home



marwan vs saad

The results of the last show before the final of Super Star 4 were announced yesterday night ... Three contestants were fighting for 1 title ... Now, only two move on to the final next week ... & Yusra Mahnoush from Tunisia isn't one of them!
The title will go to either Marwan Ali from Tunisia or Saad Mjarad from Morocco ...
To whom will you give your vote?
Who do you think deserves to be the 'Star' this year?

comments

eric
29 May, 10:41AM

marwan is deserve to win as a superstar this year go go go marwan...........we well support you

Bambusha
29 May, 11:24AM

fe taraby marwan is a way better than Saad but saad isn't bad also
any one who wins i ll be happy

FiFi
29 May, 11:26AM

marwan s voice is much better then saad thats why i ll choose to vote marwan although i like them both

sassi
29 May, 12:23PM

when i listening marwan sing a Lebanese jabali song i can't realise he isn't Lebanese!he's really incredible he have 18 old years and sing very well what another artist can't sing,jabali romantic tarabi,so imagine what he can do in the future!sincerely marwan deserve the title of superstar,men el forsa el a7ira to final!

Bambusha
29 May, 12:42PM

by the way
we tunisians always reach the finals bs 3omrna mabno7sol 3ala lakab!
so if marwan dosn't win, i won't be surprised
t3awadt khlas

disgusted
29 May, 1:34PM

both of them compared to yosra are kids playing around.

if Fairouz and Om kolthom were to be judged by popular vote they will loose to haifa and her kind.
what good comes out of public vote when we have an ignorant unrefined musical ears?

i'm simply disgusted.

meriam
29 May, 1:49PM

the best voice is out and now i must voting for marwan because he sing better than saad!he's the only talent remaining!

Lisa
29 May, 2:06PM

no Marwan doesn't sing better than saad!!!!!he could never sing that song for Abdel-Wahab that Saad sang
Yousra had a better voice, but she was changing the tunes of the songs
I'll vote Saad 100%

sara
29 May, 2:30PM

Saad voice is Far way better than marwan so i will give my vote 2 saad and i will vote so much times for him !! Gooo Saad !! we love youuu!!

MarwanAli
29 May, 2:50PM

I repsect Saad but When I read that Marwan can't sang Abdel wahab song , I want just to remember that Marwan sang a more diffuclt song of Abdel wahab (Imta ezzaman) and all the jury and everybody agreed that it's was more than successful, while for Saad all the jury said that he was not successful for that song. The videos are there to show it. Marwan was called by Rahabani the Wadi essafi junior and Iheb Tawfik only talked about him. They have both different style, I like Marwan far better. Everybody is free to like one more than the other but please ovoid writing wrong facts. Good luck to both of them.

Nimr
29 May, 3:40PM

Marwan sings like a debutant!while Saad is very sure of himself & sings like a star.He has all the star's qualifications
my vote goes to Saad

rose26
29 May, 4:51PM

Goo goo Saad,
j aurai aimée que yousra soit finaliste sa voix est plus belle que celle de marawane mais quand les juges veulent faire ou passer un message personne ne peut les stopper je crois que les plus malin d entre vous on compris le message passer par fadiya durant Pour moi c est Saad qui sera enshaa laah star vive le Maroc

rose26
29 May, 4:56PM

Goo goo Saad, j aurai aimée que yousra soit finaliste sa voix est plus belle que celle de marawane mais quand les juges veulent faire ou passer un message personne ne peut les stopper je crois que les plus malins d'entre vous ont compris le message passer par fadiya durant le prime. Pour moi c’est Saad qui sera enshaa laah star vive le Maroc

Nandy
29 May, 5:00PM

Goo saad my votes are going to you omg i was really into your songs.. goo saad you deserve to be the winner of superstar 2007

hunn
29 May, 5:24PM

inshallah SAAD wins.. i hope he winss.... ppl VOTE SAADD please.. if you guys want him to win VOTE VOTE AND VOTE...SAAD SUPESTAR 2007////////

3an jad
29 May, 5:25PM

Marwan Marwan Marwan all the way

sara
29 May, 5:57PM

u guys have to vote to prove that SAAD is a superstar... soooo VOTE SAADD... arguing won`t change anything if SAAD losses............. SAADD MY VOTE ID 4U!!!!!!!XOXOXOX

MarwanAli
29 May, 6:09PM

lol, So funny. Marwan sings like a debutant. Oh my god, if it's the case, I just can't imagine how will will be later, if as debutant is already called "oustadh fil maghna" and "wadi safi junior" and Wadii essafi, as well as Iheb tawfik congrtulates him.. Common people! let's be serious one minute. You are free to like Saad, but stop sending all this message just to say "VOOOOOOOOOOOOte Saaaaaaaaaaaaaad". Why? you think you need to say this. Is it because you think Marwan is better? or because you like him. Fair ennough so in that case , just explain and list his qualities(and he has a lot) and don't automatically talk bad about Marwan. Other people can think that you don't find arguments for Saad. Anyway good luck to both of them :)

ouidad
29 May, 6:20PM

frankly speaking both of them have good voices but each in his own style.however, personnaly speaking i think that saad deserves to win the tittle instead of marwane, because as botros and rahbani said in the last prime saad isnt only a good star with a lovely voice but he has a great personality, well educated, and a very respecful man...and even youssra ( whom i like a lot ) said indirectly that saad deserves to win the tittle.good luck to both of them

ahla amoula bil3alam
29 May, 6:25PM

hi all .i like saad a lot more than marwane. but plz can anyone tell me how to vote for saad i lost the number. i am from morocco.try to answer plz as kuik as u can and dont forget to vote for saaaaaaaaaaaddddddddddd

nancy
29 May, 7:00PM

Damn this prime was absolutly for saad he was the man ... his voice is amazinG... marwan didnt sing that good actually .. so my vote goes to saad al mjarad the second place is for marwan:D..

