amel has priority more then imad

i think this is soooooo unfair!!!! amal had to be instead of imad!!! she is ssoo much better, and the reason can´t be because of ahmed, i mean she loooves ahmed, why should she not want to be with him in the tour, i am so dissapointed that shes not with them,´it isn´t fair!!!!!
AMAL I LOVE YUUU

I don't think that Amal should have replaced Imad on the tour. Imad deserves his spot. Amal should've replaced Sally. And if Madame Roula wanted Sally to be on tour that bad she should've just added Amal to the list. I mean she added Imad as the 9th person, what difference would it make if she added Amal as the 10th.

no way she shouldnt of replaced imed...she is a good singer but all honest truth is that imad is better....both deserved to go on the tour but if it came between imad and amel imad deserved it more

guys i talked to amal yetserday and she said that staracademy never asked her to come on the tour..figures they would do that but poor girl also said that she doesnt have a contract with rotana....but she did tell me that she wants to sharek ma staracademy maureb so i hope she makes it....
i really liked amal alot and wanted her to be on the tour but she herselfsaid that staracademy didnt ask her to join them so its there loss not hers.

i love amal but imad deserved to be on the tour more then her...for bloddy god imed deserved to be at the finals and maybe even win the title...i like amal alot but imed is an amazing singer and deserves his chance to shine...i love imed and i am so happy they bought u backk on the tour...

imad is my star...sorry to amel's fan imed was the one who nneded to be on the tour...this kid is really good and everybody loves him
definately gonna go see the concert now that imed is in the tour

ِand hard luck amal I really like u but imed deserves more. Am so srry wish u the best I love all the candidates.

woah amal sucks i was mad happy she is ugly,laaema, two face acting wierdo GO EMAD!!!!!

l2 tb3an 2mal eh dy 2l trooh bdal imed

Amal should be in the tour and that's the bottom line. Even if she doesn't replace Imad. She should replace Sally then. Or Ahmad. But the bottom line is even if you do like Imad:

Amal got more votes then Imad
Amal stayed longer then Imad
Amals voice is a bit better too

Therefore there is no excuse to put Imad in the tour and not Amal. They both deserve it okay but there is no rule that says the tour can't be 10 people. If there is then Amal takes priority over Imad.

Ayoub should be in there instead of Ahmad or Sally too.

I'm Egyptian
bas lazem 2a2ol amal sotha a7la men sally wi kaman men 3ly bas f3ln hya nakad awy wi el tour lazem tb2a fun y3ny lazem sally wi imad ..
el nas msh 3yza drama 3la el stage tany

yeah 100% amal should have been on the tour, she sould replace sally or ahmed, imad my baby also deserves to go to. u lot should not use imad example of replacement because bothe of them 110% deserve to go with out question. but ahmed and sally no way man

Go Emad ... I hope everyone including Amal have seen how Ahmed was hugging Marwa all the time.. LOVE IS IN THE AIR !!!! =)

to hall madm rola she is a evil woman say there is no concert in morroco does that mean the sudent want come that sound stupid, cause i am from egypt i am a big fan of amola, and i also like marwa i want get to see her whn thy come around egypt to do there concert that sucks. the students have fans all over the country and not only in there country.

i love amal but i love imed more...they both should be in the tour but imed deserves it more...he has more fans a better voice and has the best personality...i love imed ... the only reason amal stayed longer then imed was because he told them not to vote for him but to give amel another chance...He is a real man...he would have been the star i swear but staracademy is an evil gameee
there shouldnt be a question if amal should replace imed that is a NO!...maybe amal can replace ahmed or sally not Imed...Imed is better then her
love imed and he will be the star in all our hearts

Congratulations Abed you just got yourself a nice new thread to put together Imad & Amal's fans.

Why you had to pick Imed? why Imed vs Amal?

Both Imed and Amal are better than some others...but thanks to the tribal voting attitude...they were sent home.

By the way because of this voting attitude (and other factors too) Marwa, Imed, Amal, Imane & Intisar are the last Maghrebins to participate in starac lbc.

What a shame!

Just keep fighting the wind...you may, one day....get lucky.

Sara I'm glad somebody else mentioned it...I didn't want to remind some of our Moroccan friends or Yezen too that there was no way on earth that Tina and Sally would have voted for Amal instead for Imad.

He was a gentleman.

again there shouldn't be a question about Imed or Amal in the 1st place.

