During the first prime of Star Academy 5, I felt so optimistic about this season. I was really eager for the season to start and really wished that it will be a great one and entertain us as much as the previous ones (including season 2 lol). I felt that the level of voices is great and the students seemed to be very nice, charismatic and very talented. But now I feel I was fooled and here is why:
All the great voices appeared to be bad ones! At the begenning, all the teachers were saying that this season the level of the voices is very high and suddenly they start to criticize all of them and we (as audience) are starting to see that. Why didn't we see that at the beggening?! Of course there are a few great voices but now it appears that most of them don't have voices! (all the teachers are criticizing the voices of most of the students and I am not talking about the criticzm of the performance but they mentioned most of the students' names as they are having a weak voice e.g. Zaher, Mostafa, Mirhan, Amal M, Adnan, Khaled... and the list goes on). I am wondering why did they choose them in the first place ?
They seemed very nice. They seemed very loving to each other. Now all what I see is people bad mouthing each other. They have fatal flaws in their personalities. Ok guys YEAH I know we are all human beings but in real life we have to be moderate and not extremely mean or extremely flirty... If I met any of those students (most of them to be fair not all) in real life I wouldn't admire them really. I should feel happy when I watch them, they must entertain me and I must feel sympathy towards them as much as love, admiration and respect but unfortuantely I feel none of these towards any of them (except for maybe a couple). I will try not to mention names or incidents I have watched in the dailies or the 24/7 channel but seriously only 2 or 3 out of them, I didn't see or hear them acting snakey or slutty or mean or have they bad mouthed each other.
I feel extremely dissapointed with this season although they are doing their best to make a great show (I mean the producers and the whole team) but apparently they can't switch the truth unless they decided that this year they will make it a real reality TV. By the way, don't you notice that this year there are no longer long corridor scene! I feel they wanted to change and also they show the teachers discussing the nomination thing and everything. Well guys I think they are no fun to watch anymore and I wonder what you think? Are you with me or not? I hope I am wrong and this show develops into a nicer reality tv show!
By guest writer Ghada
Comments
i am with u ghada the voices of the most of them are terrible its booriiiiiiiiiiing
mostafa has a very amazing and great voice !!!!!!!
Errrrrrrrrrr because the whole purpose of the show is to make kzillions of $$$$$ for LBC? Thats what its always been about. Come on how many contestants have really made anything of themselves?
Dude you must have been asleep a LONG time to work that one out!
HIIIIIIII ALL VISIT MIRHAN WEB SITE
www.mirhanstar.com
I think most of the students won't even make it for the first round of superstar
i am with you WALEG
that is true some good voises are in the danger to be nominated and who will win?
maybe the worst person or the best we don't know!
asmaa and adnan didnt make the first round!:D
saaad got to the final 53
Ths year all unfair is going on for example..
Ahmad was out n 5th prime which i think is very very very unfair
then asma was out very unfair which i thnk has the best voice in girls
then mustafa is not in top 5 couple of weeks which is unfair.
do u guys agree with me.....?
ghada i must say i dont totally agree wit u.............at the end of the day they r all students n they came to learn, some of them develop n others dont......but they all have one thing in common and dats potential.....be it future entertainers, singers, dancers or actors.....n its unfair to compare superstar wit star academy....the main objective of both the programs r different. singing iz all wat matters in superstar...while staracademy iz more abt entertaining u by actin n dancing n it actually showz us the process of their development and the emotions dat they go thru in dat process...its a reality tv show so they have to run dat extra mile to make the show an interesting n also entertaining one at the same time. Thank you.
Merry am 100% wid u
..although i didnt like ahmad at the very begining but i feel now like the academy is missing a lot !!!
moustafa should be given more chances cause he has an amazing charizma and an acceptable voice !! so they should use him more lol ..
i think that the MAIN THING MISSING THIS YEAR IS Mr OUSSAMA EL RAHBANI !!!! beleive it or not but the students are not getting anywhere cz they never see how they did nd therefore will never get better !! + oussama was so cool :D
i totally agree with u miss independent...in star academy most of the students have never sung in there lives so its unfair to compare both shows...besides star academy is about show business and not only voice....
eg zaher, mostafa, mirhan, amel m, amel b have never sang before they never took traiining
saad has been singing for 8 years and training and his mum is a famous singer in lebanon....
mohamed has also been singing in concerts as well as assma for years now... same as nader.
shahinaz sang in the opera...
adnan has been acting as a dj and singing as well...so guys its not fair to judge somebody whos been training for 8 years to another whos just had his first training...
this is the game...people have ups and downs...tehres so much stress in staracademy...they know that they are judged all the time who likes that...who can act normal when hes 2/7 being under scrutiny....
thanx...give them a break they are all trying so hard to entertain us...the students and teachers...:)
i totally agree with u miss independent...in star academy most of the students have never sung in there lives so its unfair to compare both shows...besides star academy is about show business and not only voice....
