well i really dont care becuase shada is getting everything she wants and i HATE HER SOOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i wish that mohammad wins hes the best congats for the top 2 and also to carlo and shaza

HAte her as much as y want, but one thing s clear

Shathaaaa is the STAR!!!

y deserve it girl, we re proud of you!!!!

good for shaza ...she deserved it ...& congrats to moh'd & carlo...

yees wallaa i knew it shadaa is soo beautiful and all nice things -

she is the star you will see ;)

irakiess are all soo proud of you wish you all the best in your future..

GOO SHADAA

Shatha is getting everything she wants because she truly deserves it! go shatha inshallah ur always top 1. and hopefully marwa gets in the top next week she was fantastic in this prime!

Wallah Shatha, you are the best singer out of the girls by far and you definately deserve the top spot. Your voice is beautiful.
Mohammad will win next week hopefully because he is a brilliant singer!
I don't know why Carlo was third though...I think Marwa deserved to be third.

* * * CONGRATULATIONS SHATHA !!!!!
-You deserve it (big time),You did great as usual, Marwa too deserve to be one of the Top-3 . . Insha-Alah next prime (with Shatha) :) Enjoy your mom Marwa :)
- God Luck ya Imad . . . keep working on your talents & we'll see you again . . Insha-Alah.

Peace,

Hi everyone,

Yes! Shaza deserves to be on top1. She got the great voice and the look. She should be on the list of the top every time since she has the greatest voice ever! Go Shaza you are a star!

Good Luck Imad you have a good voice so work hard and you are a star.

Rosi, Canada

Congrats Shatha
for being twofaced and before you try to become a star, go learn what being polite is and what respecting people is bcz it takes you a longg way.
:)

Amira,
oh i hate her so muchh!
I can't stand her.
She starts fights with everyone and is way too CONCEITED thinking that her voice is the best and that she's the ''shit''
wallah shesn othing but shit.
I hated her even more today
after I saw her talking about her ''friends'' Tina&Sally!
WAllah I wanna send a sms to tina & sally telling them you shouldnt have voted for Amal because she was talking behind your backs.
I HATE HERRR & SHATHA SO MUCH.

shatha you proved to be the fake one and not tina :D congratulatioons !
i love you tina
amma7
sally
and carlooo !

tatou you should totally send sms and tell tina and sally because people werent embarresed sending sms to tina telling her fake please ill try to do it amnd you should do it too and everybody else should do it so they can know her on her reality she and amal because in my opinion tina and saly are the best frineds in the academy they dont talk behind eachother im gonna try to send the sms

TINA STAR MAHMA SAR

ok seriously tatou get ur facts straight before you say anything bc amal did not talk about tina and sally behind their backs, all she said was that they would never vote for her bc she thinks that it would be in their favor if she got out (and thats true bc their voices suck especially tina in arabic) and also bc they would pick a guy over her and they would have if emad didnt tell them to vote for amal to give her another chance and she DEF deserved one...i mean come on, you would want another chance if you were in her place....GoOoOoO Amal!!!

to jameela 726,
u sound like u ve seen the dailies if u did then u would have seen how she was talking about sally and tima implying that they r hypocrites and were happy that she got nominated that's y they won't choose her coz she's considered a threat 2 them and then shatha gave a lecture about hypocracy and how much she hates it,how ironic is that?!!!!but sally and tina chose amal and made the right choice and btw she also said that she expects them not 2 choose her even if 3emad told them not 2 vote 4 him, so she was already setting her mind on a certain conclusion that sally and tina r hypocrites and not true freinds!!!!!but not only that, yesterday after the prime, sally was crying coz she's scared she would b nominee this week amal held her and told her that she would help her but the moment sally went out of the room she told shatha that sally will b nominated this week!!!!!!
if that is not talking behind ppl backs and hypocracy i don't know what is!!!!
i regret voting 4 amal as 4 shatha ,i ll never vote 4 her ,i hope sally is not nominee this week coz the show will b really bbbooooorrrrrrrrrrriiiiinnnnnggg!!!!!

Congratulations to the Top 3. I think Marwa should be #1 next week - her performances in this week's Prime were great! She just keeps getting better and better. She looked and sounded beautiful!

Mabrook Shaza, you are the best!! you have a greatest voice! Go Shaza you are the star! you have it all girl.

Good luck Imad and thank god Amal is back.

Nadia

okk even though i dnt like shaza that much bas i like her voice....she kinda deserves it ....bas this week i wuz w8ing 2 hear marwa being top 1 cuz she sang sooo gdddd last primeee n she looked gd:P ND I WNNA KILL MYSELFFF AMAL STAYEDDD!! THIS IS SOOO UNFAIR!!! IMADDDD WENT OUTTT ND IMAD STAYED WTF?!!? GOGOGO TINAAAA N MARWAAAA THEY RLY ROCK!!

oops i ment amal**

can anyone tell me the sms number and how to send from the USA? i Wanna send one thanx hope i get a response

yes amal stayed and im so happy 4 her
cause she really deserves it more then IMED AND AHMED but i know people can be so jelous of someone ..
and i really hate carlo so much cause he really didnt deserve 2 be on the top 3 ( my opinion)
and tina was very awful i dont like her anymore !
but shaza has the best voice in the academy !!
So good luck 2 AMAL and SHAZA

Was amal talking behinds sally en tina's back?
cause if its true what did she say extually?