nancy min Lebnan

laila bouzaid
29 May, 7:41PM

hi every body i will vote for the golden throat SAAd!plz vote for him he deserves to be the superstar!go saad go you are amazing, wonderful and stunning:)

Viewer
29 May, 8:27PM

I am happy for Saad, a bit sad for Yousra, she should have stayed for the finales but what can we do...Marwan is not mature enough...it is obvious that Saad will make it!

sara7a
29 May, 8:59PM

wow....saad better than marwan?

have u guys been watching the shows? have u seen all of the comments the judges gave each one of them? ziad boutrous gives one good review to saad this week and all of u start saying that saad is better than marwan and saying bad things about him. ill let u know ( in case u havent been watching) that marwan has been in the danger zone for several weeks in a row whereas marwan has blown everyone away with his beautiful angelic voice and his ability to sing in a dialect that isnt even his own better than a lebanese person!

Khabtit Adamkoum by Fayrouz by Marwan was as Ehab Tawfic said the best time someone has sung it after Fayrouz. Marwan Ali is the Superstar, Saad is lucky to be here ( ma7zouz) as Madame Fafia told him.

I am not Tunisian to say vote for someone from my country as some of u are saying.( votez pour le maroc). je vote pour la star pas pour un pays.


Marwan is the Superstar.

arwa
29 May, 10:12PM

I think we should be happy that two contestants from Maghreb are at the finals and please stop fighting we should be happy for each one of them because both represent Maghreb. I am moroccan and I love Saad to win because he is not only for Morocco but also because his voice is great and so his personnality and I will be happy too if Marwane get it too because he is amazing too and either one of them win that represents Maghreb.
I love Saad and Marwane.

pretty
29 May, 10:49PM

The name of the program is "Super Star" and the word satr matchs only with Saad.
First Saad has the best voice, because he is able to sing all kinds of singing, from trabi to Ray, to young songs...(In the contrary, we 've seen Youssra and Marwan how are so limted in singing different styles)
and don't tell me that they will sing only tarabi after the program, the proof is that all the ex participants of the program are singing now the rythmic songs witout exception.
Second, Saad the onnly one who has the crazy Charisma is the stage.He attracts the audiance with unbelievable charming.
Third the personnality of Saad by the opinion of everybody is the best, he is modest and treat erverybody nicely.
Come on, after all this and you still discussing who deserves to win.Of course the super star is Saad with my respect to all Marwan 's fans, even he has a beautiful voice but only in a limited styles and he has no charisma on the stage, he gives me alway the feelings of a student singing in school and not a super star.

Nice
29 May, 11:34PM

pretty...I could not have said it better. Thanks to people like you I still have hope in Saad winning...please remember SUPERSTAR and that is the entire package.

yosra's sister
29 May, 11:49PM

OMG!! I cant' believe that yosra go kicked off!! I thought that she was going to win Superstar.... Oh well, now my vote goes to Saad because unlike marwan, saad has a unqiue and manly voice!! Marwan is just a little girl... Go SAAD!!!

zohal min mars
30 May, 12:14AM

let me say it in plain english: If we bring a moroccan donkey we will still have bunch of "surpise surprise" moroccans who will write poems about how beautiful his voice is.

million$$$$ question: why do you write the same message all over the net?????? do u have anything meaninglful in your lives to do beside your mediocre amal and saad

good luck to me making it through your iiiiiiiiiiiiidddddddddddddiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiooooooooooooottttttttttttttt posts.

Zohal min Mars min Neptune min Morocco min Lebanon........

MarwanAli
30 May, 12:36AM

Really funny!!!! Why Saad fun feel the need to repeat over and over on all forum that He's the best. Are you affraid that we don't think the same? Whould be only funny if they were saying true facts but no, just repeating same sentences. Looks like it's one oe two person :)
I'm tlaking about Saad fan and not about Saad that I repsect and wish him good luck. GO MARWAN

pretty
30 May, 1:29AM

Heheheh Marwan Ali, why u didn't say the same thing in comlive? u saw how Moroccan said always the good things about Youssra and Marwan.
For the same reason that all Tunisian support their candidate, Moroccan have also the right to support Saad, not because he is Moroccan(even I am not), but because he deserves the title really, Youssra should be in the final instead of Marwan.
We don't need to proove that he is the best, his fans standed with him the whole program and they will support him till the end, and try to read the first comments here,Saad's fans are only answering your comments toward him, or u want us clap for your comments and wish wiht u the title for Marwan.Hehehehe only in the dreams.
Go SAAD

MarwanAli
30 May, 1:52AM

Reading and reading again ypu message Pretty and try to find arguments but I don't find anything!
And for your first sentence : "Heheheh Marwan Ali, why u didn't say the same thing in comlive? u saw how Moroccan said always the good things about Youssra and Marwan." . The answer is in your sentence , Hehehehe. Bcz in comlive that don't attack Marwan. So we're agree at least in this point. No ?
I never posted any post of me talking badly about Saad. And the esrt I'm agree with you, but other post I'm talking about are may be from other person and they don't say the samething :)
Good luck to Saad and Marwan.

