ITS SOOO UNFAIR IMED WENT!! just shows how unfair this program can sumtimes be....i mean come on WHY AHMAD??? he is by far the weakest person in the academy and its his time to go!imed had one of the best voices...he was better then sally as she should have been nominated,she hasn't got a great voice. WHAT THE HELL IS UP WITH TINA VOTING AMAL!!I think she kind of regretted it afterwards because she knows she disappointed imed!

i also think TINE is too overrated,she hasn't even got a great voice,shes great in english and french but when it comes to arabic her voice isn't amazing anymore!

MARWA AND SHAZA are by far the strongest girls of the academy and i like amal because she has a unique voice but i think all this ahmad love stuff is starting to distract her.
Carlo is cool too but he reminds of Joseph and i don't really want him to win this time.Im hoping the winners in order should be:
1-Shaza, 2-Marwa, 3-Amal, 4-Kammah (would have been imad if he was still there!)
5 - Carlo
Im not really interested in Ali but i don't think he looks like a winner.I hate the way he goes around arguing with people about who they should have voted for after the prime.Like yesterday he was saying to Carlo he shouldn't have voted for IMAD!I think carlo is more closer to Imad than Amal!!
And also he shouldn't have been upset with Amal for not saying sorry top ayoub after voting imad because he said AHLA LIBNAN,AHLA NELLY when he voted for nelly,never said sorry.

This weeks nominees will be something like :
ahmad, sally, amal or ali

and im hoping AHMAD will go,he only cares about looks.I like amal and i hope she won't be nominated again.
Even though imad has gone he will come out as a singer in 2 or 3 years like AHAMD EL SHERIFF.
MARWA OR SHAZA TO WIN!

Imad should have stayed not ahmad and amal.
It is so unfair...
How can imad be a nominee and not sally or ali?? he is much better than them.
Anyway,I am shoked from amal and shatha's behaviour...they are backstabers...shatha is a snake by the way...i hate her behavior...i hope she goes out soon.

As for imad,I really repsect him for what he did...he told the students to give amal another chance if he stayed with her....i really respect him for this.
Anyway,i hope shatha is out soon... a star doesn't only need to have a nice voice,but a nice personnality too...she is a snake!!!!!

Absolutely shocked by the results!

First of all, Imed should not have left. Out of all the nominees, he was the one with the best singing voice. I really wanted to see him reach the final.
Secondly, when is Ahmed ever going to leave?!
He has no talent. I keep saying this over and over again, the guy is in the Academy for the entertainment value and not the talent.
Talent = Nil. Compare him to the rest of the Students and you'll find him the weakest. When is he going to ever leave?!
How many other great students are we goig to see leave before him?!
It's not fair at all! It is beyond ridiculous.

What's next, the departure of Shaza and Marwa?!

Imed may have left earlier than when he was supposed to. But, in my eyes (and I'm sure in the eyes of many) he came out as a True Star.

Dont say this stuff people really its not necessary ! ( about amal !!)
she doesnt deserve this what you guys are saying
and whats wrong if tina voted 4 amal ?? c'mon!
but about imed he was very good at the prime
and amal was also very good but ahmed he really sucks and he must go but the khalijees will ofcourse vote for him .. and their is one thing i want 2 know and that is about amal shaza tina and sally what did amal extually do? cause she wasnt talking behinds tina sally back .. if you dont like amal just say it but dont say lies plzz people

Go amal we are supporting you her in The Netherlands

Hello..
ahmed was talking with amal and he said " amal ask them if they want 2 vote for you but she said ''No im not gonna ask my friends 2 vote for me anna akheroj be karamti wa la atlob hada y sawet li

i'm extreemly shocked of AMEEEEL.!
She was my favourite ..but no longer
I totaaaaaaaaally agree with u RANIA
When eiman was nominee she alwayz gets 20 something . Dont say we didnt vote ,Egypt voted alot for amel. she got 40 Somethin .
Guys amel and shaza really changed alot ..
I hate ali as well .
Before yesterday when they were sittin gossipin behind sally n tina n mouhammed n carloz bk omg how rediclous this is..
Amel and sally and shaza were on z same room after sally finished crying cuz of emad . Sally was crying cuz she would be nominated next week amel told her no i would help u in ur eval . Yet, right after sallyy left she was like she will be nominated . She thoguht that sally and tina wont vote to her but here we go they did vote for her .. Even though sally should have voted for emad to be sure she will be on the tour if this happened . i mean if sally voted for emad they will be 4 gurlz 5 boys so the next week it has to be a boy who will go out . but it will be a gurl who should go out . Shaza on z hand ok her voice is perfect and awesome but her personality sux first she insulted sally then carlo and she gossips behind everbody's bk . Ali is suck a mentally retarted kid he was saying i cant do anythin b/c of mouhammed if he gets out i would be in the top omg how pathetic he is ..
Ahmed el sherif asked mouhammed to take his song and rola didnt accept it while when shaza got an offer she accepted it. Ahmed is such a kid as well now he loves amel . omg omg omg ..
ROla is playing her ST***D games so early this year ..
The academy is in two groups
Sally tina mouhammed carlo ===>1 ( My best group)
Amel ali marwa ahmed shaza ===>2 ( h88888 it )
i am denfendin the first group no matter what ..
the academy will be totaaaaaaally borin if u left sally ....
I want it labanese or Egyptian this year but it is immposible
cuz marwa will win

