The 9th nomination of Star Academy 5 wasn't to my liking yesterday!
To tell you the truth, I thought the nomination was really unfair. Don't you think that Bader or Zaher should have been nominees instead of Mustapha or Mirhan?
I watched their evaluations and I thought they didn't do very well.
Zaher was reading the lyrics from a paper and Bader forgot the words ..
again!
Meanwhile, Mirhan and Mustapha had nice ideas. They might not have the best voices in the Academy, but they are certainly better than Zaher and Bader.
Don't get me wrong here, I like Zaher and Bader but I do think they should have been nominees instead of Mirhan or Mustapha.
What do you think? Was the nomination fair in your opinion or do you think there should be an adjustment to the nomination?
By guest writer Ant
comments
totally agree. this was soooo unfair. if it would have been the first time badr screws up, then ok but it's NOT. same goes for zaher. I like him and all but things has to be fair. mostafa and mirhan works a loot harder than them!!
i totally agree wid u ur sayying right mustapha is nominee this is unfair i hope he will b save by audiance i think the judges are crazy this year they dont know what to do i think they are just running the season they are waiting when this season will finsish and they will go to thier home
I think Zaher should've left before Asma n Adnan now that wasn't fair!! His voice,no offense, isnt nearly a good a others in the academy. I like Moustapha, hope he doesnt leave over the other two...im just glad dia or saad arin't nomoniees if they leave i will stop watching..and im still really upset about adnan n asma leaving
Thank you soooooo much for posting my articles!!!! I really appreciate it. I will try to write as many more as I can.
i think its totally unfair the two love birds they cant leave all three of em are my favorites i will be sad if any leave but mustafa and mirhan have to say
i totally agree wid u ur sayying right mustapha is nominee this is unfair i hope he will b save by audiance
DONT WORRY MUSTAFA
ALL UAE IS WID U
ALL KSA IS WID U
VOTE 4 MUSTAFA
VOTE FOR MUSTAFA
I agree with waleg. I think that although Mirhan and Mustapha don't have the strongest voices in the academy they did well in the eval, they had fresh ideas and were funny. The judges don't apply the rules of the game on everyone. They usually nominate students for forgetting words but a few forgot the words in this eval and haven't been touched. I like Abdallah's voice but he missed up and should've been nominated as well as Bader and Zaher who read his lyrics while singing.
I really like Diaa but if she doesn't work on her voice and start singing in arabic she wouldn't last.
I like Nader too but I hated how he went around and talked about Diaa and Shahinaz behind their backs. He should've told that he doesn't care for their opinions instead of creating all the drama.
totally do not agree with you ..
If they nominated Abdullah , then who would be the star? c'mon guys , abdullah is the best .. He has a a face that you feel comfortbale when you look at , He has a great Voice and no one in the academy has as great as his voice, and it was his first mistake also in the eval he made the teachers laugh by acting . He is genius and brillian guy. He sings in English and Arabic and he is smart , He can do everything staudents in the academy can not do so He is really a star. The finalist should be
1- Abdullah
2- Shahinaz
3- Sa'ad
4- Qwider ( but he has only a good voice which is not eough , you know what i mean)
5- Nader because i like him ..heheheh .. He can not sing Arabic so Nader please go to France and see if you can be the tenth there ..lol
6- Zaher , his voice is weak but he is really nice and kind guy
7- Bader , He has a good voice and He is a great dancer but Alisar never showed us how great he is in dancing
8- Adanan ( but he left , too bad)
9- Amal B or Amal M
10- ?????????????????????????????
Mostapha, He has a very bad bad bad voice , very weak and he has a stupid character .. the only thing that makes him stay in the academy is his baby face and because he is lebanese
ANT
i agree that zaher and badar are the weakest, however it is very wrong week 4 u to choose this subject if the likes of diaa and amal b can be nominee before some other whom are weaker thn them. thn i think its preaty much fair enough. mostafa and mirhan were treated very specail from the start and it is fair in a way. maybe they are not weaker thn some but they are defenitly weaker then others. how about amal m she sang very well and she is better thn some in there as well, to bad it looks like she is going.
