i hope alot of people read this comment and agree with me when i a say that the top 4 for the past few weeks has been completely shada hasnt been no 1 yet and she has the most beautiful voice and amal worked so hard on her beautiful song and she is not in it.

madam roula is putting all her attention on tina even though she isnt the best and whats up with mohamad being in love with her?? AND i just have to comment to all those who love marwa why is she jealous of amal because people sent her flowers and love birds?

anyway im starting to get annoyed that the talented ppl are getting ignored by madam roula i hope some ppl agree with me

Ray7ana,
You're right Shaza should be there. The reason she's not is because she is going all the way. She will win everything. So M. Rola (LBC)is kinda giving attention to the others because at the end Shaza will win all. This is what I think. People who are not getting enough attention now, will stay until the end.

yes i agree with yous Shaza and Amal should be in the top4...i mean look at that beautiful song Amal wrote and composed...so so so beautiful and full of meaning...but no that Tina who we are all sick of by now is getting all the attention and i am so darn sik of her! Also Shaza does really good in the primes even though i dont really like her but i judge on talent and i think she deserved at least 4th places in the top4 and amal deserved top3 or top2! God!!

also did people send amal flowers and love birds? please someone tell me i havent got nagham so i miss out on that stuff....

also MARWA is the biggest two faced brat! im serious guys...Amal was being nice with her 'friend' Ahmad by helping him clean his face but it seems her and her good heart don't seem to get her anywhere...i mean marwa literally mocked her infronmt of Ahamd saying stuff like 'after the academy Ahmad will call Amal and tell her i love you " and all this CRAP! and not only did she say this stuff she laughed in both Amal and Ahmad face and kept giving Ahmad these cheeky looks! and she also made fun of Amals song !God we know Amal is prettier than you and is much more talented but you don't have to show your jealously on TV...and Amal with her good heart chose to ignore her and walked out of the room because she did not want to cause trouble unlike some people! Marwa get a life honey and while your at it go shed a few kilos because you need to bad honey...AND DONT SAY im being mean BECAUSE after THE WAY MaRWA TREATS AMAL in the academy there is no such thing as being harsh!

I agree with you all; Shaza is amazing. It's annoying that she isn't getting much credit for the hard-work that she puts in. She always makes her performances look effortless, and is always perfect. She's great. In fact, I liked her from the every first prime.

Dani,
I like your thinking :) I would like to see her at the finals, along with Imad. And hopefully, she'll win.

And, I never thought I'd say this but, Amel is really starting to grow on me. I didn't like her at first because I thought she was an emotional wreck. I thought she was too weak to be in the Academy. But, she proves me wrong on the live shows - she can really shine. Every prime I see her improving, getting more confident and more pretty (Masha'allah). Hope she goes a long way.

Rachel,
Wow, I never knew Marwa did that to Amel. But, good on Amel for walking away. She did the right thing. Marwa is not easy-going, in fact she seems very paranoid and suspicious about what is going on around her. She needs to calm down. Ahmed confessed to loving Marwa, and also confessed loving Amel. But the only difference was that he viewed Amel as a friend, and Marwa more than a friend. So, the story of the love-triangle is closed. So why is Marwa still suspicious about it. At that rate, she will lose him. She really needs to get a grip of herself. Really shocked by that news.
Amel has got a big heart and is a very lovely character but, she doesn't deserve that. And when she comes out of the Academy, Ahmed won't need to say "I love you" because all her fans will. A thousand voices are better than one. And I'm just one of the many.

I'm not really getting all the news (because I lost all the Arabic Channels on my Satellite - annoying) but,...

... what is this about people sending amel flowers and love birds? Please tell.

lou lou
When did ahmad confess to loving marwa as more than a friend, please tell me.
also, today on the dailies someone sent ahmad and amel 2 lovebirds, and someone sent all the girls a bouquet of flowers except marwa. She started crying and Ahmad made her feel better. I felt really bad for her because imagine if it was you.
Lastly, marwa is the sweetest in the academy, but she is young and when amel was cleaning ahmed's face, she did not make fun of amal's song but said that ahmed will want amal after the academy because she was jealous of what he said to her in his eval!!! amal took it as a joke.
The only evil person is Shaza, who loves causing trouble for everyone else, and she thinkss she's better than everyone! You can tell none of the guys can stand her.
The reason everyone likes marwa from the guys is because she is sincere...she wears her heart on her sleeve which could end up hurting her. And the girls are jealous because she gets the attention of the hottest guy..Ahmed!

MARY lmao the hottest guy Ahamd???? are you serious he is disgusting and no ones jealous of Marwa ok shes the one who is showing her jealousy of Amal for some reason maybe its beaucse shes prettier than her and more talented and has the ability to create beautiful songs jus like Rachel said...! and also because Ahmad did an eval on Amal, and because someone sent Amal love birds and each girl received flowers exept her and because Amal received roses from a guy from Jordan while the rest got pink and yellow oh theres are actually a million reasons why MARWA is jealous of AMAL and shes making darn obvious...NO ONE is jealous of her being with Ahmad lol and cetainly not Amal who is way over it but it seems MARWA is not convinced that Ahmad is not into Amal! AND MASHALLAH AMAL IS SO BEAUTIFUL! shes growing prettier and prettier every day!

god i hate MARWA

i love Amal...HER' AND shaza deserve top4

OH and i hae to admit im so jealous of Amal shes so beautiful and sweet and good hearted ohhhhhh i love her so much and i wish i was justlike her---her song was so amzing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!---

I M A Q T,
There's no need to be so harsh, ahmed may not be the hottest guy ever, but all of the girls wouldn't be fighting over him if he was as you say "disgusting".
I am indifferent when it comes to amal, but I don't think she is that pretty, she has the biggest butt and belly compared to the rest of her body, and she walks like a duck.
Yes I agree marwa may have acted jealous about what ahmed told amal in his eval, but amal was acting so jealous of marwa when her and ahmad kept on receiving all of the sms's a few weeks ago.
Finally, amal's song was not that good, you sound like a stalker obssesing over amal this way!

man i miss dani already =[

Ahmed an Amal were sooo Happy.I'm sure the guy really loves her just watch the 24 h channel,he denied it just to perserve his "masculine" or macho image.It seems pretty obvious.