Ali=== i hate u so much now ... u r jealous cuz mouhammed is talented u should say i want to be like him not i want him to be out . really he is annoyin when sally won the audience last time he was like i am still higher than sally is this all what u care about u dun care if she is bk or not .
Ahmed=== he is becoming down he really loves amel but he doesnt want to show it to u he is afraid dunno of what ?! he is getting down he was ful of energy and power but it is coming down..
Mouhammed == he is the most talented guy i have ever seen . I love the strong friendshop between both of carlo and mouhammed it is amazin and he is real man . To most of u who didnt realise yesterday when they slept they all slept but mouhammed couldnt stop crying he was like i will miss u emad he misses emaad .. u r amazin mouhammed
Carlo== u r the star . u show ur real character i really love ur voice ur personality ur character every single thing in u u r amazin and u deserve to be the star cuz u r already a star.
Tina== the academy's baby . TINA ISNT FAAAAAAAKE she is real . If she talks in english it doesnt matter who cares shaza and amel alwayz talks in french so what ?! tina is the most talented gurl in the academy then sally . i love the friendship btw both of sally and tina as well they sounds funny together.
Sally=== if u will go out i will stop watchhin starac u are the life of the academy u creates life whenever u go . sally her voice is nice she sang nice with nawal el zoughby and amazin . sally is also talented
Marwa== i started likin her apart from the love triangle issue she might be the top1 next week she sang alot in this prime.
Shaza= strong voice zero personality loves gossipin loves that's all i can say about such a character .
Amel== she dissapointed me alot about what she said behind sally tina mouhammed bkzz i didnt really feel u will be like shaza someday
Emad i cant even imagine u r out .. WHAT HAPPEN TO TUNISIAAAAAAAAAAAA!! why didnt he gets the audience emadddddddddddddddd is out can u belive it omg i cant he was awesome . His voice is amazin best lookin guy real man it hurts he really desrved more than ahmed . Emad u r z star .
about the guests i loved nawal she is alwayz stunnin and her daughter is really cute . joseif atteya i still dont like that guy he gained more than 20kgzzz his face is tooo hairy .. he should care more about the way he looks more..
GOOO TINA MOUHAMMED SALLY TINA
GOOOOOOOO LEBANON
GOOOOOOOO EGYPT
GOOOOOOOO TUNISIA

It was really UNFAIR that Imed left, he is much better than Amal and Ahmed...he could be the star if he stayed..GHASARAA ye ness!
About Amal, she was very, very bad at the prime, omg what an awful voice and very cheap that she sang another lovesong for Ahmed...doesn't she get enough of it? the boy said 10000 times: " NO I don't love you Amal"...
Amal is irritating a lot of maroccan people I know here, because she has no respect at all...she openly talks about loving Ahmed, she dresses like a cheap girl..for example : today she wears a black short..very short and dances with it in the garden..omg..it was very embarissing...our family in the room said immediatly..: Haram , hel bent , ma 3andaha i7tiraam , no respect..turn on another chanel...pffff very cheap of you Amal..I hope you will be nominated next week..than you will sure go home....
Marwa..is the star, very good at the prime, mashallah, she wears respected clothes..and is a natural beauty...and she has a great voice!!!!

What the hell is with that shaza ? she really sucks talking about people in their absence , is she stupid or what ? doesn't she know that their is audience watching the crap she is doing.Amal also turned 2 have a weak unpleasant character, she is sticking to that snobby shaza convincing themselves that they r better than others and that they have good ethics regarding the others. I think the academy spoiled shaza and nothing stops her now ,she has the permission to do whatever she wants even insulting ,gossiping,...At the end even if she wins regarding her voice and the academy support,she will not be loved , she might fight with other singers in the real life with that personality , I hope from my heart that Ammah wins as besides talent he is not a trouble maker,he respects his fans and this what makes a person a star. Even if he doesnt win the title, he took a chance to show what he has and this the main point..

