iam egyptian but merihan didnt deserve it she was very bad in the eval.
nader deserved it moreeeeeeeee
NADER NADER NADER u r the best

wat happened to amaell and i like the breakdance that nader and moustafa did didnt know they could do thiissss

MIRHAN DIDN'T DESERVE IT MOHAMMED HE'S GREAT, ALL THE STUDENTS THEY ARE DOING BADDDDDDDD!!!!!

merihan sure she deserves the top 1
especially for her outfit she wears in the last prime in baddi 3ish
walawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww minimum top 1 :P:P:P

she didn't deserve it Mohammed deserve it, the other student r doing very badddd!!!!

lol now dont tell me mirhan is better than SAAD , abdullah , adam or even shahinaz... whats wrong with them. SAAD sang Excellent in BOTH prime and evaluation ..did u see mirhans eval??? or ZAHER sang worse than Diaa in the eval but they didnt show it... i thought they said they take into account both eval and prime? guess they didnt...

SAAD, ABDULLA , SHAHINAZ deserve the top 5 ... ZAHER and MIRHAN dont

OMG... MIRHAN didnt deserve it AT ALL..
im shocked ..x

so aline just because she wears short clothes she should be top 1???? What about the voice ,isn't this for students who want to become singers????!?!?!?

And why didn't Mohammed get more songs to sing he was only once with bashar !
I hate the teachers they want mohammed out!!

How could zaher be in top 5 ?? I like him he is funny and cute but i think no voice , i still dont think anyone deserves top 1 this week , but if we talk about the voice then definetley Mohammed !
I am so afraid that he is going to be a nomine next week and if the fans doesn't return him he is out because everyone hate him and know that he is the real cometiton (spelling?)

i am sooooooooooooooo happy dat merihan is da top 1!!
i am soo happy dat saad n shahinaz r in the top 5 as well!!

i hope dat nader n mostafa n amal B n amel M join da top 5 as well!!

Omggg i cannt believe adnan got the ppl vote like omgggg who voted for him now hes going to think hes all that with his GF asma and todayy he missed up ssooo bad when he was singinng with basher ewwwwwww poor diaa i luv herr she soo nice and sweet and khalid im going to missss himmmmmmmmm soo muchhhhh

Mirhan needs to get a life. Just because she showed some cleavage and danced like a clown it doesnt mean she's the best. Her dumb attitude needs to stop, if she's the oldest in the academy it doesnt give her the right to treat everyone like garbage!..she simply DISGUSTS me..and its sad to know she got top 1!
Shahinaz is 10 times better than her. She always sounds great, im hoping someone would wake up and put her as a top 1 student sometime soon.

i love the dance nader and mustafa did and the best thing in academy was this song sung bu diaa it vas very god and about top five i hate the top 5 i think mirhan dint deserve that much to b no.1 i think mustafa deserced to b the no.1 he did great in evaland iam also v.hapy that MR.MOHAMMED was not in top 5 YESSSSSSSS
AND I THINK NADER ALSO DESERVED TO B IN TOP COZ HE DID WELL LAST WEEK

GO MUSTAFA GO

Merihan DEFINITELY deserved top 1 !! not because someone has a great voice means they should be top 1 or even in top 5 .. it depends on alot of other things..
Mohameds personality might be the worse i have EVER seen !! and all he does is sing songs. nothing more, if he stays the way he is he will be out by maximum next week !!
Merihans personality is very strong.. and i am really happy for the way she stood up to them.. She does not treat anyone like garbage on the contrary she was verry nice to everyone since day 1. remember how she used to spend time with khaled talking in Khaleejji ?
But she said before that once someone offends her she changes and this is what she did, everysingle word she told khaled and mohamed were true, she did not swear at them she did not insult them .. and this is why they apologized because if she wasnt right they wouldnt have apologized and this is why everyone other than the two morons stood by her side and thought she was right..

I am happy merihan is top 1 however, i wish she was a little bit more conservative in how she dresses because i want her to be flawless...

wwwwwwwwwwwooooooooooooooooooowwwwwwwww MIRHAN IS TOP 1 >>>>>> CONGRATS MIRHAN >>>> I AM SOOOOOOOOO HAPPY MIMA U DESERVE IT GIRL>>>> U ROCK

Mirhan??? this girl is so 'baladi' , she's a 'radda7a' #1 not in singing!

i completely agree with bambina and zaher should have been a nominee not in top 5...he butchered james blunts song...so far the top 5 were pretty fair not this time...

