AMAL WOU BASS
voting was rigged ahmed deserved it
i miss u amsl i love u sooooooo much
amal star mah ma sor!
go marwa and shatha!

No, the voting was not rigged. Ahmad had a horrible voice and everyone knows it. Sally should have gone though.

But I do like Amal, Marwa, and Shaza.

Goumhour sally gamed 2aaawiiiii!
She beat Kuwait; wooww begad; MABROUKK.

Congrats Ali
and Hard Luck ahmad,
you looked so cute today!

GOOO SALLY TINAA CARLO AMMA7!!!

Wallah forget star academy its soooo rigged!
SALLY SHOULD BE GONEEEEEE
ALI SHOULD BE GONE!

MA BARAF SHU SAR MA HAYDA BERNAMAGE!!!
Walla Amal w bas!!!! Mafi Ahson min hiyee!!!

Madam Rola is just getting LOADS of money from Saudi Arabia. But the Saudi's are only voting for him because he's from their country (go figure!!) I am something completely different from the nationalities on the show...of course I am arab but most importantly Syrian, I LOVED Amal she was the most amazing women in the house, and highly talented, she WELL deserved to be on the show, bas instead they have a bunch of people who are clueless of what the show is about and are so worried about themselves, and flirting with the other students in the house.

About this prime, I think it was rather BORING. one of the worst ones I swear...

Ali or Sally should of left, def. NOT ahmad...hes far better than they are!

GO SHADA AND MARWA!!!!

gooooooooooooo shatha u r the best out of all

The cute looking, the beautiful voice, the QUEEN of Star Academy, YES YES SHATHA
Good Luck #1

Salam, Kindly let me have your comments and answers ,because am really confused with what is going in this programme, i been watching the original copy of star academy , but it was real copy and there was no games like what am seeing now in this arabic lbc programme.. they have a very talented students such as Shatha,Marwa,Emad,Amel,Qamah and Carlo .. they got rid from Amel & Emad by the voting game and what is the next step another HISHAM ...????? this is not fair at all, and another thing why they keeping the noisy girle sally shouting all the time, it is overacting , we can't bear them any more and what about this ugly faked tina why they are keeping and continuing show her as a talented student , ok she sing the english & french songs good and she dance good, but all of them they can do the same if they are asking for, and in the addition to that they have the big strong great voice like SHATHA, please waleg if you can show my msg, and am appriciate if I can get an answer from madam Rula , this will help.

p.s. for all the eygptian people by voting to sally you almost lost Qamah .. Carlo stop playing with sally take care of your voice and training.

Hamda of course we didnt loose qamah, plz dont say that otherwise egyptians will loose sally. they r voting 4 her, yeah, so they can choose 2 vote 4 mohammed also if sally was with him. how r u guys thinking plz egyptians dont u ever be that bad and et rid of ur daughter this is so selfish. u can choose when 2 vote 4 sally and when 2 vote 4 mohammed.

hu went out n hu stayed?!?! plzz sm1 tell me!! its not ritten here any1 tell meeee or waleg tell mee!! hu went out by the students?? plz tell me evrything bout the nominations

hanz.....Ali was saved by the public...then it was between Ahmed and Sally. Marwa and Shatha chose Ahmed and Carlo, Tina and Mohammad chose Sally.

Anyway, I'm happy with the way things turned out....I think Ahmed deserves to go because he doesn't do well in the Academy.

Shatha lo Mohammad to win!

people just save your money 2 vote for shatha in the finally.

goo shatha walla you are the best, even marwa had a nice voice to but she can't be a star she even don't know howw?!?

im 17 years old & marwa is in my eyes 16 maan she can't be a star with this baby thingss...

JUST SHATHA forget the rest....

MARWA can and should be the star this year,she's n'1,so GORGEOUS last night,however the prime was very annoying, but marwa was great,i feel bad for her now that ahmed is gone,she's in love the poor girl

Dose any one of you notice when it was the finall secend before the results comes on the screen it came then gone for one secend then comes again .. this who they change the results .