MarwanAli
30 May, 1:59AM

Oh! foget to say. I'm using the same Id in all forum. Which is not your case... So you proved what I said before :"Looks like it's one or two person ...". No worry, just kidding

superstar
30 May, 3:30AM

wow.....zohal min mars + marwanali !!

i am with you guys 100% ! they did the same thing with amal in star academy....as if she was THAT good! and the Saad fans! instead of trying to convince urselves + the rest of us who are cultured enough to see that Marwan has more potential than Saad, you should send him a copy of next week's lyrics for each song. Maybe he wont mess them for a change.

Marwan Ali Superstar! ( dont forget to vote marwan fans!)

julia
30 May, 4:39AM

MARWAN TU ES LE MEILLEUR, ON VOTES TOUS POUR TOI ,TIEN BON TU AS UNE VOIX EN OR TU ES UNIQUE , BRAAAAAAAVVVVVOOOOOO, U ARE THE BEST MARWAN..WE VOTE FOR YOU , FROM CANADA TO MARMAN .
XXX JULIA

a7la
30 May, 5:50AM

we are all with you marwan.

on est avec toi marwan. U ARE THE STAR IN EVERY WAY!

honestly
30 May, 10:49AM

Hey Tunisians , do u have some problems with Moroccans or what?
You are making me laughing.We are used already for your noses and your racism toward your kids only, you don't accept the honest compitition.We all saw how u treated Shada even she was the best, because she was half Moroccan only.
so it seems that ths name is a new sickness for you, so may god make you occuered really.
Even your nonsense of staracademy of the stupid Karawi, Moroccan candidates (Hajer) shine more than everybody, and see XFactor how are talented the Moroccan candidates.
Saad is talented, and stop jalousy toward him, and he doesn't need your stupid views , the proof that the public voted for him to arrive to such level.And your Marwan should particiapte in ecole des fans, the word star is not for him.I don't believe even how he has arrived in the finale episode.
And for the jalous who attack Amal,she is more famous than your fat and ugly girls.
Stop nosens Tunisans and your films to gain attention from others arabic kind people.At least they support without attacking Moroccan.

Omar
30 May, 11:39AM

Neither of them deserve the title .. but I think Marwan is a better person than Saad
Anyway lets wait and see if the contest was MATCHFIXED and whether the rumours are true that SAAD is being supported and they will make him win .. cheaters if they do !

SALWA
30 May, 12:41PM

c domage que YOSRA NE SOIT PAS AU FINALE?j'aurai aimer que le final soit entre YOSRA ET RIHAB,je suis tunisienne et j'aurai ete heureuse meme si RIHAB aurai gangner le titre.C 2 VOIX SON EXCELENTES.
le finale est maghribin c le plus important pour moi.apres YOSRA que ca soit SAAD OU MARWAN C kif kif.
je suis pas pesemiste mais les tunisienne n'ont pas de chance dans les programe libanais.c domage.
je vote MARWAN commum,

a
30 May, 12:53PM

saad is the best sibger in the world and also his so cute i will vote saad 1000 times

Saraa
30 May, 3:31PM

`Saad you've got it all your voice is soo special and beautiful so my votes are defenitly for Saad.. and yes i totally agree with : honestlye! tunisian people have some problems with moroccan people!? but i dont understand it we are all arabs and i dont see such things in europe ( i live in the netherlands) the people are really friendly with each other and why cant we be like them???

Go saad you are in my eyes allready a star!

zohal min mars
30 May, 4:51PM

because I'm zohl min mars min Neptune I try to understand what makes certain human beings act the way they do.
and
because I see some Moroccans saying things and other Moroccans "totally agree with" I thought I share with you what I did find which by the way public info.


kingdom of morocco.

population:
33,757,175


literacy:

age 15 and over can read and write
total population: 51.7%
male: 64.1%
female: 39.4%

That leaves us with a whopping 48.3 % can't read or write.

But this % doesn't look too terrible if we see people like "honestly" can read and write to some degrees never mind "making me laughing" "your racism toward your kids"" make you occuered really""stop nosens""your films to gain"..."stupid Karawi" "stupid views""your fat and ugly girls"....


I only wonder how many form the 51.7% that can read and write have actually passed elementary school or even have the simple common sense.

Very sad but I came to believe there are reasons why the majority of Moroccans give people billion chances to ridicule them specially when they produce the kind of our well cultivated "honestly" and more so when they "totally agree with" such kind.