mhmd desrvs to be out of the program coz of the behaviour not be in top 1 . i m happy 4 mimi be happy for her too she is creative and has a nice character , zaher is weak but he tries and saad and abduallah are the hard workers good luck to everyone
congratulations mimiiiiiii

mimi
i m moking abt mirhan top 1
they said in the reportage abt her that she sings while dancing
oh come on we r not stupid it was obviously recorded
adnan got pple voice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! so weird
y diaa sang english song with khaled n adnan
as if she s ssaying look pple i cant sing in arabic i mist sing in english to hide my weakness i wonder isnt it supposed to be arab staracademy ???

aline I'm so sorry i miss understanded you !:)

Mirhan Top 1 because of the dance last week, they keep showing how she was moving her As++++. Now the more you show and the more sexy, people watch more, Rula is happy and you are top1. (Haifa Wahbi= good example)
Mustapha & Zaher are keeping them for the girls they love those guys and every body knows that they can't sing....

how do u say Moha did good in evaluation?he forgot the lyrics.His voice is JUST strong, but bad...he is out of tune ...very boring
the best voices are Saad # 1
C hahinaz # 3
Badr # 4
Abdallah # 5
However they favor Abdallah because he sings Occidental as well...They should give Badr a chance to prove himself, his voice is excellent for Tarab
I love Diia...hope she stays till the end..the best personality
That Adam is a dirty person

wwwwwwwwwwwooooooooooooooooooowwwwwwwww MIRHAN IS TOP 1 >>>>>> CONGRATS MIRHAN >>>> I AM SOOOOOOOOO HAPPY MIMA U DESERVE IT GIRL>>>> U ROCK

EWWWW NOT MIRHAN!! SHE IS DISGUSTING AND HER TEETH ARE FAKE EWWW I HATE THAT GIRL

AMAL B SHOULD HAVE BEEN TOP 1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

woooooooooooooooooo adnan and diaa are back i'm soooo happy for them good luck kaled wow love it in your face adnan haters go adnnnnnnnnnan and diaaaaaaaaaaaaa

what the hell!!! mirhan didnt deserve it AT ALL! in her tableau last prime she wasnt singing, it was blatantly play back and she was just miming and dancing.............not top 1 quality!!!
nader or amal b or abdallah deserved it more!!
bye khalooooood gona be quite boring without him but good 2 see adnan back.

no man come on i think ths is not fair at all. i agree with u all mirhan didnt deserve it at all their are pple who's better and works harder thn her, the bst pple are well known like saad, nadar, mhmed, abdallah (although his crazy). bt i like shahinaz, and amal b diaa, she was nominee so she is out of the list 4 this week, bt thy come stright after those other bst pple so thy should have won it. i personally believe jst like sally from last year mirahan has the weaks voice out of the grls ths year.

p.s. i love the brazilian thng thy did it was cool.

OMG! why is every one picking on Mirhan. i think she deserve being top 1. and everyone that was in the top 5 deserve to be there. when they mentioned her name she was surprised..and plus the academy is trying to give everyone a chance in being TOP 1 besides Mohammad was already top 1 and he didnt do that good last week... and the teachers look at everything and how they treat each other in the academy and by the way i see it mohammads voice is good but his personality is terrible and he hardly gets a long with anyone. I have nothing against him., and i think hes one of the best voices in the academy but i think he needs to work on his attitude...besides that CONGRATS MIRHAN and everyone in the top 5.
im glad khaled left it was time...Congrats diaa and adnan u guys deserve it..

GO MOustapha...saad....nader..shahinaz...and mirhan!!!!

what the hell is u guys problem i think mirhan deserved it more than anyone shes beautiful can dance she has a very nice voice even though it may not be the bet it is still very nice shes creative, she totally deserved it 100% congrats mima mhmd has a nic voice but he doesnt listen, SO EVERYONE STOP HATING ON MIRHAN HOW COME WHEN EVERYONE ELSES WAS TOP 1 U SAID CONGRATS THIS IS SO STUPID U PPL NEED HELP!!

GO MIRHAN MUSTAFA NADER SAAD AND DIA AND JUST SO EVERTONE KNOWS IM NOT EGYPTIAN IM LABANESE..

before I used to like mohammed from jordan but now lately when I saw when the teachers were discussing his behaviour i gut disgust..
when wadi3 said that he asked mohammed to sing with the coral he got upset & wanted only to sing by himself..

so he thinks alot about himself, he's still n the academy and behaves like that..."az3ar style".. idnt thnk he ll make it far..

regarding merhan..she's ok

what?!!!!
nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!
nader is not in the top 5.OMG it is totally unfair unfair unfair.
saad and abdulla are always in the top 5,we've already memorized it (ta7sel 7asel) bas inno fi 3alam 3'airon in the academy 3am yit3abo kamen.
shahinaz deserves more than the rank 5,she must be in the first rank or at least the second.
mirhan even though i like this girl very much ,but i think she doesn't deserve the top 1because last monday she was sick and she said that she feel uncomfortable with the eval's song.the only reason that made her reach this, is the clothes and movement in the last prime.
what can i say ROLA liked that!!
wow good jop mirhan you now have all the qualifications (the body more than the voice)
SO WALK ON THE ROLA'S WAY YOU'LL NEVER REGRET.
zaher was bad in the eval how come he is in the top 5.OH NO COMMENT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm really shocked .
UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR.

