I must admit, that was the most emotional elimination by far. I had tears in my eyes.

I must admit, that was the most emotional elimination by far. I had tears in my eyes.

Saad is the best!!!

good luck asmaa althought i was so hapy for zaher today i was so upset:(

heyyy guyzz plzzzz can somebody tell me what did nader say to manal????and what did diaa and merihan tell her???i missed the dailies todayyy thank you ..plzzzzz

I know, I felt bad for Adnan!!!

Yeah it was pretty sad i am like sooo bored soo people plzz stay on here for a while and lets talk !!!!! anyway ..... my favorites are:
BOYS: Saad, zaher, mostifa, and nader (but all are good)
GIRLS: BASHOUSHA, TINA (haha last year :[) amal m. and dia and basically alll girls!!!

my favorites are :zaher of course and nader mostafa

hey dima stay oon!!!

it was very sad today even though asma isnt one of my faves but i felt bad for mirhan cuz of the situation she was is and for adanan and did u notice when mirhan came to apoligze i felt like adnan hated her, i really like mirhan if it was anyone else they wudnt have went and apologized i cant believe chahinaz talks about mirhan nehind her back and i thoght diaa was mirhans best friend not chahy but whatev mustafa is the best to be he is so cute and talented.

BEST GUYS: MUSTAFA NADER ZAHER
BEST GIRLS: MIRHAN AMAL B, AMAL M

I USED TO LIKE DIAA BUT SHES A TRADER

WALEG why u summerize the story??? it showed manything about NADER.plz someone tell me what was them.plzzzzzzzzzzzz.

HEY HEY PEEPS!!!
I AM SOOO BORED SO LETS DO A ABOUT ME SEGMENT !!! no TOO personal info!! PLZ NO NO NO !!! well i am 13 live in the usa i am from PLAESTINE(lebanon) , and algeria( hahakind of like amal b and zaher !!! haha!!!! I am best friends with doumou(deana) in fact we are on the phone right now!!!! I love star acad. i would DIE with out it !! jk but yeah and i love music and yeah!! NOW YALLL DO IT!!

I cried so much today! I felt soooooo bad for Adnan...and I have a feeling his emotions are what going to eliminate him next week bc he is so sad about asma...Be strong Adnan! I really wanted Asma to stay but then again I didn't want Zaher to leave either...but it is the way of the game and next week someone else that we love will be leaving too:( Have you guys noticed Mohamad is really trying to be nice???? I love him soooo much! Good luck to everyone and especially to Asma!!!!

HEY HEY PEEPS!!!
I AM SOOO BORED SO LETS DO A ABOUT ME SEGMENT !!! no TOO personal info!! PLZ NO NO NO !!! well i am 13 live in the usa i am from PLAESTINE(lebanon) , and algeria( hahakind of like amal b and zaher !!! haha!!!! I am best friends with doumou in fact we are on the phone right now!!!! I love star acad. i would DIE with out it !! jk but yeah and i love music and yeah!! NOW YALLL DO IT!!

l0o0ol douniaa! am sory jst read ur comment:! i love starac and its gona b boring with out it butt this primee was awful we need goood musicc not haifa:S

hahaha i don't her eighther hahahah

poor adnan he loves asma i really was touched today and felt bad for them..
any way good kuck for both of them.
as for nader he loves his gf manal he said that he was just kidding with merihan bs zawedha shwya he noticed that when chahinaz talked with him so he said that he loves her and he wont hurt his her...
as for amal m. he get on her nerves as she was calling kuku to calm her and encourage her but he told her that he has alot of problems.:S:S
gooooooo NADER , CHAHINAZ , SA3D , ABDALLAH , MOSTAFA

heyyy guyzz plzzzz can somebody tell me what did nader say to manal????and what did diaa and merihan tell her???i missed the dailies todayyy thank you ..plzzzzz

luck*** she***

I was sad not because Asma left because Zaher stayed.. I should go and thank who voted for Asma:-
Starting by Diaa, Amel M, Adnan, Saad and Ending with Abdullah.
I object with those who thought that zaher is better :
starting with nader, shahinaz, mostafa, mohamed, bader, ending with mirhan>>>

TOZ FIHOMMMM

hi evry one yesterday was the sadest day ever i mostly because of adnan i'think asma should've stay nader is trader because he know how much adnan and asma love each other beside she's a maghribine i'was very dispointed

Can someone please explain the story of Nader that happened today in the dailies. What's going on with him and Mirhan? Somethin about the Eval etc.... I didn't get it.