May Allah help us. That's all.

sara7a
30 May, 5:12PM

si quelquun fait une attaque contre les marocains, c de votre propre faute. Vous donner des fausses informations sur votre precieux Saad et sur votre precieuse amal!

et vous savez quoi! comme a votre habitude, vous sautez sur les tunisiens et penser qu'ils sont jaloux de vous! mais regardez combien de stars au liban dont la tunisie est fiere de porter le nom ( saber , latifa, ahmad al sherif, et plein d'autre - en plus, c toujours les tunisiens qui sont les plus aimer dans les shows ici) et POUR VOTRE INFORMATION, les tunisiens SONT VRAIMENT VRAIMENT POPULAIRE AU LIBAN!

je ne suis meme pas tunisienne( je suis libanaise) et je suis porter a defendre ce merveilleux pays ainsi que sa STAR Marwan Ali, PARCE QUE VOS ATTAQUES ET VOS ARGUMENTS contre lui sont inutiles.

je ne suis pas non plus anti-marocaine du tout, jaime de nombreuses stars de chez vous, mais la, avec toute lattention et toutes les folies que vous avez faites pour AMEL et maintenant ses arguments hors de place pour Saad, je commence a avoir l'impression que vous voter plus ou encourager seulement que pour votre pays, et non pour votre talent.

im writing in french because it seems that when we write the posts in english, the saad fans keep repeating the same thing over and over again.

ye3neh 3al 2alileh teb3o el bernemej ( the least u can do is follow the show) and then after tha give out REAL REASONS and REAL arguments on why Saad is the Star.

Nshalla Marwan Superstar.

kate
30 May, 6:09PM

saad is the best

Proud_Morrocan
30 May, 6:48PM

Well were do i start from I am Moroccan and will vote for Saad to win because of the following:
Great voice
Can sing different styles of music
Very funny
can act
great in stage
etc
These are my reasons and just to your own information last winner of Superstar3 and it SAAD own roomate this years after livivng said that SAAD deserves to win.
Brahim alhakami
Ahmed Hussein

And to the lovely Sara you need to knew more about Moroccans than just finding STATS from the web.
Moroccans can read,write and Sing. I will not go to the low level you got into to talk bad about another Arab country but that is one reason we all don't get along.
Go Saad and Marwan both of you are STARS
I will miss Ahmed Hussein very very much he was great singer.


honestly
30 May, 9:14PM

Hehehe Zohal or marikh.
I didn't even want to go down to your level and answer you for your first comment.A person who uses the "donkey word " in his (her) comment reflects very well his dirthy mentality, and with all my respect to this great animal that deserves to live in the earth more than you.Lol.
And as smart you are because u can use google (thank god that you know that) , type also in google the history of Morocco, The rank of Morocco in telecommunciation, in internet in the north Afriqua....and as we can give you simply all the statiscs about Tunisia, but I don't have time for such nosense really , specially to inform someone stupid like u who doesen't leave harissa 's country for a moment , so for sur the harissa is influencing your mind and u are immagining that Harissa's land is Switzland for example.lol.
and I won't continue answer crazy persons who think that wining musical program is a national achievement like star academy and Super star.You don't learn from the disaster of the death of people in a concert of star academy.
May god help u to get occured from this nosense.

honestly
30 May, 9:29PM

ce message est pour Sara,

Cherie, On suit le programme plus que toi.Les raisons pour lequelles que Saad merite de gagner le titre sont trop claires plus que les rayons du soleil dans le jour sont les suivantes:
1-La voix de Saad est maginifique et capable de chanter en excellence dans tous les registres , du Tarabi, il a chante Oumkalthoum et Abed al Waheb en excellence (tapez dailytmoon pour revoir les episodes),du moderne, du Ray meme.

2- Son charisme de star
3- Sa personnalite

et ne me demande pas de m'exprimer en chinois la prochaine fois pour que tu sois a l'aise.

mneeeeh haik?lol

zohal min mars
30 May, 11:03PM

Being Zohal min Mars min Neptune I have been always amazed by some of the earthlings (that's what we Martians disrespectfully call you).

You are in the bottom's bottom but you like to say "don't want to go down to your level".

I never thought there is another lower livable bottom until I came across the unrecognizable creature called "honestly" who claims that s/he and co (including donkeys) are worthier of living IN THE EARTH. Little s/he knows, I only live ON earth if I will ever stop by but s/he may rest in peace IN THE EARTH (the poor thing doesn't know the closest distance we ever came close to each other was 55,746,199 km )

Funny you had all the time to write what made stupidity itself seem decent but you didn't have time to look up stats that have actual facts in them not run your mouths like bunch of ranting fools as you always demonstrate over and over and over.

"honestly" next time just to prove you passed elementary school try using nonsense instead of your "nosense" and cured instead of your "occured" but you are still free to write "Noth Afriqua" any way pleases you.


If you come back running your mouth again I will convert my stats from % to actual numbers then you will know even harissa(that you buy from the black market) won't help you tackling them.