eg zaher, mostafa, mirhan, amel m, amel b have never sang before they never took traiining
saad has been singing for 8 years and training and his mum is a famous singer in lebanon....
mohamed has also been singing in concerts as well as assma for years now... same as nader.
shahinaz sang in the opera...
adnan has been acting as a dj and singing as well...so guys its not fair to judge somebody whos been training for 8 years to another whos just had his first training...
this is the game...people have ups and downs...tehres so much stress in staracademy...they know that they are judged all the time who likes that...who can act normal when hes 2/7 being under scrutiny....
thanx...give them a break they are all trying so hard to entertain us...the students and teachers...:)
OMGGG!!! i cant stand amal M. she had to leave b4 asmaa!!! asmaa has a betterrrr voiceee!! and mirhann as weelll i hatee mirhan and amal M. they had to leave b4 asmaa as asmaa is better than bothh!!
in any game we have weak n strong persons
thats y they chosed nader that cannot sing in arabic plus they can use this point as weakness to nominate him in later round
maintenant les professeur se mettent a faire les procès!aujourd'hui c'était le tour de NADER a être crucifié le pourquoi c'est simple ils le crucifient parce qu'il fait tous ce qu'on lui demande de faire a la perfection ! ils osent même dire que abdallah en anglais est meilleur que NADER alors pourquoi c'est jamais lui qui chante avec les stars étrangères!ils sont d'une incohérence hallucinante la semaine dernière NADER pour WADI5 était l'unique professionnel parmi des étudiants, pour marry il avait la meilleur voix dans l'academy ,après une semaine pour eux NADER est devenu la personne a éliminé!je salut la cohérence de ces professeurs qui changent aussi rapidement d'avis juste parce qu'une roula saad qui adore l'odeur de l'argent voit en 5abdallah les millions de dollars qui pourraient se verser sur son compte,alors voila qu'elle se met a attaquer NADER en affirmant lui avoir donné ce qu'elle n'a pas donné aux autres !et la me vient a l'esprit une question mais qu'est qu'elle a offert a NADER de spécial par apport aux autres ???et je ne trouve aucune réponse parce qu' en réalité tous ce que NADER a pris comme compliment il les a arraché de leurs bouches par son talent qui lui permet de faire des exhibitions remarquables la ou les autres chantent lui il vole!et malgré ces compliment yalli mestaketrinon 5alih on le voit presque jamais au top 5 puis a NADER le plus grand compliment lui est venu de alessandro safina et non de roula saad et safina est loin d'être incohérent comme roula saad ou marry ou même wadi5 qui m'a vraiment déçu !alors qu'elle arrête cette roula d'attaquer NADER juste parce qu'il est extra dans ce qu'il fait et qu'elle aille se chercher un autre argument plus valable la prochaine fois pour s'accaparer les dollars du khalij !et avec ça je dis vaut mieux 1 5abdallah qu'1 mohammed mais NADER reste the best!!!
I really liked what is said and yes its soo true most their voices sucks i mean common Mustafa not yet a nominee? He should have been long gone. I think Khaled's voice is much nicer than Mustafa's no comparism. It doesnt piss me off Mustafa is still in the academy but what I will call cheating fair and square is if he ends up in the tourne. I'm Lebanese by the way, but lets face it facts are facts I think Bader didnt deserve to be a nominee this week so what if he screws up a couple of lines. Did you guys stop and hear his voice honestly its amazing. Abdallah's voice lol seriously whats so good bout it, it sucks no offense. Mohammad what can i say the dude should go out asap terrible manners and speaking of which didnt Madam Rola say that its not just based on voice but also being friendly blablabla.. Well, i dont see her sticking to her words at all. Anyway star academy 3 and 4 were the best atleast we have Jeeran to watch that will keep us entertained cuz star academy is nothing but lets just say.. Useless with unfair judges.
Take care!
I really liked what is said and yes its soo true most their voices sucks i mean common Mustafa not yet a nominee? He should have been long gone. I think Khaled's voice is much nicer than Mustafa's no comparism. It doesnt piss me off Mustafa is still in the academy but what I will call cheating fair and square is if he ends up in the tourne. I'm Lebanese by the way, but lets face it facts are facts I think Bader didnt deserve to be a nominee this week so what if he screws up a couple of lines. Did you guys stop and hear his voice honestly its amazing. Abdallah's voice lol seriously whats so good bout it, it sucks no offense. Mohammad what can i say the dude should go out asap terrible manners and speaking of which didnt Madam Rola say that its not just based on voice but also being friendly blablabla.. Well, i dont see her sticking to her words at all. Anyway star academy 3 and 4 were the best atleast we have Jeeran to watch that will keep us entertained cuz star academy is nothing but lets just say.. Useless with unfair judges.
Take care!
ok people if you just watched the basketball game right now on the 24/7 channel you would agree that these students have no manners what so ever especially adnan and saad they were screaming and hitting and were extremely rude. there are excepetions however like nader, amal b, zaher
and ya i hate abdullahe is two faced and he sounds like the frog but its obvious the lbc is gona make him the winner this yr!