EVERYONE WHO VOTED FOR IMAD PLEASE VOTE FOR MARWA IF SHE IS EVER NOMINEE OR IF SHE GETS TO THE FINAL,plz dnt let her down!!make her a star because she looks like a star and deserves to be one.

IMAD - he's a winner in my eyes and im sure many agree,he had a nice personality and its so sweet of him to say thank you to everyone who voted at the end of prime.he will be another ahmed el sheriff!!

TUNISIA...i know its disappointing imad left and u voted well,the difference between him and amal was only 3% DESPITE SALLY SAYING IMED WON'T GET MANY VOTES!!
WAKE UP NOW,U HAVE ONE TUNISIEN LEFT AND U CANNOT LOSE HER!

Come on everyone, you seriously have to get MARWA to win.I don't care about shaza coz she has a bad personality and she will be a star with her gr8 voice even if she leaves now!

Marwa has the whole package - natural beauty,lovable personality,nice smile and the most UNIQUE VOICE LIKE IMAD SAID BEFORE HE WENT!!

Tina U NEED TO GO....U ARE CRAP!!she only cried yday for sympathy votes(if she is ever nominee) after admitting shes the weakest.

Mabrouk to AMAL but BOOO AHMAD U SUCK AT EVERYTHING!
Amal if u don't be careful about the way u act u will lose all 33% of the voters u got yesterday!

If ahmad is nominee next week,vote for the other people,AHMAD HAS GIVEN UP AND LIKE ALISSAR SAID "HIS EXPRESSION WHEN SINGING IS FAKE".

(If ahmad nominee with sally + ali, EGYPT + SAUDI + OTHER VOTERS GET VOTING FOR SALLY + ALI STRAIGHT AWAY,THEY CAN'T GO BEFORE THE CRAP AHMAD!)

What a disappointing prime, seriously.
Not only did the best, truest and GORGEOUS boy in the academy leave but AMAL & AHMED CAME BACK?!
Wtf is that.
I understand Amal's return because it was only her first nomination although I can't stand her fakeness but ahmed?!
Wtf do you people see in him?
Looks?
It's not gonna get him far.
His voiice is so ugly.
I can't even stand listening to him sing.
All he's got going for him are his arms, his looks, and the loev situation.
That's the only reason LBC is keeping him
so ahmed fans, dont think hes in there because hes talented.
Also, Shatha is getting way too much credit. I prefer Marwa's voice over Shatha's any day and although I dont like marwa, atleast shes not a backstabber and doesnt talk behind her friends backs like Tina&Sally. Wait no I lied, she talked behind Amal & Emad's back.
OH I guess we have an academy full of fakes and backstabbers. :)

To that Iemand or whatever;
what hapenned between Amal, Tina&Sally really did happen, go wtch friday's dailies.
Amal and Ali & The snake (Shatha) were sitting in the living room talking about whos gonna vote for Amal from the students and then Amal started saying oh theres no waay Tina&SAlly would vote for me because they're jealous of me because Im such a big threat. Like wtf who does she think she is? She's so conceited its irritating. She wishes she'd been in the top5 as much as Tina already has and her voice is so ugly. YIY. 7aram law 3enda talents kena 2olna fiha tshuf 7ala bas ma 3enda shi eim jissm alwa2. Honestly, at first I liked Amal and hated marwa because Amal kept crying and treid to make everyone feel srory for her/pity and try to show us that marwa's the bad one. Now, I've completely changed my opinion because Amal proved to be just as fake and disrespectful as Shatha. I guess to find out when someones fakee, nominate them. What else is she hiding from us? Haram she has like a double-personality. Khassam bel shakhsiyeh. And she seriously needs to stop chasing Ahmed around; 7aramm hes rejected her how many times now? 5838538. ''Amal, I love you as a sister. Amal, I cant give you the same feelings'' How many times have we heard those words? She still doesn't get it. 3anjad she reminds me of a dog chasing him around. Did you hear when shes like ''If I wasn't nominated with Ahmed, then the audience wouldve probably saved me but I'm with ahmed, he deserves to come back and so do i'' WTF EMAD IS BETTER THAN BOTH OF THEM SAFAR MIT SINEH! And she was so shocked when she was nominated, AHAHAHA. Did you see her face expression. She was probably thinking ''ME, AMAL THE GREATESSST, NOMINATED?! NOO WAYY'' YALLA INSHALLAH NEXT WEEK AGAIN NOMINEEE W HAL MARRA BAAARRRA. You amal/shatha fans are so blinded by their ''TALENTS''. Don't you see the way Shatha interacts with other students? She treats them as if she's the boss and whatever she says is always true and must happen. Snake bi 8538538heads. 3anjad her ugly personality's making me hate her voice.

