some mental issues that make you hate people that much.
    Anyway, you need help big time, to prove my point you called yourself ahbal, so what does that tell us, but anyway keep sending comments because thats probably your only way of contacting with people because i cant imagin you have any friends.

  1. Marwa
    Marwa

    Wallah Haram if they make Nader a nominee, because he has a lot to show us! Today they only gave him Half a song, when other got 2 to 4 songs!!!! Its there fault! They better make him sing a lot more in the next prime hopefully!

  1. to the writer of ahbal and ahbal
    to the writer of ahbal and ahbal

    ahbal u honestly need help i have to go with the person who wrote to ahmal..... moe is an amazing person bas he has an anger problem..... also that was a bit too harsh there that wrote to ahbal but it was funny

  1. nessma
    nessma

    any body knoo the son mohammed and saad sang last week in the prime and the evaluation song shahy and most of the girls sang:) thanks rly appreciate that !!!

  1. nessma
    nessma

    and whoo are the singers:)

  1. mirhans brother
    mirhans brother

    gooooooooooooooooooooooooo mimaaaaaaaaaa 7ayete i luv u sis ur d best all d students were amazing 2day bt 7ayete sis ma tez3ale bcoz of mustafa dnt worry u will meet wiv him actually amal woud av gone out bcoz dis is d second time shes nominee

  1. jordanian princess
    jordanian princess

    omg, I'm so proud of mohammad!!!:)

    he waz the best in the prime!!!!

    Congrats moe on the Top 2, I'll say congrats to you next week when you get the top 1, inshallah because u deserve it!!!!:)

    goooo moe, you're the best from all of the rest!!!!!

  1. meemee
    meemee

    welcome back mirhaaaaaaaaaannn !!
    sad for mostafa :(

  1. jordanian princess
    jordanian princess

    omg, I'm so proud of mohammad!!!:)

    he waz the best in the prime!!!!

    Congrats moe on the Top 2, I'll say congrats to you next week when you get the top 1, inshallah because u deserve it!!!!:)

    goooo moe, you're the best from all of the rest!!!!!

  1. felicia
    felicia

    I want to give my 5 cents on each student too,lol. However, Idont speak arabic, so im going on stage presence, entertainment and whether or not i need to press mute when i hear the person sing.

    Mohamed- OMG, i love him, i could just listen to him sing all day, i dotn need to know the language.

    Dia- she is horrible, she doesnt sing, she shouts, next to amel bent she was invisible today.

    Zaher- NEXXXXT!!!! Why is he still there?

    Abdullah- His face makes me laugh, and that's not compliment, he has this goofy look, its annoying but his voice is ok i guess.

    Amal B- she reminds me of britney,(well when britney was hot) not the strongest voice but she's fierce

    Mirhan- she can sing????? she just pretends to be sexy, that's all, she can be the next haifa.

    Amel M- bless her heart, but she should be a model instead

    Bader- No stage presence at all but ok voice.

    Saad, he has nice eyes, his voice is ok, i get bored watching him perform though

    Naader- cant sing in english, his voice is mediocre but everyone seems to like him.

    Anywayz thanx 4 reading everyone, hehe!

  1. mohmd
    mohmd

    i am so sry 4 mostapha he deserves really 2 stay
    mabrooooooooook mimaa u r gr8

  1. Yezen
    Yezen

    Well lets see,

    First of all I am dissappointed that Nader did not yet get to sing the arabic song he had planned. I wonder why they put it off still? He sounded great when he was practicing. He only got 1 part. Nader needs to sing more variety.
    Second, happy birthday to Zaher, but he did terrible in "Eye of the Tiger".
    Third, Shahinaz did well tonight but got too many parts. 4 parts? it's too much. One should have gone to Amel B. Mohammad did very well, Saad and Abdullah only had one part.

    I am very sorry to Mustafa, but that is the way things worked out.

    Lastly I'll have you all know I am very happy for Amel Ma7alawy. She came back by getting votes she deserved. Nader, Dia, and Amel B. were from il Maghreb and close to Amel M. so they all voted for her. Shahinaz is a much closer friend to Amel then Mustafa.

    Zaher and Mohammad were real men today and voted for the person who deserved their vote and who had stood with them instead of listening to the pressure from the audience.
    Congradulations Amel M.
    Mustafa, has done well and come far.
    Mirhan.... I don't understand why people vote for her but oh well. They will likely use her voting strength to take out Badr.

  1. jana
    jana

    it was moustafa's fault for playing around and goofing around and not working hard....thats why he is out.