Neverthelesss i wish amal m and safo ganna come bk inshallah.
gooooooooooooo NADAR, AMAL B, saad, diaa, mohmed, zaher, shahinaz, safo and amal m
sorry i dnt agree!! mirhan needz to leaveee shee suxxx!! i hatteee herrr !! zahheerrr????? oo cmon walegg!! this nomination is totallyy faiirr!! and with amal m!! amal m and mirhan are supposed to be out from day 1!!! mirhhaanan!!! omgg !! u tellin me shez betteer than zaher??? noo wayy! zaher cannn SINGGG IN ENGLISHHH VERYYY GOODD! mirhan can show her skin! soo sorry but i dnt agree with u! this nomination wuz totally fair as i wuz waiting 4 it to come and nominate mirhhan!
By the way, zaher reading from a paper wasn't because he didn't know the lyrics. It was part of his idea: to be jaree2 by "ignoring " the rules. Like shahinaz was "ignoring" the lose weight rules. He was reading the lyrics(although he told the teachers he DID know them), using the mic everything they were told not to do yany. and it WAS jaree2, because he really didn't know how the teachers would take it.
Amal I agree with your ranking of the finalists but they way things are going now I won't be surprised at all if they let go of some of the best to keep some drama people. After all it's a reality show, you know what I mean :)
zaher said in his evaluation that he had the paper so he will not forget any words which would cause him to be a nominee again. He told the teachers that he knew the song but he sang it from the paper anyway. Why would he even bother to memorize the song if he read it all from the paper? he should have been nominated for that....but he got lucky. he has to be careful next time. Also, badr forgot the words and 3 teachers put him down for nominee. the 3nominees did alot better. Atleast they didnt forget the words. I still like zaher though.
The theme for the evaluations was BEING DARING! which is not obeying the rules and being different.
Zaher read from the papers not cuz he didnt know the lyrics or whatever...just because it was daring since they ARE NOT allowed to do it... He was nominee 3 times... I think maybe they should give him a chance to succeed if not they will put him nominee the next week....Honestly Mirhan SUCKS and Mostafa may be cute but his voice is weak!
So they deserve the nomination :)
THIS ISNT ABOUT WHO HAS THE BEST VOICE DURING THE EVAL..ITS WHO HAS IMPROVED, ZAHER IS TRYING AND EVERY1 LUVS HIM...MIRHAN AND MOSTAFA WERE UNFORTUNATE THIS TIME CUZ THEY WERENT IMPROVING BUT THAT DOESNT MEAN THEY'RE WORSE THAN ZAHER.
l agree aswell is totaly unfair so pleaze people come on and vote for mustofa and mirhan pleaze people come on they both diserve to stay lm sure everbodie agrees with me!!
I think Mostafa and Mirhan deserved it because Mostafa forgets lines nearly every prime, that is simply not good enough, and his voice is the weakest after bader and zaher.
Mirhan only has stage presence but no voice,this makes her the weakest of the girls. And her eval wasnt successful coz she wasnt exactly communicatign the idea of 'doign what you want,, saying what you want' she just flirted with Wadi3 and asked him to marry her, which was cringeyyyyy!
I dont think Amel M deserved it that much because she can sing better then Mirhan.
Even though Zaher wasnt nominated this week, he will be next week because he has the weakest voice, even weaker than bader, who i think has actually a good voice.
For tthe next two or three weeks the victims of nomination will be Mustafa, Mirhan, Zaher,Bader, and Amal M.
The rest are safe for a while.
I wonder what Mohammeds punishment is going to be coz Madam Rula said shes planned something...
hi ana bas bade oul 3an bader ino 3atoul biyinsa el kalem wa bi iloun sorry wa biyirgha bi 3ed mostafa ghana ktir helow le tole3 nomine? kila sa3bara bi sa3bara bas 3aladou khalige!!!!!!
Mohammed s punishment is every body will go out the but him this will tech him somthing i think he has a very good voce but his maners are bad i guest most of the poeple from salt i,m from there too. I have the same traies.. Haaah hah ha LOL
zaher may be good looking but he has no talent.
mirhan should leave she s a sham for each egyptian,she 's a 25 years old and she want to make relation with adolescent mostapha18 and nader19 she should go home back and think about other rhing to do
Rola is punishing him? That's retarded, i dont think that will help, it will just make him more angry, he will hate everyone more now. I hope she gets some sense in her head and realise that, thats not the way to go about helping him.