Go Sally, Tina, Amma7&Carlo. =)
The only real people who don't backstab their frienndss.
Go lebanon&Egyptt.

plz waleg dont delet my comment coz i need to make something clearl for people:-

Y,Y i u lot like ths? its so easy to judge people, with bad thoughts, but never with good 1. y can no longer people see the good, 4rom the bad? y is it tht we only see th bad and wanna comment on it quickly, without even thnking abut it?

it's so easy 4 u lot to judge amal and shaza. and i hav realised somethng, tht marrocans, irqa, tunisia, algria and perhaps syria, thy r the ones tht get most of the bad comments.

whn u lot saw amal and shaza and ali talking it was only seen by the daily program, & u lot know better, tht the daily not everythng is shown clearly. amal has the right to thnk how she wants, she was in danager in going out and she said wat she felt. and shaza has the right to vote to amal as this program turned to nationalism. and u lot hating amal coz she came back coz imad left, u should realise that it was her foult tht thy chosen her.

wallah u lot dont know wat kinda trouble u lot r getting urselves in with letting ur tongue lose like that. its not good 4 u lot to talk abut people like that image if that was ur sisters or ur brothers in there u wont like people talking abut thm lik tht.

wat goes around comes around, so be careful. u might be saying all ths bad thngs abut amal, shaza and etc. but u lot might end up in same situation as thm

so plzz let god do the judging and u jst keep u good thoughts of people and if thy r bad keep it to urselves plzz ths is no joke

good luck imad and hopefully amal will stand on her feet now and work harder, coz she has gr8 talent.

to amal

ur comment is so powerful yet so true. its abut time ths people try to understand something.
y judge people, with bad thoughts?

haters r get more and more everyday. everytime its some1n's turn to be the victim of haters

- the week before last week (2 weeks ago) it was marwa......

- ........last week amal and tina.........

- ........and this week once again amal and shaza

wat the hell, get a live man. how can a person hate some much. i guess thy hav experience so much bad times in their live tht thy r ready to take it out on some1 who hasnt dan anythng to thm.

i guess this sunday amal and shaza should get ready for a bad time in the sms section. i feel so sorry for thm, my god be with thm inshallah

hahah.... o my god.. now your like it ore not imed is gone.. i realy loved him but its a game.. there are losers and winners. And in this is a game where only one will be the winner.. and its for sure that the teachers know who it will be.

stop fighting about a game.. and stop hating people you dont even know at person..

And Amal is great Tina will win or Mohammed...
No one from Maghreb, i dont get is but they dont like us.. (hahahahah)

So Staracademy maghreb it will be...

Maghrabia from the Netherlands..

i totally agree with amal
but rana plzz shut up amal is 100 times better than you dont be jelous and she didnt say that ..
man .. shaza and amal are best friends and dont talk about them like this whole crap you saying i think sally must be nominee next week cause she is so two faced like tina ..!!! its still my opinion so hate it or love it and shaza voted for amal cause they are best friends & shaza is 1/2 moroccan !!

to everyone
amal doesnt irritate me !!
only tina and sally irritating me so much i hate them they re really two faced
im a moroccan and everybody her loves her..
dont act jelous plzz people imed is now gone and so deal with it i wish him the best with everything but dont react it on amal she dont deserves it

Imad, my love left.......amal sucks.she is a disgrace to the moroccan people..when she sings i just switch the channel and the fakest person is the big doofus called -ahmed....he just leads girls on and lets them be....imad should of never left.

OMG thats not fair i dont like amal or ahmed and besides EMAD WAS THE BEST HIM AND MARWA AND MOHAMMED AND SHAZA... emad inta star and ur the best forget the rest ... star academy isnt fair at alll thats wat i think b3den emad deserves to stay amal has no voice what so ever her voice is soo squeky....and ahmed lets not talk about him he has the worst voice ever

warda
dont act as if ur very respected with ur family,
if it is rily u wudnt hav watch things on tv.coz nowdayz its how every arab wears,luk at haifa..........and so many mo.if u dnt like any1 then stop yo jealousy and talk about the ones u like.
by the way amal is a star in the eyes of many ppl ok!!!!!

to sabrina
amal isnt a disgrave for moroccan people plzz speak for your self ..! go amoula we are supporting you people can be so jelous i dont understand why..? maybe cause she s beautiful has a good looking and not 2 faced like tina & sally

Good luck

i mean disgrace

Thank you, Rana, I'm totally agree with you!!! I'm glad there are people like you who see the FAKEness of Amal..ieuwwwww she is very , cheap and irritating, always stuck on Ahmed like glue...well...the fakest people of whole the academy are: Amal and Shada...they are COBRA's..with 10000 faces...and much maroccan people I know hate Amal and Shada both, because of the fakeness and because of the unrespectfull clothes...
MARWA is the star, mashallah what a voice and what a natural appearance and great character..she is not fake!