    Amel B deserved top 1, congrats to her, she deserved it a long time ago!
    shahinaz is shining more and more...
    mirhan seems more and more used by the academy as the "attention grabber"
    saad is boring
    abdullah is showing a horrible side to him lately...
    moe is improving VERY SLOWLY
    badr should be out
    zaher needs to shine more...
    nader hasn't changed but hes good
    dia is good.
    amel m- shes nice, but she will leave soon.

  1. sousou
    sousou

    Diaa was really good today. And for those who don't like her though luck.
    Moe, and Shahy did really well one of them should be top one next week. Mustapha did well in the tableau too bad he had to go, but it's game one of them has to go. I thought bader was scared to fall from the swing :) that's why he didn't move at all throught the song :)

    Zaher, was cute but didn't do well, so I think he is going to be nominated again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  1. Lou Lou (the original)
    Lou Lou (the original)

    TO ALL MIRHAN FANS:

    Can you please give me 5 strong reasons why she deserved to stay?

    Because I don't think she deserves to!

  1. mirhan is in
    mirhan is in

    shes preety
    she can sing
    she egyptian
    she can dance
    awesome person and funny
    .............................................

  1. W
    W

    Lou Lou (the original)

    I can give you 5 strong reasons why Marihan should leave right away:

    1. Very weak voice (worst one from girls)

    2. She uses her body and moves to get attention.

    3. She humuliated herself by going after a 18 year old kid even after he told her 10 times no.

    4. Very rude and aggresive especially when she get mad at somebody.

    5. She does not know how to forgive, you can see that when she deals with shahinaz and moe, still very cold with them.

  1. love shahy
    love shahy

    i dont care about anyone only shay she is amazing and pretty hard t obeat.. she looked amazing begad all that running worked.... vry pround of her and she improved love the eval,,,,,,,, k biee

  1. MOSTAFAAAAAAAAA
    MOSTAFAAAAAAAAA

    cant believe that mostafa got out omgg
    they should've gave him another chance, they way they gave amal another chance
    MOSTAFA YOU ARE THE BEST AND YOU'R THE STAR IN MY EYES AND EVERYBODY'S EYES
    I LOVE YOU MOSTAFA ALWAYS AND FOREVER

  1. layla
    layla

    i agree with sousou, dia, shahinaz, mohammed did very well everyone didn't really stand out that much tonight. anyway prime was boring as usual and went very fast why? but anyway based on tonight nominees will be zaher, bader and someone else i dont know who

  1. meemee
    meemee

    mirhan has a 1.strong personality
    2.she dance well
    3.her performance is awesome
    4.friendly
    5.sings well

  1. Yezen
    Yezen

    Dear Mirhan is in,
    - Mirhane is pretty. But so are Amel and Amel.
    - She can not sing well. All teachers agree on this.
    - Yes she is Egyptian. But all of them are from a country. Not sure of your point here.
    - She is a terrible dancer.
    - And people are very frustrated with her behavior and are fiding it immoral.

    felicia,
    I am aware of Nader's slight accent in english songs(English is my first language). But so do many European singers such as Allesandro Savilla. He actully has what is takes to be a world lass singer. His voice in english is far from mediocre. He is a good singer in all languages including arabic(every time I hear hi sing arabic it sounds good). Nader's performances are getting a little boring because the teachers give him the same roles EVERY SINGLE PRIME. They always make him sing with a crappy foreign singer that can't sing as well as he can. If only that had given him his arabic song this week or some other unique performance.The teachers are not crazy, he really is that good lol.

    Nessma,
    The Song Saad and Mohammad sang last week was "Sagheer il dinia" by Assei Hilani. Saad did it more like Assei but Mohammad was much better.

    I think a lot of people here are being too harsh on Abdullah. His voice is perect. He is much better then Saad or Mustafa.
    I feel sorry for Mustafa, he is much better then Mirhan and probably better overall then Zaher. He's about as good as Badr but Badr is boing. But a lot of people are over estimating him. Mustafa's voice is vry weak, which has showed in all of his songs today and recently. Honestly Mustafa should have focused more on his work and less on keeping Mirhan away. If he had he would have been able to do better lately. Honestly Mustafa hasn't had a good role since the first 3 weeks. Oh well. I think he will be in the tour.