Its interesting to hear everyones perspective on Star Academy. Maybe im in the minoirty but i like everyone, and i dont have hate for anyone. Sure i like people more than some, but why is there a need to make fun and be rude about other contestants. GUYS THIS IS ONLY TV, take a time out.
About the whole Shatha Amal thing, i watched alot of star academy this week and i think i can come up with a reasonable analysis. Amal was really upset this week cos wen her name was called up as a nominee tina and sally smiled. Come on how would tht make u feel? also this week tina sally ammah n carlo spent more time together as a group and hardly spoke to any1 else, if u guys watched 24/7 yesterday Tina even admitted it to shatha. So amal really thought they wudnt vote for her. and btw the only reason they voted for amal instead of imad was because imad asked them too.
And so amal had a right to say tht she didnt think they wud vote for her, because they gave her good enuf reason too. And dont try and twist shathas words mister. Ali was saying how he doesnt like to make problems with people, and shatha said they one thing i dont like is being a hypocrite, if i dont like something or someone has done something to upset me ill tell them so tht the air is cleared.
U guys shouldve seen hwo shatha comforted tina yday wen she was so upset, and the nice things she said to tina

Shatha is a snake....she is rude,she fights with everyone ...i hate her.
A star needs a nice voice and manners...she lacks manners...

She was talking with amal a day bfore the prime about the votes...she spoke about sally and all the others and who they will vote for in a really bad way...shame on her...like a 10 year old not 25.
i hope she is out soon.

It was really UNFAIR that Imed left, he is much better than Amal and Ahmed...he could be the star if he stayed..GHASARAA ye ness!
About Amal, she was very, very bad at the prime, omg what an awful voice and very cheap that she sang another lovesong for Ahmed...doesn't she get enough of it? the boy said 10000 times: " NO I don't love you Amal"...
Amal is irritating a lot of maroccan people I know here, because she has no respect at all...she openly talks about loving Ahmed, she dresses like a cheap girl..for example : today she wears a black short..very short and dances with it in the garden..omg..it was very embarissing...our family in the room said immediatly..: Haram , hel bent , ma 3andaha i7tiraam , no respect..turn on another chanel...pffff very cheap of you Amal..I hope you will be nominated next week..than you will sure go home....
Marwa..is the star, very good at the prime, mashallah, she wears respected clothes..and is a natural beauty...and she has a great voice!!!! Next week top 1 inshallah!

i think shaza is the most shrewd person out there. When she votes she eliminates the sudent she thinks will be competition to her. Dany, Ayoub now Imad , Ali too by eliminating Imad he become top 4 from the guys last time he voted for Azuze instead of Ayoub. guys i hate them so much. sally could easily have voted for Imad and become one of the top 4 girls but anyways
i loved ayboub so much he is so pure and also kammah and the winner now should be Merwa.

Yeaaaahh ,,
im so happy 4 her she deserves it more than everyone in the academy you are my star
extually you and AMAL

To warda
amal doesnt irritate me !!
im a moroccan and everybody her loves her..
dont act jelous plzz people imed is now gone and so deal with it i wish him the best with everything but dont react it on amal she dont deserves it

Hey (iemand) i agree with you and dont agree. We Khaleeges dont hate morroccan ppl?? just because you know 2, or 3 ppl who hate morroccan dossent make us ALL hate them. acctually amel was the second best girl from me list i love her soo much and i know soo many ppl who loves amal,sofia and many other morroccan ppl so just dont make anymore rumors we had enough when they said that 38% amal
&37% ahmed thats all a rumor ok we dont want any RUMORS please ppl STOP MAKIN RUMORS!!!

I'm fed up, i wanna talk and just express wt i feel:
Amal should Leave, she is a snake, she is a monster, she is a jerk, i hate her, i hate her, i hate her, after wt i saw on the dailies and how she treat sally and how she is showing off bla bla, i hate her, she should've gone out this prime, imad is a way better than her, she is the most annoying girl in the academy, oh pls, they come hear to learn not to marry from now, she has no self respect, Marwa is the best. Sally is soo nice and funny, tina is gr8, shaza is fine, but amal is the worst girl in starac.4, tina and sally voted for her just becoz she's pathetic, the gossip girl, the rumor spreading girl, i hope she is out, amal out, amal out. And for the snake (amal)'s fans, i dont care if u respext my comment or not and i mean wt i am saying.