The Results were :
Ahmad 38 %
Saly 35 %
Ali 27 %

the voting were more than 750.000 votes that's means more than 1000000 US$ for only one week .

Amal We Will Never Forget you .. and i heard that amal is going to kuwait on monday ,

except for Marwa , this week's prime was awfully boring and dull

Go Ali Go

i already imagine the worst scenario, ali will get always the highest votes till the end, OMG if he has a little dignity he will leave the show he can't even sing i don't know what is he thinking...best think that stupide little spowled ahmed did leave

Hey everyone I'm just soo happy Sally is back!It was Ali or Ahmed's time to go, and this week Ahmed left. One big coicedence is that Ahmed left right after Amel did.

To samie_jr
I know everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I just disagree with a point of yours. Carlo and Tina have beautiful voices! One thing that bugged me during this whole star academy is how the teachers kept on telling Carlo and Tina that they need improvement in their arabic singing, eventhough others in the academy (ali, ahmed,maysoon etc...) sang even worse in arabic! thanks and good luck to all students and yes I agree with WXCV and their point about Ali. I seriously think he may just win it with his strong votes, but it's unfair because he has the worst voice in the academy!

PLEASE Stop arguing all of you.For me,both 3 nominees had to go out.With all the respect,they're ok but not the best students for this competition.I think that LBC has to take a look at Future Tv's "SuperStar" candidates.They're 1000 times better than Sally,Ali and Ahmad.Whatever,I think in the finale there will be Shaza,Marwa and Mohammad;The winner hopefully will be SHAZA!

Go girl,you're D BEST

There is so much hatred and bigotry on this site. It’s intolerable to read some of the insulting and vulgar comments posted. How can a recreational Television program create a political/regional cyber war involving various factions utilizing weapons of hate, racism, verbal abuse, and uncouth comments? It’s pretty shameful if you ask me. Why are people on this site spewing such malicious insults and posting such vindictive language? Why do we feel the need to always hurt each other? It’s unbefitting of our humanely qualities and civilized upbringings. There is no reason for anyone to feel that they are superior to the other just because they belong to a certain country. Every Arab country has its own unique qualities and characteristics. They have the good and the bad. The Middle East is filled with civilization and immersed with rich history and culture. No one can make the claim that one country is better than another. They all have their own distinct qualities. Why do we always have to be so nationalistic to the point where we forget our humane nature? Why can’t be good citizens of the world? Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying that you should not be proud of whom you are and that you should possess a patriotic devotion to your homeland, but it’s unnecessary to have such extreme patriotism. It can be lethal, and it can strip you of your humanity. God has created earth and he made it so vast for us to live on it cooperatively. The reason for its diversity is so that we can get to know each other and learn about our differences, and consequently, appreciate it. Why do we have to fill it with hate and destruction? There is a simple solution to all of our problems, and it’s called respect. We need to respect each other and respect and honor our various opinions. Everyone should be respected. Same goes for the students. I see a lot of hatred toward the students whom you don’t even know. We may not like some of their voices, but there is no need to poke fun of their faces, weight issues, personalities, or their nationalities. What happened to objective/constructive criticism? Why can’t we just judge them solely on their performances and voices? And don’t tell me this is not a singing competition and it’s about everything. It’s a singing competition. I don’t see them acting in the primes. I see them singing. At the end of the day, the person with stage presence, voice, and musical talent will make it in this business.