  1. dana
    dana

    OMGGG MOHAMEDDDDDDDDDD CANNT BELIEVE ITT AMAZIng espically the solo i was likeeee omgg wow.... he should be top 1 walllah haram the guy is tryinggggg .. and shahinze number 2 .. he deserve it more cuz did better he did better than her.!!!! but i cannt believe saad and abdallah suprisee... well thats goodddd.. i luv mhamed and did u guys see how mohamed switch beds after he took mostapha bed cuz he like how his head hurts cuz of the colf airr... and nobody said anything to him untill mirhan opened her mouth but he was calm and everythinggglike the guy didnt do anythingg poor him he has a point

  1. felicia
    felicia

    Yezen,
    I cant agree with u on nader, im not here to argue, im not arab, im an american born with an obsession with middle eastern culture, go figure,
    Anywayz, i heard nader sing muse's song, and i dont remember the name right now, but i couldnt understand a word he was singing, he does not pronunce his words properly. Secondly, his voice is very monotonous. He has an ok voice but it's not world class, however, many artistes today cant sing for **** so i guess he has a chance.

  1. mabrouukk
    mabrouukk

    mabrouuuuuuukkk amoula m. u r the best mwaaaaaaaa
    hard luck 4 mostafa. i wanted mirhan out!!
    i'm leb nd i'm happy for amoula more than being sad for mostafa.
    amoula deserves to come back she is the most talented w her nomination was unfair!!

  1. BENTPALI4LIFE
    BENTPALI4LIFE

    ITS NOTTTTTT FAIRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!1 1ST OF ALL MIRHAN DIDN'T DESERVE TO GET THE HIGHEST VOTES SHE DOESNT EVEN SING SHE'S JUST LIKE HAIFA USES HER BODY N MOANS ABOUT ALTHOUGH MIRHAN IS WAYYYY BETTER BUT SHE IS STARTING TO IMITATE HAIFA!!!

    2ND OF ALL BADR WAS SUPPOSED TO BE NOMINEE INSTEAD OF MUSTAFA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    BADR MESSED UP LIKE HELL IN THE EVAL AS ALWAYS N THEY SILL GIVE HIM A CHANCE!! THATS PATHETIC SOOOOOOOOO UNFAIRRRRR!!!!!!!! ALTHOUGH I AM HAPPY 4 AMAL M I AM SAD 4 MUSTAFA I THINK MIRHAN SHOULD HAVE LEFT!!!

  1. amani
    amani

    damn it moustafa doesn't deserve it amal should go out coz she already took her chance n moustfa got nicer voice than her, i like amal but im sad coz mustafa went out, n even he got a better voice than mirhan, the girls got the look nt the voice ,ouffffffffffffff its unfair , im happy coz dia is in the top 5

  1. Ahbal
    Ahbal

    To all of you who don't like what I say:

    Don't read my post! That simple. Close your eyes and it all goes away.

    I use the name Ahbal because it is funny and unique. And I dont hate everyone, I like Zaher, Amal B, Mustapha , Nader as personalities. I really don't care much for voices. There are plenty of good singers out there, don't need more ;)

    So when I am going to vote and spend my money, it is going to be on a person that is respectful, open minded, and sets a good example. SO would that be Mohamad? Anyone could ever dare to describe Mohamad as respetful? Open Minded? or a good example????

    Ya jama3a, Mohamad makes me sick. Shu a3mil????? I see him and hear him speak and feel like he was a bull in a previous life!! Wallahi wallahi the guy mish tabee3i. He is MEAN to everyone including himself!!!!

    Think about it. How do you win Starac? You have to get the Votes from the people and the fellow students. This guy does everything he can to make as many people hate him inside and out!

    Even the teachers admit that if he was a nominee, he will LEAVE! Because he will not get much votes and the students will not save him! He is hated by a lot of people. And stop convincing yourself that they are jealous! He imagines things and is convinced that everyone hates him.

    To those who love Mo, I have to say that you too need therapy. If you find Mo's demeanor and intelectual level satisfactory then, you too have issues.

    Bambina, your name isn't much better , little italian baby.

    Roula: I loved your comment. It was cute ;) I still not going to listen.

    Qwaider sucks!!

  1. sarah
    sarah

    Felicia where are u from my dear?

  1. audrey
    audrey

    felicia,

    Since you are not Arab and you don't speak arabic, how do you follow this program? And why/how are you interested in Middle Eastern culture? I apologize for coming off as nosey but I'm kind of curious!!!

  1. To ahbal
    To ahbal

    To Ahbal,

    I dont have a problem with you not liking moe becasue everybody has a different taste but i have a problem with someone like you saying weired stuff about one of the students (moe) like you want to see him suffer or go crazy and very harsh words about him. I personally dont like some students for many reasons and i want them to leave the show before others but i would never wish them anything bad, they are just young people who are trying to be famous.

