true how tina is top 1?
again?

Hi everyone,

I can’t believe it “Tina won Top 1????????? Why and for what performance????? Please don’t get me wrong I am not against her but to be honest Shaza, Marwa, Imad, Mohammad or Carol should get top 1 not Tina. Those 5 students have the best voice in this season!! And their voices way better than Tina!!

Last prime Shaza rocked!..Imad performance with Ahmad Elsherif was amazing, Marwa was so good in Alkudes..Carol was very good!!! I just don’t know why do they discriminate between students…Every year they have one special and distinguish students and this year their special student is Tina but whatever they do to her she won’t get the title of star academy!! The audiences know who deserves this title and Tina is way far from this title even if she gets top 1 from now to the rest of this season ..she won’t!!

I can say more but we all know that life is unfair!

Rosi, Canada

I agree with you, Rosi! Tina is the favorite. And for what? Her voice isn't better than Marwa, Shaza, or Amal. I don't get it.

congratulations 2 salli and imad, ayoob ... good luck! (tina didnt really deserve top1 by the way!)

Tina deserves to be top 1!!! wohooo go tina!! she had to do the evaluation in a short time and i think she did a very good job... congragulations tina...

Wohooo yay sally and imad are back....yaya

go ama7, carlo, imad, sally, tina, and ahmad

omg. seriously whats wrong with them? firstly she wasnt in the academy 4 so long, secondly her eval wasnt all that, thirdly she generally doesnt deserve it more than marwa, shaza, amal and mohammad. lol plus why are they makin such a big deal of her performance with chris de burgh? i got so bored when they sang it i changed the channel. i dont have anything against her, i like her shes sweet and talented and all, but theres definitly much more deserving students! oh well, lifes unfair.

of course she deserves it
did u guys not see her evaluation??
are u blind? she did the best evaluation!!!

hi
to every 1 who voted 4 sally...........THANX
the egyptians promised amal lovers who really stood by us this week....and we will deliver that promise whenever she needs it...we r ppl of our words as 4 the 7'alijy ppl apart from DUVIAN UAE who really stood by us .u sold us out this week and actually stabbed us in the back so all i ll say...................thank god who stood by us but i m so sorry no matter how much i love a7med i won't vote 4 him
welcome back 3emad and sally!!!!!!

it's very unfair??i don't get it...i feel like tina is the star while she didn't do anything to deserve top 1!!!so what go and do with chris de bourgh a song but it wont be such a success.

u r welcome miss miracle. Egypt is an arab country just like UAE and it has a special place in our hearts. And besides as I said and keep saying Sally is improving alot and without her the academy is no good. I have 2 be fair Ayoub sucked in the eval and sally was way more creative.
GOOO GOOO SALLY. Congrats EGYPT and TUNISIA and hard luck 2 OMAN

This week's top 1 changed my mind about top1. Madam Rula proved that you can be out of the academy and then become top1. So it won't be surprising if we see Maissoun, Nelly and Khaled as next week's top3 !!!!!
I like Tina. She's very talented but I think it's too much for her. At least she didn't do anything special during last week . Even she wasn't that great in last week's prime.
BTW mabrouk Tina and good luck

Emad we want u soon in the top 3 ... coz ur the best go emad GOD with u INSHA2LLAH ur starac 4

Hello miss mircale:
I think that we Khaleejes didnt stabb you in the back because our son Ayoub was in danger so we had to vote for him..We cannot let him go without voting for him..See you voted for Sally we didnt tell you why didnt you vote for ayoub ..we didnt tell u "u stabbed us".Its a game..We suppourt first the people that are from us from the khaleej and then the outside of khaleej... By the way why didnt u vote for ayoub I think u stabbed us.. u voted for sally because shes from your country ..u couldnt betray ur country and vote for ayoub right..Thats the way we did.. We voted for ayoub one of us khaleeji..So please a request for you to think before talk..You should think about our situation in the same way..No offense..
Thank u,
Hope you get my point
P.s
Marwa deserves to win top 1.. Go marwa go ahmad go imad go ali:D:D

thnx to all the ppl who voted 4 sally.
egyptians never forget thier girl.
and a very big THANXXXXX to amal's fans who stood beside us this week and we promise to support amal whenever she needed our votes

and about the top3 i think marwa and 2amma7 deserved it,but tina?? i dont think soo!!!
i believe it would have been better if they put carlo or amal.

im starting really to like carlo,though i hated him at the begining,i think he became less rude,more friendly and somehow funny.

go egypt
go tunisia

**el_pharoah from egypt**

i dont understand how tina could be top 1, when last week she was barely in the academy.
i think shada or amal deserved the top spot this week.

congratulation imad and sally all moroccans loves them hard luck ayoub i just wanna say that staracademy gharb hada mo chark awssat aktar aghani primes aghani gharyba wala mara chofna chi tableau maghribi anyway good luck for all candidates especially imad amal marwa and chada

can i ask a question...what is so great about ahamd? can someone please tell me. i dont see how the girls can 'love' him. to me he seems quite arrogant and a bit superficial. anyone?

