OMG im speechless!! AMAL?????? I was almost CERTAIN he'd vote 4 amal:O
poor marwa:S:S:S
Anyway, overall, the prime was good!! good luck amal!!!!:(

goo sallly u rok!!!!! ur the best!!! u were supposed to win the votes but starac cheated... AS USUAL!!!

WE LOVE U SALLY

FINALLY AMEL IS OUT =D

AMAZING PRIME. i am so so so sad for Amal, but i wudve been sad if sally went home too. allah yiwafiqka she looked sooo stunning today mashallah 3aleha. she looked prettier than any other star academy student ever. i am in love with shatha's voice, she was spectacular tonight altho she did forget the words to ' i love u baby'.
next week nominees are ahmad, ali, sally.. and remmeber 2 nominees will leave next week, so ahmed is leaving 100% along with ali i think, because the khaleej vote will be split, and so sally will return

did u see that guys egypt and ksa only differed by o. something i was like dancing u know when ali said sally bgd thnxx for everyone who voted for sullol really bgd and since when marwa is a friend of amal and is crying for her,also thnx to carlo and tina isa we re gonna return the favour,tonight's prime sucked they seemed to ran out of ideas everything was lame,any way bgd am so srry amal left good luck amola,isa tkonty fel tournee,annyway mabrook l kol 2ly by7bo sally w swtolha!

Omg I'm in complete shock!
I didn't watch the whole prime ,
I just caught the last 10minutes
and the results of Ali&Sally were SOOOO CLOSE.
Ali=35.47% &Sally 35.18%!
That's crazy.
I really liked Ali when he voted for Sally
because it was so surprising.
I thought he wuold for sure vote for Amal
but 3anjad, kberet bi 3eini ya Ali.
I LOVE YOUUUUUUU SALLLLLLLLY!
Workk harder,
shidi 7elek. :D

oh my god, the difference between Ali and Sally was very very tiny. He was 37.35 and sally was 37.18
Congrats 2 Ali and Sally and hard luck 2 Amal

u guys, maybe it's for the best that amal went out, she did a good prestation, she got this high, we can be proud of her!
but i was surprised that carlo was a bit rude to her, he just said "Sally" i didn't follow the program well last week, is he mad or something.
anyway... congrats egypt! we wish u and sally the very best(speaking beond the amalfans!!)

fake amal left!!!!!!!! yahoooooooooooo!!!
ali made the right choice by choosing sally!

Thank God tonight's CARLO'S SHOW ended. It's ridiculous. Mohammed and Tina sang only one song and all of the prime was devoted to Carlo.

u kno wats funny in this programe?
is that wenever someone is out, the person he/she was with during the students votes goes out the following week... example:
nelly vs maison = maison out
dany vs nelly = nelly out
dany vs imane = imane out
azooz vs dany = dany out
ayoub vs azooz = azooz out
imed vs ayoub = ayoub out
amel vs imed = imed out
sally vs amel = amel out

SO yea:D this show is quite predictable and i somehow knew that amel was leaving cz of this!! so again i think and im somewhat sure that sally is leaving next week, maybe with some1 else since things might chnage from now on in the nominations!

Does anyone agree with me?

I'm not really shocked, but you could expect anything at this point. Although, I would have hoped for Salley to leave given that she probably has the weakest voice among the nominees. I mean all three are around average, but she's the weakest of them all. I guess Egyptians are really big on voting. So I didn't expect Ali to vote for Salley. I guess he wanted to redeem himself. Although from an objective point of view, he should have voted for amal given that she has a better voice and can actually compose songs. Alas, this is a game, and things happen unexpectedly.

