Wow! im speech less .. totally unexpected

i love how u guys are SO up to date!! thnk u thnk u :)

omggg it was such shockk,,, amall wow.. im suprised and i didnt want khalid to be a nominee this weekkk i felt srry for him he did his best... but the whole thingggg the way they did ittt goodddd but kept u on ure nervoussss and its good that asmaaa is a nomiee she need to learn she cannttt foul around 24/7 she there to learnnn and workkk not make love storiesssss

oh my god if anyone ca n go 2 last week's prime comments i ve written that imane ur day is so soon and here re my expectations!!!!!!!!!!!!! i hope she had seen it when she kept doing silly stuff last prime my guess is that imane is comming back this week and amal m7lawy has got the ppl's votes
asmaa hope this would teach u something

omg asma is nominee? oh my good why???
Pleaaaasee voteee for asmaaaaaa :D

I think Iman will leave

hahaah mouteee ya imaaaaaaaaaaan
you was so happy when ahmad left sooooooo feel likeee ahmaad youuu snakeeeee i hate youuuu i hope you will leftt and i think asnan will win the results and amal M will come back

its all about where u came from . the 3 of them are from alma'3reb so that means they wanna get 1 of them out . also as we see 3 girls cus many boys was out . really silly ( kind of happy that khalid is not with them )

Asma will get people's votes, and amal will get her friend's votes..Iman will leave..and i think shes the worst out of them anyway!

its all about where u came from . as we can see the 3 of them are from alma'3reb so that means they wanna get 1 of them out . also 3 girls cus alot of boys was out . thats silly ( kind of happy that khalid is not with them ) . i think that amal will be out

I think (I don't hope) that Asma will win el jomhurs votes 100%.. Because the two others are both from tunisia so it's gonna be hard when tunisians has to vote for both..

El tolab will have to choose between Amal M and Imen and that's where it gets exiting.. But I already know for a fact that Zaher/Amal B will vote for Amal M.. and the rest is .... still unknown! But poor Nader he has to choose between the two girls from his country.. good luck! :(

I REALLY WANNA SEE AMAL MAHLOUI BACK IN THE ACADEMY .. AS FOR ASMA AND IMEN I DON'T CARE CUZ I CAN'T TAKE THEM SERIOUSLY THEY ARE TOO IMMATURE!

jawa and diana

why are you hated her so much asma is more talented than the other girls really

it's just that she didn't good on the prime.
just stop you're comment with you and not telling everybody that you hated her the're peoples who likes asma PEOPLE like me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DON'T YOU HAVE ANY RESPECT OF THE NOMINEES.YOU'RE REALLY CHILDLISH REALY .AND IT IS VERY DIFFUCULT TO VOTE BECAUSE THEY ARE FROM MAGHREB AL3ARABI.
BUT I HOPE THAT ASMA AND AMAL M WILL COME BACK INSHA ALLAH THEY BOTH DESERVE SECOUND CHANCES.

AND IF SHE IS IN LOVE(SHE'S NOT IN LOVE WITH ADNAN HE IS JUST A FRIEND)LET HER BE.IF YOU WAS ON THAT AGE DEFINETLY YOU THINK ABOUT THE BOYS ON THAT AGE STARTED THE LOVE OF COURSE.REALY PEOPLE YOU ARE SO ANNOYING AND SO CHILDLISCH,I BET THAT ASMA MORE IMATURE THAN YOU.PLEASE GET A BREAK!!!!!!!!!!!

can somebody tell how can we vote give me some sms number or so that we can voted.

i think the nomination was totally fair
Asma or Amel M. will win the votes...and iman should leave that is enough i hate her esp. last prime when she was laughing that ahmed left ...
isaaaaaaaaaaaa imen leaves..
gooooooo NADER , MOSTAFA ,Sa3D , ABDALLAH , SHAHINAZ ,MERIHAN are the best

OOOOOOMMMMMMMMGGG!!!!
Lolz, I don't really care about them, all i care about is that ZAHER, MUSTAPHA, NADER, MOE, MIRHAN, ARE NOT NOMINEEEEEEEESS.

asma is not immature she is great i hope she will get the public votes

how can we vote please tel me

Hello every one. As a Moroccan I am so proud of Diaa and Asmaa. They have a great voice, and great looks I still think that they both did very well in the Eval. I like all the students this year even Adnan I think he is funny. I like him and I don't blame him about what's happening with Asmaa. Remember they are both teenagers. What do you expect. I blame the LBC because they are the one that show us what they want us to see.

