The nominees after seeing eval this week should be : Sally
Kammah
Marwa coz she forgot

I feel sorry for Marwa and Shatha coz they forgot and i hope they dnt put them as nominees coz they are AMAZING singers. I don't think Shatha will be put coz they know she's good but im scared for Marwa.

I don't really care about Sally coz she was crap like 5 weeks ago and should have gone before Imad and Ayoub
Kammah is good but he is the worst out of Marwa,Shatha and Carlo.
EGYPT if Sally and Kammah are nominees VOTE for Kammah coz hes soooooooooooooooooo much better but its up to u.....
I think Marwa will stay if she is nominee because she has the Khallej,Tunis, Morocco and other countries with her.
Even if Sally manages to somehow win this year, we all know the REAL stars of this show and Marwa and Shatha!They will be able to get a record deal because of their voices.
Kammah and Carlo are average and i don't mind them winning but im sick of males winning all the time..

MARWA AND SHATHA TO WIN.....not the messed up Sally

I THINK VOICE WISE amma7 waz the best of course...HE HAS AMAZING VOICE MASHALLAH...marwa has a great voice too but she shouts sometimes..and she duz good almost in fayrouz songz only which they alwayz put in the evaluationz..SO COME ON Y3NY!
and as for shaza..MY GOSH SHE 4GETS THE LYRICS ALL THE TIME..
CARLO..i like him but i dont like the way he singz arabic songz.it soundz kinda weird.,.
AMMA7 W BAS MEN EL A7'ER!!

i totally agree with H.A.R, 2amma7 was the best out of the 5, then carlos!

order of people in the last eval:

-mohamed 2amma7
-carlos
-marwa
-sally
-shaza

i'm so happy with the 5 finalists!!!!!!!!!!!!1

2amma7 is the star!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

plz not shatha and marwa!!!!!!!!!! one of them must win, mohamed and carlo: nice voices but just not good enough
sally: man she really overstayed her welcome, had to be out before maisoon!
any news from hanaa? or even amal?

STARAC 4 sucks really
i miss starac 1-2-3

All the girls forgot their lyrics,but at least Marwa song the part she still remembered well,which wasn't the case of Shada.For the boys Amma7 did well like usual,but I didn't like the performance of Carlo,he's funny yes,but his singing wasn't good.But anyway we'll see tomorrow...
Maghrebi,hoe is't?:p

I dont have the 24 channel so i havent seen the evals and im in school now so i have to wait till the rerun tonight to see the daily but from what i hear from u guys im soooo happy cuz if amma7 did good mayb he wont be nominee this week it sounds like the 3 girls will be nominees but that would be horrible because that would mean that either marwa or shaza will leave along with sally. Maybe the teachers will be a little lenient considering the grls where on a trip and couldnt practice but it also was the last eval and whose nominee this time determines the finals... aaaahh.. my perfect nominees this time are
carlo, sally and marwa with marwa returning

i saw the evaluation,2amma7 was the best then comes carlo.But the girlssssssss honestly and although i love`em all they suck.All of them forgot the lyrics.if marwa,sally and shaza were not nominees it will be real koussa and 3'esh 3alanyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

HOW ON EARTH can u say Kammah is better than Marwa and Shatha. Marwa has such a unique beautiful voice and Imad and Kammah himself said,she deserves it more than Kammah!
Kammah is good but not the best out of the finalists.
Come on people, everyone forgets lyrics once ina while so don't start saying Shatha is bad just because of this.
Don't forget, Carlo and Kammah had the advantage coz they got more time.

YEAH he's good but i don't think he's better than Marwa and Shatha because they have been good from the start to now.Kammah was a nominee which shows he can be weak aswell.
What do u mean Marwa and Shaza are just girls who have good voices.....i thought this was a singing competition..lol..Kammah is just a boy with a good voice too.
I think Kammah is amazing at composing and all that but you have to admit he can make it on his own and thats why i think Marwa and Shaza deserve it...plus, we've seen enough boys winning!
I think its time for a moroccan/tunisien to win because they have been amazing every year and now its their turn.

Even if Marwa is nominee, i think is a BIG threat to the other finalists because she has lots of people with her.

Law inti nominee Marwa,Kuwait is all with you and so is Saudi.We love you no matter what you are THE star.

tab sally and marwa forgot but how dare shaza remove the paper and read the lyrics really rude
kenit khalia decent w bsharaf tensa 3ala eno tghanneh heik men el paper

i voted alot of times last time for u 2amma7 and still i will and we are all with u ..u are the star this year im isa isa sure ..coz ur da best (shaza is too old to win .lol.. she has a bad personality and marwa has a gr8 voice too but they have nothing missing ..(no one can say that this year they want to let a female win ..BULL**** ..ofcourse not and though EGYPT WILL BREAK THIS FACT..