To Bayan,

First of all, we have a very respectfull family..don't even go there ok!
Second of all we don't watch strippers so we don't watch Haifa...
Third of all...why would I be jealous of a crazy too dreamy, maroccan girl -amal-, who is 2 faced, has no respect, no voice, no looks, who puts 1 kilo makeup on her face???
And...don't forget..this is a maroccan site, so offcourse there are people who write good things about Amal...but I haven't see 1 good site of her..
So inshallah, she will be nominated next week..and fly back with air maroc..to the atlasmountains....

Marwa is the star anyway...

you Guyz..........

amal mentioned that there is someone who hates her in the academy i guess a girl...and that they looked happy when she was named a nomine..does anyone know who that is???

woooooooooow im so glad that ahmed won!! Ahmed your voice is so cool and perfect dont worry about those ppl they are just jealose that we one against them!!! i love you soooooo much

you Guyz..........

amal mentioned that there is someone who hates her in the academy i guess a girl...and that they looked happy when she was named a nomine..does anyone know who that is???

Of course Ahmad won.
He has a whole country with money and time to spare watching stupid programs like that.
Amal should have been eliminated.
What an annoying presence.
Marwa should slim her butts; she looks like an overweight teenager trying to pass as a loveable carachter and all over the khaligee american-wanabe.
Anyway, not easy to get rid of a Khaligi unless competing with another. So next time it's gonna be Ahmad, the Saudi guy (whát's his name?) and zomeone else.
The arabs are fighting around their contestants whom they are going to forget after a couple of days, while Rola is counting the money.
Go LBC, the best ripoff institution in the Middle East . LOL

hey you lebchris SHUT UP youve said enough we are not americian wanabees you are the ones you call america your mother if they tell you kill your self you will kill yourself if they say anything to u you will straight do it

the results of this prime were disgusting. i cant believe imad left, im still in shock. ahmad shudv been out. imad was the best of the 3 in both talent and personality. i love u imad, i'll miss u sooooo much :( ur a true star! the academy's quite dry without him. Mohammad and Shaza i have hope in u 2, keep it up!

guys ,
plz calm down ,take some time b4 responding 2 any comment nomatter how irritating and provoking it is otherwise it will turn into a war zone over a game that will b over in 5 weeks!!!!!! any one watched the dailies today?i think it would explain alot of the hush hush talks that took place yesterday[4 those watching the 24/7]i think after wut was said we can all c who's arrogant ,who's pretending and who is really decent and was misunderstood by most of u folks....i understand it may come as a surprise 2 amal and shatha lovers

warda just shut up ..!!
are you a khalijee or tunisian cause i know they hate moroccan people a lot stop being jelous of amal she is just 2 perfect and much better than marwa ...thank god she is not a pig like her ..just stop acting like this and she really has respect 4 everybody .. but marwa isnt a star hel no!! if amal goes out i will support SHAZA cause she is the one with a beautiful voice and she has it all ..!! i hope she will be nominated next week inshallah

Miss Miracle,
I missed the dailies :( What happened?
- I bet it was a good one.

omg did you guys see sally on the dailies
she was really mad at amal but thats the whole fact that i dont understand so sally if you dont like amal no more wy did you voted for fer come on why ... ?? sally was first really amazing i loved her so much but now i really hate her ..!!
why did she talked behinds amals back .. ??? why sally .. !! i really dont like her anyomore and she must go out because if she is gonna stay then it wont be that sweet sally anymore
by the way the prime was so boring i dont like staracademy extually i hope their wont be staracademy 5 i really hope so

Congratulations to all for making it to the top. They all have nice voices and deserve it. I would have loved to see Marwa up there.
She was great at the prime. Maybe she will be in somewhere in the Top 3 next week, personally I would put her No. 1 :)

Miss Miracle,
I agree with what you said (well,… almost). I have to admit, I really do enjoy reading your comments. I don't always agree with you, but there have been times where you manage to steal the words out of my mouth. Nice work :)

I couldn't believe what Amel was saying! I think it's really rude and stupid of her to talk about who will vote for her and who won't. Really why wonder, doubt and question what is going on around you. You never know what will happen next. But, the time that you spend in there should be a time where you can look back and say that was the best time of your life and that you enjoyed every second of it. Enjoy the company of others that are under the same roof as you. Make the most of it. Opportunities like that don’t come around very often.
Why waste a few minutes by speaking about that?!
Does she really not appreciate anything, not even the people around her?
Incredibly rude. I was really shocked by that attitude.
In my opinion, the high-spirit, respect, lust for life and energy that was in Ayoub, was why he won the hearts of many. But, Amel doesn’t have that spirit but, she has won the hearts of many too. And it’s not by her singing, but by her involvement in the ridiculous story of the love-triangle. Her name was everywhere, everyone knew who she was. It was the drama that captured the attention of many and got the media buzzing about what is going on.