It is so hard to see any of them leave but it is part of the game. I think this week one of the student from Tunisia will leave for sure. This is why; we had 3 Lebanese one left. We had 3 Egyptians and one left. I really like Ahmad I think he will be very succesful in his life and he has a great talent. Now it is time for Tunisia because there are 3 students. And I think Iman will leave this time. I have no problem with her at all, but I think she will be a better dancer than a singer. One day she was sitting with Adnan and she told him she rather be a dancer than a singer. So I think those words will get her out.

They get rid of the Iraqi guy first because he does have potential and they don't want another Iraqi to win. I don't think this year will be for Lebanon either even though I love Saad and Mostapha they have a great voice and they will go very far specially Saad. I love his voice, and his looks he is so cute with Diaa. I love when I see them together. I don't think it will be for Egyptian either because they had their chance all ready. They won’t give it to Abdullah, even though I like this guy he has a great voice. I think Abdullah and Saad will be very successful even if they didn’t win. And I think Abdullah, and Saad will go very far in the game. Good luck to them all.

This is what I think, and what I seen happen before. The winner this year it will either be Mohamad, or Amal B, or Nader, or one of the Moroccans Diaa or Asmaa. Even though I doubt they will give it to Morocco because this past 4 years of Star Academy, LBC don’t like Moroccans I don't know why.

I knew Khalid would not be Nominee this week. I think he did well in the Eval. They will give him a break to see if he will change. And he was so funny today; he really tried to do better in the Eval.
And for Asmaa this is her wake up call. She does have the potential and talent she just needs to work harder than ever. I do give Asmaa credit because she is 16 and she did very well in the academy with older students. I think she is really mature for her age 16. And she does have a great voice. I am not saying this because I am Moroccan, but I am saying based of what I see. I don’t think she will leave but I could be wrong. I won’t be upset if she leave because the whole program is planed, and it is a game. I am 100% sure that Amal will not leave either. But for Iman I wish her luck in Dance, because she is really good at it especially what we saw today. Best of luck to them all

Thank you for reading my comment, and remember this is what I think. And to all the people who use the word HATE please don’t use it for your own sake. It is a bad word. Support who ever you want. Whether you like them because they are cute or maybe they are from your countries use good words for support and don’t start a war. And remember the saying (what goes around comes around)

Diaa and Asmaa we are so pound of you keep up the good work.
Come on Asmaa wake up you can do better than this.

Love,
Proud Moroccan
From LA

Asma is more talented, indeed, but in what? in jerking!
what does she has?no voice, no cuteness no naturality, very immature...she thinks she is the baby of the Academy & every1 is going to fall for her.She better packs & go home

asmaa z gonna get da highest votes, cuz shes morracan n da other 2 r tunishans so obviously asmaa might get da highest, by da wat can some1 plz answer me, r asmaa nd adnan still 2gather?????cuz they dont look lik it...

proud moroccon

i agree with you.asma needs to wake up she can do better than that.
i am also a morocan and i realy like all of them but my vote is to asma because she had voice.realy she had the voice and she need to have a secound chance.

and all that hate is not the sullusion of this we need supported our favouriete students not in some kinda war.we all brothers and sisters.

can somebody tell me how can we vote to the student

Asma will get people's votes.

Amel will get her friends' votes.

Imen will get the f*ck out of the Academy, finally.

Good.

asma is very talented girl and who are you to tell who is good and who is bad you don't like her so keep your opinion to your self all i read in here i hate iman i hate adnan i hate asma i hate abdallah give us a brak bite it looke in the mirror you will see an agly person! there full of hate goooo asma.

Who says Asma will win the public's votes? I think it will be Amal!
Good luck to all of them x

Asma: I hope you realise now that you've got to start concentrating!
But I haven't seen the evals and the comments of the teachers, what did they say and I heard Asma did good in the eval?!