Omar
30 May, 11:35PM

What happened to Fadi Abdul Khaleq ?? will he and the other finalists be back for the final show ? they always bring back the 12 finalists in a song together .. hope so this time too!!

arwa
31 May, 5:40AM

Hey all stupid maghrebins. Instead of being happy this year that two maghrebins are in the final and wish them luck you are arguing about stupid things. You will never get along like glf people or middle easterns just stay the way you are with all these hate and fight about stupid things. that's why you'll never win or unite.
It's disgusting what we hear in this forum you should allgrow up tunisians and moroccans.

nadia
31 May, 6:21AM

hey ZOHAL min MARS,
In your comments, I see lot of hatred towards morocco!! You took the time to bring and show us your statistics about it...all the informations listed -am sure- are the same or likely the same in other arabic countries..and for your information North african people (morocco, algeria and Tunisia) are more ..way more intelligent than middle eastern people...I don't know where you are from..but really you sounded sick..so I urge ..please..to take care of yourself as soon as you can,
Peace,
Nadia from somewhere.

S.M.S.
31 May, 9:58AM

Interesting. I would say someone should revise their geography books!!!!

meriam
31 May, 1:02PM

l importance ce n'est pas de chanter tout les genres de chansons (om kalthoum abd el wahab....)mais bien les chanter,chose qu'a trés bien fait marwan!puis pour les marrocains qui disent qu'ont est jaloux,les tunisiens n'ont pas insulter saad c'est une grande fierté pour le maghreb d'avoir 3 finalistes dans superstar on est tous gagnants dans tous ça alors pourquoi traiter marwan de"little girl"c'est trop offensif et ça n'a rien avoir avec la compétition!c'est normal que j'encourage marwan car je l'adore et pas pour autant je vais me mettre a insulter saad et si vous suiviez vraiment l'emission vous auriez su combien saad et marwan sont des vrai amis!alors arretez cette guerre débile et que le meilleur gagne!(c'est a dire marwan ha ha ha !)

imed
31 May, 1:10PM

et meme si les tunisiens avec les programmes de real tv libanais n'ont jamais gagné car ceux ci font tjs gagner le pays avec plus de population, il faut comme meme voter marwan!ne le laissez pas tomber!

leila
31 May, 2:20PM

SAAD ET MARWAN méritent tous les deux de gagner le titre. ce sont des amis, donc arrêtez de vous lancer des insultes!!!!! hchoula wallah !!!!!
on est tous des maghrébins et on est censé être unis pas se bagarrer pour des émissions de chant c'est vraiment honteux....
Prenez au moins exemple sur la starac maghreb, eux au moins ils sont fiers de faire partie du GRAND MAGHREC et ils s'entendent tous très bien.....
à bon entendeur salut!!
BON COURAGE A SAAD ET MARWANE ET QUE LE MEILLEUR GAGNE

Nada
31 May, 8:02PM

Screw Saad And Screw Marwan and Screw the program and Screw anything that make us say stupid things about each others and i'm Tunisian and proud to be!

Proud _Moroccan
31 May, 8:03PM

Some people here have more personal issues.
The purpose of this forum is to talk about Pro and Cons of each contestant in the final prime and who will win and not to insult each other.
Please grow up and show that Arabs can really keep a constructive conversation and that they knew how to make there point across without any insults.

Thanks

Moroccan_Girl
31 May, 10:25PM

proud moroccan you are totally true ! why can't we be like the other countries !? and this is a forum to talk about saad and marwan and not about the history of tunisa or morocco people you've got to grow up! im 100% for saad but is wish marwan also good luck!

Hanin
1 June, 1:26AM

What's going on these days between you Tunisians and Morrocans?! Chill out!! both of the candidates deserve the title and it's not that big deal anyway..I feel like you're waiting for the smallest things to make a story of.

and I didn't watch this season that much, but I bet that the Tunisian girl would win..unfortunatly she didn't and now I believe Saad will..he has more potential and he's more like a star than Marwann..Marwann is kindda dead I dunno, I bet he'll prefer to go to his simple life and be one of these who disappear completely after the show..lol Sorry for his fans and I repeat I dunno any of them thaaat good and I'm not a fan either. Anyway good luch for both

marwanfan
1 June, 3:18AM

MARWAN STAR! MARWAN STAR! VOTE VOTE VOTE FOR MARWAN!

Katya
1 June, 3:20AM

vote for the voice.

vote for the smile.

vote for the charm.

vote for the beauty.

vote for the best.

vote for Marwan!

Good luck to both, but nshallah Marwan Star!

The Yousra Fans, Vote for Marwan! This is What she Wants!

KATE
1 June, 8:06AM

SAAD IS THE NEW STAR OF THE MAGHREB ARABI, VOTE FOR HIM, HE DESERVES TO BE THE ARAB SUPERSTAR ARAB CONGRATULATION SAAD FOR BEEN IN THE FINAL , YOU WENT A LONG WAY, BEST OF LUCK ! WAY TO GO!

brigitte
1 June, 8:11AM


MARWAN W BASS-EL BA2I KELLOU KHASS!

meriam
1 June, 12:46PM

marwan superstar,farid staracmaghreb and raja xfactor,maghreb arabi the best!

lili_86
1 June, 1:35PM

saad et marwane sont des vrais amis et frères alors arrétez d'insulter les uns les autres et que le meilleur ou plutot le plus populaire gange j aime tous les deux mais je souhaite que saad gagnera

sara
1 June, 1:42PM

saad the winner of superstar 4

sali
1 June, 1:59PM

Saad my husband is the super star.
I hope that he will marry me.That's the main for me.
And don't touch my husband with nay bad word ok?

marwa
1 June, 3:17PM

Marwan. Marwan. Marwan. Marwan. Marwan.
Marwan.