    About your comment about people who likes moe need theropy, you are right, we do need theropy, you know why? because we are so in love with, we adore his smile, we cant get enough of his amazing and strong voice, and we can watch him day and night and we still want to see more, i guess we need help because star academy will finish in few weeks and we wont get to see him anymore.

    One last thing, if you dont care about voices in the show and just watch it because of personality as you said then i will recomend another show for you that will really help you and you will enjoy it more and thats (Dr. Phil) i hope you know what i am talking about, he can really help you with your hate/anger problem that you have.

    P.S. the name ahbal is not funny or unique at all, its very stupid.

  1. BB
    BB

    who evr wrote the comment above
    THANK U SO MUCH
    i was going saying the same thing lol =]]]

    mohamad is star in my opinion and if the teachers didnt like him then y would they give him a solo today and put him on top 2????? =]]

  1. faiza
    faiza

    i agree with u BB HEE WAS AMAZINGGGGGGGGGGG I LUV HIMM but i have a question... in the prime mohamed hair seems more than in the academy like in his last eval when he took off his hat his hair was shorter and not as much .. like do they use fake hairrrr and ive seen old pic of him heee had lots of hair wat happened.. but i dont care luvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv and will vote for him till the end
    inshallah hes top 1 next week

  1. To Ahbal
    To Ahbal

    To Ahbal,

    You are awesome. You should change your name to Wisdom. every word you said is true.

    Thanks so much for what you said. And to all who don;t agree with Ahbal ento mahabeel.

    I also can't wait to see Mo punished, what is the big deal. He was bad and he is getting what he deserves. Its not like Saddam will punish him, it is just a little game from Mme Rola.... you people lighten up.

    Qwaider Sucks Big Time!

  1. kiki
    kiki

    why did they give only less than half song to nader it is so not fair are they treating him bad because last time they said that they are giving him more attentions than others if that is the case they are wrong they didn't treat him right they only give 1 or 2 songs every prime is that fair i am so not getting it. to the people who think nader is by far the best please vote for him if he is nominee coz i think they will nominate him soon let us show them he has fans and he is better than anyone in the academy they think that diaa sings better than him what a load of crap. i was so sorry for zaher for the position he was in to choose between mustufa amal and mirihan he even told his country to vote for amal i don't know what he was thinking but i think it was because he wouldn't have to choose between mirihan and amal m.
    p.s nader is the best he wii go far good luck to u

  1. Rana
    Rana

    I've thought alot before posting my opinion here. Mainly because i find some people offensive and attacking each other for no reason. So i hope when i give my 2 cents ..please, no one attack me!

    The prime was overall one of the better ones artistically and entertainment-wise. I thought many of the students have shown they improved this time and the song choices were great. I love Angham, so i can't really complain.

    Zaher - He has one of the most decent personalities in the academy. He's nice and respectful and nothing like to cause trouble. However, his voice is very weak. I couldn't even hear him today when he sang "Eye of the Tiger" and he chose a very very low voice range, too low for even him.

    Saad - He has a very nice and soothing voice. Old songs like Abdelhalim's and Farid really suit him. He's a nice guy but he needs to learn to control his anger when it comes to competition

    Abdallah - Again, great voice and what sets him apart is that he has a wide range, so it allows him a bigger variety of songs. I like his voice and he has charisma on stage, yet the constant smiling sometimes makes me uncomfortable lol Also he seems to have a bit of a childish personality.

    Mohamad - what a guy! He's very complex and you either like him or you hate him..no inbetweens lol. I think he probably has the strongest voice among the boys (strongest doesnt necessarily mean better because some songs require a mellow soothing voice to actually enjoy) However, in a certain type of songs he excels among his peers with no competition. His personality is a bit complex. He seems like a nice guy at heart but he has some communication impairment. Doesn't know how to get his ideas across or to accept other's ideas/words. Sometimes he amazes me at how stubborn he can be with even the teachers.

    Bader - good voice, Zero stage presence. He is such a sweetheart, so unharmful and is like a teddy bear..you just wanna hug him. But, today's prime when he sang with shahinaz i became 100% convinced that he is SO boring. Shahinaz was right next to him and he had his back to turned to her the howl time and seemed like a lost kid on a swing waiting for someone to tell him the song is over lol.

    Nader - I personally love his voice. I have a certain taste in western music and he perfectly fits it for me. So i got no complaints about him in the english department. His pronounciation can be alittle weird at times but that can sometimes be common as well in even western artists. I heard his voice in arabic and it's decent, he seems to be trying. However, if he doesnt challenge himself more then he will never make it in the arab world. I wish to see him one day be daring enough and choose the arabic song to sing in the eval. I think it's not fair because other students are challenged by the difficulty of the arabic songs (and basically stuck with it).....and i say this from experience, almost all english songs are fare easier than arabic songs to sing. So Nader and Diaa get it much easier in the eval.