Now, out of the eight contestansts, I think the weakes four are Salley, Tina, Ahmed, and Ali. I'm not a big fan of Tina, so I think she needs to be nominated soon. She might be an awesome person, but definitely not a good singer. Even her singing in English is around average, and it's very nasally. I'm watching American Idol these days, and any of the 24 contestants can take her on. So, she's not taht good in English.

anyway, best of luck to the contestants. One thing: I didn't understand the halloween/fire/witch scene. It's not halloween. Halloween was back in october, and it definitely did not fit the song. It just did not make any sense to me.

amal was far beter that sally! marwa chapeux 3anjaddd gr8 voice god bless ! carlo tayoob 3an gher 3ade:P basharno the second song bet3a2idd basss ahmad messed it up:S:S! go marwa

bgd calm down everyone ali gave sally her chance as amal took hers asl y3any if amal had her mind in her head she would have taken the star this year and really till this i didnt insult the girl on the contary i wished her good luck and i voted for her last week and carlo just said sally because shaza was so rude when she said amal and hey for god's sake shaza and marwa and ahmed have been talking behind amal since forever now this week they re her friends so suddenly when was shaza amal's friend who stood be amal every now then wasnt it sally or am i watching another star academy!!come on people u all know that sally works so hard so please wish her luck as we wish amal all the best in her life,may she blessed isa and may we see her a big star oneday!

by the way amal you rock girl
carlo
ali
hate you so damn much!!!
i really want2 write something in the sms-night

To All ,

First Viva amal you we will not forget you for along time .

THE REAL RESULTS FROM INSIDE LBS WERE :
SALY = 37
AMAL = 34
ALI = 29

If saly gots the high vots ali will leave but LBC like to gain more money next prime to but Ali with Ahmad nominea .

Big thanks to all Amal fan and lovers .. to Rachel from Australia , Mohannad from , Palestine .., lahen elkholod .. every one ..and to for me i am going to moroco to see amal there .

This prime has really surprized me!!! first i was expecting sally to get back by votes but she didnt...then i thought that if ali gets back by votes then 4 sure he would vote amal back but that didnt happen too :( ...but anyways i agree with some here i think sally & some one else will be out next week ....Good luck amoula ur really a sweet person ...& Congrat'z 4 ali & sally...

P.S. ali really shocked me

I wasnt shocked at all with the results of this prime. Rola wanted amal out 3 weeks ago. I knew it when wadia took all songs from her and she sang only with the nominees that week. She didn't deserve to get out. I can't beleive Imed and Amal left before Ali,Saly, Tina, and Carlo. This prime is the worse prime ever. I think this show is anti-maghrebin I hope that all maghrebins boycott this rediculous show.
For us we chose our stars and Mme Rola is not going to oblige me who I will listen to.
I will not be surprised if Marwa or Shata get nominated next week because we know that there is a big hate in their hearts for us.

looooooooooool shadi Yeah better not say a word on him he was amazin this prime a reportage a song and a top1 amazin anywayz hilda was so annoyin when talkin to bashar she couldnt say anythin ehhhm . weird tina didnt sing anythin today this is redicilous. amma7 was amazin , i loved the song with carlo and shaza but it would have been better with tina .. carlo was so so so so so so hot today and fares karam SUKED he should lose some weight . Marwa was sorta openin her mouth so much while singing today but she rocks!! and ahmed no comment should be out i didnt like it when he sang with bashar thanks god bashar sang more than him in it ..:D:D
Welcome bk salllllllly
and gooooooo carlo amma7 tina sally ali
next week nominees :
1.Sally/ali
2.ahmed

First of all, FARES KARAM IS BEAUTIFUL!! When is he touring the US??? Beside that, I think that Sally doesn't have a good voice. Sorry, bas sotha mekharbish awy...Anyway, she is a waste of a spot. I really wish people voted according to vocal talent. I love Sally as a person, I think her personality is fun but her voice isn't doing anything for me but making me cringe. 2amma7 all the way!

Oh my god I don't belive it. Amal is gone. I feel so bad that Amal left she deserves to stay she has a great voice than some people. But there is nothing we can do it is a game. We love you Amal and I think your fans disapointed you today. You left as a STAR in our eyes and we are sooooooooo proud of you. All Moroccans loves you and so proud to see their STAR reach this far. I wish you all the best in your life. And a great success in your songs, I can't wait to here them again in a CD. Amal you need a brake from all this nonsence. This is a begining for you, I love you.
Ayoub, Emad, Amal, Shaza, Marowa, and Mohamad are Stars no matter how far they get.

congratulation to Sally & Ali tonight. And let see how far you can go. Eventhough I think this is not a singing compatition any more. To all the fans be fear next time and vote for the student that have a voice and can go far. Too bad Emad & Amal left we love you both.