Hi all,

I Just want to tell you that guys calm down don’t be harsh on students..those students are human and they almost live in a very stressful environment. people are criticizing them for every single word..that is unfair… be positive about them and wish them all the best of luck.. they really deserve to be stars..

I can only predict who will continue singing or acting..

Shaza even if she doesn’t win she will be a great singer and she will have a bright future as a singer

Mohammed even if he doesn’t win he will be a singer and he will continue composing and writing his songs..

Marwa if she wins or not she has a good voice and may be she will be working with Al rahabina since she has Fairoz’s voice

Calro..I don’t know whether he will take it seriously or not..but I hope he will be a singer I like his voice

Sally, she will be a very good actor.. in a comedy movie or series..or she might be a presenter in a show..

Tina she is very ambitious girl and she will do her best to be a singer…

Ali is also a ambitious and he will do his best to be a singer..

Ahmed he might continue as an actor or presenting some shows as Hisham “star academy2”

Imad he will have a good future in singing he has the voice and stage charisma so he will continue..

Amal she has a good voice and she will be a singer..

That is my prediction and I wish all of them the best but of course I wish this time a girl will win…enough boys ..

Please this is my opinion from what I’ve seen so far…No offence to anyone and I like all students..

Natalie_Cananda

yea amma7 better than Marwa

Now i kinda believe Elie, she might be right guys...last time she was right, and from what i have seen from the evals what she said is true, they will put marwa, saly, carlo and MAYBE shaza nominee, and saly and shaza will return so that the egyptian votes will be split and shaza wins...
I dont want her to win though, great voice and everything but not a good personality, i didnt like her since that fight she had with carlo and amma7...i'd like to see amma7 or marwa win...they both deserve it...

Hey Natalie, since u r in Canada, when do the dailies come now, after the time changes, cuze im confused and I didnt watch it since then

Plz reply...

all people have to know that KAMMAH is the star ok MASR kolahhha ma3aaa fa plz ma7adsh sayy that shaza or marwa star isa they will be nominaaaaa offf i hate the bothhh offffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff marwa w shaza offff bgd

Hi everyone,

I saw the evaluation today and from what I see is that it's hard to predict who will be nominees tomorrow.
All of you are making up excuses to the girls, I was too but from what i saw later is that for example wadih told them that taking the song late last night is not an excuse for forgetting the lyrics, on the contrary if anyone wants to do s.th he/she will do it. I am just quoting wadih's words.

But what really struck me was what shaza did, she not only forgot the words but also she darely got out the paper and read. shaza is the kind of person who never admits that she can be wrong. In addition to telling wadih "you are too strong to live without u" what was that???

can anyone plz tell me!!!!!!!!!

Im in Canada and they put the shows at 1:00 or at night they put it at 7:00

Thanks Alex...
Does anyone have prime 13 vedios, I wanna see them and they r not on youtube...if anyone knows where to get them from plz post the link...
thanks

i love sally and marwa..they are the best

yasmina, me mij alles goe. me u?

i really hope that shatha and marwa aren't nominee!! for the ones who say that mohamed is better then marwa and shatha: huh?!
the most difficult songs to sing(classic), who sings them? right... marwa and shatha(i think marwa more). who were never nominee? again shatha and marwa.
who're the ones with real facial expression, no funny things with the face nor eyebrows, and really shine at the stage.... don't let me reply that, it's obvious! im not saying mohamed is bad, she's got a good voice, but is just a bit boring to look at :s. and it's a singing competition: the voice counts for everything, yes also acting and dancing, but i never saw a play during the prime.
if a guy was winning, i wanted ayoub or danny. sad they're out!
i miss emad and especially amal, also iman(i think her voice was better then amal's)
grtzz

yasmina, me mij alles goe. me u?

i really hope that shatha and marwa aren't nominee!! for the ones who say that mohamed is better then marwa and shatha: huh?!
the most difficult songs to sing(classic), who sings them? right... marwa and shatha(i think marwa more). who were never nominee? again shatha and marwa.
who're the ones with real facial expression, no funny things with the face nor eyebrows, and really shine at the stage.... don't let me reply that, it's obvious! im not saying mohamed is bad, she's got a good voice, but is just a bit boring to look at :s. and it's a singing competition: the voice counts for everything, yes also acting and dancing, but i never saw a play during the prime.
if a guy was winning, i wanted ayoub or danny. sad they're out!
i miss emad and especially amal, also iman(i think her voice was better then amal's)
grtzz