Here is my critique of the remaining contestants:

Shaza: Best voice, good stage presence, and possess a good musical ear
Marwa: Amazing voice, good stage presence, but needs to control her vocals at times
Carlo: sometimes he demonstrates his vocal abilities, and sometimes he’s just about ordinary. I think his voice shines in some songs, and it just lacks this luster in others. He can sing, but his voice is not unique.
Mohammed: nice voice, but not beyond average. I think his talent is shown in his ability to write and compose songs. He’s very talented when it comes down to playing instruments. Does he deserve to win? I don’t think he should be the star, but he will make it far in the business post-academy.
Ali: You know..he’s pretty shaky. I think he needs a lot of practice, but he has a nice voice, but can’t project like the others.
Tina: I never really appreciated her voice. It’s definitely average. She’s doesn’t have the stage presence, and I just don’t take her seriously given that she sings only in English. She needs to start changing her game and start learning some Arabic songs. After all, this is an arab singing competition.
Salley: She has an average voice. Her stage presence is not very amusing, and I think after the academy, she’ll probably get a lot of offers in acting. I think maybe acting should be her niche.

ahmed..i cannot stand the academy without him and i cannot see marwa without him..its too boring now..and the dailies today was so much affecting and sad...poor marwa

Wow. Ahmed left. Wow.

Out of Ahmed Ali and Sally, Ahmed was definately the best. I like his voice but if he just fluctuated a little while holding a note itd be sweeter to listen to. I wonder why all the good people are leaving and the crapppy ones are staying. Dani, and Imad, (especially DAANI!!) left. Now Ahmed. Grr. And tho, yet again, i missed ANOTHER prime, i dont belive that more people in the academy wanted Sally and not AHmed. He seems to be the joker in the house.

ALi gonna send them all out ..just like hisham and be a star at the end ? ? ? is he?

gooooooooooooo ama7 u r star like mohamed 3ateya he won in star academy 111111111
haha egyptians r always z best

A reply to you ZERO not zoro

One thing I’m not a UAE_nutcase I’m 100% you are the one,
I talk coz I always speak the truth if you don’t like that it means you are worthless
You mentioned about Barbie that’s means you are the one who plays with Barbie until on your 2os Grow up you r still that kiddy , I know it may sound nonsense to you coz you can’t understand and never will you understand coz you are just 9 years old , you asked how old I am , if you have common sense you can guess that but unfortunately you don’t have that, too sad…..
You said you forgot to tell me your “flipino” maid even looks better then my bimbo sally let me tell you then you didn’t forget to tell me coz you don’t even know what are you talking about you are just that kiddy 9 year old girl or boy, you even don’t the spelling of Filipino too sad Grow up Grow up stop your nonsense
First you were talking bad about your maid now you are trying to change your words , so to pretend you are good with your maid, I can say nothing other feel piety to you
Again you said carlo is a gay and he may not want to go out with me , what the hell is wrong with you why would I want to go out with him , I love him that’s all coz he is a good singer, good actor and much more
And I see you keep on saying he is a gay , I think you are the one who is a gay , so for a long time you didn’t get a gay to accompany you as your galfriend so that’s why you are broken and keep saying nonsense

Grow up if not today
You never grow up
And why should I pretend to be a gay , I’m gal and always speaks the truth I’m not like you who is a gay , You are zero not zoro
Get that in your kiddy brain
Go sally, carlo d:

Zero not zoro take an example here from engy
"hey UAE,everything that u`ve said abt sally is totally right,she is perfect...carlo ,tina sally & qamma7 r the best
Posted by: engy at March 10, 2007 02:54 PM

Thank you engy for supporting me coz we r right sally, carlo, tina & kammah are the best d:

hiii guys, im soo sorry, but ahmad deserved to leave , he doesnt have a good voice, anywayz, good luck to the rest. gooo ammah, sally, tina., carlo, i love u guyz, i miss imad , ayoub and azooz so much,shaza is the star

IM Sorry but ahmad was a lot better than sally... he can at elast sing more tha one language... sally is just there for being anoying yelling screaming acting young...
shes a good person but star quality zero..

same goes for tina.. im the us and her voice is average in english in arabic zero her stage presetn zero no peronsality and no manners ... in the us we really dont like her.. carlo has a great voice but perosnlity zero no manners as well.. i feel so bad cause imleabnese and the lebanese this year are not that good.. i wish dani stayed... instead of these too...