Wow I thought i was the only 13 year-old commenting on these stories :P I think for the weeks to come, were going to be welcomed with very surprising eliminations. I think the competition is really on now!

Omg Adnan was so cute, he loves asma so much, It was so sad, i hope nader is happy now you trader.

LOL I thought i was the only 13 year-old commenting on these articles. I think the eliminations that are coming towards us will be the most surprising yet! I think the competition is really on now!

I wonder how you girlz talking about adnan in his good way he is only a bad guy who love all girlz and have no respect for anyone of them..

He should go out . go to you tube and see how he made Kuwaiti ppl angry from him

Omg Adnan was so cute, he loves asma so much, It was so sad, i hope nader is happy now you trader.

O.M.G! people stop calling Nader a traitor, its such a heavy word, and Nadoor is the sweetest guy ever! Please think logically not mentally , Nader chose for friendship, not nationality, and this shows that he is loyal, descent and great friend, you don't find many people like him these days!!!! And it was Mirhan's final decision that got Asma out, so thiiiink before you speak please, poooor Nadoor! < He is such an amazing , sweet guy! ^^

Can someone plz explain the story that was going on between him and Mirhan.

me....can u tel me where in youtube can l see about adnan u said?l mean what shud l type to check?

Guys i promise u that one of them both Adnan or Asma sooner or later are goin' to leave the academy & there will be alot of drama & tears, but actually it was gonna be better if adnan had left first to see asma disastrous reaction at least she is a girl she can weep as much as she want but come on he is a man not like this he acted so childish & as a teenager, he need to grow up a lil bit actually..... so much. anyway i'm not blaming any guy for crying for any reason but not this way this is too much god give men more power to handle situations that are tougher 10000000 times than this.

jessica well if u have arabic keyboard write fadee7at asmaa wa adnan and paste it thyere he isss mad:D lol

why you stil hater his only 19 and never been in love before asma was his first love it was real feeling no act there so shut up like all the midel pple do every think under table so go remember your brother never did any think rong with another girl or your boy friend or it is ok to be under table so shout your mouth of who judje people i think he try to hide behinde his sin .peace

wel lgot asma adnan but just normal clip togther in academy.anywaz thanx

Today was the saddest day ever in the academy. I cried watching the dailies today and I cried more when I read in Panet about Adnan. I feel so bad for Adnan today. He really like Asmaa and it did show today. Adnan you can’t hide your love to Asmaa and today we seen it. I missed Asmaa so much she deserve to stay but it’s a game and we need to move on. There is nothing we can do right now. Today was sooooooooooo boring just like the prime. I wish her good luck. Asmaa is a STAR in our eyes. She will do well now out side the Academy. The Academy did lose a STAR yesturday. Adnan’s love to her couldn’t let her concentrate in her work.

Adnan it is very sad that Asmaa left but it is time for you to improve and concentrate in your work. Do it for Asmaa be strong and she will be very happy if you want far. We love you Asmaa and Adnan you will be a cute couple. Good luck to both of you. Asmaa don’t give up now this is your time to pursue your dream. Asmaa the STAR. Remember you are only 16 and you will be a Star before all of them. You guys that hate Asmaa just wait and see.

Diaa, Adnan, Saad, Abdlellah, and Amal M really showed today how much they care and have a good heart about their friend. Not like the others even though I like them all. Amal B congratulation I am happy that you are back because you deserve another chance. Amal B you don’t need to be that exited because it only happens once. They all got high votes the first time and than they leave for their next nomination. You better work hard or you will follow Asmaa.