Shazaa should not win. Today in the dailies, she cussed out kammah and carlo and said ya walad el k....(dog) and she was pissed. She is a loser and has the worst personality of any student that entered the academy she is horrible. Her voice is okay but marwa has a much better voice. A star is a star all around. As for the evaluation, hey all of you shazaa supporters and marwa supporters, stop hating on kammah and carlo get over it they both did good in the eval, clearly the girls were horrible...oh some will say there excuse is traveling.. but for shazaa she was horrible in the last prime reading of a paer on the piano with the iraqi guy and totally screwing the heck out of elissa ayshalek song. Shazaa needs to be nominated if not dismissed from the final. My final is marwa mohamed and carlo best singers most derserving all around stars who dont just start fights with people and cuss for no reason!

Salam all, I want to let madam Rula Saad that the nomination needs to be fair this time, this means that Shaza doesn` t deserve to be nominated i don` t denye that she did forget in one of the songs in the prime that i think was because of Wadi3 as she only knew about if the night before the prime, as for the eval i am with that she could have done better in the 1st song but as i heard they also recieved it late. To summarise Madam Rula give Shaza the opportunity to be in the final as she deserves to be in there. And one final think i`m not being biased but the IRQAI people would be really happy in a small way as you all know we are in a sad and in a dangous place and want just to be happy so pleaseeeeeeeeeeee don`t let Shaza be nomine. P.s I really like Marwa as well

Maghrebi!!! diffcult songs blblba blbla . You say amrwa and shzaa sing difficult songs. You know why shazaa ssings 7 songs in every prime because she kisses wadi3's ass. marwa sings them right, other ahnd shazaa doesnt know the words and makes up words and sounds like a man. I am not egyptian but be fair and honest to what you say. Mohamed sang set el habyeb ette rthana ny of them, sings for abdelhalim all the time in the academy and can sing classic songs but he is not given the chance in primes.

Hi guys i am miram from Canada and I really agree with Natalie from Canada.The last 5 candidates especially are all awesome and they all deserve to win and no matter what we say there will only be 1 winner and u cant reaaly change the results unless u vote for the best student.
For me, voice wise 7ammah or marwa or shaza should win they have the best voices in the academy.
I feel like this season went by so fast, even though I think that 1 & 3 are the best seasons
Anywayz wish them all the best

Miram-Canada

Shazaa is a fake iraqi she is never lived there! please don't pull the whole iraqi card into this. Enough be fair and madame roula doesn't care what you think and if madame rolla is fair put shazaa nominee and lets see what happens.

nominees are
marwa
sally
shaza/carlo

karen you are the same fake shazaa supporter and one of few that support shazaa should have been out of this show way back with her attitude. The only way she would win is if they cheat and change the results. No one likes her. You are one of like 5 people lol I can say what i want and sweetie dont change your name 5 or 6 times with same ip and write messages to shazaa it wont make people vote for her. Ppl dont like her period and she sucks!

Iraqi girl is very tuching because really most iraqi people hearts with Shaza since it is the first iraqi girl to participate and has a real iraqi voice!!

I am surrounded by iraqi friends and saw how much my friends are excited about Shaza..and actually she deserves the suppor of iraqi people..

I am with iraqi people and will support shaza all the way and hope Mm Rola be fair with her since she was the one who shines the primes most the time with Marwa and other students..

I will vote for her as much as I could in the final inshaallah..

Shada has a very bad personality and sometimes she thinks she is bestter than the others, but but but SHE CAN SING! She has the VOICE and thats most important ..

YALLAH SHADA, YALLAH IRAQ (L) You are OUR STAR.

We want IRaQ to WIN this year.. PEace and LOve (L)

Wow lool thank you for this website..so nice!!