Sara i totally agree with u...imed could have went all the way to the finals but he was a gentelmen and let amal geta nother chance...what other student did such a thing for another student? morocco should love imed for what he did for amal
as for the tour, amal is good but imad is better...imad has more fans and alot of people will go to the concert to see imad...i like amal but imad has better voice then her, better style,and a better personality (all the qualites of a star)
there shouldnt be a comparrison between imed and amal because imed is better then her...u can say sally and amal, ali and amal but not imad and amal

imad all the way...love amal but worship imad!

he is perfect in every wayy

amal was talking bad about sally and tina when she was a nominee saying that they were happy she was a nominee and she even told Ali that the last thing they would do is vote her back in and they both prooved her wrong by voting for her

imad deserves more ... imed is already a star...he doesnt have to wait for staracademy to do something for him...
i personally didnt think amal was that great but she is better then alot of students on the tour but no way is she better then imad...imad is one of the best candiates of staracademy history!!!

i was freaking out when i thought imad wasnt gonna be on the tour but when i saw him come out i was so excited and happy...

love u imed and u deserved to be on the tour more then anybodyy!!!

guys i really really think tht it's unfair tht amal wasn't chosen
In my opinion, Amal's voice is 1000 times better than Imad's voice and cmon give the girl a chance
she could have go on the tour and see ahmad 4 the last time

akide amal btesthe2 aktar men saly w ali w ahmad w tina w its so unfair ma tkoon bel tour w nchalla tsir 2ahla star w bala l tour joane frm leb

amaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaal star bala tournee w bala final
waht a big fadeeeee7aaaaaaaaa roula sa3d made!!!!!!!!! why sh is supporting tina carlo and marwa? why she cares a lot about marwa? sahda this year deserves more than marwa to be finalist without nomination // sma3to akher khabariye ?eno akher nomination kanet 3 nominees w marwa kanet talet essem bs roula ma badha tala3ha nominee fa khaleta bs 2 nomine w lkel betsa2al lesh ted3am roula marwa? becos of starac maghrib 3arabi? mshan yrba7o joumhour maghrib 3arabi? shame on you roula w akeed ameeeel deserves to be in the tour and in the final with shada instead od the jealous girl marwa bs rabna kbeer gogo amaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaal gogo shada you r the staaaaaaaaaaaaar everybody vote 3 against zolm roula

amelle has priority more than imad w marwa w carlo w tina w ahmad if shies not in the tournee all those should be also out of it !!

we love you amelle and lbc + roula + star system will regret it!!!!!!!

emad and amal should b together in the tour plz dont say that amal if she can replace someone eit should b emad NO if she should replace someone it should b ali or ahmed who both suck big time
AMAL 2etzalamet men elakher and think all amal s fans should say to the lbc that this isnt fair by calling them or sending them emails they must at least know how much she s popular if they still dont know

amal is the best , and maddame rola is stupid ... Amal is the best and i hope that she well be a famous singer in the future because she deservite. she was soo talented...

amal is great singer, and the most beautiful girl in the acamdemy.....:D:D:D:D:D:D

star academy is just a game to generate profit...they dont care about having no SUPER SINGER...all wht they care about is $$$$$$$$$$$$$$...the 8th chosen are always the same (2 from leb female and male, 2 from Gulf kuwiat and saudi arabia, 2 form moroco, algeria and tunis, 2 eiher egypt or one egypt amd one from syria..it all depends) so when u see something repetitive to that exterme..it says something to u...its all a game and it's all about the tour that generates lot of money to LBC...

نكد وغيوره وهتقسم المجموعه نصفين بعد خروجها الكل كان مع بفض سالى تضيف على المجموعه بهجه احسن امل نكد نكد نكد نكد وممصله بارعه وهتجرى ورا احمد بدليل مدام رولا رفضت انه يسافر معاها ايطاليا ووفقت على مروه

thank god en amal mosh fel tour.. congrats for qammah sally carlo tina emad

Once again, Amal's obsessive fans are out in force. If you want Amal on the tour, then call or write the show. There's no need bashing the other candidates. That's probably why Roula decided against Amal - too many of her fans became rude and nasty to the other candidates and also called her dirty names. If you want something from someone, calling them dirty names and accusing them of cheating ISN'T going to get you very far. Use your brains, okay? Roula probably thinks Amal is encouraging all of you to act like this. You made up stories about Marwa, Shaza, Sally, Tina, Carlo...EVERYBODY! When Ahmad said he only thought of Amal as a friend, you turned against HIM...before that you couldn't love him enough. Now, I see someone named "Prince" (an Amal fan, of course) who is calling Marwa a "trashy nasty girl" because she liked Ahmad. Ha! Why doesn't Amal call off her attack dogs and maybe she'll get somewhere with Roula. If you want people to sympathize with Amal, stop bashing other candidates.

All I say to al magrib el ARABI it is time to wake up and smell the coffee
Start your own STAR ACADEMY better than going over there look at the last 4 star acedemy results
LEBANON or EGYPT and were is ATTIA and all the rest a bunch of loosers and for my Tunisian friends neither marwa nor imad are going anywhere it is going to be an lebanese or an egyptian to WIN again and SHADA you would of won if you mother was not Moroccan
forget middle eastern music and god bless RAI and AITA and lets see if any of you over there can sing other than Houb and charam songs that did not get us anywere
God Bless Morocco

ooh my god waleg u took the words out of my mind.i dont think she was evenoffered its that old hag madam roulaa

from Egypt,
Ali is a much better singer then Sally so he should not be replaced.