To all Diaa’s haters she did what they told her to do. She is not the one that chose the song or said this is how I will perform it. The whole talblue doesn’t match the song. If she was dressed up like Merhan did in the Haifa’s song. I think you guys will like it than. This is not a good song any way I don’t belive the academy let the student sing that kind of a trashy song. But Diaa did really good singing it. It’s the surrounding and the close that don’t go with the song. Give the girl a break she does have a great voice. The people that said she screams you guys are bunch of haters. What’s about Mohamad he doesn’t scream but Diaa does. Wake up guys. They both have a strong voice. Be fair you guys. You are free to like who ever you want but please some respect to others. We are all human been.
To the person that said diaa looked like the cows in stage. That is soooooooooo wrong, rude, and mean. If you are a human been you don’t say that. Think about your god and start praying from now on. Because what you said is bad. I will pray for god to help you because you need a lot’s of help. I feel sorry for you.

I like all the students. I wish them all luck. We got so attached to them all now. It will be so hard to lose any one and we saw that today. Asmaa we missed you the academy is boring without you.

Love you Asmaa
Love you Diaa
Love you Saad
Love you Adnan
Asmaa, Diaa, Saad, and Adnan best friends for ever.

Peace

oh goshhhh,, i feel so sorry for adnane ,,, he is so saddd ,,, he really loves asma ,,, and whoever tought that zaher's voice is better than asma they are totally retarted ,,,, i mean come onn you alll,, it is obvioussss that asma's voice is much much stronger that zaher's ..... Mirhan just wanted asma to leave ,,,, girls stuff... nader is soo stupiddd , MAKE NO SENSSS to vote for zaher... he sounded sooo idiot....

Amal B is 22 not 28!!!!!

PLEASE does anyone know why Zaher did that bad on Lady in Red? I mean he did not know a single word, didn't even say the word Lady in Red!!! Did they play the wrong song for him? He totally made up the words and sang on the fly. It was soooooooo funny!!!

Was there an explanation by Zaher or anyone?

Abdulaziz,
I'm sure you have female relatives. How would you feel if you see, in print.....for the whole world to see, them described as sluts, tarts or heartless hookers? How very thoughtless, heartless and tasteless of you.

Disagree with someone's choice, opinion or action, but don't go calling them names, as harsh as the above.....especially when you know absolutely nothing about them other than the edited material (there's a 30 - 45 minute delay on transmission) that we are shown.

You're right Asma is under-aged and really should not have been allowed on this show, especially since she came with an agenda that did not include working on her musical talent. She had no chance of making it through another week without being nominated for elimination again, so it was best to just rip the bandaid off once and for all. Voting her off, does not, however, make Mirhan a whore as you mentioned under another thread. She had to make a choice and either way she wasn't going to please everyone or even herself, but she was left with the final word and she said it.

It looks like you're adding a second name to use for target practice, namely the other Egyptian, Chahinaz. So now, she has a weak and limited voice? Hmmmm??!! It's ok for you to not like these two girls...that's your opinion and you're entitled to it. Heck, it's ok for you to not like all Egyptians...and I'm sure that none of the 78 + million Egyptians will be affected over such an insignificant fact, but please......don't you start bad mouthing people because you're totally frustrated over a GAME for crying out loud.

Take a deep breath, calm down, count to a hundred or a million, if that's what it takes, but please control yourself and always remember.....that what goes around, comes around. I'd hate to think that someone in Mirhan's family had to read your very tasteless description of someone who wouldn't know you (or care to, for that matter) if she tripped over you on the street.....a total stranger!! Just put yourself in their shoes for a sec and think about how much you'd hate reading or hearing something like that about someone you love.

Finally, if this show is ticking you off so much....why not hit that little button at the top of your clicker and be done with it once and for all. No point in watching something that obviously brings out the worst in you, right?

Peace.