Lol Sarah you got that wrong Abdallah wont win i'll tell you why.. Cuz star academy2 if you watched a saudi won so i only think its fair to give another country a try im 101% sure that Nader will win cuz i see no tunis who has won yet and plus if you pay attention during the judments star academy you'd realise when the teachers say all of them sound as students but Nader proffesional. Lol, to me Nader sucks just cuz he shouts yaaay in the middle of his songs bil prime out loud means he got a good voice? I actually set the tv on mute cuz its seriously annoying. But then again, its only a game and i would bet anything that Nader will win Star Academy5.
Take care!
I Think that this season was built on certain strategy that divided the accepted candidates in to 3 categories the first one is the strong voices( no matter the figure)that are able to sing in arabic well which are : ABDALLAH, AMAL BOU SHOUSHA, MOHAMAD QUAIDER, SHAHINAZ, SA3D.
The other category is the sexy appealing candidates which was accepted for other reasons rather than thier strong voices which how handsom, cute ,funny, charasmetic the candidate is , & this is the major category whom teachers says about them that they need to work upon themselves & this ain't gonna happen & they are: ADNAN, ZAHER, MIRHAN , MOSTAFA, AMAL MAHLAWY, KHALED , EMAN
There voices are zero like M.Fouad had said,
ain't no hope in them.
The third category is the moderate voices whom they thought through work there will be progress in them are: AHMED NICE, DIA2, NADER, ASMA, BADER
& thoes guys it worth trying with them, but they lack some how in thier talents.
I still believe that the final 3 will be :
ABDALLAH, SA3D, SHAHINAZ
if Mustafs voice is bad tht y he came top 1 in the first week>>>>>...he was already trained before entering acdemy n
WAKE UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
U ALL OK
HE DESERVES 2 BE IN FINAL OK
BEST OF LUCK SAFOOOOOOOOOOO
wel my opinion is that even though in past years there were some weak voices the primes were so entertaining they had fairouzs songs and dabkat and nice tableaus, everytime I see a prime this season I always watch it thinking there's something missing like somethings not right....there's no hanaa or chayma to sing those great fairouz songs and there's no marwa or shaza with charisma and strong voices there's angels who sing horrible songs idk wat do u guys think??
I agree the voices are so bad this year, I don't even know how did let them in. But I believe that they have three or two voices that can make it to the final. Even the years before they did not have everybody great I believe Rula makes like a quota of the countries because she is worried about the money and as some body said it before, they need some good looking boys or sexy girls to attract people.
guys instead of going on about how Mustafa is great, pay attention...hes not.
You wouldnt even care if he wasnt good looking so grow up, his voice is nothing compared to Saad, Abdullah and Mohammads.
ghada i don't agree with u at alll... ithink t hat although there are backstabbers like diaa muhammed and shahinaz. unlike you i think that starac 5 is one of the best seasons. you didn't meet ppl. like zaher nader mostafa and saad all together in one season. i rlly luv them all in exception of a few (badr, mohammed, diaa, shahinaz) bas i think they r all talented in their own way and you said that all the teachers are criticizing them, you r wrong there is only one teacher who does that (fuad) that's it
i still believe that everyone has his/her point of view although i agree with u wen u said that season 2 was the worst.
ghada i don't agree with u at alll... ithink t hat although there are backstabbers like diaa muhammed and shahinaz. unlike you i think that starac 5 is one of the best seasons. you didn't meet ppl. like zaher nader mostafa and saad all together in one season. i rlly luv them all in exception of a few (badr, mohammed, diaa, shahinaz) bas i think they r all talented in their own way and you said that all the teachers are criticizing them, you r wrong there is only one teacher who does that (fuad) that's it
i still believe that everyone has his/her point of view although i agree with u wen u said that season 2 was the worst.
hey!!! i dont agree with ghadaa she i soo not rite ... star academy 5 is really NICE i like it and even the last seasons.. GHADAA u just dont know if u dont like it dont say anything well there are lots of ppl how like star academy 5 like meee!!! I LOVE THEM (L) its one of the best and the ppl who said bad stuff about them u dont have taste and ur soo rudeee !! and the person who are happy that adnan and asmaa got out goo diee ... and mustapha rocks i love himm he was top 1 from the first week becuz hes one of the best and inshalla he will go to the final.. i agreee with some ppl who say that mohammed and shahinaz are backstabbers but not the rest .. I LOVE NADER he has such a great voice... and abdulla hes soo talented hes better then others and who said that abdullah is a frog hes not but u r !!! i think that star academy is great this season and i dont care wut other ppl sayy i will still like them !! GO STARACADEMY 5 and KEEP THE GOOD WORK !! ( ADNAN missing u ) ( mustapha my luv) :D:D:D:D STAR ACADEMY5