Amal out soon
Marwa Star

Shadi, Lebanon

guys,
plz calm down and take sometime b4 responding 2 any comment nomatter how irritating or provoking it is otherwise it will turn into a war zone over a game that will b over in 5 weeks!!!!!!!
if any one watched the dailies today he/she would understand most of the hush hush talks that took place yesterday[4 those watching the 24/7] i think it would give u an idea about who's arrogant,who's pretending and who's really decent and was misunderstood by most of u folks...i understand it may come as a surprise 2 amal and shatha lovers and esp. amal's........but a gr8 voice isnpt enough 4 me 2 buy a singer's CD or watch a movie i must love the person,that's me.i don't know about u but every one has his/her own opinion so plz if u want 2 respond 2 my comment i expect it 2 b in a civilized way coz afterall we r all civilized ppl.
thx 4 reading my comment

to mubarak
im happy to hear that thnx that you react
and its true what you said it was stupid from me to think like this but their are people who hates us but not everyone and yeah sofia was Super i also love her so much and especially hanaa she was really awsome
thnx for your comment

yes amal was talking about tina and sally i saw it and she said in arabic but i'll say it in english"wen i was nominated i saw people who was very happy that i was nominated and she was saying about (tina nd sally) and she showed it soo much and she said to sally u should thank god ya3ni bcoz she wasnt nominated
she is soo rude amal and i dnt like her anymore i used to like her but i hate her now for sure for wat she has done and said and she cant love ahmed by force and she has a bad atitude too !!

hey the tops was really good congratualation shatha carlo and mohammad carlo and mohammad keelp going ur have the best voice ever and mohammad i want to tell u keep going and make new songs and if u will be a winner of star academy i will be the first person who will make a party

hey everyone i am sorry for saying this i was totally convinced that shada deserves to win even though i would love mohamed to win cause he is from my country but as i was saying this was the past after shada proved to be a two faced freak i now hate her more than i loved her and i will pray everyday that she won't win i hate her so much and amal too ofcourse cause they proved how back stabbers they could be ,talking in a bad way behind sally & tina's back that is so impolite and now i realy regret that i voted for that ***** amal and i really want her out .....
have anyone seen yesterday's and today's yawmeyaat you would know exactly what i am talking about .
it's not only about voice but it's also THAT they have to be a star ,a star which means polite and decent and can represent their countries and these two girls they proved that they are not star material ........

thanks for reading i would love to see ur opinion

AMIRA FROM EGYPT

To iemand,
we don't hate morrocans.
I LOVED SOFIA MAREEKH SOO MUCH.
Bas Amal,
I hate her more than anything.
I despise her, seriously.
Shes so fake and ugly and a backstabber.
She fooled us at first
but from the comments Ive been reading,
people are starting to see the REAL AMAL which happens to be a backstabbing liar and definelty not a true friend.
Getting close to Ali so the khaleej can vote for her, thnking shes so amazing and she should sing with Nawal instead of Tina&Sally.
You can fool a person sometime
but you cant fool everyone all the time.
Bayanet 3ala 7a2ee2ta.

Go Tina, Sally, Amma7&Carlooo !

You guys are so pathetics, yesterday before the prime you were all with amal she is the best and so... and today after the prime everybody hates her, because she is saying so loud what is true. does sally and tina needed to go all over the place to know who they can vote for. imad now becomes their best friend, come be realistic, this is a competition, everyone of them will change their mind every second in order to protect themselfs, there is no friendship in a competition, you don't know that. amal is trying to save herself but i think in my opinion she is more direct more than anybody else, i am not saying she is the best because sheis not, she does have her style and it is certainly better than sally and different from tina. they are all stressed because they are reaching the end, it is hard, be constructive don't look at their personality you have to see their talent and this is why they are there for. now it is true sometimes it is unfair to see imad and amal nominees but that is their decisions,
for me the most talented one who really deserve to win despite her personality is shada, you have to say that her voice is incredible, this is the best voice of all star academy. one person who can sing in so many languages with same tone of voice, i am sorry i don't know a lot of people who can do it even Biance or cristina aguilera.
my opinion amah and shada will be the finalist.

wALEG DO U KNOW HOW TO SEND AN SMS TO THE SHOW FROM USA THX

Dina, I respect your opinion but I just wanted to comment saying that if it was true and that the game is based on talents and not personality then they wouldnt trap the students in a house for 4months with 62cameras surrounding them. They obviously want us to get to know their personalities because a star isnt all about talent. Look at haifa, her voice is pretty weak but her personality is so lovely and bubbly and thanks to that, a lot of people like her!
A star needs to respect herself so others can respect her and not throw temper tantrum whenever she feels like it.

I respect everyone who say that amal is a backstabber, i hate her now, i hate people who wants everything to themeselves, eg.Amal:
1_She needs Ahmad
2_She needs Votes
3_She needs to be the star
4_She needs Marwa out
5_She needs to humiliate others
6_She needs to throw all the girl out

Well Babe u will be the first girl out hopefully.
The finalists will be
Marwa
Shaza
and a guy (carlo or mohammad but i want CArlo)

but marwa will win becoz she will have the gulf + tunsia+ morocco + algeria + some lebanese like me and my skool frnds...voting for her...

Marwa star
Amal out

Shadi, Lebanon