To all the jealouse of Shaza..Why are you so rude..it is meant to me that you are so jealouse of her success..Her voice is amazing and to be honest I think she is the first one who will continue working very hard to be a great singer..this was her dream since she was a child and I think she deserves to have her dream to become true

Wish all the students best of luck and stope the rude and insulting comment because it is not nice..at all..

hey seriously marwa does not have the qualities of a true star...she cant control herself around food which makes her look reallly bad and the only reason she used 2 hang out with ahmad, ali, ayoub and abdelaziz was to get the khaligi votes when she gets nominated seriously its all a big act...she didnt even cry as bad when the people from her own county left marwa cant win starac 4 it will be a disaster

i think ammah is the best i think the best top 3 is he carlo and shada sally i love her but her voise isn't as good as the others but marwa's voice is good but i hate heeeer toooooooooooooooo much

thank you natalie
u said it im with u all the way
shatha will be the star

to iraqi girl
not because you are runing your country we should let a fake bad pertsone to become a Star i dont agree with your comment at all (the IRQAI people would be really happy in a small way as you all know we are in a sad and in a dangous place and want just to be happy so pleaseeeeeeeeeeee don`t let Shaza be nomine.) this a star competion not welfare support for your people how fight stupidley the other iraqi people for stupied reason.
the nominee this week will be
1- shatha
2-Marwa
3-Sally
and Sally will win the vote
so this will give the chance for Carlo to win the final after egyption vote splite for Qammah (the Star) and Sally
this is my openion

First of all thank you Karen for giving us the opportunity to watch the evaluation of every students …

When I read people comments about students’ evaluation I thought that Shaza did really bad…BUT when I watched each student’s evaluation I knew that never believe most comments …because basically they are very bias to their countries which is understandable but ..at the same time they should be fair…..guys praise the student from your country but don’t say lies..

The first think that caught my eyes that boys have used the microphone to make their voices look better and I don’t think it was a good idea since microphone never make the stronger..Shaza and Marwa they both didn’t use the microphone and their voices were wow..

Carlo…he used the microphone and sang..then I was lost about his idea of the mother ..then all the sudden when he started the song there wasn’t any feeling …

Mohammed also used the microphone and sang well then the second song about the mother wasn’t that good ..

Shaza read few words from her first song and sang very well..I liked her idea of her misunderstanding her mom until she left and was away from her mom…then she sang the mother song with passionate and her voice was very touchy…then she thanked all the professors …very well done Shaza…

Marwa..her voice is strong but she as the other girls forgot the song word…but she did a good job Knowing that they were away from the academy and didn’t have time to memorize the songs..

Sally no comment..don’t get me wrong I like her but we all know about her voice problems…

You welcome Lena for your information if Shaza doesn't deserve the support I wouldn't do that but she is a real star

I will be the first one to buy her Album CD

Shada should be nominated for her AWFUL prime performance [she messed up the Elissa song nashazzz 3al ekher and the words of Amor a la Mexicana] w el eval was terrible
Sally should be nominated because she can't even sing a haifa song without messing it up and the evaluuation was sooo bad
karlo and muhammad to the finale!

faisalfaisal don't you think one Mohammed Atia is more than enough for you...so you want Sally to win!!! wow what Sameah to tarab voice you are..

Star Academy first was Mohammed Attia ...where is he now..

Last year star Academy..Joseaf Atia..wow did you watch prime 12...did you see the real shining star..

Next year star Academy...you will watch Shaza..singing and supporting Sarac 5..

Wake up man!!!

and by the way...there is a huge difference between Carlo and Josef basically becasue Carlo can't sing Arabic songs..Carlo for French or English songs..that is all..

Don't you watch Ausam's debrief...

Hi, thank you karen for that website this is the first time i actually watch the evals.. except the carlo one doesnt work... I always thought sally had a weak voice but i realized that she barely gets to showcase it.. her voice is great... I think all three grls equally embarrased themselves by forgetting the lines but what they did sing they sang well and amma7s was very good too... i dont know who will be nominee but going on the forgetting of the words it might be all three grls

this is my opinion about the evaluations. but b4 ill just like to say that really its not far that the boys got much more time then the girls and i really think that the judges should take that into consideration even though they most likely wont.
marwa- her voice was good when she was singing but i dont think she handled it properly when she forgot the words. u can tell she was struggling. i felt sorry 4 her.

shada- even though she forgot part of the song her singing was done extremely well. i really liked her idea and think that she was the best one today. even when she 4got the words it didnt look that bad when she got the paper out and read it cause she stayed calm and patient.

sally- no comment like someelse said she should of been out agesssssssss ago.

carlo- he shouldnt of been allowed to use the microphone its not fair. he did betta then usual but i dont think he is betta then marwa or shada. and personally, i just dont find him interesting to watch.

mohommed- he did ok but also its not fair how he used the microphone. and like carlo i dont find him an interesting performer and dont think he is up 2 shadas standard.

