Hi every1...... i just have 1 question...
Dont we all agree that star acadmey 3 was MUCH better than this year????
3anjad..... kenou killon mahdoumeen w they all had nice voices!! i used 2 watch the dailies every day and they were really nice!!
this year i only watch the prime bcz i feel like the majority r all fakes.... im lebanese and last year i was so proud 2 have a guy like joseph attieh in the academy, and a cute girl like maya........ this year carlo and tina r fakes w jarasou l libnanieh......
so, would anyone like to second my opinion??

i think carlo didnt sing well at all and so did 3ali...
as 4 sally and tina their ideaz were different from the otherz and creative too...but i think tina shud work on expressing her self in arabic..
QAMMAH will do hiz eval 2day insha2allah thats what wadi3 said when 3ali and a7mad were CURIOUSLY wonderin when will he perform hiz eval..GOSH!! GIVE HIM A BREAK U GUYZ!
i think the nominees will be :
1.AHMED
2.ALI
3.SALLY/CARLO

I have no predictions at all this week! Its going to be beyond tricky and 100% shocking to everyone... I don't think it'll be good news to anyone. Tina's evaluation was good but I have to agree with working on her arabic but if she feels she expresses herself better in English and is more comfortable with it she should stick with it. Sally's was nice but i (unfortunately) think that it needs more nerve, more power. Didnt get to see Carlo's. Mohamed's is hopefully tomorrow morning. Wishing him the best of luck and along with all the students, Good luck with this nomination its gonna be tuff!!

Carle and Tina are way overdue to be nominees !!

About time Mm Roula !

i saw shaza's eval.......it was gorgeous!!!!!!!

i think that the nominees are going to be from this list:

-ali
-ahmed
-tina (hope not)
-sally (unfortunately, i adore her)

GOOD LUCK 2AMMA7!!!!!!!!!!
GO SALLY, TINA, CARLOS, 2AMMA7, SHAZA!!!!!!!1

hey guys,
i missed the eval on purpose coz i can't stand that stress any more ,i feel 4 the students ..ireally think that this show is becoming painfully addictive at least 4 me...
waleg u said that sally's idea was creative and did well!!!!! wow!!!wow!!!thank god ,i hope that it is enough 4 her not 2 b nominated as 4 ali ...sorry u messed up ....but i think with the pattern they r working with throughout the show[i just noticed that!] the one who gets the audience votes gets at least a week of immunity 2 use the increase in viewership unlike the one who gets students' votes ,however sally's percentage was really close 2 ali 2 the extent that i didn't get it at first ,i didn't know who won ...i beleive that result was the closest in the history of star academy show ever!!!!!don't u think so?!!
i hope sally isnot a nominee....waleg u said she did well.....i know u r subjective so i m going 2 take ur word 4 it

I think the nominees are:
1.Ahmed
2.Ali
3.Carlo

I really think that Shaza did really well and sally's idea was very creative and her voice is much higher and better and the ba7a is almost gone, am wondering why people think she will be nominated. Also marwa did really well and Tina as well.

WOW im still affected by watching Shathas evaluation. Walah i think it has been the best evaluation this star academy, and her voice moved me, i cried so much.
She sang habaytak very well, and then her scene was about Iraq, althought it shudnt be called a scene cos everything she said was so true u cud hear it in her voice. She spoke about the atrocities going on in iraq and how shes never been there and wishes to see it one day, and how one day there will be peace, and she cudnt hold her tears, she was sobbing whilst her talk, and then she sang 'tathakar' by kathim al saher and all i can say is wow. the song is moving in itself but coupled with her voice mashllah. As an iraqi she made me feel proud to be an iraqi, and as iv never seen iraq before in my life i cud feel everything she felt.
allah yiwafoqich ya shatha.

hey guys did you see shaza's eval 2???

it was amazing and wonderful how she did
she is a real star and no one can tell me thats not true ok...you have seen that in this eval-

goo shaza till the end and all irakies and all ather ppl are with you for sure...

you are the star ,,she is the first iraki woman and make a really nice person with her the most best voice in the academy .

inshalla inshalla i hope for you will the star ..

for me the nominees should be realyyyyyyy this time!!!!!
1-aliiiiiiiii (and i hope he will be the one to live the academy)
2-ahmed
3-sally
maybe they will do a 4th one and it should be carlo!

i didnt watch it but i wanted to know something every1 is saying the student where all creative and ths and tht but the main point is did thy sing well? coz ths wats ganna get thm in trouble even if thy were creative.

ya Allah i missed shatha's eval. plz does any1 knows where i can find it??

if u miss any eval watch it during the dailies
hope u see what u missed.
carlo,b4 entering to his eval,said it will be 3 nominees and 2 will b out

i missed the evaluations too, but i think that the nominees should be:
1) Tina
2) Ahmad
3) Carlo

you guys plz some one tels me have Marwa done well on the evals!!!!!!!!!!!!! plz answer me plz i'm about to die 4 her she's an amazing girl...plz tell me she did well.plz GO MARWA 7AYATY....i'm praying 4 u...plz answer me

