OMG! I can't actually believe am gonna say this.. but Adnan was AMAZING!! more over I think he was even better than Saad.. who wasn't as great as always!

I'm not a fan of Adnan.. but he keeps it like that and am gonna change my mind.. that's a given!
good job.. really!
*still bewildered a bit.. I haven't seen this coming at all!*

WTH!!!
okay something gotta be off this evaluation!!!
coz I know for sure that Mohammed can do waaaaaaay much better than that.. at times he was off tone and his voice was quavering!!

so what? is it some kind of curse hit the best 2 guys in the Academy?!!! this is not them.. they r 100 times better than that.. I was watching in shock!

I liked Saad's and Adnan's scene.. it's nothing original.. just a save play.. but they pulled it right..

Mohamed and Amal's scene is more creative but a bit vague, and they lost me at some points.. I'm not impressed.

Amal's voice was great but she seemed out of breath more than once.. but still she was quite good!

OMG! I don't know now what to expect from the rest.. I mean Saad and Adam totally let me down.. I guess all I can do now is wait and see.

yes yes yes.. adam and saad could be much beter specialy saad coz he issss gr8 with abdlhaleeem mhamad isnt as goood with abdlhaleem usually he is more wadi3 alsaffi

adnan was goood
amal b nooo she forgot lyrics and was out of breathh
imans scene was gr8 not the singing
baders singing wass okkk to some extentttt
haydolthat i saw
nader usualy betterrr nashaz
asmaa ws good
diaa not badd
amal m not good

so far out of the four girls I've seen Asmaa was the best! she sang perfectly and her tone was just right and sweet.. loved it alot.. good job Asmaa.. and keep it up.. hope u perform on stage like that!
Diaa..mmmm.. I'm just wondering does she deliberately changes the tone of the songs to suit her voice.. or she's just always off tone?? I have a dream is one of my fav. songs.. and I don't like it to be sang like that!at some verses she was right and at others she was totally off.. and she changed a few words on her accord too!.. Diaa was totally out-shined by Asmaa in this eval.. liked there idea too.. it's simple and cute

Abdallah and Mirhan.. best scene so far.. Abdallah made a great psycho.. and Mirhan also did a great job playing the victim.
singing wise.. Abdallah should work harder on studying the songs!! he totally forgot some lines.. didn't he do the same thing last week too?.. Mirhan has a sweet sweet voice.. but really need to work on it.. the first 'meshwar' was wrong.. second 'meshwar' was right.. Abdallah was kinda mechanical in the first part of the song.. and I don't know whether it was the recording or his real voice that gave that strange ups and downs.

Is it true that NADER didn't sing well in the evaluation ,plz somebody tell me because i have missed his evaluation.
GO nader you are the best.

hi nader sang ok bas he is usualy better he saidd it kamen and i didnt like their seen

after today's eval,i think the nominees will be mostly girls:amal b, diaa and amal m.

it's officialy a curse! LOOOL =D
Nader.. Nader oh Nader.. why vendalize my song =(?? I love this song.. don't u sing it like that!!.. Nader voice was like if it is coming from under water!! or as if he was connected to a vibrator.. Amal M. was kinda scary *alot scary actually* and she did the tones well and everything.. but I don't like the song from her.. it was like converted the A's into E's if anyone one knows what I mean.. didn't like their scene it was creepy to me.. =D.. but hey at least it stands out.

Chahinaz and Khaled.. BORING.. the most boring evaluation ever.. have no idea why Khaled was running ecstatic about =$ !!!
his singing improved.. Chahy was fairly good.. but not WOW.. they both were very boring in the eval.

Badr and Iman.. it was kinda funny at last.. Badr sang beautifully.. Iman was better than before too.. but also nothing so interesting in the scene as well.. though I loved it when he strangled her! LOL

can't hear Zaher and Mustafa so till a further note.. no comment.

so I think Mirhan this week should remain in the top 5.. Adnan should join the top 5 *he was really good we have to admit.. he should be rewarded for that*.. about the rest.. I don't know the best students are rather falling back rather than making a progress!

RIKA thank you for ur comments ....... i totally agree with u

WALEEEEEEEEG...IS THERE ANYWAY WE CAN SEE ZAHER AND MOSTAFAS PLZZZ CUZ THATS THE ONE I WAS WAITING FOR ALL DAY!

iliked the scene of nader and amal it was different ,ilike wierd stuff lol and they r good in actin,ooh im really worry about nader coz in the end he messed up,ba the actin was good and the singin too just in the end so what do u think who will not be nomine right ?????????plz tamnoniiiiiii

akeed he is nott 3 gurls aw 2 gurls and khaledd amal m , iman... all indanger i dont wana put my hopes so high 8-) butt i thnk so

dina.. u're welcome sweety ^.^
glad someone agrees with me.. it's really a wonder who will be nominee tomorrow with Khaled *coz that's a given*

okay soo....this is what i think.