    Mirhan - I don't think her voice is suitable for professional singing. She doesnt have a bad voice for someone who can sing a few tunes when they're bored. But going on stage and actually aiming for people to be entertained by her voice? I don't think so. That's like waiting to be vocally entertained by Haifa or Dana! She is a nice girl and all and she's fun to be around. But she relies almost fully on her body and dancing to attract the viewers. I think she will be better as na actress or a TV presenter. She needs to go soon!

    Amal B - Her voice confuses me. Sometimes it can be really nice and others i can't even bare to listen to her. I like her personality though and charisma. She's sweet and is a very hard worker. Maybe one of the most hard working people in the academy. And to me that can be the only reason she deserves the Top 1 today. Because people who work hard and try their best deserves to be top 1 at least once. One more thing, she really gotta calm down on stage a bit. Sometimes she scares me with her excessive dancing lol.

    Shahinaz - Wow. I think that word doesnt even begin to describe this girl. This is a girl with a golden voice that can take you back to the times of Fayza Ahmed and Laila Mourad to Magda Alroumy and contemporary artists. At first she didn't have a lot of stage pressence but she is also a hard worker and is improving so much in that area. Today she totally stole the show for me. As a die-hard Angham fan, it take a lot from me to say that Shahinaz actually sounded better than her tonight. She's got such a strong voice and it was so obvious when she sang with Bader. I can totally see her in the final and i really hope she wins. She is losing credit in the Top 5, but i think it's intentional. Rula and the teachers are know that the student who earns the most points from the top 5 gets the money in the end. And i can guess they think Shahinaz has high potential of winning the title and don't want her also taking the money. That's why people like Mohamad and abdallah and Saad make it to the top 5 every once in a while as well but not frequently.

    Amal M - such a sweetheart. She's everybody's friend and i would say she's got the second best voice after shahinaz, but ofcourse with a huge gap in between. She's a hard worker and i can see her being successful after the academy

    Diaa - exactly like Nader. I like her style and her voice in western songs. But in arabic she probably needs to work even harder than Nader. So far, it just doesnt suit her at all. She's a very nice girl however


    I'm sad for Mostafa's departure. He was such a great guy and very friendly and sweet to everyone. He's just very unlucky, because i can guarantee if it was Mirhan standing next to him for the students to choose between he would have probably came back. I hope we see him again in the tour.

    well, that's all folks. I hope i didn't forget anyone

  1. lebanese
    lebanese

    I think that this whole academy is FAKE!!! Mustapha is endowed with a better voice than both Amel M and Merhan. It was NOT fair at all:(:(.. a bon.

    I love you Mohammad Quwaider, you are the best among them all! You really deserved the top 1 this week! (another one of Roula Saad's mischiefs to hurt Adam on purpose).

    Have you all noticed that they barely spoke at all about Moe when they announced him second this week!! Explicit discrimination, don't you think?

  1. lebaneseprincess
    lebaneseprincess

    I agree with ahbal!

    honestly mohammed has a beautiful voice but he is so rude he deserves punishment to get his act together I hope he gets nominated so he can wake up and change before everyone turns against hiim.

    I am going to miss mustapha so much

  1. nadia
    nadia

    I think t it is unfair that they never give Zaher the chance to shine .he always sings a small part of the song .Yesterday that singer Amal bent didnt let Zaher or Diaa to sing with her .she sang most of the song.zaher i believe in u and that u can shine more and more but if they give u the chance coz till now they didnt give it to u so hopefully they gonna let u sing more so we can listen to your romantic voice.

    Zahewr I love u ,I believe in U ,enough said.

  1. nanoose
    nanoose

    To Ahbal, you are now posting to urself because no-one cares what u have to say, How sad,
    Sorry little boy, to break it to you but no-one cares what a ahbal thinks, since by your own admission you call yourself ahbal.
    But with therapy you will improve.
    To the post that said Moe has communication impairment, you seem to me as a smart accurate, articulate person. I applaud your judgement.

  1. soso
    soso

    Wow mohammed was so amazing.. he is a star wallah bmoot fik ya mohammed qwaider


    WE will miss you mooustafa

  1. mia
    mia

    Why does everyone keep thinking that Moustafa was better then Bader...or some keep thinking that ZAHER is better then Bader.
    Bader has a good voice and the teachers have said that many times...its just his confidence which can be changed easily.