Is this true?
Rola's punishment to moe is to make him stay in the academy and everybody goes out?
When did she say that?
If thats true, then she is really stupid and ignorant because thats not how you solve the problem if she thinks he is a problem, she should talk to him one on one, explain the situation, advise him, make him understand that he should listen to the teachers and not be late for class, basically she should treat him like someone who is under pressure and stressed, who had quit smoking and its killing him, and if all that did not work then she can punish him but not like this maybe make him clean the academy or wash dishes, laundry or stuff like that.
I dont think the nomination was fair at all:
they should picked:
Abdallah - forgot everything
badr - forgot last part and repeated twice
zaher - very weak voice
First off Waleg I somewhat disagree.
1. The nomination is based not only on the tests but they are a total package. Zaher did very well with his nominee song and the reading the words was part of his act. Badr didn't do well with his song and maybe should have been nominee but his dance was good.
2. I think Abdullah should have been nominee just for the sake of punishment for his bad test. We all know he would come back with a heavy voting majority and hopefully not mess up a test again till the finals.
3. Mirhan deserves to be nominee. Her idea was not good at all. Infact it has been used twice or three times before in star academy. And she acted almost like a prostitute during her eval. Her behavior has become unacceptable. And her voice is terrible, she didn't sing right, she can't dance, she can't act, and she can't draw. Her only asset is appearance.
4. Mustafa really didn't do great with his test. I don't think it's a stretch that he is nominee.
5. If anyone it is Amel Ma7alawy she should not have been nominee. She sang her song perfectly well dances much better then Mirhan.
i am a lebnese girl w i say mostafa n mirhan deserved it w long time agoo kamen i donno why they were protecting them w waited till now to nominate them!!!
bass amel m. did not deserve it at all it is soooo unfair to her. they have been treating her unfairly since the beginnig of the show she is sooooo talented w very kind.
AMOULA M. mwaaaaaaaaa
ummm mustapha sings better than mirhan/zaher/bader.....that wasnt fair for hm attt all.....but u know zaher should have left way before asmma...no offince i like him but the boy cannot sing....then mirhan she cant hit no notes/................
mustapha all KSA/kuwait/uSA with u baby dont worry
Waleg excusme ,but u r wrong .Havent u heard yesterday the teachers discussin about Mostafa?Wadi3 said he hand not improved at all and this must end coz now it is critical moment for the program and even he said he told him a thousand time not to to a certain gesture with his hand but he keeps doing it in the stage and Mary said that he just care about his looks and Alissar said he is handsome but has no future in music business .So waleg whta can u say after seeing their comments? While Madaam Mary is really happy withj Zaher coz he is improving and even she said to him and Saad and Abdallah were sitting that She tought alot of people from many countries who have the Same weak voice of Zaher but they improved bettter than alot of students who had strong voices and successed more.
Zaher i love u ,I believe in U .Enough said.And as fro All nominees they deserve to be .I forfot Foaud said about Mirhan that she is cute and can dance and long time ago he sent her to Alissar and alisar said take her back coz she cant dance.Stop talking about Zaher our love.
I think it is unfair and also fair,bcz Mirhan didn't do well in the eval,but she isn't the weakest,the both Amel are weaker then her.It's also fair,bcz her eval's idea was not so original & that's why she is nominated instead of Boshoucha.I'm egyptian I love mima &I will vote for her.I voted 4 her till now 38 votes & I will still vote 4 her till the last moment.End now you should understand why egyptian every time.To Safo the judges should give him an other chance,bcz he is not the weakest & for ZICO &BIBO,they r the weakest,but ZICO shouldn't be nominated,but BIBO should hahahahahahahahaha.
GOOOOOOOOOO MIMO MIMO MIMO!!!!!
All the egyptian r with you
& AMAL go home
the only one who can do thing other arabic singers can not do is BADER
the others have nice voice, so what kathem 3amro diab, wael, rashid, asala, saber, an'3am & nancy have nice voice too!!!!
other sudents can sing well? guess what, our famouse singers can do it better than them!!!!
What I want to say this show failed to show us something different than what we see every day on our channels.