Ya Alla Sheza is the best, she song very good as usual as she has the best voice in the academy since the begining of the academy.. and about her scene , it was more real than a scene,it was truth what ever she song , something like a dream, although am an eygptian ,but i have to admit she is sooooooooooooooooo nice and respectful, she know how to act and she know that she came to this acadmy to sing and to be a star , not to do something else like the others, which they lost their talents in the academy.

i think karlo will be nominated with ali,ahmad and sally....and 2 u "angie from egypt" marwa did very well,she and shaza did an amazing job...sweet marwa will be top 1 this week. MARWA,SHAZA AND AMMAH R THE BEST

الله يعطيج على كثر نياتيج يا شذى، خليتي كل العرب و العراقيين بالخصوص يبجون ، أنتي أحسن وحدة تغنين و أنشاء الله انتي تكونين ستار .زهرة من البحرين

NO amani i'm sorry but marwa did as well as shaza...they're both talented and so shaza is in no way better than marwa...don't 4rget the age difference btw them...marwa is 8 years younger than shaza.8 years so it's alot of experience...GO MARWA U HAVE THE BEST VOICE IN THE ACADEMY

go go go cheza , u r zhe best ....

Angie

marwa was great in the eval she talked about palestine and she said that she was born there..however she was unsure that she did well and she is thinking that she will be nominee..i didn't see shatha's why was she crying?

MARWA is the best!!!!!!!!!!!! she did very well she should be Top one this week...not TOP 3 but Top one!!!!!!!!! She's by far the best student in the academy.shada and tina did well too. good luck for all the students,especially MARWA!!!!!!!

I beleive that shatha is the best I agree with amani and with all who support shatha , she is talented and I wish that she will take her chance to be the 2007 star academy 4

OMG don't tell me she didn't do well....my god she won't be nominated,it's impossible,she's the most talented one on the academy with shaza....marwa don't cry plzzzz .... i hope she'll make it n'1 on the top 3

please any body saw shada eval, i missed her i been in the class, please tell me how did she do exactly ,i addorrrrrrrrrrrrre shada , she is the best all the times.. , i saw only tina and she was singing in english as usual, i think she had to join the western programme of star academy , not the arabic one, cz she is good in english songs and dances not in arabic at all, poor , she try her best but it is not her place here..................

ahmad and carlo r buging marwa on the live channel...they're really starting to get of my nerves let the sweet girl breathe...ahmad is such a looser,he's childish 4 his age..and ANGIE marwa did really well she and shatha were the best

i love you sheza, u are the best , your voice,behave, and every thing , i love you sheza i love all the iraqi guys@@@@@@

yeah jennfer i've seen that they were trying to make her cry,no really they are disterbing her the poor girl...she's young and true. go marwa u deserve the best girl....i don't give a .... about shatha,i hope the old om monghar will get out....GO TINA GO MARWA GO CARLO

halloo jullie zijn allemaal goed maar ik denk dat chaza star zal worden en ik hoop het ook.

i think the nomenies are
1tina
2ali
3sally
ali will have highest vote
the people who will vote for sally is:mohommed,ahmed,marwa
the people who will vote for tina is:carlo shaza
sorry tina
there is gonna be a top 2
1.marwa
2.if mohommed did well its mohammed if he didnt then its shaza
freind of the week:marwa or ahmed

hey guys,
i wanna ask something ....if sally's idea was creative and she sang well as waleg has said then y would she b nominated while u say that others forgot words and messed with the tones?!!!! i think having a different voice doesn't mean a bad voice....i know she doesn't have a strong voice like shaza's but it's not bad .....as 4 a7med.....i have 2 admit that he messed it in the prime ..he was a given a golden opportunity but he messed it up...too bad!!!i think this may result into his nomination.....tina..well,i adore this girl but i ve noticed that they have been taking the songs away from her 4 the past 2 weeks ..i think that means she'll b nominated soon probably this week unlike carlo where they increased the no of the songs he sing in the prime....if u noticed last tuesday they showed the bad side of all the students except 2amma7 and shaza ..i think that means they r making a distance between them and the nomination unlike marwa!!!!i think we will her name soon...i don't think she'll b in the finals 4 the same reason amal was nominated ....she's from maghreb 3araby so she can't win it this year as star academy maghreb is launching their 1st season!!!!!!
i hope sally isnot a nominee coz she did well this week and she deserves not 2 b nominated [that if they r fair]...
anyway we'll c 2morrow
i 'll give u a tip...if u wanna know the nominees b4 the announcement just call the voting no. as if u r gonna vote and u 'll b amazed!!!!the names r already there ready 2 vote 4 b4 helda even tell the the nominees themselves...that's how i found out about last week nominees b4 the announcement.

OMG shaza really touched me!!....she was amazing & so true!!.....however i missed marwa'z :( i think nominees will be

ahmed
sally
ali

mamar, leuk da je nederlands praat,
maar dit is een engels forum!!!