Well said Emme...Abduleziz thinks he is the philosopher of this site,Criticising everyone but Mohammad & Abdallah
What did they do so special for Saad?actually they treated Kammah & Carlo like kings, for nothing...no voice, no cuteness, no charisma
What's wrong with letting Saad sing a song for a special occasion?He just had that one song the whole prime.!!!!!He is the only one who can sing properly, as well as Chahinaz.
You like Mohammad & Abdallah, fine......would you be happy watching the whole prime entertained by those 2?One has a zammour boring voice with wrong tune, the other has a good voice with no charisma or stage presence
Diia & Nader are entertaining in Occidental, just like Carlo & Tina last year, but a little bit more classy & cute & Natural
If you are expecting someone like Shatha, that is not going to happen every season, she is one of the rare to be able to sing in all languages & entertain all the guests of the primes in a very professional way
Hope Mme Roula keeps Saad singing a little more, or it would be our turn to turn that TV off.
He is the only one who can put an atmosphere with a golden voice. As the matter of fact, i wouldn't mind listening to that Barja prime over & over

nada i advice to see what wadih told saad today and then say he is the only one who sings propely!

I did see & hear...it's all a game to calm down the others who think they are favoring Saad.Come on!don't we all have ears & know some music to judge that Saad has the best voice & stage presence?
Why is he given the hardest & bigger songs at the prime, otherwise?

#1. You cant compare seasons as to which was best. They are all unique.

#2. As for all of us arguing here about who has to leave when, it doesnt even matter. It is pretty obvious who is going to be in the finals.
Mohammad, Shahinaz, Saad, and Abdallah.
Because in the end the ones with the most powerful voices go to the finals regardless of personality or popularity.

#3. Last season they showed Shada fighting with all the others, with reason considering they were so immature compared to her.
They showed Carlo, who although had an incredible, incredible voice, was an arrogant and moody boy.
They both had haters and werent praised for their sometimes difficult personalities, but they still went to the finals because of their talent.
The same will happen this year. So I reccomend you guys dont get to cought up in this game so early because all of these students will be eliminated at some point, and there can only be one winner.
Does it matter if Asma left this week or the next? Not really, Either way she wasnt going to win and we all know this.

#4.People who claim Nader is a traitor. Far from it. Im not a fan of his voice, nor do i think he has a chance of winning. But he is NOT a traitor. Actually, for all those who vote based on nationality, they are the traitors to the arab people, because they create divison amongts them. Like saying "oh youre maghrebi so you deserve my vote more" is dividing the arab world.
What the heck does nationality have to do with talent?!
This is about choosing the best singer!
Although, you might argue Asma is better than Zaher at singing, she didnt work hard. And sometimes hard work beats talent when talent doesnt work hard.

#5. The people who can entertain and have some popularity but not much talent get a little farther.
For example Sally, Tina, Ahmad, Imad last year.
Probably Dia, Mirhan, Nader, and Zaher this year.
The two Amals can be added to this list also.
They are kept there for ratings and entertainment because they put on a decent show, but lord knows they will never become huge stars. They are there to fill in the void.

#6. They always keep people who have romances going on to a certain point.
In the end, you wont be a sucesseful singer because of a silly romance right? But it will keep people watching the show.

Point being, dont take it so seriously. Nationality, personality, or romance dont make the winner. Talent does. Seasons One and Two made a mistake in regards ot this.
Third season took talent seriously, and you had Joseph win. Who deserved it. Although I would have liked Shayma in the finals instead of Hana.
Fourth season, Shada, who sometimes outsung the professional guests and deserved that title more so than anyone in the hisotry of the show.
Hopefully, this season will follow suit and not repeat the mistakes of Season One and Two.

And finally, You will never have anything to do with these people, so stop defending them as if your life depended on it. Just enjoy the show and take it for what it is, ENTERTAINMENT.