GOOOO TINAA!! AND SHUT IT EVRY 1 HU DUZNT LIKE TINA!! THe judges take her top 1 becuz in the previous prime she did wonderful especially with that chris de burg singer nd her voice veryy nice in the last prime with the valentiness its sweet i hope AMAL AND SALLY get the hell out ov da academy n marwa shaza n tina stay!!! amal ewwww weeekkkk personality....zay ek habla....sallyy weekkk voiceee they only vote 4 her cuz she her cloth n she shows her self bas....thats wut i rly think...n i like emad carlo...i h8 ahmad soo much he got 2 get the hell out 2!!!

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH U HANNA WUTS SO GR8 IN A7MAD???

hanz get a life SALLY AND AMAL dont suck only you do!

YOUR WELCOME EGYPT we stood by yous because we know how much you love your girl and inshallah she will work harder and not be nominated AGAIN... Amal we love you habibty

GO AMAL but was it just me or didnt she sing anythign this prime..i mean its so unfair...the prime was dominated by the same people while Amal was finally given a chance to sign with the NOMINEEEEES???? GOD!

she only sang with the nominees in that tableau, because she has a sore throat...and wasnt allowed to sing any of the other three songs she had been given to practice.

i dont think its that no one likes tina but more that she has become the favourite and it means that others are missing out on singing opportunities to prove themselves. tina may have sang great in the last prime but shada for example was even better.

hanaa, london.

hanz what you said about amal and sally was very rude. seriously get a life.
amal's personality is stronger than others in the acaddemy, and i feel the only thing that is letting her down is her liking ahmad. otherwise she is nice friendly, and helps everyone in the evaluation. sally has the likeability factor, she makes the academy fun. its not about the clothes she wears and how she wears them.

hanaa, london

Hanz, How the hell ur rude to sally and amal??
first Tina is only great in english songs but arabic? she is just like carlo sucks! second Sally is a great dancer and she is much better than Tina who is involved in everything! but i know why the academy r doin dat by makin her top1 every time and those stuff..because they won't be able to make her the star because if they done that ppl will discover the fact that they r all fake and they won't find any candidate requestin even to the academy lol their might not a staracademy 5 :D:D so they won't be able to do that so they decided to rewind her by makin her winnin everythin up also they r doin the same with Ammah who they won't be able to rise him up too because egypt won before...They are trying to get shazza away of the champ by her nose's surgery and she won't be able to contunie singin which will open the way to Amal and Marwa racin together and THEY DESERVE IT ...One of them will win this season because the winner will be a girl this season..AHMED should jump out of the window our burn his hair lol he sucks really and he needs to visit a doc to stop his eyes from rollin in the primesssss :D:D

Tina didnt deserve what is she getting .. she is more of a western singer and show girl..not an oriental singer ..and if you concentrate more you notice she has problem with her breathing .(means she needs s nose surgery)>>

Marwa is doing great and she is the one long time to be no.1 ...

Carlo , Sally , need to be out .. no charisma and boring .. same goes with Mohammad Ammah

Ali , amazingly doing better !!

whats wrong with Amal ??

the best singers are Marwa and Shaza .. but i rank marwa as no. 1 ... maybe because of her positive attitude toward everyone and her great smile

I honest think that the teachers now are putting Tina in the danger zone themselves. She is their favourite but they are making the audience hate her by always shoving her in our faces. the girl is sweet and she is a harworker but her singing voice is limited. I think she deserves to stay int he academy still at least for a couple more weeks. But believe you me, the point will come when the teachers WILL HAVE TO put her as a nominee and then the audience will not save her and her friends could only save her depending on who she is running against. Therefore, the teachers are saturating us with her right now and making us hate her because she is simply taking out of the share of others who also deserve more....and in the end it will be no good for her