Shatha and Marwa are the best, all Amal-fans with them, one of them is going to win!!!!!!
is it true 10 000 ppl in the airport of casablanca for Amal?

Y are you guys still saying the three nominees theres still mohamed witch i dought that he will be nominee but still, you never know what lbc can do!!

shaza ya 3asal ...walah arou7 fedwa l3younich ...a7ibch hwaya

but i think that the nominees should be:
1) Tina
2) Sally
3) Carlo/Ahmed

marwa & shaza u go girls!!!

EL WAD KAMMA EBN EL FALA77777 IS THE STAR!!!!!
SUPPORTING HIM ALL THE WAY
YOU TOO PEOPLE
have u noticed how the academy is divided into groups now?
khaleejs togther
and then egyptians and lebbanese together!
and then did u hear amal telling ahmed,shaza,marwa and aly to stay(yad wa7da)?how rude?!
anyway i dnt really care because my favourites are the lebanese and egyptians so i love seeing them together!

any1 knows if I can see shathas evaluataion somewhere?
youtube or anywhere?....

She was singing about baghdad and crying at the end of todays yaomeat....is it possible to see the whole thing anywhere???

nominees for this week are:

1- Ali
2- Ahmed
3- Tina

Mohammed hasn't performed his evaluation yet so it's early to predict the nominees

Hi... i dont have the 24 channel so i haven't seen the evals yet... and it sux cuz they only show us very little in the dailies..

i hope your right about sally doing well cuz i really want her to last a little longer.
I hope the nominees are:

ali
ahmad
carlo or tina (i love them but i just want sally to stay a lil longer)

i wonder how the nominations are going to be anyway, Madame Rola said that things will change and we'll see tuesday... i'm soo curious

yes its ture there were 10000 people in the morrocan airport in CASABALNCA awaiting Amal hopefully we will have photos soonb!!!!

AMAL WE MISS YOU HABIBTY YOU ARE THE SATR AMAL YOU BASS

GOOD LUCK MARWA AND SHADA! THE STARS WITH AMAL

this week nominee
sally(go home honey you are rubbish)
carlo
ali
ahmad

amal ya maliket al ihses
amal wou bas

lets not start comparing sally with amal!
sally is not rubbish, she is he only girl who is not trying to pretend to be something shes not in the academy
she doesnt go following ahmed like some people used to do
i like amal, but if ull start saying bad stuff about sally ive got a long list!

bimbom do u think tht there photos of amal in the airport? i hope there is and if any1 has it place post so we can all see it plzzz. miss amola alot.

hope the nominees for ths week r:

-sally
-ahmed
-tina/carlo

I agree with you Loriana, Sally may not be the best, but theres one big list for each and every single student in the academy!!!

love you sally, hope you won't be bit by LBC this week!!!

loriana darling u gara keep u hair on. in here we compare and thts the only way to find out who should be the star, not personal but if u ganna be personal other people r ganna answer u back and u aint ganna like it so stop starting conflict. i truly thought and still think amal is better thn sally in talent wise, i dont even wanna get to personal so jst chill man

hope the namoniees are going to be:-

sally
tina
carlo

goooooooo marwa and shaza 1 of u's two r hopefully the star

ps. loriana, maryam is right u better keep u bad list to urself coz i have 1 of sally which has no end, but i aint ganna start stop conflict now abut sally and amal.

hi everyone i live in canada and here star academy isnt that big of a hi...me on the other hand as one person said its quite addicting so yea....as for the nominees who knows ..maybe ali,tina, carlo.. or ali,sally,carlo...who knows bt good luck to all...

stars TINA reppin lebanon..:)SHATHA great voice or MOHAMMED!!
neways peace ppl!

i watched all the evals and i think the students are better than last week and as 4 the nominees:

if they're 2 then it's:
1.ahmed
2.ali

if they're 3 then it's:
1.ahmed
2.ali
3.sally\tina\carlo

and hope 2amma7 will do good in his eval tommorow,cuz im expecting this guy in the final,if not the star :)

and loriana,
im with u in every word u said,i didnt like amal telling marwa,a7med,3li and shaza to be 1 hand,but anyway i dont care 4 them aslan.
i prefer the Egy\Leb group,THEY ROCK !!
and plz guyz enough of this amal love fest,come on get over it and stop crying like '"we want amal back".i felt sad also when dany and imad left but i didnt do like this.

and i have a remark about sally's eval when she put the cubes together so they will show egypt's flag appeared upside down i.e. black(top),white(middle) and red(bottom),while it's supposed to be red(top),white(middle) and black(bottom),so does she really doesnt know how egypt's flag look like??? :S
or she just didnt notice that she put the cubes upside down???
and i think she really maybe dont know the egyptian flag,since she's talking in lebanese accent all the time maybe she wants the lebanese nationality,im starting to think she's changed unfortunately,cuz i liked her a lot.

*2amma7 is the star*