LOVE AND PEACE

go asmaaaaaa we love you plz vote for him

I love you all girlls pleas donnt goo:'(

Elyssar 's opinion is that Asma is no good!!!!!so we better say good bye to her
remember that because of Elyssar, Amani Sweissi didn't win..She couldn't stand her.
she is always smiling to Iman & Amal...those would return

@NESSRINE

awaaaal shi read right
i said i hate imaaaaan
and i dont like asmaa but i liked her last week because she voted for ahmad
yes asma is talented but she is too young AND I HATE HER AND TO DALIDA EVERYBODY CAN SAY HIS OWN OPINION IF HE OR SHE DONT LIKE A PERSON HE CAN SAY IT! and kill al MOSLEMSS in this academy they have to respect their relegion!!!!
OKKK AND I AM SURE THAT THESE GIRLS ARE NOT MOSLEMSSS AND MANY OF YOU OFTEN SAID DONT BRING THE RELEGION BUT ALLAH IS everywhere""!!!
noone from you looks and say that a swimmig pool is a biggg mistake ,noone from you says that the girls sit with the boys onnnnnn a bed ,and soooo onnn you all know what i mean i like starac but i often think to myself wallaaaaah haraaam!!!

zaher ya alyyyyyyyyyyy ya amar minn gamani kil palasteine mark meriam

vote for ASMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

PLEASE I DON'T WANTED HER TO GO

WHY THE TEACHERS NOT GIVING HER THE SONG THAT SHE LIKES

SHE LIKES TARAB A LOT .AND WHEN SHE WAS SINGING 3ALLI GARAH WAS GREAT

NO SHE ONLY HAVE TO SING AL THAT SILLY SONGS

PLEASE VOTE FOR HER

oh Diana i was thinking the same thing tht she was sooooo happy when ahmad was out i feel the same thing oh im so happy my enemy is nominee thak god i wish she gonna out ths prime aameen inshallah she is rediculaous i i still dont knw y she was happy ahmad was her frnd i dont knw ??????????any way i miss ahmad i cant forget him

love u mostafa go..................

Faty.. u said what I wanted to say.. though I wouldn't use the F word *but frankly I laughed a lot because of it =D*

Asma for sure will get votes.. she's the best voice out of the three.. she deserves a chance.. specially she was the best girl in this eval.. even sang better than Chahy!

Amal M.. for sure will have the votes of Amal B., Mohamed, Mirhan, and Zaher.. have no idea about the rest.. however I wish they give her a second chance as this is Iman's second chance.

P.S.
I really don't wanna Amal M. to go.. I love Academy's Angels and don't want them separated just yet!

i wish madam rola gonna have a wild card rentry oh her show coz ths is very poupolar in every show and i wish ttht the person gonna b back is ahmad coz i really love him i cant forget him i miss u NEES..............

i think the three deserves the nomination (no offense):
asma :because of the last primes and i think that the teachers want her to wake up and focus on her lessons .

iman: totally fair,but the question is:IS IT TRUE THAT IMAN WILL LEAVE THIS FRIDAY?! or her colleagues will pick it again like what happen with khalid last friday.(everything is possible .so i will wait till the next prime).

amal m:i feel sad for her .hope she'll get the audience vote (even though i don't think so),she is my favourite out of the three.GOOD LUCK AMAL.you deserve a second chance.

go mostafa .
go nader you are the winner this year nshalla

i hate imaan
im so happy sheis nominee hahahahahahaahh
i just hate her she was very happy in last prime and were loughing on ahmad now im loughing on her lollllllllllllll hahahahaaha i wish she gonna b out inchallah i love u diana u r right i agree with u

hope that AMEL M ll come back because dhe deserves more ....... i sont care about the others ........ HAPPY THAT MIRHAN AND NADER ARE NOT NOMINEES

I think Mustafa is the cottiet and the smartest guy i ever seen in star acedemy oh god he is sooooooooooo cure MASHALLAH i wish he will be the of STAR AC 5

love him go u all r with u

Ma3 kol e7teramy le kol elly men tunis, bas ana hamoooot mel far7a eny Eman nominee wensh2allah hatkhrog, we law makharagetsh el esboo3 dah, haybo2a elly ba3doh be2znellah! That's what she gets for treating Ahmed like crap when they were voting, she was totally disrespectful! Hopefully Asma gets the highest votes b/c she really deserves to stay, SHE HAS A BEAUTIFUL VOICE!! and Amal.M is WAAAAAAY better than Eman.

heeeeeeeey asma nominee yesssss yesssssssssss i hate her and amal 2 go out yarab iman terga3
asmaaaa go out go out
yesssss yesssssssssssssss

i voted for amal m .. good luck to all of them:)

hey Guys, i have a question...
at the beginning on Starac 5 when they were introducing themselves...Amel said here dad was Egyptian, but he passed away...so tht makes her Egyptian....i guess they dnt mention it cz they dnt want Egypt 2 vote...makin it unlikely for her 2 get the jomhour votes...
Wat do u guys think...

no Sandy.. they mentioned it last prime.. they said she is Tunisian with Egyptian roots.

yarabe asma tirebah yarbe sawito lasma 3chene tistahle

I really dont see why people like Asma. Everyone says she acts mature for her age but i dont think they are watching the dailies. If they were they would see she is extremely immature. I agree with diana.. this is not the way muslims are supposed to act. I hope asma leaves, shes tooo annoying. Amal deserves to win the public's vote. She has an amazing voice, great looks, and class. I want Imene to stay because she is very entertaining to watch plus she sings well.