As for the comment about Sally and Amal being out.
Amal has got a decent voice and a very sweet personality and i see so many others that deserve to be out before we even get nominating her. and she's not a habla. she is a very senesitive person and she's in love with the wrong guy. Im not trying to say we should pity her but love is a matter out of our hands and we shouldn't repremend her about it. She's not hurting anybody
Sally sure doesnt have the strong voice but you know what..she has the rest of the package. She's got the dance moves, the personality, creativity in her evaluations, and the stage presence (today she didnt even seem like a nominee. she had a great composure and actually had fun) and most of all she has the likability factor. She will have to go at some point but again...not now. It wouldnt be fair when there are certain others who lack alot of that package

Tina dosent deserve to be in the academy she has no voice its so ugly.she kisses ass to much she thinks shes the best she has talent but not in her voice she needs to go.she really gets on my nerves.sally amal and marwa are nicer . amal has a great voice. marwa should be the star.chris de burg is not that popular anymore he hast got a voice . anyway anyone who does a duet with him is not heard of only in lebanon. so who cares if tina won a duet with him shes not christina agliera.

Seems to me Chris de burg interested In Tina herself rather than her voice ....An old man who wants to be with a teen girl .!!

mercy l kol ele sawato l sally
eza kanet
el maghreb
or iraq
or 7ata suadia arabia!
THANK U VERY MUCH!
masr kolaha hatswat l ali,shaza w bezat amal la2n el maghreb is the closest country to our heart.
<3333333333333333333
love u all so much

oh i forgot to mention the top 3
marwa deserved it and kammah AND TINA!
please guys stop saying that tina didnt deserve it she Did deserve it
go tina i love lebanon

sara mn masr

i agree with buffy and rana

AMAL didnt sing that much because WADDIH removed her songs due to her tired voice...she got a cold and now she needs to rest thats why Marwa, Ammah got alot of singing this prime.s

ME GET A LIFE?!?!?! AND WUT I SAID BOUT SALLY N AMAL AINT RUDE!! OPEN UR MINDZ PPLE! N U GET A LIFE!!! Y AMAL DIDDNT SING CUZ THEY DNT WANT HER SHEZ TOO BAD,,,,,,,, SALLY Y NOMINATED 2ND TIME?? CUZ SHEZ BAD 2!!! PPLE LOOK AT THE VOICE N PERSONALITY N TALENTS!!! but wut i rly think ov this hole show its that its all rong!! this is not hw we arabs r!! oo look we arabs r bringing french pple 2 sing but do french pple tell arabs 2 cum n sing in their primes??!? !!

comon!!! 4 reallll!!

first of all, to miss miracle: ur soooooo lame!!! "stab us in the back"---> ur a FREAK! get a life and get over it! i'm not khaleeji, but lebanese and honestly i find ur comment soooooooooo childish. every1 votes 4 their own and obviously the khaleeji's r gonna vote 4 ayoub n not 4 sally! u did the same thing! so should the khaleeji's hate YOU?! lame!
secondly, i really like tina, i seriously do. she has a nice personality BUT she soooooo cant sing! i mean 4 God's sakes she was ONLY in the academy (during lesson times) for TWO DAYS!!!! only wednesday and thursday lessons!!!!! friday is just getting ready for prime and she came tuesday at night when all lessons were finished. now common, WAT THE HELL?! HOW CAN SHE BE TOP 1 BASED ON TWO DAYS?!?!? teachers r really retarded!
thirdly, wat the hell? she was in london for FOUR days!!!! wen amal went 2 venice she only went for 2 days! n ayoub went 2 austria for only 2 days as well! i swear LBC r soooo obviously treating tine special! teacher's pet!
i personally think shaza is the best. she has the best voice, is a good dancer, can act and is mature and hard working! she deserves to win!