Oh and Sali, sorry to break it to you, but Saad is already married. Keep up with the news :) Watch all of his videos, and watch his ring finger ;) sorry to ruin your fantasy. Plus he did say he was married.

cutiegirl
1 June, 3:19PM

Marwan....

Marwan...

Marwan...

Need I say more?

Vote for the superstar...vote for the best Marwan Ali.

Leb_girl
1 June, 3:51PM

Saad is not married!!!!?
he is still young he lives in america i've heard
anywayz he is AMAZING


Goo saad

GOo saad

Goo saad

Goo saad

GOoo saad

YOU ARE HOTTT

leb_girl
1 June, 3:52PM

Goo saad

GOo saad

Goo saad

Goo saad

GOoo saad

YOU ARE HOTTT

nancy
1 June, 5:21PM

Saad and marwan are actually both good but marwan isnt that profesional like saad.! but thats how i see it ...! my opnion
Good luck 2 both of them but saad is Great i hope he wins it!

nicole
1 June, 5:23PM

marwan is the cutest, the best voice, the most professional, simply the BEST.

go go go go go go marwan.

sara spain
1 June, 7:32PM

saad is the best! from the beggining abdellah told him he will compete 4 the title because he was excellent and he could conserve it.every time he sung he could capture the public in all the styles.
and i would like 2 let u see a thing specially 4 you maghrebins saad is the only maghrebin who let us be sure he is proud of being maghrebin he only obligated the jury 2 let him sing a maghrebin song.marwan always choose jabali songs 2 make the jury like him.saad is already a professional he trust on himself .alhamdulillah we are so proud of him.
finally i want 2 tell u im not offending marwan he has a nice voice but saad has one excellent sharkiya as said abdellah and ehab he can sing in up stages and also in bass.repeat the prime ziad saw he did a mistake in the 9th prime and told him hell be a star till the moon what do you want more than this? saad has all factors of a star.ah i forget see one more times the duos and you'll see the big difference.saad could make the two duos excellent against elly fi einy in which he didnt participate nobody even tunisians im sure they didnt like it yousra said it
i hope u dont hate me i have only said the truth and i hope you 2 learn 2 respect the others LES TUNISIAN.i saw a lot of moroccan hope good luck 2 marwan because they are educated as Saad hes a son of his country.

mariama
1 June, 8:12PM

saad est une grande fierte pour la chanson arabe.

sa voix magique qui precede son charme, son caractere et sa personalite sur le theatre font de lui une star.

cela fait longtemps qu'on a pas vu de vrai star et il en est une.

je l'adore, lui souhaite bonne chance et que Dieu le preserve.

mariama
1 June, 8:17PM

saad est une grande fierte pour la chanson arabe.

sa voix magique qui precede son charme, son caractere et sa personalite sur le theatre font de lui une star.

cela fait longtemps qu'on a pas vu de vrai star et il en est une.

je l'adore, lui souhaite bonne chance et que Dieu le preserve.

nancy
1 June, 8:36PM

sara spain you are totally true about saad he is just amazing he can sing every single song but marwan can only sing jabali but we need a superstar who can sing every kind of styles en that is saad !
go saad !!!'people vote for the one who deserves it! both of them actually but saads voice is unique so my way 2 say VOTE FOR SAAAAD AL MJARAD

MarwanAli
2 June, 12:22AM

Before just want to say that comparing Marwan to Saad has nothing to do with putting against Maroccan and Tunisian, this is a shame for the ones that try to do it. I won't point who started everybody can go through the comments in this subject. I want to answer to sara spain. I will ovoid attacking Saad and some wrong facts she said about him. But I have to anaswer teh ones she said about Marwan:
1- Sara spain wrote :"marwan always choose jabali songs 2 make the jury like him". Fisrt this is not respectful judgement and most important that it try to wrongly inform people, as first he sang 2 jebali songs among 16 songs. I don't need to add more on this
3- I won't do like u and talk about Saad, I will just mention few of the many many compliments the jury said about Marwan just in the 2 last primes unless It will take me all the night :) :
- Ziad Boutros (Prime 9) : "Hik ykoun el maghna" meaning "singing shoudl be like this"; "hik sharsyet nejm" menaing "this a star personnality". He said them after Marwan execute teh 2 songs.
- Ilyes Rahabani (Prime 9): "inti oustadh fil maghna" menaing "you're a singing professor" . He said it 2 times after each song.
- Ihab twafik (Prime 10) : He only gave comments to Marwan , saying that after Ferouz , Marwan was the best executing the song.
Anyway, Saad and Marwan are outside this game whene people try to argue with wrong information and they both deserve to win and it's normal that they have fans that they are not agree but a minimum of respect to them and to the forum reader by arguing with real facts.
I'm marwan fan and think that Saad we will win, even if I will try my best and vote for Marwan. So good luck to both of them. You can check all what I say is true in Dailymotion where all the video are uploded.

staracfan
2 June, 12:43AM

First of all,I'm sorry to tell you guys,Saad isn't from Morocco.He was born and raised in the United States.