I don't understand why she doesn't think Tina and Sally are true friends of her. She doubts their loyalty and friendship. She doesn't mind talking so openly and rudely behind their backs. Very rude, that is a side that I don't see very much from her. She spoke as if they would want to get rid of her because of she is a "tough competition" and a threat to them - what is she talking about?!
Does she really think she is all that?!
Fair enough if her voice was that of the same level as Shaza’s or Marwa’s, to sum it up in one word, amazing. But it isn‘t!
I never really like her singing voice, but I did like her personality until that moment.

But that wasn't the only shock this week - Shaza and Carlo.
I tried to imagine what it would be like being in Shaza’s shoes; really upset and a little angry at the same time; and there is another person in the same room as you who is failing to understand you. (S)He is not trying to be there for you, but against you by rubbing the issue in to your face. Simply makes the matter worse. Now, that is the last thing one would want. I would hit the roof. Wouldn’t you?
I certainly would not go as far as she did though.

Shaza has developed her reputation for having an amazing singing voice. She has also developed another reputation for having a bad attitude. It’s a known fact that Shaza has a very short temper. It’s so easy for her to hit the roof. When things don’t go the way she wants it to, it’s like pressing the big red button and suffer the consequence. She is very demanding and diva-like.
She always crosses the line and insults others around her. I would like to think that she does not mean everything that she says. I think that if one gets really annoyed and angry about something they end up saying things they really don’t mean.

This whole heated drama could have been avoided if Carlo didn’t get involved. I mean, look at Mohammed he simply walked away. I’m not saying that was the right thing to do but he avoided getting involved. I can see what Carlo was trying to do, tell her the truth. But he should have be been careful of how he approached her because like I said earlier, Shaza has a reputation for being short-tempered. He could have tried to calm her down first before telling her and make her understand. If that didn’t work, then he could have simply walked out like Mohammed.

To be completely honest, I don't think it's a matter of age gap. You can get on perfectly well with anyone if you simply click with them, understand them and appreciate them.
Unfortunately, the relationship between the two is nothing of such.

I think both of them were wrong.
Shaza lost her temper really easily and Carlo was making things worse.

Imad :( :( :( you are the best!
Shatha I hate you!I hate you! I hate you! You are the biggest snake on this earth! OUT OUT OUT!!
SHATHA NOT TINA IS A FAKE YOU ARE A FAKE!!!
GO OUT OUT OUT!

guys,
i hope u get wut i ve said coz what i saw in the dailies today,i don't know about u, proves atleast 2 myself that i was right when i got disappointed in amal and wasn't being unfair 2 her coz this time sally told 3emad y she would vote 4 amal coz she thought he would get all the guys votes + marwa so he would win anyway but it would b really painful 2 amal if they don't vote 4 her and she gets out with only 2 votes!!!she felt 4 her and she asked 3emad not 2 b upset with her and 3emad took it like a gentleman who didn't expect wut 3ali did!!!!! then next in the presence of one of amal's best freinds lately so that no one would accuse her of talking behind amal's back which she didn't coz she said that she is used 2 to the TENDER amal and was surprised of the gr8 change in the way of speaking and dealing with her that was almost descending and humiliating in every look and word which the 3 of them [sally,tina,marwa]tried 2 refer it 2 being upset about the nomination .
my personal opinion is[u may agree or disagree] sally and tina again proved amal wrong and it wasn't 3emad who told them 2 vote 4 amal,they did it coz they felt 4 her and that they r not jealous of her and not being hypocrites with her!!!! in case u havent noticed in the dailies when sally,marwa,tina were talking they weren't wearing their mics as they were getting ready 2 get on stage so 4 u who would start saying it was all an act infront of the camiras ...they had no mics and it was almost time 2 get on stage so they knew they weren't live esp that they werenot wearing their mics atleast sally wasn't[ i m sure of it]where as we know once the student takes his/her mic the camera goes 2 another student untill he/she wears his/her mic......
i ve just posted my opinion in a civilized way i know some of u won't like it and even attak it i just expect from such civilized ppl as u 2 post ur response in a respectful and civilized way.
thnx 4 reading my comment

i hate star academy from now on i think the best program is future super `star thats the best programme ever with real stars and not fake as mm roula's show !!