hi,
first of all my comment is not childish and not lame and by the way, i do have a life.the thing was 7'alijy ppl r dealing with the whole thing as if they r a single country and they keep singing 7'alijona wa7ed zay maykoon homa 3arab we 2e7na 3arab 7aga tanya ....does this mean that egypt ,lybia,tunisia,morroco should start singing 2e7nan shamal afrikia wa7da+ when a7med,3azoz,ayoub were nominated they were the ones asking us to favor certain candidat over the others then saying c'mon we r all arabs.but suddenly ,now it's 7'alijona wa7ed again and they form an isolated and diff. country who should vote for the candidat who is from this area...........i understand of course when ppl from oman vote for their son,coz as u said ..it's only normal AND NOT LAME 2 vote for their candidat but 2 start voting based on [the country is in our area?!!!!!] c'mon guys. i m not underestemating el7'alij power but u should have seen the lbc chatting this week and last week........every 1 asking 2 vote 4 this candidat and promise 2 vote 4 their candidat!! .i understand that ayoub has supporters among the 7'alijy ppl but 2 look at the chat and find that they forget[ we r all arabs] comment and they r 7'alijy and should vote 4 the 7'alijy candidat ............anyway,wut was meant 2 happen already happened....we just expected that sally's and 3emad's lovers in 7'alij would vote 4 them as 4 those in oman,ofcourse we understand their position.p.s :if any 7'alijy out there voted 4 3emad or sally then by all means accept my apologies as 4 those who didn't ..u made a choice and i respect that but just remember that 4 weeks earlier there was a heated discussion about voting acc. 2 nationality esp. in 7'alij where they vote for each others just coz of the same area ,same happens in ma3'reb 3arabi however, i think it's 2 a lesser extent than in 7'alij...i m posting my opinion[ AND I DID THINK B4 TALKING ]in a civilized way ,i expect the response in a civilized way and remember we may agree or disagree it just has 2 b in a civilized way as 4 the term [stabbed us in the back]if it hurt any1 then i apologize 2 him/her but it doesn't change the fact that i m not convinced that countries in same area is same as the same country...btw lebanon is in asia so does it make it from 7'alij ...i m asking coz i m really wondering and really i m not making fun of any 1,plz some 1 answer my question[does lebanon being in asia makes it a 7'alij country?]and if no then y not?
thnx 4 commenting on my comments any way .

A lot of you guys are right about it not being possible for Tina to have been named top 1 based on her fantastic performance last week, simply because she wasn't there most of last week. But she did do well at the prime and she did a fair job (although it was pretty much a bang up job so she could make her flight)in her evaluation. Therefore, I think she was named top 1 because of the incredible offer she has just received from Chris DeBurgh. Do not and I repeat, do not try and downplay the magnitude of this offer people. It is huge! It is bigger than huge for a 19 year old newbie in the world of music to receive such a generous offer from an international star like Chris DeBurgh. This will will give her career (probably overseas) a major jump start if she plays her cards right and gets the right management team to represent her. Do not begrudge her this wonderful chance she's getting. Granted her voice doesn't work out as well as it should in Arabic, but in English and French she does perform her heart out. She's also very driven to better herself and I find that admirable in an aspiring artist. She takes her criticism well and actually applies the advice she receives from people like Usama Rahbani and Mme. Mary, which many of the others resist and often consider offensive.
It is very possible that Tina is being overcompensated now because she's very likely not going to make it to the final prime and that's all right. She's earned what she's getting now and we should all applaud her success, be happy for her for the great opportunity she's getting and wish her and the others well.
Peace.
Emme

i think Tina deserves to be the top 1 and for all you people that are saying wat she did
she planned her evaluation in only 2 days and ayoub imad and sally who get almot a week they got to be a nominee and the song last prime with carlo was fantastic so she did deserve go tina she really rocks and people be fair why always you want the persopn you like even if they suck like amal didnt year guys hear wadee saying today that her voixce is getting weak so they canceled all her songs accept for one i mean come on you want her to be the first id rather put imad even if her is a nominee

GO TINA YOU ROCK

i think the teachers are really overdoing it! i mean tina gets top 1 again?? this is not cool!!!! i used to like tina but she's kinda making me get another view of her! what happened to the others?? they're making it seem like she's the only contestant... now im part lebanese but i don't go with country.. i go with talent!!! sally is getting on my last nerve!! i mean all of u who say that u love her... what is it bout her?? i mean it definitely can't be her voice... cuz its not good... if its her personality then thatz a bad reason!! really i think all of us should think about talent and focus less on country!! i didn't mean to hurt anyone's feelings.. i was just giving my opinion.

samie_jr

you cant go around telling us that TINA needs a noise surgery that is rude sahza needs one or maybe you do dont be a hater i mean thats it she won we can change it now so guys either put a godd comment or dont write anything please waleg help me out here

TINA ROCKS

i meant we cant change it

TINA STAR MAHMA SAR

rynie

im iraqi and i love tina she is the best she have talent

TINA STAR MAHMA SAR

TINA i hate her so much i swear they are rubbing her in our faces and she looks like a rat so much,...im lebanese and im saying this and this is ARABIC STAR ACADEMY not Australia or American IDOL!!!!! doesnt anyone get it! her voice sucks in arabic (you know the language of our countries hellooooo the main language here people) Mariam go keep your precious TINA and Wadeeh cancelled Amals songs because she was sick! she had a cold and her voice was weak and needed to rest! ok so dont take it another way just because you dont like her...also CARLO rocks and SALLY and Imed welcome back and Tina go home or go live in London for all i care god the prime was also crap no offence but are the primes gettting worse by the week!what made it worse was the fact that Amal wasnt seen half the night! Tina doesnt deserve top 1 the lbc just needed a way to present her 'her gift'! The top1 belongs to others like Carlo, or Amal.!