This is a good example of how the LBC manipulates the show direction! To get rid of Iman they have Asma, who will get the majority of the public votes, and Amal-M, who will get majority of the student votes, because she is not a threat to anyone and you can count by each student ...

Abdulaziz,

First of all, thanks for responding my comments on the preveous articles. I always enjoy reading your comments, they're always right: the thing you sad about Gabi vs. Khaled and the LBC, ...
It's all true, but I couldn't say it better nor think it better!
As I recently wrote in a comment, I think Amal will be saved by the audience: Asma has created a problem in Morocco! Some people from the Moroccan government sent a letter to StarAc saying that Asma must leave for her own sake! And so on...
Salaam, wherever you are...(your quote :-p)

Thanks 4 the reply Rika...i guess then IMO tht Amal will b saved since she has 2 countries voting 4 her...which will make a difference since her vote wont b affected by the fact tht she is a nominee wit another Tunisian...fingers crossed

no offense...but they are all annoying and weak. i dont like this year's staracademy...i miss straracademy 3, i think their voices were much better, and they were much more mature.

asma is nomena wowww shocked she have a good voice but i dont like he so i hope she gets out and iman will get out this week or next week amal is nice i think she shold stay for a longer time!!! r yaaaaa zaher keep on working hard we love u (:

Hey, Maghrebi from Belgium!

Nice to get your response. In case you're wondering, I am in NY (state). Thanks for the news about Asmaa. Somehow I feel very strongly about her "case" (...) Anyway, I think she will get more support because the majority of voters at this "stage of the game," according to some poles in the Middle East, are the female voters, and they do not find Amal-M attractive (as some guys do). I think the LBC took her in the show because for a "decoration" (especially appealing to the male audience), like Shuru last year. Etc., etc. (They just want to get rid of Iman ..). If you read the last prime thread and my answer to "Arabia" I must tell you I had to scramble it fast as I did not have much time, and did not actually explain the main thing behind that assessment, and will do it after the next prime (so you will get my point fully explained). I browse this site twice a week, after primes and nominations; as I expect to hear something interesting from the site owner or the contributors in the forum, but it does not happen often, mostly just teenager fights ...

A bientot !

To Maghrebi from Belgium!

Oops ! A typo occured (and sorry for some other obvious mistakes) : "pole" - should be "polls"

aaaaah, some ppl r just hating on khaled but i wont mention names cause this show will be over and very1 will be cool again and stop acting dumb, well, its just a show, we basically kinda know who will win, its either mahmad, or saad, or nader, cause they have good voices, and the rest will leave eventually, i hope khaled doesnt leave..ill be voting for him all day, and night and call all my friends in kuwait to vote for him, well goodluck khaled, and i hope asma leaves cause all she does is cry and act like a baby which she is and all she did is act dumb with adnan, so go amal and imane

Hi everyone!First of all, I was very shocjked when I heard that Asma was a nominee.

Last week,Wadii told Ahmed that they evaluate everything.I ,personally,don't believe that.

The judges put Asma(I'm sure) as a nominee only based on her performance on the last prime.You all have to admit that she did the best in the evaluation (Compared to the other girls).

Some people also forget the fact that she's only,I repeat ONLY 16 years old.

So,to all MOROCCAN, ALGERIAN, EGYPTIAN, LEBANESE, PALESTINIAN, IRAQI, SAUDI ARABIAN, KUWAITI, SYRIAN people( Sorry I didn't mention the rest) to Please Vote for the Best nominee, for ASMA BASIT from Morocco.

Please do NOT forget that she's only 16 but she's one of the Best. Shahinaz is 23 years old. Can you imagine how good Asma's voice would be in 7 years?

Just imagine! She's Going to be Al Mutriba Asma!!!!

All I was trying to say is that LOOK AT HER POTENTIAL.