Second.He constantly forgets the lyrics.It's unfair because in the auditions,people who forgot the words were kicked out of the competition.

Third.When you say he's got charisma in the stage, did you mean Saad?That's true he has in it not on it.His eyes are always down when he talks with the judges.He's shy,We can barely hear his voice.Yeah, and you say he's got charisma!!!

Who cares if he sings "every" type of songs.I rather sing one type of song,do it well than singing thousands of types but suck at it(like Saad does).

That's My and so many other people's opinion.

Please vote for Marwan,he really deserves it.

The girl that said that Saad is HOT(Leb_girl),Are you kidding me,Do you have mental issues,Do you have any taste or you are 8 years old?

Please I'm waiting for an answer as soon as possible.

Last time I wrote comments,someone asked me are you Omar?No I'm not.I always use the same username and that is staracfan.

Bye bye ... 'till next time!

MarwanAli
2 June, 2:21AM

Sorry As MArwan fan I have to answer to starac fan. Saad is Maroccan and proud to be Maroccan. Let's keep this show for music and happiness.
People that likes Marwan, please vote for him and try to make your best so he become a super star.

SuperstarMarwan
2 June, 3:20AM

Don't worry MarwanAli, Marwan will be superstar :)
because all of his fans won't stop voting for him, including me.

And it's so funny how all the Saad fans are giving WRONG INFORMATION about Marwan. Please keep the respect and your facts straight. Instead of trying to put Marwan down ( as a Saad fan, don't you have anything positive to say about him?) why not try to show why Saad deserves it WITH right information please.

Thanks.

yosra's sister
2 June, 3:27AM

OMG!!! Saad was born and raised in the United States? Where? Which state, because I live in the United States!! Somebody please tell me!! Go SAAD!!!

MarwanAli
2 June, 5:25AM

Marwan Ali Superstarenvoyé par MarwanAliTheBest

???
2 June, 7:54AM

I keep reading that there is a set up and Saad is backed up by the King of Morocco, and that he will win Superstar....

if this is the truth then wow i am really really disappointed, seriously saad sang poorly a lot more times than marwan, i was wondering why he was still in the show after beeing in the danger zone THAT MUCH.

if anyone has information, share please.

KATE
2 June, 8:24AM

??? WHAT YOU HEARD IS NOT THE THRUTH, THESE STORIES THAT WERE MADE ABOUT SAAD ARE WRONG. ONE PERSON NAMED OMAR IS THE AUTHOR OF ALL THESE STORIES. HE DID NOT LIKE SAAD, SO HE DECIDED TO POST WRONG INFO ABOUT THIS KID, SO PEOPLE WON'T VOTE FOR HIM. TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, THIS IS VERY SAD THAT PEOPLE ARE GETTING SERIOUSLY BAD. GET UP ARAB AND SEE WHAT'S GOING ON AROUND YOU, YOU SETTING HERE FITTING ABOUT MARWAN AND SAAD. SHAME SHAME SHAME....

KATE
2 June, 8:25AM

??? WHAT YOU HEARD IS NOT THE THRUTH, THESE STORIES THAT WERE MADE ABOUT SAAD ARE WRONG. ONE PERSON NAMED OMAR IS THE AUTHOR OF ALL THESE STORIES. HE DID NOT LIKE SAAD, SO HE DECIDED TO POST WRONG INFO ABOUT THIS KID, SO PEOPLE WON'T VOTE FOR HIM. TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, THIS IS VERY SAD THAT PEOPLE ARE GETTING SERIOUSLY BAD. GET UP ARAB AND SEE WHAT'S GOING ON AROUND YOU, YOU SETTING HERE FITTING ABOUT MARWAN AND SAAD. SHAME SHAME SHAME....

poupée
2 June, 11:23AM

marwen is the best
a chaque fois que je regarde super star je voix que marwen merite vraiment de gagner ou saad eb7essou ma5nou2 sawtou ya3ni je voterais volontier pour marwen "el fanen essaghir" ou "wadi3 essafi mta3 tounes"

sabrine
2 June, 1:52PM

bonne chance saad tous le maroc va voter a toi té le gagnant vive saad et vive maroc

staracfan
2 June, 4:38PM

Hey Leb_girl,I'm still waiting for an answer!

Leb_girl
2 June, 4:47PM

Staracfan i dont know what your problem is but its my opnion go play what your toys or something cause im not into your S**T right know
take care oh yeh btw im not a 8 years old kid i think its you

Goo saad you are still HOT!:D

Leb_girl
2 June, 4:50PM

im not going to spend all my words on you...!
and we all ready know that you are not into saad stop waisting your time here its not for you..

Hicham
2 June, 5:35PM

The game is fixed... " تبدو يسرا أقوى المرشحين للفوز باللقب، رغم ما يتردد في أروقة البرنامج من قرار جهة مغربية بدفع ملايين الدولارات لدعم سعد المجرّد. وهذا الأخير يبدو واثقاً من بقائه حتى الحلقة الأخيرة، "
Check Al-Akhbar newspaper site :
http://www.al-akhbar.com/ar/node/32780

imed
2 June, 5:48PM

I'm sure the direction of future want saad Winn and they will do anything for that you will see!