Happy Birthday Shaza you are a true Moroccan and a true friend who care's about Amal. Marwa & Ahmad thank you for tring to save Amal. We will support you tell the end.

To all the Fans who voted this week for Amal thank you, thank you and thank you for every time you took to vote.

Amal good luck
We love you Amal
Amal STAR Mahma Sar
Best of luck to you Amal
Amal we will miss you
Amal Come to U.S.A

Your Fan Khadija
Moroccan American from U.S.A

I wasnt shocked at all with the results of this prime. Rola wanted amal out 3 weeks ago. I knew it when wadia took all songs from her and she sang only with the nominees that week. She didn't deserve to get out. I can't beleive Imed and Amal left before Ali,Saly, Tina, and Carlo. This prime is the worse prime ever. I think this show is anti-maghrebin I hope that all maghrebins boycott this rediculous show.
For us we chose our stars and Mme Rola is not going to oblige me who I will listen to.
I will not be surprised if Marwa or Shata get nominated next week because we know that there is a big hate in their hearts for us.

To be honest, Sally did not sing YAY very well, Amal was good, and A3li I don't see any differance. He sings bad!!
Obejectively Amal had to stay together with Sally. Unfortunately the Saudis give big $$$$$$$ to LBC, so if A3li would have left. Lbc would see her inkom diminisch lol.
I think A7mad improved a little bit!
Carlo and Mohammed were awsome !!!!!
Tina did not sing very much, so I wont comment on her.
The best talab of this prime were MARWA AND SHADA!!!!!!!
Marwa' voice was so beautiful, i fellt in heaven lol.
Mabroek la Shada for her 26th anniversary

Faysal.

GO SHADA
GO MARWA

AND GOOD LUCK TO AMAL MALIKET IL IHSAS!!!

This program is not for People from North Africa!!!!Hope that u are convinced now!!
Imed and Now Amal,where are we going???
Racist!!!!

LBC becomes racist/cheater
when the people you like leave
and when they don't win because you DONT vote.

Mabrouk ya dynamo ya SALLYY!
Go Amma7, Tina, Carlo w Salllly. =D
Bestt students.

W im so happy
the snake, amal, is out.
Bayanet 3ala ha2i2ta when she was nominee.

wondering why ahmed and ali got so far although there voices are HORRIBLE ...?
well its because the country they come from are practically the feul/food/energy for star academy's $$$ especially for roula!!! and sally got this far because egypt joined kuwait and ksa for the feeding of star academy!!! lol, and u silly people who vote are practically buying the tickets and all to all the places the students went, believe it or NOT! and im just sitting there enjoying the show while ppl spend their money on sillyness!!!
PEOPLE WAKE UP, there are many ppl put there who need this money more than star academy does!! ppl are dying every single second in countries affected by poverty, isnt that 7aram? and isnt it also 7aram to spend money on crap? i mean wat good will it bring you if your fav. student won?! NTHTN cz after tht u'll be spending more money on his/her albums!!!
i don't care what the reactions are because the truth does hurt huh?

mcrey_111@hotmail.com

I AM SO SAD AMAL LEFT. SHE DESERVED TO STAY. THIS IS NOT A FAIR GAME. GOOD LUCK AMAL.
GO MARWA. YOU ARE THE BEST

omg.. amal.... i am so upset... last week it was imad, n now amal!!! u were always in the top, along with imad, everyone i like is going.! n that was the same with dany being in the top! all u three were great at the start, n then u had to leave.. gonna miss u amal... n good luck to all..:(

Since yesterday when i saw that huge cake sent by Prince "i dont know who" to Ali and i knew since then that he will win but i didnt expect that he s that coward. This chicken ali is a backstabber who the hell does he think he is to say i gave a chance last week for amal and i ll give one this week to sally bcz i m fair no ya bawab you r a chicken and selfish and u prefered ur own benefit on ur friendship to amal and ur principles that u pretended last week u know very well that amal deserves more than sally
Be a man stand for your own beleives and princeples ya gaban
seriously i cant find words to describe u
next week enshallah u r out out out
how come emad dany and amal are out before you ya bawab fe3lan
btw the academy loves sally and are very subjective towards her she was saying now thanks for all who voted for me saudi kuwait and then MASR la ya habibty u should have said masr fel awel and it s pretty clear the academy loves her maybe bcz she doesnt stop talking in lebanese accent and swearing by el3adra!!!