    Moustafa outshined Abdullah in ya bint al jeerany, abdullah didnt have the right voice or it.

    And once again Mohammed proved hes already a star!
    Mirhan will go next week, they'll put her up against Bader coz hes from saudi, enough said.
    When i look at the students the only two who i imagine as real stars (and this isnt not about personality since most of you think every singer ha sthe a nice personality, think again, welcome to the reality) they are; MOHAMMED AND SHAHINAZ. And i think Amal B isnt bad at all the second strongest girl.

    one more question : WHY IS ZAHER STILL IN THE ACADEMY?!!!!!??????

  1. ahbal 2 to ahbal ahbal
    ahbal 2 to ahbal ahbal

    ahbal i am wit u 100% qauidar is a foolish guy he suks he has disrespect n amal b n mirhan a d best fuk mo

  1. mustaphaaa LOVER !!
    mustaphaaa LOVER !!

    im soo sad that safoo got out !! OMG its all from his friends wut friends are thesee !! he only got 3 points and amal m got 6 ... i really hate the people who voted against himm ...ZAHER wut rong with ya, ur saying that she voted for u last week when u were against adnan<3 ...well mustapha voted for u when u were agianst asmaa( miss her ) but amal didnt vote for u !! u people are unfairr !!! im sad he got out but im sad more becuz his friends didnt vote for him his friends that he doesnt trust anymore ... come on guys u saw mustapha didnt get any points and u kept on going and voting for AMAL M. dont u guys have a heart dont u see him with no points at all ... I REALLY THANK saad, abdulla , and bader for voting for himm ... I WAS REALLY SHOCKED ,,i started crying aloot !!dont blame mirhan ... its not her fault that she got the highest vote and she was the most who cried yesterday for himm!! ... wut made the prime sad is when he went !!

    MUSTAPHAA UR A STAR !! AND WE ALL LOVE YOU ( TAKE CARE ) and i wish u all the best and i hope that u will be in the tour..... ( AMAL M. doesnt deserve to stayy ))!!!
    WUT bothers me is that mohammed didnt even feel sorry for himm he was just sitting !! UHGGG!! HATE MOHAMMED"S attitudee!

  1. felicia
    felicia

    To sarah, im from coral springs, florida.

    To audrey,
    I cant explain it,lol...I know i cant really follow the program because I dont understand a thing, that's where waleg comes in, Im home studying right now for exams if ur thinking, she has no life. So, whenever it comes on, i watch, its not that hard to understand a bit of what is going on, then i check waleg, its really a form of entertainment for me because at 1:00 p.m, there is nothing entertaining showing on regular cable.

    As for my obsession with middle eastern culture, no, im not trying to be arab, i picked up arabian dance about 5 yrs ago and i fell in love with the music and it all went downhill from there,lol. I am not totally obsessive though, I do have a life, anywayz i hope i cleared that up for you, any more questions?

    As for ahbal, you say u dont like mohamed cuz he doesnt have any morals and he is not respectable yet some of your posts have been disrespectable, I guess its the pot calling the kettle black....lame.......

  1. BamBina
    BamBina

    hmm ahbal u know what im the only one here who is against u yet i didnt mention anything about your nick name .. anyways i dont care.. and weldone u got one thing right is that BamBina is an italian name but whats wrong is that u understood it in as "being a BABY " and not as a name which is given in italia for a baby girl.. just like some people have a name :sarah, dima. aziz etc in italia they have a name Bambina for girls and bambino for boy... .. i never commented on ur nick so if u dont have a proper comment on what i told u above dont go commenting on my nick... and want more info about BamBina take ur time and google the name...

    and adam just gave the bed back and went back to his own bed and said sorry to mima and mustafa ... its just a BED like come on next thing they'll say please dont step on this piece of floor coz some one steped on it and if u step on it the world will come to an end...

  1. audrey
    audrey

    Felicia,

    Im imressed!!! Not too many Americans (non-Arabs) dare to step out of their bubble and actually immerse themselves in other cultures especially non-Western ones. Good for you!!! I'm glad that you enjoy the culture and have the time to follow it. I'm also impressed that you actually have the arabic satellite!!!lol!!!! You actually have motivated to step out of my bubble as well and explore other cultures...

  1. roro
    roro

    hey who watched the 24/24? how were the students after the prime??