If you didn't feel sick of it yet, I did
but I really liked Bader & I can see the potential he has got to be a real pop star
at least he is different that ha can dance in a very lovely and difficult way while other arabic singers can't
at least he can do an interesting show of singing and dancing that other arabs can not do, but unfortunatly Madam Rola doesn't want us to see what he can do on the stage.
In other words,
He can be the ONE MAN SHOW, that we miss in our arab world
to W: rola ISN"T stupid, she's very very smart about her show, and if she DOES do that to mohamed she'd be 100% RIGHT. because this guy, there's no TALKING to him about anything. everytime he argues with somebody you can see proof of that. he refuses to accept that he could have done something wrong, and argues argues argues till the other person beyezha2 and gives it up. with wadih, with zaher... everyone. so the best way for her to teach him a lesson would be to DO something, not just talk.
to yowas: bader isn't doing anything interesting, he's just mix and matching michael jackson routines with whatever he sees on tv today, it's not like he's the next alissar. i doubt he'll be doing anything new like that for a while. so no, no one man show, just a rerun.
plz people who love marwa imed ahmed cherif ameni bahaachaimaa wajdi VOTE AMAL M SHE DESERVES OUR VOTES IT S SO UNFAIR THEY DIDN T GIVE HER CHANCE SINCE THE BEGININNG THANKU YYYEEZZEENN DANDOUNA AND ALL NICE PEOPLE I LVE EVERYONE WHO LOVES NAADDEER
Amal M Don't deserve to be nominne /aram .. she must be back vote AMal M
ZAHER IS THE BEST!! AND I LOVE MOSTAFA AMAL M AND MIRHAN SO I WANT THEM ALL TO STAY!! AND I VOTE FOR THE THREE I LOVE THEM SO MUCH!!!!! GO MOSTAFA AMAL M MIRHAN ZAHERRRRRR NADER AMAL B
To Nadia,
If Mustopha is so bad to you, why did the teachers put him in the top 5 last week? They said he is improving with charisma and a good voice. They also put Mirhan in the top 5. And just to let you know, I don't hate Zaher. I like him and I dont want him to leave either but I was just saying he is one of the weakest in the academy so I thought he would be a nominee instead along with bader. I like all the candidates, but they are all going to be nominees someday.
i think it was really not fair they shouldnt have nominated mostafa because it does beat zaher reading the lyrics from a paper and didnt abdalla forget the words and i didnt think bader did that well either. so thats 3 right there.. i have to admit even though mostafa is my favorite he didnt do his best but he still shouldnt have been a nominee if there were people who did worst.
GOOD LUCK IN THE PRIME SAFOOO I LUV U!!!!!!
hiiii alll ...
first of all i think mostafa and mirhan they deserve more than amal mahlawy and i want 2say somethn that mirhan and mostafa they are friends maybe they have crush but it doesnt mean that they love eachother ...
isa isa mostafa and mirhan they will win and they will be back i love them so0oo0o0o0oo0o0o0o0o00o00o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0oo0oo0o00000o much g0o0o0o0o00o0oo0o0oo0o0 mimo and safo they deserves .. go0o0o0o0o0d luck
and i am sure that when mimo and safo go0o0o0o0o0oo0o0o back they will work very hard cz not to be nominated any more and if anyone of them leave the academy will be very bad,discusting ... plz vote for them
plz EVERYBODY HELPS ME TO SAVE AMAL M
she doesn't deserve to be nominnee she is really sweet plz no matter from which country u r we are all arabs plz help her SHE IS KIND AND CALM AND VERY CLASSY
Dear Monky,
Gues what!!
Other student are copying famouse singers too in the way they sing + they have a similler voice too
no one of them has got the voice that is never heard on the earth!!!
and
you seem not an international fan
I'm a fan of Arabic + english + hindi + korean music
and all singers dancers in these regions started with matching MJ moves but then they started to have their own style and they had an extraordinary success
like Justin timberlik, Hritik roshan in india, and Rain in South Korea,
Bader dance very well despite of his weight (10kg+) and watching an arabic singer doing so is very interesting coz its different and matchless in the arab world, believe me there is a huge number of dance fans in our arab world, but unfortunately no even one singer was clever enough to focus on them.
If you really want to think rationally, you'll admit there is a gab in Arab world in this feild and who is going to fill it, will have a great success
and always remember:
Success is not about doing the things correct as the others, it's about being different.