For all the people who said so what if saad sang for his sister and its a special occasion, well i just have to remind you that the show is about the students, the competition, and music not about families and relatives and wasting time on showing stupid reportage about the sister of one of the students where other students cant even get to sing or even do anything, i am not a fan of saad, i dont like his personality or his character, he seems mean and fake to me no matter what he does but i cant blame him for yesterday's show, its all rola's planning, she wants to show him to the whole world, first she brings his whole family and barja people, and he sings for them by himself, then she bring his sister and the fiance to the academy, then special report yesterday about them and a song dedicated to them by saad by himself again, a full song, so whats next a wedding in the prime? Rola is playing a dirty game this year, she is taking money left and right from all the countries from voting but gives all her attention and services to saad, again i am not blaming him at all, she is just making this show going down the drain, people started to hate this season, rola is showing the girls in a very sexy short dresses to attract more viewers, giving chances to her favorites and hiding the real talents just because she does not like them, then why did you pick them? i feel bad because its so unfair, i get mad after each daily and each prime, she shows too much of mohamed durng the dailies in a very bad way and not showing him at all during the primes, why? just because he is too good and she afraid that people might like him more than saad and recognize his amazing voice, if you want saad to win then make him win but at least give the others chance to show their talents so when they leave the show they will get offers, jobs or something, since you are not helping them at all just showing how bad they are all the time.

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE
does anyone know why Zaher did that bad on Lady in Red? I mean he did not know a single word, didn't even say the word Lady in Red!!! Did they play the wrong song for him? He totally made up the words and sang on the fly. It was soooooooo funny!!!

Was there an explanation by Zaher or anyone?

W...if you hate the show that bad, just shut off your TV & go to hell
Go Saad...you are the star!
Roula exposes you because you are the only one with a good voice
I hope she makes another celebration for Saad.he is the most entertaining one.

Nada

I should not reply to low class like you but i will, who the hell are you to tell me if i can watch the show or not, i do what ever i want, i say what ever i want and i will trash saad and rola as much as i want so if you dont like it dont come to this website and dont read the comments.
Again, saad you are the star just because rola likes you. she will do anything to make sure you win, so to all saad's fans start celebrating from now, because saad academy for this year season 5 already started the parties for him.

anyone know where i can get today's dailies from?? im dying to see adnan's reaction to asma leaving!!

oh and i totally agree that saad is the teachers pet...he gets sooo much attention as opposed to others! which sucks, cause im starting to hate him..

hi proudmoroccan i cant beleive that u cried. today was just the day were i met the most emotional moroccan guy in my life he was so sweet when talking to his wife it was just amazing. am moroccan too from illinois but ive never thought that my countrymen were that emotional maybe i will start changing my mind. also u seem very into starac i wonder how much u spend watching it. i don't keep on that long usually but smtimes after a long day in college i like to take a quiq look here and there.

Hi Mia-t

Nice meeting you Mia. Yes I did cry today I felt so bad for Adnan. I also felt bad that Asmaa left. I cried because I cared and I have a good heart. Not like some people whom been so cruel to others in this site. We are all human been.

Mia for your own information I am older than you, my younger sister. I do have a beautiful family that I care about. I have a 14 year old and a 12 year old, and I work full time + my kids are in soccer clubs. I don’t have time to just sit and watch TV. Yes I do like this program and I do watch it when I have time. There is something called recording. You read my comments 4 times and you though all I do is sit and watch TV. No sorry I do have a commitment that comes first and it’s my family.

I love Asmaa and Diaa they are beautiful girls with good voice, talent, and charisma. I am proud of them as Moroccans. Asmaa will be a STAR Insha Allah. Mia-t I hope I answered your questions. It was nice talking to you.

Peace
Proud Moroccan
From LA

Madam rola yesterday told Zaher on 24/24 channel that he impressed her and all teachers coz when he totally forgot the song he pulled himself togother and made up a new song with new words and even he made the people behind her back wonder what is the name of the song and who is the singer.She said u were so confident and u kept singing and similing all the time and this takes courage and Stage presence,and charisma.She was so happy that he didnt stop singing,or throw the mick or even leave the stage.Thats way iam so happy coz u were in a difficult sitiation and u made up this new song immediatlly without showing fear or pressuse .she even said iam going to recored that new song for u so u can hear it.Any way she likes Zaher as well as i do and now even more .as for those that Said that Nader is a traitor ;he is not ;he voted for his friend .what about Diaa when she voted fOr jessica instead of Imen from Tunis?