AMAL STAR MAHMAR SAR!!!

Tina needs a voice surgey i agree and god she is so annoying and Mariam go stick tina up your a'ss....

THE top 5 in my opinion (i dun like the top3)
- Amal
- Shada
- Marwa
- Carlo
- Mohammad

myriam why are you asking Waleg for help??? everyone has there own opinion whether you like it or not!

hanzz I agree wif u i dont fink amal or sallyy should stay in da academy .amaa for her shes not in staracademy shes in LOVEACADEMY loll and sallyy i dont evenno howshe got in staracademy at the starttt loll
she doeasnt even have a gud voice to b \honestt.
and 2 all u haters around dat r sayn dat tina didnt deserve 2 b top 1 seriously guys r u blind or watt .gooooooooooooooooooooo tinnaaaa yallaaa work harder so u kn b toop 1 again nd keep stikn dem up der facesssss.. nd by da way i dont fink Tina likes Qammah altough hes a very nice guy but sorryy hunnii shes got rabehh i rekon he treats her so gooddd like a pwincesssx
ow cuttteee mannnn

TINA is top 1 ...and now????

dont get me wrong but remember last year Joseph
he wasn't so much times top 1 or he never been i dont know..;)

but he is now the STAR soo...

SHAZAA will be the star 100%.

she is soo good man. she never sucks in a song or been shit to ather ppl---

she must win thats it .save your money to vote for shaza...

Shaza, Mohamed Ammah, Tina and Marwa are the best , they deserve to be in top 3. ( although I don't like Marwa and her silly act). Shaza her voice is powerful and perfect in everything, Ammah is a singer, composer and perfect in everything, Tina also has a very good voice. Fourth is Marwa. As for the bodybuilder he is good at singing english songs only , he is worst in arabic songs but the teachers are really favouring him.

I miss azooz very much

guys stop insulting sally. her voice is not bad she has a tender unique voice with great dancing, looks and personality. The proof that everybody likes her is that she has got the highest votes so plz stop insulting her. She is everyone's friend and supporter in the academy and we all like her and always know that the show is not only for singing and a real star should have the comlete package like sally.

Tina is oke for an English top 3!
But in Arabic, NO WAY!
She gives me the impression that she is not proud of being an arab girl! She always sings in English or French! Like others said it is an ARABIC star academy and not Western!
Shada deserves the top 1 1000000000000000000000000000000 more then Tina!
Marwa and Mohammed also deserve it!

Does someone know what that song was that everybody sang?? I think it is Fayrouz but I'm doubting.

Faysal.

People .. Why the hell ur arguin about those stuff now when the result is all clear...

First of all the star this season will be a girl because the previous 3 seasons were boys...so if a boy won again gurlz will be like :" is it a boyz show unfair ! blah blah ". So this year it will be a gurl..
It can't be Tina because she is lebanese and already josef won the pervious year so they can't let her win even that they wish they could..but if they did..ppl might go and kill rola lol
And For Kammah..they won't let him also win but they r rewindin both of em by makin them top 1 and friend of the week ..In My opinion Ammah won't care about bein the star anymore because he already became a star..i mean his songs are all over the sites ! and it is cd version! www.hellmakers.com
I bet when Ammah gets out he will be kidnapped by singers and writers and he will be the 1st one to have an album
For Amal...she got a nice voice and am happy dat she decided to stop lovin that Ahmed she finally found out that he is just a kid who is playin around and can't be serious he is just playin on her feeling ..and that was rude..

Marwa her voice is great and she can be one of the stars this season and also Shazza but i hope she doesn't make the srugey because they made that offer to her so she won't be able to keep singin that good like before and she will be out ..so i hope she makes her mind well...

So Finally we have Marwa , Shazza and Amal which i think Marwa will be the winner :) even that i wish Amal does too

See?? why we r arguin when everythin is so freakin clear!