Tunisian,
I'm sure millions still want to be in starac middle east rather then starac maghreb. Starac middle east will always be better because it takes the best of many cultures including the maghrbi culture. There will be candidates from maghrib il arab next year.

ahmed Sara,
Imad really was not so much of a gentlemen he was kind of rude and definitley short tempered. He got in way more fights then Shaza. Second of all he did not step aside for Amal. Tina said that she went back stage and told him that she was going to vote for Amal and then Imad said it's okay. He did NOT tell anyone to vote Amal! Imad has weaker votes then Sally Ali, and Ahmad so no, he would not have made it to the finals because Marwa is the real Tunisian representative this year. Ali voted Amal because it was her first nomination and Imads second and that is why he saved Amal. There is no way Imad would have made the finals. He has weak votes and though he had a good voice it's not nearly as good as Marwa. Besides Imad would ruin it for Marwa if they both got to the finals and Marwa is a WAY better singer then Imad.

But I still think Imad still deserves to be in the tour WITH AMAL. Imad is better then Carlo in arabic lol.

lecia,
your comment desn't make sense. Amal is from maghreb il arabi just like Imad. And if this is about money then Amal got more votes then Imad meaning that she is more popular and will get LBC more money...

wallah haram amal deserves to be in the tour
3angad s3elet 3alayha
and whats about her songs who will sing them???
ro7i ba3id ba3id and ana 3aysa ulak kalam

Morocean,
Chill out. Marwa might win this year actually. Besides just because no one from il maghreb has won doesn't mean starac didn't help them when they were out. Take Ahmad el Sheriff for example. Besides someone from maghreb il arabi is in the finals just about every year.

Besides. Starac maghreb will not have all cultures like starac middle east. It won't be as diverse.

amal should be replaced by sallu at least she has talent or instead ali (the monkey) sally and ali should not be in the tour
imad deserve he and amal
I HATEEE ALIII AND NAWAREYE SALLY(nawar maser) look at her mum

forget amal not being in the tor how about intassar she had a very nice viose

ok first of all dana, sally is NOT A NAWAREYA. it takes a realy nawareya to say that. and besides amal has no voice, no expression nothing!! where the hell exactly are you from? don't call maser nawar... i'm from palestine? so.. and u kno wat u haven't even met sally's mom, so wat gives u the freakin rite to call her a nawareya too? ppl like u should go to hell!

I think that Amal is really good and everything and I kind of wanted her to be in the tour, but the thing is that Imad should not have left that soon and the teachers do know that. Personally what I think is that Ali should not be in the tour and Amal should take his spot, if anything were to be changed that is. Imad is a good singer, he tries really hard and he deserves to be in the tour more than half the people that are in the tour. Congratulations to all!

I really wish that we didn't get to this point. I thought that 1 starac for all Arabs should be the best way to go...we all had faith...but it's a shame.

No Yezen there will NOT be any participant form the Maghreb in starac lbc next year. The contract between Qarwi& Qarwi and the original starac owners prohibits starac lbc from including participants form the Maghreb also from benefiting financially and that's why there is not a single phone line this year for any of the Maghreb countries... go to starac lbc website and check it yourself.

It's just sad.

well ...if u dont like sally s mum it is ur own problem YEZEN but dont judge all the egyptian by saying nawar...SHAME ON U,, we are talking about amal and the tour not on sally and her mom

Moroccan 23 there is already a starac Maghreb you should support it if you are serious...the best part about it is if you go to daily motion and type nessma tv, look for Hajer, Kaouthar and Hamid (all of them Moroccans) trust me you will feel sorry listening to Amal or better yet check super star Saad he is Moroccan too, this guy is amazing...stop this non sense and support who is worthy among you.

I know that Bahaa and Amane had much better chance to win than Marwa and they didn't... I have to say no body stole or cheated them...people voted for other candidates for whatever reasons...they have the right to vote whatever way they wish but we have also the right to try to protect our kids and young talents form exploiting them then living them heart broken when they outdone everybody else...it's just not fair.

By the way I don't know how many more years on top of the 25 years (she lived and benefited form Morocco) it will take Shatha to learn to say couple of Moroccan words to speak to Amal, Imane or even Marwa instead of using Egyptian or Lebanese accent....Please people some thing is wrong here.

God bless all Arab nation because we badly need his blessing...we are so pitiful

Moroccan 23

I've been holding my horse for sometime now. ;).

NO WAY..she doesn't deserve to be there when they showed sho are the 8 students going on the tour i said Imad should have been one of them..a few seconds later Imad was right there between them...he deserves it....Go Imad

Moroccan 23...tla3tee zweena bezzaf yal marokiya...merci.

By the way I know you are deing jalousy from both: my Marwa and my harissa. lol.

seeree allah yahdeeke.

imad is the best we mosh kant hatb2a tour without imad

NAWAREYE nawar egypt ??what does it mean iam egyptian and i feel it is an offensive word .somebody plz reply.nobody speaks a word about egypt.