  1. Nour
    Nour

    Roro,

    1)The girls were crying specially Mirhan
    2)It was so boring to see Amel sitting and saying,that she will work hard,bcz of the tour.Actually that was what I understood,bcz tunissian is hard to understand.
    3)I heard from a friend,that someone came to them in the academy,but I don;t know who.
    4)They saw mostafa from the window and all of them were screaming or crying bcz of him.
    5)Mima spoke a little bit with amal.b about her hard relationship with him and that she tought that he will normaly come back,but amal.b told her it;s hard for the students to leave amel.m and choose mostafa.

  1. rana-lebanese
    rana-lebanese

    i watched the 24 hour channel and only a couple people were by the window saying by to mostafa which was unfair because he deserved so much more because he always said bye to everyone else. still after a day i cant believe that he is out. mostafa u really deserved to stay and it is too early for u to leave. i really hope you will be in the tour. the academy without safoo is nothing its just plain and boring he was the one who made everyone smile. im really going to miss his smile and everything about him..
    WE LOVE U SAFOOO!!!!!!!!!!

  1. nessma
    nessma

    thanks yezen!!!! do u knoo the song the sang in the eval.... i think moe is an amazing singer but he has a temper problem....... that doesnt mean u should hate him for who he is.. this is a singing show not a personality show................. GO shahy ....... and who ever wrote that mirhan should stay in bc shes egyptian soo is shay noone loves her bc shes egyptian they love her bc she can SINGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! love u egypt!!!

  1. Dolly to nooooo
    Dolly to nooooo

    The One Who Wants To Know The Voting Results 4 Each Student.
    Who Vote 4 Amal M.
    1-Dia
    2-Shahinaz
    3-Amal B.
    4-Nader
    5-Mohamed
    6-Zaher
    Who Vote 4 Moustapha
    1-Abduallah
    2-Badr
    3-Saad
    Hard Luck Moustapha =( =(
    Really We'll All Miss u =(

  1. RoRo
    RoRo

    This Prime was SO boring! ... Angham just made me go to sleep .. Amal Bent was cool ... and the Tableau's were ok

    Performance wise:

    Saad - great voice and in general nice guy, although he has such nice colour eyes I feel like they are DEAD .. there is no energy in them ...

    Mohammad - again great voice BUT ... he needs to REALLY REALLY sort out his attitude ... the guy is too too rude and constantly on his nerves ... even if he wins star academy ... he still needs to sort out his behavious because no one is going to work with him on future projects and albums if he has that temper!

    Diaa - really strong voice and in general good presence .. but she does tend to SHOUT sometimes .. and it gets really annoying .. she is ok personality wise ... but she needs to start and sing in Arabic ... there is simply no excuse!

    Nader - absolutly LOVE this guy .. he has such a nice and lovely personality ... very peaceful with everyone ... such a great guy .. great stage presence .. and a brilliant voice in english .. AND honestly he has potential in arabic too .. he practiced with mohammad a bit a few days ago on the guitar and he sounded really good!

    Amal B - Love her character and personality .. she is fierce and confident .. and lovely at the same time!! ... and she sings in both arabic and french ... and she is gorgeous .. what more could you want!?

    Mirhan - this is the girl that should have left tonight ... she is a haifa wannabe and like Madam Mary and Wadi3 said her voice range is very very small .. so all I am going to say is that we already have 1 haifa (who is WAY more hot) we dont need ANOTHER one. I have nothing against her but all she seems to be doing is shaking her booty rather than singing!

    Amal M - lovely girl ... really nice girl .. her voice is ok ... she sang "entre nous" well ... but I think she should stick to modelling .. but I am happy she is back!

    Mustapha - shame he left! ... he has a nice voice .. charisma .. and a cute look ... and I think he deserved a second chance to show more if he had more to give!

    Bader - he is a really lovely guy .. but no stage presence .. and quite boring .. but he is a sweatheart though! ... his voice is ok

    Zaher - really nice personality and character .. but he should have left 2 primes ago .. the guy's voice is WEAK! .. and he did a terrible job on the song "eye of the tiger"

    Abdullah - he has a brilliant voice in both english and arabic ... really nice and likeable guy ... but yeh I do agree he is a bit goofy looking and doesnt really have the looks of a star .. maybe he can improve that when he does eventually become a big name ...

    Shahinaz - Brilliant voice! ... she is really confident on stage now .. she is opening up more and more ... i think she realises that she has to change and be more energetic and active and playful on stage like the other girls .. and she is doing that .. she looks AMAZING too .. her new haircut and look is so nice on her! ... i think she is fun and gets along with nearly everyone .. but she puts up with Mohammad's crap behaviour too much ... she's too patient with him ..