dando0ona

I agree with you hundred percent. Nader was very good in the previous prime. And on the eval he and Zaher performed together. Nader was soooooooooooooooooo much better than Zaher. Zaher even forget his words and Nader kinda tried to sing along with him to cover his pals a**. And Zaher in top 5 and Nader not. This is really funny.

Love you Nader. You deserve much better

Mirhan don't deserve to be Top1.. i think that shahinaz is mush better..And i hope that Mohammed will be in the top5 next week he sung only one song and it was so great ..... *ANd i hope that shahinaz will be top1 next week she deserve it MORE than mirhan
Good Luck Mohammed & Shahinaz

mirhan do not deserve top one her voice is ugly
shahinaz has an excellent voice she deserve top.
mirhan looser looser never loved her at all
if she is a great dancer that do not mean that she has great voice or that she deserve top1

yea i agree with you guys, mirhan didn't deserve it,she doesn't know how to sing at all. i thought that shahnaz or mohammad or nader were gonna be #1. i can't even believe that mohammad wasn't even in the top 5. Rola is playing a game, she wants everyone to hate mohammad so he can go home, well guess what he's the best out of all the other students so he's staying wethere she likes it or not:)
good luck mohammad, shahinaz, and nader<3

Next week's nominees
Mhmd, Adnan, Asmaa
& if Mhmd doesn't get the audience..BYE BYE =)

& Top 1 is not about voice..it's about how much of an effort someone put in their work for the week

& Mhmd messed the 2 sentences he had to sing with the GREAT Bashar...=)
Mhmd nominee
Mhmd nominee
Mhmd nomineeeeeeee!!=)

& even though i LOVE Zaher..Nader deserved his spot in the top5...just because Zaher didn't have much to sing last prime

mirhan has the weakest voice out of the girls.....she shouldnt be top 1.
nader or mohammad should have been instead.
shahinaz has the best voice out of the girls but she has no stage presence at all! shes so boring to watch and doesnt know how to put up a good performance........she needs osama rahbani 4 sure!!

how can MOhammad be top ! when he forgot the lyrics at the eval?he was arrogant & missed classes....he performed terrible at the prime?
Top 1 is based on all those, not only a zammour voice with no tune
he thinks he knows it all...when the guests sing, he makes a grimace like:Oh, I'm better
he makes believe that he plays the guiatr, but what is he playing?just bumping to disturb his friends all the time

mirhaaaaaaan is the best ;) she deserves to be the top 1 in all the primes :P:P
luv u meri

Listen everyone, think of it that way .. if someone is already strong then if theyre top 1 its not a big deal.. but if someones whos not that strong goes there then is something. im not saying merihan is weak im saying that there are people who are stronger than her(voice wise) but do not work as hard as she does. personally i watch the evals everyweek and shes always very creative and if you noticed she helps others with their ideas too.. give her some credit
Mohamed does not deserve to be TOP 1 at all because he is depending on his voice and he does not work on the eval or anyth and this is not enough at all

OK...SO FIRST OF ALLL WELCOME BACK DIAA....WE LOVE U...SECOND OF ALL WHY IS EVERYONE AGAINST MIRHAN..DONT BE HATING BECAUSE SHES PRETTY AND SHES GOT EVERYTHING TO BE A SINGER...HER VOICE IS BETTER THAN AMEL M., ASMA...MIRHAN IS THE MOST RESPECTFUL GIRL IN THE ACADEMY.SHES FRIENDS WITH EVERYONE AND EVERYONE LOVES HER...MOHAMMED GETS ON MA LAST NERVES..HES SOOO AGGRESSIVE AND THINKS HES ALL THAT...YEAH HES GOT A GOOD VOICE BUT A SINGER IS NOT ONLY BASED ON A GOOD VOICE ITS ABOUT THE WAY HE TREATS OTHERS AND HIS TEACHERS...HE DOESNT TAKE ANYONES ADVICE AND ALWAYS WANTS TO START A PROBLEM....I DONT LIKE HIM AT ALL HE NEEDS TO GROW UP.....SO ALL U HATERS OUT THERE WHO HATE MIRHAN DONT BE JEALOUS...KEEP THE FREAKIN COMMENTS TO URSELF BC THE GIRL DESERVES OUR ENCOURAGEMENT...IM AMERICAN AND I LOVE THIS SHOW ALOT...GO MIRHAN, SAAD, DIAA, SHAHINAZ, ZAHER, MOSTAFA, NADER,AND ABDALLAH

Mithan does not deserve it!!! But I know that Madame Rola is trying to give everyone a chance to be number one so wat ev.