i really agree with you miss miracle
but sally she must tell it 2 her in front of her face (amal) and not behind her.. right?
cause sally was really nice 2 everyone but now she s not and if she was my friend i would never speak 2 her .. cause she must say it in her face

to cassie,
sally was upset with amal coz of the change in behaviour lately esp. after the nomination but the things that made sally upset..well,she said everything in the presence of marwa ,amal's best freind lately who didn't contradicted it but tried 2 refer it 2 amal being upset with the nomination but i have 2 agree with sally [don't forget that marwa didn't deny it]those words that amal said hurt and she shouldn't have said them ,she'snot the first one 2 get nominated... but at the end sally made her choice by picking amal after telling 3emad not 2 b upset with her when she does that[that was on the dailies 2]coz she felt 4 her and that she thought it's not fair even if there's gr8 chance u would leave 2 get out with only 2 votes it will look like that u weren't loved by ur freinds ,she didn't want amal 2 feel like that ...so u c cassie ..sally wasn't backstabbing amal ,if u 've read my previous comment then u'd know that she was upset with the change she noticed[and not only her]and that she loves about amal being so tender...but y that major change that hurts her?!!
thnx 4 reading my comment ,i hope u got my point
i ll b waiting 4 ur civilized and respectful response
thnx

to sofia ,
sally said those words in the presence of amal's freind marwa who didn't deny any of sally's words so if she wants 2 speak behind her back she wouldn't say it infront of marwa .u c some of the comments i read from ppl on this forum states that sally and tina r forming a side and talking with each other about the others but if sally is talking infront of the "others" especially if it's one of amal freinds then it's not really talking behind her back + she didn't insult amal on the contrary she's upset that the amal she loves is changing unlike wut amal said who 2 me personally sounded like that she already set her mind on a conclusion that they won't vote 4 her coz they think it's in their best benefit 4 her 2 go away...she was thinking and talking and a different way from sally who wasn't trying 2 talk behind her back[that's my opinion] coz she didn't wait 4 amal's freind 2 leave ..she said it infront of her.....and amal's freind didn't deny it...
thnx 4 reading my comment

sorry but i forgot 2 say something ,some 1 said that tina n sally smiled when the third name was mentioned[amal] ...i m guessing they smiled coz sally was afraid she'd become nominee so she made it... i m saying that coz 3ali also smiled and was releived and so was carlo.....simply they were happy cozthey weren't nominee ...wouldn't u ?it doesn't mean that they were happy that amal in particular was nominated otherwise y can't u say the same thing about 3ali and carlo....just coz u don't love the person u don't have 2 expect the worst untill a fact is established either by words or actions....
thnx 4 reading my comment

To miss miracle !
you are totally right and i understand it
but everyone is talking so bad about amal and maybe amal was really totally confused what she said ( because she was nominee and didnt know what 2 do i really adore that girl she has really a great character and i hate it when i see that whole crap about amal ..!! she really dont deserve it so miss miracle i hope you know why i said those stuff
and im also thanking you for reading my comment
and my opinion

well, I have been reading comments since the time of the prime and i intended to write one earlier but in all honesty Emad's departure just put me off everything.

In my opinion, worst prime and worst nomination results ever. The one person i really wanted to stay was the one to leave and the one person i really wanted to go won the audience vote. I was impartial to Amal as long as Emad would be the one to stay. God, this really sucks.
Out of the nominees Imad seemed to be taking this experience the most dilegently and was really benefitting alot and improving alot.His voice is much better to listen to than ahmed (who in my opinion has no tone what so ever and his facial expressions seriously freak me out when he is singing) and even Amal who has good potential but can't even show them because she is forever crying or whinning or just being weak.

I know this is a talent show and we're supposed to jusdge them only on voice and performance. But they don't put the 24/7 channel on if that was really the reason. They want us to see what their personalities are like. I have to say that this week has really shocked me in the terms of personalities. Shaza...her anger management and total two-faced-ness with most who surround her. She insults others...talks badly behind their backs...so dominating in an irritating way. And even Amal, who i used to like alot, talking behind people's back and being nice in their face. What the hell is going on. I know it's human to make mistakes but when it just keeps happening and happening and happening.....it's not mistakes. It's part of the personality. How many times did Amal talk badly about Sally and Tina in the past week when they did nothing to her. Sally asked for her numberin case anything happens cuz u never know. Imad asked Sally for a souvenir in case one of them leaves and she didn't take it badly. Mohamad told Sally if you leave stay in lebanon untill the show ends and she didn't take it badly either.