so overall, "I" think the nominees should be:
1. sally
2. carlo
3. mohommed
BUT thats not going to be the fact cause this show is never fair. si=o the nominees probably will be:
1. sally
2. marwa
3. shada (or carlo)

inshallah shada or marwa stars.
btw: 4 pple who hate shada cause of her personality, its not that her personality is ugly its just that she is a really straight person and cant be fake like others. shes been living in a house of snakes (sally,tina,carlo,mohommed) for 4 months so i dont blame her 4 being that way!

missing MALAKIT EL AHSES AMAL
we love u here in australia.

wow.. guys i don t know what on earth you are saying.. i mean despite the fact that this is a singing competition, i really think how well each person has progressed thru the whole 4 months is more important.. i dont kno what you people thought but i really thought that 2ma7 nd sally were good.. 2ma7 cuz of his voice.. and sally cuz of her idea.. i mean, she wasnt the best vocally, but she progressed very well and i thought her singing was much better than other evaluations.. to the person that sed she messed up a haifaa song, she didnt, haifaa just sang with her and sally had stopped, as a way of being polite(i rewinded it to check =] )
carlo, was okay, but his idea got me puzzeled and his accent had the western style and i think the teachers will comment about that..
i dont know about you guys, but i dont think Staracademy would want their star to be a rude, ill behaved person and that is how we have been seeing shatha on T.V ... i think its a way to show people that shaza, even though has a great sick voice, isnt such a star after all.. the biggest proofs can be shown everywhere.. for exaple,in todays daily when she cussed 2ma7 and carlo and wen she had a huge fight with sally cussing her too and the biiggg one with carlo.. i mean if they wanted her to shine infront of the students then they wouldnt show them.. she could have gotten away with forgetting the words in todays eval but i doubt her gettin away with that paper! i mean it is REALLY rude.. she did that in the prime too.. she had a paper.. and forgot the words to the ELISSA song.. if this is a fair nomination she should be one of them.
shaza might claim shes iraqi but she has never lived there, but whoever gave her the idea to enter as an iraqi really was smart. last year we all know that the only reason joseph won was becuase of the war in lebanon.. i mean it was played rite but we all know that lebanon(and the countries that voted for him) cant beat egypt.. it was a way to make people happy in lebanon. and for all we know, they can do the same thing again.
marwa i doubt her wining thou, i mean she has an okay voice its not great cuz it seems like shes shouting sometimes.. but really we have seen her been made fun of cuz of her appearance and her being reprimanded for eating and stealing food.. i mean i bet everyone knows her for that then that she has a good voice.. so that can dull her staracademy winner chances.

im egyptian and i swear im not just saying that cuz sally and 2ma7 are egyptian but really, we can all agree that 2ma7 deserves to stay in the finals and no one can hate the kid.. sally she progressed so much and fought for her stay in the academy despite the discrimination she has been thru.. i mean look, she sang well in the evaluation and i bet she could have sung like that in the last prime if she was given the chance.. i mean the ELISSA song had her name written all over it.. and by giving it to marwa and shaza.. well we all know what happend..
dont criticize wat i sed.. its my opinion..
if anyone is to win.. its deff 2ma7 but thats including his personality.. if we took the personality matter aside.. then shaza would also be in the finals.. too bad that it is =]

Yasminnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn if you are not bias you wouldn't implied that last year was not fair when Joseph won...because basically he was the best among the three..don't get me wrong ..I like Hana and Hani but Joseph was the best… and Actually last year was the first year that the winner really has it all…

So don't make an excuse that Joseph won because his country was in war...then Shaza so far has the best and the strongest voice..among the students… if you wanna hear singers like haifa "with all the respect to haifa" you can find it every where you just need to turn on the TV and I am sure you will be amazed how many new faces every day you watch BUT the nice voice, and the charisma on the stage..JUST few singers you will find..so please don’t tell me that all the sudden Sally became Najat El Sagera or Fairoz!!!

Shaza is Iraqi no matter what you say...I know very well why your comment are most the time rude, mean but honey that wont get you any where..and by the way I don't think the lbc will be fair this year if Shaza and Marwa won't reach the final because those two girls worked very hard and they were the most two students who made the prime enjoable…and the most the primes were successful because of them…

No offence honey but this the truth

I just want to let Yasmin, the person above me know that Joseph won because he was talented!!!!! For your information, the war in Lebanon happened AFTER Joseph won...know your facts before you talk :P !

Shada has a very bad personality and sometimes she thinks she is bestter than

can someone plz tell me how i can watch star academy episodes on the internet! Thx