I WILL NEVER WATCH STAR ACADEMY
FROM LEBANON

Sally don't be happy coz yourdays are counted.You are the type of person that deserve to stay in starac lebanon WHERE the cadidates aren't judged according to their talents.Ali and Ahmed you should thank God 1000 of time for the petrodollars you have got and the votes coming from.You are the fuel of the academy without you nothing can go.We weren't surprised to see Amal leaving.this was mentioned along the week in different forums.it was clear that they wanted to get rid of her.

look*

lol mohamed isnt jealous of amal hahaha
amal isnt good god she cant sing for beans
mohamed is better then her and if you put them against each other mohamed will get a higher % by alot

I hate Mme Rola , professors, and that stupid Ali.
They told him to choose the best not the worst. He's so pathetic.

btw this was the worst prime ever in the history of star academy
full of mistakes and very short although it was 2 hours and half like everytime

Don't know what this whole tragedy is about regarding the voting off of Amal! You'd think they voted off Om Kalthom for crying out loud lol!

Amal was barely an average singer and an even worse songe writer. She's hopelessly emotional and has issues with self-esteem, but that's her problem! Granted, she's a better singer than some of the students that remain, including Ali and, especially, Ahmed, but that's not because she's good, but rather because they are bad!

Finally, Sally may have a limited voice (though the limited tunes she can carry are easy on the ear), but Star Academy is not only a singing competition, and Sally is arguably the best dancer/actor of the remaining students. So, ya, she does deserve to stay and I'm happy for her. GOOOO SALLYYYY!

attention to all addicts and viewers of staracademy 4 : dnt vote bcoz this year winner is mohammed kammah and u will c and look sally she got soo many votes and comparable to ali so wat about mohammed we arent going to let mohammed be the 2nd like hani last year thats unfair ...go egypt and marwa and tina and carlo and ali are the best too !!

OH MY GOD PEOPLE ARE FREAKING OUT AND CALLING PEOPLE NAMES JUST BECAUSE PEOPLE LIKE THE OTHER
STUDENTS IN STAR ACADEMY BETTER,I MEAN WERE ALL THE SAME IN GOD'S EYES SO THOSE PEOPLE WHO KEEP ON WRITING BAD COMMENTS, GET REAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hi vivo !! u are a pathetic and u seem to know nothing about the real candidates and u said that mohammed makes a song that u can make in 2 minutes then why arent u a pop singer now or a lyricist or smth and amal her song says "roo7 eb3ed be33eed hakamel wa7di el taree2" thats all and she sings it in a sleepy way as if she is digusted from the song and doesnt like it p.s no one messes with EGYPT !!

to all

Save your money and dont vote anymore .. at LBC everything is fixed .......

I just dont understand why anybody would be happy that Amal left. She is by far the best out ali and sali and she really really didnt deserve to leave.

Im really disappointed in lbc and the arab people for voting for someone less deserving like ali and sali. Who would want there star to be one of them? they have no voice and it doesnt make sense to me. Once again the arab people got it wrong and voted for the wrong person. if this was fair amal wouldnt have been a nominee first of all and second she would have gotten the highest votes

lets hope that marwa and shaza win because thats the only way the show could redeem themselves

i hope u all realise that sallys days are counted, now she had the luck but it won't stay like that, she'll be out very soon! ahmed amazed me tonight with his voice, itwas better then usual.
ppl, don't get aggressive to eachother. it's not fun amal left, but don't think that this is the last u heard of her, i'm pretty sure she'll be very big, she already brought out 2 songs of her own!!!! and what's with Carlo, first he and amal were friends and now he started to treat her like crap! can anyone tell me?(objective plz).
read good what im writng: we all knew,te be really honest, that amal was leaving sooner or later, she couldn't reach the finals, we all know that.... but neither can sally! i think she'll be out next week!
good luck to the rest, especially shatha and marwa
ps: amal's not a snake!!

SERIOUSLY? alot of u were refering to ali as ugly .. so what? the show isnt about looks! seriously i cant believe u guys ur so rude and shallow .. go sally go ali !