Someone
2 June, 8:06PM

Go SAAD! He's gorgeous! Besides, he has an incredible voice and he's so polite.

sali
2 June, 8:20PM

Please give up Marwan's fans.Saad my husband is the winner this year.He is borned to be the super super star.
My Saad will sing tomorrow:
1- Ba3eed 3anak (OumKalthoum)
2- Alleyl (Wadi3 Safi)
3-Abed al kader (Cheb Khaled)

My darling Saad will rocks as always.

Goooooo Saad

staracfan
2 June, 8:22PM

To all Saad fans.

Do you really think that he's better than Marwan?
Oh my God...It takes 100 years for Marwan to reach Saad's level,Saad's very low level.

I wish Marwan good luck and may god bless him.As for Saad ,I tell him to return to USA to his wife and kids and live their normal life...

staracfan
2 June, 8:38PM

Hey Leb_girl

I'm sorry about your age.I meant to say 7 and a half.If I'm 8 years old,so an 8 year older can structure a paragraph better than you do.

I have a question,do you live in Lebanon?

mohamed
2 June, 9:26PM

saad le boon chanteur du monde

honestly
2 June, 9:26PM

Saad will be the winner this year.I am telling you from this moment.We all as Saad's fans will explose the vote from tomorrow to offer for our charming prince the title , because Saad deserves really to win.
No matter what the loosers are saying from now.Keep dreaming.Lol.
Saad is the super star of this program.
GO GO GO GO GO
SAAD FOR EVER

mohamed
2 June, 9:31PM

saad vive le maroc et vive les chensent marokan

marwanBEST
2 June, 11:23PM

nshalla nshalla nshalla marwan star we love u marwan.

fatina
2 June, 11:26PM

please please please marwan fans do not stop the voting for him! he is the true star!

hind
3 June, 1:08AM

saad was not in the danger zone so many times plz people stop lying!!!!!!!!!!!! saad is the best anh he will win and plz do me a favor i know it makes you feel better inside when you lie on saad but get over it!!!!!!!

marwanfan
3 June, 4:35AM

hind....its kind of obvious you haven't been watching the show. Even the Saad fans will confirm that Saad has been in the danger zone the last couple of weeks....come on!

don't call us liars please. any person that watches the show knows that saad was in the danger zone more than 1 time.

vote marwan.

mohanad
3 June, 8:18AM

of course Saad deserve to win bcoz he has them all the look +voice+appearance on the stage+ carizma...while the other guy whose name Marwan has nothing and he is so poor in everythings....

I think the only tunisian guy who is really perfect in every things is Ahmad sherif with no doubt while the other boys are so poor and have very ugly voices such as Ayman Lissiq from superstar3 last year, Marwan this year, Imad thisyear in staracademy4, wajdi El-Ak7al from starc3 are totaly so poor....

the only best from tunisian candidates Ahmad Sherif plus all the tunisian Girls such as Asma Othmani, Asma bin Ahmad, Yussra Ma7nosh, yossra fro starc of north Africia(Arabian moroco world), Amani from starc2, Baha in starc1 , Shaim in starc3 and Marwa in starc3 are the only best voices from Tunisia while the rest are so weak


Go "Saad" Go Go we all with u bcoz u r really deserve to win as same as Ahmad Hussain from Lebanon u r the real future stars

Kamal
3 June, 8:54AM

yes I agree with u Mohanad ayman from last year have very thick and ugly voice and very horrible look with that ugly nose..and the same thing this year with Marwan who has very ugly look, very poor personality as well as his voice is not that much good ....Only Ahmad Al-sherif is the best from the new tunisian stars while the other tunisian boys either fom superstar or staracademy ar not good at all ...Saad really deserve to win bcoz he is attractive as Ahmad al-sheirf and has special carizma beside his beautiful voice ...he is is a real star same as Ahmad al-Sherif...and this is FACT which is Ahmad al-Sherif is the most student who make success and popularity from both superstar and staracademy bcoz he is perfect in all sides and the pubilc after the programs have finished just look for the most perfect star,,therefore ahmad sherif make success even more than the ones who win the titles either from super star or staracademy.. and I think that Saad will be as Ahmad Al-sherif bcoz he is perfect in all sides
WE ALLL WILL VOTE FOR SAAD BCOZ DESERVE 2 WIN

meriam
3 June, 4:16PM

i hope marwan Winn but omar what happen you?calm down you can tell your opinion without insult!

sara
3 June, 5:13PM

omar, can u get lost
plz get a life and quit talking shit about people.
nobody like ur stupit comments.
i wish good luck to saad and marwan
sara from egypt

Proud_Moroccan
4 June, 4:14AM

Both contenestant were great and goos luck to saad hopefully he will be the Superstar this year.
and enough about the media articles that says that Morocco spent millions for him to win the guy lives is the US not far from me a modest life who will spent millions on him and his is not even known all bullshit media hipe.
Good luck brother may the best WIN and will miss AHMED HUSSEIN he was great and have a great voice
To SAAD admirers check hsi website in myspace.com
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendid=170868333