Badr - he actually did pretty good...i dont think he will be a nominee.
Iman--> definetly a nominee- she didnt do great.
(their scene was boring)

Khaled-- i dont know..he improved...but do u guys think he will be a nominee?? i dislike him and i want him out...and its the students faults for votin him back...because i dont know if he will be a nominee this week.
Shahinaz-- she did well, she wont be a nominee.
(their scene was SOO UNORIGINAL)

Abdulla- it was weird...i dont know if he sang and changed his tune in the middle of it...it might have been the recording..but i doubt he will be a nominee.
Mirhan- she did really bad! i feel bad for her, but her singing was not good...and i think she will be a nominee.
(the scene was good)

Asma- she was the best one out of the girls, in singing that song...she did amazing. i hope she isnt a nominee because the prime...but i feel like she will be.
Diaa- she did surprisingly well...she wont be a nominee.
(the scene was cute)

Nader- he didnt do that well, but he wont be a nominee.
Amel- she might be a nominee cause she didnt soo well, and i did not understand their scene...can someone explain?

Amal B- SOO BAD! OMG. she will be a nominee....i am soo upset....she is one of my fav...but she didnt do well!
Mohammed- he was okay, he wont be a nominee....ps someone again explain to me their scene...i didnt understand it...it was plain.

Adnan- he did surprisingly really well...i was shocked. i really dislike him and the way he treats asma and i want him out...but he did well so he wont be a nominee.
Saad- usual, pretty good...wont be a nominee.
(their scene was okay)

and waleg...there is no sound on zaher and mostafas...and plz can u fix that...because that is the one ive been waiting for the most!

THANKS

You guys think Khaled would be a nominee?

i dont know.. he sounded pretty good and the teachers seemed impressed.. maybe if the scene was better he would have definately secured not being nominated..

i think the nominees for sure are
Amal B
Amal M
Iman
but offcourse in danger are
Khaled
Nader
Abdullah.. kid forgot words the last two evaluations!
and offcourse Zaher.. he didnt do well in New york.. bummer really

i hope it wont b amal b cozz in the primee she was really goood. and yes i dnt thnk khaled will b i hav this feeling every1 says he improved

jana why do u say mirhan did bad i thought she actually did well.

i think the nominees would be khaled, ofcourse, iman, and nader

JANA I AM NOT AGREE WITH U....... MIRHAN DID VERY GOOD IN ACTING AND HER SINGING WAS GOOD TOO NOT THAT BAD AS U SAID SHE GOT A BIG TALENT IN ACTING MORE THAN THE OTHER GIRLS AND HER VOICE IS SO SWEET AND ROMANTIC....... AMEL B FORGOT THE WORDS BUT I HOPE SHE WONT BE NOMINEE ... AMEL M WAS SINGING BAD SHE WAS AFRAID .... IMAN'S VOICE IS SUCKS .... ZAHER WAS NOT THAT GOOD ..... KHALID SHOULD BE OUT ...... ABDULLAH AND NADER FORGOT THE LYRICS ......MIRHAN NO WAY TO BE NOMINEE NOW....... GOOOOOO MIRHAN ALL THE WAY AND I LOVE NADER SO MUCH

HOW WAS ZAHER "NOT THAT GOOD" IF U CANT EVEN HEAR THE SOUND?

i love zaher so much and i hope he wont be nominee but i did watch his eval at the 24 channel and he was nit that good....... sorry

NO....omg why zaher?!?!?! did he sing in arabic or english?! omg...i like him a lot..but his voice is weak...HE NEEDS TO IMPROVE. UGHHH ZAHER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i am so upset. i HOPE he isnt nominated...

I liked Diae and Asmae's evaluation. They interpreted, acted and sang very well both songs and the scene they played was very cute. Way to go girls!

i like the eval of dia and asma they were great,the acting was good.and i found asma ssooooooooooooooooo sweeeeeeeeet she did it good.oh please let her not be nominated.pleaaaaaaaaaase.

i realy like the girl now.she is so sweet i don't get people why they hated her so much.
i hope she will not be nominated, and i hope that's she will do it great in prime i realy hope so oh she realy had the talent.

so please go asma,nader,mohammed.

i like these 3 peoples a lot.

i think the nominee will be khalid,iman and .....(mirhan) she good in acting but not in singing that is my opinion
it's difficult who will be nominated.
the other i don't no.

