omg... without a doubt starac 3!!!!
JOSEPH fady khalifa maya chayma wajdeh.......
i mean how can u not love starac 3 the most????

For me it is star academy 4 because of this people:
sally qammah Imad marwa

Reem Ghazali! So Star Academy 3!

The worst by far was Starac 2
followed by 4. This year was absolutely lackluster with very boring characters.
I am still nostalgic to the first season.
The group was great, there were 5 Lebanese, and the teachers were the coolest. Plus the idea was fresh and it got us all tuned in.
After season 2, we lost enthusiasm.
However season 3 was bombastic with talents like Joseph, Hanaa and Chayma, and a very compact and BEAUTIFUL group.
The beauty of the contestants is also a factor of attraction. Season 3 excelled in that.
Season 4 and 2 were also disastrous in that respect

i agree with u lebchris....... 4 and 2 were terrible......... 1 was great bas 3 was awsome!!

how can we forget the songs during night by fady and joseph (wel3aneh)
how can we forget el droubeh bi chaima w sandou2 el bed wel batata
how can we forget the hilarious khalifa
fady wel khdoud
other than there were lots of talents the show was funny without problems like sa4 and zizi amani haters,boring love story ahmad marwa amal,
so in sum sa1 and sa3 and if i have to choose sure 3 is the best

star academy 1,3,and 4 were the best 2 wasnt nice i didnt even watch it at all.. but the best was this year honestly it was i loved it i felt i was living with them i would watch it day and night it was hard changing the channel and not see them on the 24hour channel anymore oh well it was nice for a change..
take care!

Nothing beats the original. So StarAc 1 gets my vote.

i didnt see star academy 2 can ppl tell me was it bad....?? i only watched 3 and 4 and i liked themmm both they were both great i luved joseph from star academy 3 and luved marwa ahmad and imed from star academy 4!! but lots of drama in the forth oneee

1 was the best
3 only hani
4 cuz of kaaamah carlo sally tina and emad

Star Academy 4 was the best, cuz a Shada won .. She was the first girl who won and the most talented ! And ofcourse because of the king Ahmad Dawood ! ´But I agree with you that Amal and Marwa were boring !

at the second place: Star Academy 3 , Because of Joseph, Fady, Shaymaa and all..

Then comes the first season, because of Ahmed el Sherif, Bashar and Mohammed Attiah

And at least star academy 2, but it wasnt bad,, I liked Ahmed Salah El-din Bashar Qaisi, Salma, Amani, Zizi, HishAm, Ahmed Hussein..

Thats my opinion..

star academy 1 was my favorite. it was fresh, and the students were all great singers. they had talent, and i don't know, i fealy they were innocent. maybe not. second best was 3.. i rllly liked it. well in terms of voices, star academy 3 won in that. wow..chayma, hannah, mawrwa, joe, and some of the earlier girls. they were awsome. aslo star academy 3 intoduced the most talent, as in instuments( most students), languages (french, russian, well star academy 4 had a bigger language vareity, but whatever), and dancing, (maya especially)..

anyway SA 2 was horrible. ughhh.i don't remember anyone..maybe amani..oh yah..wheres hisham??? well mohemmeds gone too..but still

lol

Star academy 3 waz da besttt ... Mabrouk ZouZou u r da best !! He should be the winner over all 4 seasons since he was the best out of all the other winners!!!

This is the order

Staracademy 3
Staracademy 1
Staracademy 4
...............
...............
...............
then staracademy 2

hey same here i loved star academy 3 all of them they were cool n fun n not childish frist then 1 bcoz of bashar n atiah n mira n sofia n ahmad sheriff n many then 3 because of emad n marwa n amal only n last one is 2 because of salma , bashar ghazawi , ahmad salah thats all but i hated tina , sally ,carlo men they r plastic

of course starc 1 is the best bcoz they were so natural and has humor spirit besides their great talents and great voice as well as Ahmad Al-sheirf who is the most beautiful and charming boy over the four seasons was in starc1 therefore starc1 is the best even though that attia doesnt deserve to win and bashar doesn't deserve to be with the final 3 and ahmad sherif is the one who must win and number two khalawy or baha but still starc1 is the best

second best is starc 3 they have talent action in events even though some of the students ar not natural and just acting such as fady who imitate ahmad sherif, khalifa emitate Attia, maya emitate Myriam attallah, hany emitate both ahmad sherif and khalawy....etc and other students who amitating the previous students but we can put it in the second place

the worst starc is starc2 and 4 despite there are some good students like Ammma7 , Marwa and Ahmad Dawoood and carlo but still is boting and just repeatation of the previous seasons

of course starc 1 is the best .no season can beat starc1 and ahmad sherif ... i think that most the people love starc1 but actualy most the fans of starc1 don't enter in this website bcoz it is along time since starc1 finished and here there is no so much news about starc1 therefore most of starc1 don't enter here including me ...and I just enter today since along time.....but for sue if starc1 fans enter here for sure starc1 will win over all of them

asslan the the rest seasons are just imitation of starc1 and its candidates...even the song of starc3 and the advertisment of starc2 & starc3 are so horrible in comprision with the great song and vedio clip of starc1 and their lovely advertisment

as well as the peronalities , talents and voices in starc1 are thousand of time better then the other season...starc2 just full of fighting and problems between the candidates ,in starc3 just full of love stories (masa5ah wi 2lit 2dab) and the candidates just use to imitate starc1 candidates'carizma and full of cheating in result and attacking khaligi candidates and let lebanon win by cheating over Rym and the khaligi candidates who have very high votting....starc4 is full of boring and repeatation of love tringle story...actually this tringle love had started firstly by Ahmad Sherif with his fiancee Eman and Myriam 3attallah in starc1 ..after that this story just repeated in every season in starc 2 with Katia, Jihad and Bashar Qaissi...in starc3 with fady ,vivo and Maya...and finally in starc4 with Ahmad dawood ,marwa and amal....

beside of that in starc1 the students were more natural and were really funny beside their great talent which create very great atmosphere in starc1 while the after seasons the students were full of actting and every candidate use to imitate one of the previous candidates in starc1

starc 1 is totally the best