OK FIRST OF ALL WHY WOULD WE THE PPL THAT ARE JUST WATCHING THIS SHOW BE JEALOUS OF MIRHAN? IT'S NOT LIKE SHE MY COMPETITION TO BE JEALOUS OF HER. AND BESIDES SHE IS NOT RESPECTUFL AT ALL, SHE YELLS AT EVERYONE THAT GETS ON HER NERVES, AND SHE MAKES THEM FEEL LIKE SH*T, HELLO , SHE YELLED AT EMAN, SHAHINAZ,KHALED, ADAM, SHOULD I GO ON? THAT'S WHY SHE GETS MAD EVERYTIME SOMEONE TELLS HER SHE'S FAKE, MAYBE BECAUSE SHE IS. I LIKE ADAM BUT I LIKE TO SPEAK THE TRUTH, HE NEEDS TO FIX HIS ATTITUDE BUT HE STILL HAS THE BEST VOICE.

1. Merhan did not deserve top 1
2. She has a weak voice
3. She has a bad temper,we all saw that last week.
4. She won because she danced like haifa with tight shorts and top, thats what rola is looking for in a star.
5. She is very arrogant and does not forgive others.
6. She is in love with a 18 year old kid who is next to her looks like her son.
7. Non of her friends thought she deserevs it thats why they were all shocked and did not congratulate her at first.
7. Comparing to shahinaz from her country, shahinaz has much better voice, actually you cant even compare the two when it comes to voice.
8. She can be a show girl who dances, acts, but not singer at all.
9. The students like her because she is not a competition to them, thats why they hate mohamed and shahinaz, they have the best voices and everybody is jealous from them or at least want them out soon.
10. Afte all, i am not impressed with marihan at all, she seemed sweet the first couple of weeks but now i can defenitly see her true personality but thats what rola likes, people like marihan, just so she can show off more skin and tight clothes.

how come the eldest candidate act as if she is younger than asma
how come she says ah mohamad lessa faker t2olli mabrouk 3al top 1 ama eja w alla mabrouk
but hey even asma told her mabrouk but cos merihane was shocked of the result cant see in front of her what others do

U guys are making a great deal of the Top 5. It doesn't mean anything in the academy. Zaher (I like him) almost got nominated this week but he's in the top 5. This is just a way to encourage the students u can be in the top 5 and still be nominated, Nader was gre8 this week but he's not in the Top5 so what, it doesn't mean that he'll be out next week. THE IMP THING IS HOW LONG U STAY IN ACADEMY NOT HOW MUCH U"RE IN THE TOP5.

U guys are making a great deal of the Top 5. It doesn't mean anything in the academy. Zaher (I like him) almost got nominated this week but he's in the top 5. This is just a way to encourage the students u can be in the top 5 and still be nominated, Nader was gre8 this week but he's not in the Top5 so what, it doesn't mean that he'll be out next week. THE IMP THING IS HOW LONG U STAY IN ACADEMY NOT HOW MUCH U"RE IN THE TOP5.

ok, i dont think that mirhan should have been the #1 but alteast they had shahinaz there, cuz she is really good! i think star academy is just a soap opera thing!!! seriously, it all makes sense, how come ALMOST EVERYONE in the academy has a crush on someone, How come at night, diaa and Mirhan talk about love and relationship with their MICS stuck to their SHIRT!!!?? doesnt that seem fishy to you???? How come Diaa,who was nominee, got like 2 songs and a half, but zaher didnt sing at ALL!!! it really just is getting really fishy. especailly since now mdme rola is making every student talk about their personal life and stuff!! shame on you, shame on you

People, relax!
Mirhan isn't the best but she's ok, and why wouldn't she deserve to be top 1 this week?
Yes Shahinaz is much better, but she'll be top 1 eventually! It has always been like that with the best girls in Starac: Shada was top 1 in the 9th prime, Hanaa in the 10th prime, Chaymae top 2 in the 10th prime, Marwa ... well I don't remember, but I don't think it was in the beginning of the show.
Who do think will be nominee?

XXX

People, relax!
Mirhan isn't the best but she's ok, and why wouldn't she deserve to be top 1 this week?
Yes Shahinaz is much better, but she'll be top 1 eventually! It has always been like that with the best girls in Starac: Shada was top 1 in the 9th prime, Hanaa in the 10th prime, Chaymae top 2 in the 10th prime, Marwa ... well I don't remember, but I don't think it was in the beginning of the show.
Who do think will be nominee?

XXX