For the nominations it is going to be a little harder to decide this time because the "weakest" candidates like Khaled, Zaher, Badr, Iman, Amal M and Adnane did OK during the eval. On the other hand the stronger candidates like Amal B, Adanan, Mirhane or Saad didn't live up to my expectations. Nader, Asmae, Mustapha, and Diae were OK. This said some were really good at acting their scenes like Iman, Amal M. Adnane, Khaled and Chahinaz. I hope the judges sort it out in a fair manner.

hello everybody,
for me i think that (based on the prime as well) :
khaled 50% gonna be nominee today,
i'll surprise you, but i have feeling that dia will be nominee today also, why? cause they didn't gave her many songs to sing in the last prime, wich lead her to be nominee this week or the next week. it's planed

imen (musttttt go home) i wonder why is she still there! no voice no singing tableau in the prime! why? she's dancing like najwa fouad there! kan lazem trouh la bernamej "hezzi yanawa3im" .

i think that amal B didn't sing well ( but i don't think she will be nominated )

asma did well in the eval, but maybe they will put her nominee (based on prime)

oh, mirhan did well also, i think that she really has a potentiel in singing and acting, i like her voice! and she's sweeeet a lot.

good luck to Dia and Asma

In my opinion the best 5 were:
Mostapha, Nader, Adnan, Mirhan and Saad(because he sang the song SOLFEGE which shows that he is using what the teachers are teaching them)
The worst 6were:
Mohammad, Amal B.(even though I like here), Imen, Amal (good scene but singing off), bader and Abdullah (even thought he's really talented)
I think Khaled might escape this week from the nomination because they will give him a chance for one week before he's out next week.

PS did u hear what Michelle said after the scene of Mohammad and Amal B. :he said that he didn't understand anything...That's bad for both of them.

Finally the nominees are:
1-Bader
2-Imen
3- btw Asma(because of prime), and Amal

Go Asmaa and Diaa. Their eval was great. Good job both of them they have a great voice and great looks. We are so proud of you. Both of you will go far if Madam Rola doesn't cheat. I doubt she will give them a chance. Based on the past 4 years she hate Moroccans. Good luck to both of you.

Love,
ProudMoroccan
From LA

go adna asma saad abdallah dia and i don't know why you don't like adnan he is the tolest one in the acad.and don't forget he is 19 years only.he didn't love asma at the begining but now i think he liked her. i like this couple.so cute and funny together.

Hello every one. I agree with you all. Diaa and Asmaa did very well. As a Moroccan I am so proud of them both. They have a great voice, and great looks. I like all the students this year even Adnan I think he is funny. I like him and I don't blame him about what's happening with Asmaa. Remember they are both teenagers. I blame the LBC because they are the one that show us what they want us to see.

It is so hard to see any of them leave but it is part of the game. I think this week one of the student from Tunisia will leave for sure. This is why; we had 3 Lebanese one left. We had 3 Egyptians and one left. Now it is time for Tunisia because there are 3 students. And I think Iman will leave this time. I have no problem with her at all, but I think she will be a better dancer than a singer. One day she was sitting with Adnan and she told him she rather be a dancer than a singer. So I think those words will get her out.

They get rid of the Iraqi guy first because he does have potential and they don't want another Iraqi to win. I don't think this year will be for Lebanon either even though I love Saad and Mostapha they have a great voice and they will go very far specially Saad I love his voice, and his looks. I don't think it will be for Egyptian either because they had their chance all ready. They won’t give it to Abdullah, even though I like this guy he has a great voice. I think Abdullah and Saad will be very successful even if they didn’t win. And I think Abdullah, and Saad will go very far in the game. Good luck to them all.

This is what I think, and what I seen happen before. The winner this year it will either be Mohamad, or Amal B, or Nader, or one of the Moroccans Diaa or Asmaa. Even though I doubt they will give it to Morocco because this past 4 year of Star Academy LBC hate Moroccans I don't know why.

I don't think Khalid will be Nominee this week. I think he did well in the Eval. They will give him one-week break.

Thank you for reading my comment, and remember this is what I think. And to all the people who use the word HATE please don’t use it for your own sake. It is a bad word. Support who ever you want. Whether you like them because they are cute or maybe they are from your countries use good words for support and don’t start a war. And remember the saying (what goes around comes around)

Diaa and Asmaa we are so pound of you keep up the good work.

Love,
Proud Moroccan
From LA

Proudmoroccan:

you are so right
your comment is absolutly true and specially about dia and asma they did amazing,their eval was so cute i really liked it but i think they will put asma nominee cause she didnt do well in the prime..

and please people stop being so negative about everyone... if someone has his opinion let him/her say their opinion dont be so negative to each other

PEACE!,

Sara

he sara you also from holland me to

can you say to me how can i vote for asma
and how can sms them please i just want to know

alvast bedankt

Hey Nessrine

.. i'm going to search how to vote for asma i think you can see it on the ofcially website www.lbcgroup.tv or something

alsjelieft,

PS: wel leuk als iemand hier nederlands kent