I can honestly say that Imad's departure is a turning point in the academy. Now they are split in 2 groups
Amma7 - Sally - Tina - Carlo
Amal - Shaza - Marwa - Ahmed - Ali
tension is tremendously increasing and no one is comfortable around each other anymore. Sally and Tina even said to each other that they don't feel like staying anymore.

In conclusion, I should say that Imad left and he is the star n my eyes and i can tell he is already a star in so many others' eyes. Just wait a year and you will see him on TV again acting or sinsing. He's got the star personality, charisma, attitude. Mashallah, he is the only guy in the academy that really made feel like he was a true Arab "rajel" with his responsibility and never talking behind others' backs ..even when he was nominee with anyone he made it easy on them and it's obvious in how much amal became close to him during the nomination. He always gave others' advice regardless of the fact that they were competting against him and he frankly stated who deserved to be the star even if it wasn't himself.
I think now he realized who are his true friends. Tina, Sally, Amma7, Carlo who climbed on the fence to say goodbye and they reassured him they will call him many times to see how he is doing.
at least he came out of the academy with the love of many fans and 4 true friends.

P.S: it is obvious Sally and Tina voted for Amal because he asked them to plus he kept gesturing with his head towards amal when they had to say their vote. And not to forget shaza's irritating repeation of "vote for Amal..vote for Amal" for the whole day before the prime. However, i do think they regretted their decision in the end. It's obvious if u watch the 24/7 channel.

I can see where youre all coming from. And come on lets all stop pretending were perfect and admit we all have good days and bad days, days where were nice and days when were completely unbearable. I think both carlo and shaza fit into this category. They were both to blame for the fight they had, and it was carlo who started the fight and carlo who swore first. bas 3ayb al shoom 3ala shaza for biting back when she should know better.
next week nomination will be ahmad sally and ali

Guys seriously ur allowed to have ur own opinions but lets not lie to ourselves.
Shatha has not backstabbed or said anything against tina or sally. SHE HAS SAID NOTHING ABOUT THEM. it was amal who behaved in this way because she thought they wudnt vote for her.
TOMORO sms night is gonna be explosive

rana thats not True AMAL didnt say to sally and tina to vote for her .. do you remember when ahmed said 2 amal ask your friends 2 vote for you and she said no im not gonna ask my friends 2 vote for me and if you dont believe me look at the dailies

look, amal wasn't gossiping, and she said that she saw joy in the eyes of some people when she was nominated, and i heard sally was talking about her, and not vice versa! the dailies don't show us everything, haven't u all noticed that they only show us the bad things and this, what how do u call it- the 2 groups??? c'mon ppl, and all the people who're talking bad about amal, plz act normal she's a sweet girl and she's not fake, yess she cries a lot, but is that forbidden? u can always find something to talk about amal! and i think amal and sally still are friends and as for the voting: everyone votes on whom they want, don't be mad at someone for not voting on ur favourite student... we all know amal is the next one to leave but at least she's going out at the 12th prime so that's a whole prestation.
ps: is it me or is marwa's voice not as good as before? has anyone ever noticed?
anyway good luck to you emad, im still convinced it wasn't ur turn to leave, but ahmeds :'-(

i cant believe imad left...imed didnt even deserve nomination...come on do u really think sally, carlo, tina, and ali are better then him...no way...imad had potential to be a star...lbc are cheaters....on waleg imad had the most votes...ahmed barely broke a hundred voters...he has NO fans...imad was adored by everyone...great looks, amazing voice and excellent charisma...i voted for him like 75 times..he won the public votes but lbc change it...walla7..imad knew that lbc are cheaters and he left with pride...i love imad o much and hope he will be a star like he deserves to be
imad inta 7ayati

guys save your money and stop voting....lbc are cheaters and they will award the title of the star to whoever they please...lbc needs to be taught a lesson and no one should vote...lets see if the khallegi will pay for their show...no they wont..maybe then they wont cheat anymore
lbc u drove away an amazing person and a true star- imad

By the way: Did you know that Amal was on the castings for Staracademy Maghreb, and that they didn't want her there! hahaha..she was too bad..it's a shame that LBC putted her in the academy.
I hope Amal will be nominated this week..she is nothing worth, she only stick to Ahmed the whole day in her short skirts...tfoeee...no respect, no voice, no character but 2 faces!!!!
Shada is the big snake in the house and Amal is her assistant..
And please people, don't think every maroccan likes Amal...that's not true..A lot like Marwa and Imed...In fact, Imad was the star...but now he is gone, Marwa will be the one...
Next week we'll say bye bye Amal...you don't respect your country..with your clothes, your openly love for Ahmed and never talks your own language always talks egyptian...very FAKE