  1. dalia loves safoo
    dalia loves safoo

    hiya I REALLY WANT SOME1 TO ANSWER MA QUESTION why dose everyone hate mirhan and wat has she done to use! i think she is one of the best girls in da acadmey so if u dont lik her plz dont talk abot coz aother poeple like her ok FS

  1. Yalie
    Yalie

    RoRo, I agree with you about Shahi. However, I'm disappointed that she is getting this attention because she decided to forget her values and wear short dresses/swimming suit which she refused to wear in the first half of the show...

  1. gabriella
    gabriella

    can i PLZ know why did mirhane cum back ? and y dd safoo leave ?

    and why ddn't any1 vote 4 safoo ????? like saad had to , badr dn't want him feeel tht nobody wanted to vote 4 him & abdulla is his "close friend"

    ddnt rola say tht the nomination is based on how the person interacts with the ppl in the academy ? mohd doesnt interact with anyone here , even shahinaz his ex-close-friend doesnt like him anymore!!!!!!!!!! the dude only has a voice , period

  1. jaida
    jaida

    mirhan is back...ta2o mooto koloko !!!!

  1. Susaaaan
    Susaaaan

    No the nomination is not just based o that...its mainly based on the persons voice and what they have to give on stage. And Mohammed has the voice an hes got a lot to give on stage.
    The way they interact is one of the last things they think about.

  1. meemee
    meemee

    yes mima is back ;) cuz she is the bestttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt

  1. yowas
    yowas

    the only one who can do thing other arabic singers can not do is BADER

    the others have nice voice, so what kathem 3amro diab, wael, rashid, asala, saber, an'3am & nancy have nice voice too!!!!

    other sudents can sing well? guess what, our famouse singers can do it better than them!!!!

    What I want to say this show failed to show us something different than what we see every day on our channels.
    If you didn't feel sick of it yet, I did

    but I really liked Bader & I can see the potential he has got to be a real pop star
    at least he is different that ha can dance in a very lovely and difficult way while other arabic singers can't
    at least he can do an interesting show of singing and dancing that other arabs can not do, but unfortunatly Madam Rola doesn't want us to see what he can do on the stage.

    In other words,
    He can be the ONE MAN SHOW, that we miss in our arab world

  1. yowas
    yowas

    Gues what!!
    Other student are copying famouse singers too in the way they sing + they have a similler voice too
    no one of them has got the voice that is never heard on the earth!!!

    and

    you seem not an international fan
    I'm a fan of Arabic + english + hindi + korean music
    and all singers dancers in these regions started with matching MJ moves but then they started to have their own style and they had an extraordinary success
    like Justin timberlik, Hritik roshan in india, and Rain in South Korea,

    Bader dance very well despite of his weight (10kg+) and watching an arabic singer doing so is very interesting coz its different and matchless in the arab world, believe me there is a huge number of dance fans in our arab world, but unfortunately no even one singer was clever enough to focus on them.

    If you really want to think rationally, you'll admit there is a gab in Arab world in this feild and who is going to fill it, will have a great success

    and always remember:
    Success is not about doing the things correct as the others, it's about being different.

  1. gabriella
    gabriella

    ppl dnt get me rong , i dnt hate mima ,, itzz jst tht the voting was supposed to go to mostafa thtz all

  1. jordan first
    jordan first

    ahbal i kow why ur name is ahbal
    stfu u dont even know moe and u judge him by the way he acts on a show that is run by a lady who hates him............
    u should be ashamed of yourself . if u tried to sing against him u would look like s***
    he is the best in the academy and the star
    u need to see a doctor and get some meds or u need tostop takin too many,,,,,,,,,,,,lololololol
    ha............i think u should call this number
    1-800-GET-HELP u need it retard

  1. elaa
    elaa

    academy bet2aref bala safo ... i wish amal will be nomine this week

  1. shahad
    shahad

    elaa,l wish amal m will be a nomine this week hate that gerafee safo l sceriously miss u habebey ba mote fek xxx.

  1. Maryam
    Maryam

    I'm an Iranian Arab. My cousins and I have been fans of this exciting program for a long time. But we're sorry we cannot vote. Is there a possibility for us to get to vote for our favorites?
    Many thanks,
    Maryam from Ahwaz, IRAN

  1. LENA
    LENA

    ps..i sooo think Mirhan is there for sluttin around!!i love MOHAMMED!!!he is real...he is just being himself,,he cannot pretend like da others do,,,i hope either MOHAMMED OR NADER WIN,,,they desrve it!!!does any1 have any idea how 2 sms dem??hook me up??thanks
    one love!!!

comments powered by Disqus