I can't beleive this stupir guy voted for Saly. Both of them don't deserve to be on the show in the 1 place. I hate how the people vote for the nationality and not for the talent. Amal would be finalist with marwa and shaza if it is based on singing performance, charisma, beauty, ihsas, ans composing.
Amal we'll never forget you, you are always in our hearts. Ali you are so stupid. If you are really as you said last time that now is time of justice and people should vote for talent and who deserves to stay, you would voted for Amal not for Sally.But it seems that was just a stupid reason to get rid of Imed because you were jealous of him. You voted for Saly just because of the egyptians votes. But beleive me they wil not vote for you because you will be nominee again next week with the other loser Saly.
I hate you and that my last comment because I will never watch this crap anymore.

GOO GOOO SALLY WALLAHY KOLO LOVE YOU
AND GOD LUCK 4 AMAL .. I LOVE U
AMAL 2 BAS SALLY KAMAN LAZEM TAKHOD FORSETHA ZAY
MA AMAL KHADETHA LESBO3 ELLY FAAT :)

Wow!! Ali voted for Sally, how unexpected, but you know what, HE JUST PLAYED IT SMART!! because Egyptians are high on voting, and if he chose Amal, then next week when he is a nominee again, the whole of Egypt will vote for the person against him, and he'd lose!!
I was hoping Ali would leave this week. I can't stand him anymore, he's the reason my beloved IMED left.

I HATE WHAT IS HAPPENING IN STAR ACADEMY...WHY WOULD SHAZA AND MARWA SING A SONG ABOUT LEBANON...IT SEEMS THAT TINA IS BEING EXCLUDED A LOT FROM THE PRIMES>>>PLS I HOPE TO GET AN ANSWER (I am from canada)

first of all thanks to Ali he corrected his big mistake last week because Amal should have left last week, you have seen how Sally and Tina was crying last week when they found that they have make a big mistake by giving their vote for the fake Amal, thank god she left because I think her real reasen to join starac4 is to get a husbend and this is not the right place for her

I think the end will be as follows:

1-2 Mohammed Qama7 or Marwa
3 Shatha ( the fake)
4 Carlo
5 Tina
6-8 Sally, Ahmed, Ali

its clear if every one watch the 24/24 channel well and see without any racist emoitions,
and for the people who use bad words this show their nature and behavior, so I think they use it in their normal life with their freinds and family, their parents have not teach them that these words are used in streets not in recpectful families, I was choked that some you girls are using these bad words

I konw many of you will not like my comments but this the real fact you should face

hi all,
1st:the prime was average,bashar was AWESOME,fares karam sucked and hilda was a bit annoying

mabrouk 4 sally her return to the academy,u see the voting results were really really soo close,ali was 37.35%,sally was 37.15% also thanx to 3aly 4 voting 4 sally(unexpected move),im really starting to think he's fair,though i hated him before

carlo and shatha's song was awesome,2amma7 sang well in his tableau,but i think the halloween and stuff didnt suit the song,bashar's 2nd song was fabulous but ahmed ruined it as usual :S

vivo,
ur such a hater,2amma7 is the best,he is cute,honest and better 10000000 times than ur prescious amal. he isnt jealous of her cuz he is simply better than her and if u wanted amal to stay that much why didnt u vote 4 her alot instead of just blaming ali.

from egypt,
sally doesnt swear by el3adra cuz she's a muslim,she's called sally a7med and her mother wears hijab and she always swear by the holy quran(w el mos7af)

to nibx
your star mohammed he was combarse in the academy when Amal was shining. Mhammed is becoming interesting in the academy not because of his talent but just because of his love to stupid Tina. They're both stupids.
I can't beleive what is happening. Last 2 weeks when Saly was nominee, you were asking Amal's fans to support you to save your girl and at that time Amal was a star. Now Amal is ........
That's so rediculous, you are hypocrite people and think only of yourselves. I hate you and i hate your stupid show and you are the most dumb people on the earth because you're wasting your money on ridiculous things like you.

hey faysal r u the one who wrote the sms to sally that saids:sally ur cute but u need takweem?
if so lol..cool.
and i love u sally good luck sally,kammah,tina,and carlo.:]
love u bye

sara mn masr