As for Marwa,girl just GROW UP!AND STOP YELLING AND SCREAMING all day long.I really start to dislike her.

Go Tina
Go Carlo

LOOOOL Mary... I agree with you 100%...Marwa is a lot prettier than Amal and I can understand why Ahmad picked her..You say Marwa is evil but can you really blame her.. Everyone keeps talking about her weight and it needs to stop..Whats wrong with our society.. They want all girls to be anorexic..If she is happy the way she is then let her be..We are here to judge her on her voice and what she does in the academy and NOT her weight.
BTW..Amal didn't sing well on Fridays Prime.. The words may have been nice but the singing was awful..

did u guyz see MARWA'S sweaty underarms yuk it was groose when she was crying coz no 1 got her flower lol go amal ur the star.....

Marwa u are the best better than amal..
U have the best smile..am i thin u and shaza is to the final be cause u they have the best voice..
And maybe marwa is fit but, she had a white heard love u marwa..U are starac 4

LMAO Mary amal has a belly and walks like a duck????? lmao hahahaha thats the funniest thing i have ever heard god people on this forum are so bloody stupid! you cant say that WHEN MARWA is next to Amal lol cant you see the difference and Amal has got a very beautiful body and face and she walks like a women not a bloody overweight thing who cant even walk or dance ok even tina tried to change the way Marwa walks and tried to tell her to tuck her stomach in ok so dont talk bull because lol its pretty uronic talking about Amals weight lol when theres MARWA think before you say things ok cause you are embarassing youself...also BELLA you said Amal doesnt sing well in primes....are you ok honey because serioulsy you are way mistaken and when OSAMA cam he commented on how bad MARWA sang in the prime! not Amal...lol LMAO did you see how Marwa cried because no one gave her flowers lol its like not giving a lolly pop to a baby! and see her face when Amal and Ahmad got love birds hahahhaa jealousy big time lol shes the biggest back stabber also NELLY learn how to write english before you comment here ok especially if your planning to mock the contestants...

go carlo
go amal
miss you dany

lol COMMON SENSE you are so right!!! lol Mary your comments are so sad...also BELLE ahmad chose Marwa??? lol he didnt choose anyone he treats MARWA like shes a child lollol

I really cant stand Tina anymore.She is really annoying,ugly and she thinks she is the best.I cant stand her.Did u see what Osama Rahbani said about Tina's voice?he said that while she is singing you can herjust air(her breathing)and she was out of tune most of the time.and even his comments about her singing with MIriam Faris in arabic ;the LBC shannel didnt put it up coz u know all that Tina cant sing at all in arabic;that's why Osama's comments about her singing awfuly were not passed 4 the audience; so the perfedct image that LBc is trying to build 4 her will not be ruind.

Also,did anyone see yesterday SMS comments? most of the SMs were 4 TIna and Thank God they were blaming her 4 being so bad with SHatha coz Tina Yield and screamed at Shatha when she told her that u r lucky coz u r going to London ;so Tina told her that u r so jealous from me.Imagine this Shatha Jealous from TIna ? Can u believe this ? so guys it is obvious what we r facing coz all the attention is given 2 TIna however she is so ugly and cant sing one line in Arabic.
and her personality is so ugly.

and 4 MOhammad being in love with her ;it is not true(thank God) coz he said that in the past before the show started he had some feelings for her ,but not any more coz he considers her now just a friend like all the rest of the girls and even yesterday TIna recevied 1 SMs telling her that it is good that she is with Rabee3 coz they deserved each other coz Mohammd is 2 good 4 her coz he is so perfect from inside and outside;you cant imagine how her face became even uglier (wolahi). i feel sick coz Madam Rola is trying 2 make Tina popular by using MOhammad's success by putting her song on TV over and over .GO mohammad and all students who are being invisible 2 Madam Rola except her sweet TIna.

Mary,
I think you mis-understood me. I didn't say he confessed to loving Marwa, I just said he sees her more than a friend i.e. has a stronger feeling for Marwa, than Amel. I don't really know how she feels for him. But remember the time he had to choose one of the two, he chose Marwa over Amel.

I used to like Marwa but, her attitude and behaviour really shocks me at times. Now, I don't really know what I think of her. Even though I like her voice. But there is a clear impression of jealousy going on against Amel. I don't like the fact that Marwa is always screaming and yelling- why can't she just chill! What is it about Amel she can't stand. Ohhhh, Jealousy is an ugly thing.

This rival thing of Amel vs. Marwa is getting on my nerves. Marwa can be so childish. She seems to target Amel because Amel is far too kind, making herself an easy target. Really mean. She knows that she can be as mean as she likes to Amel and get away with it because Amel can't stand up for herself. She doesn't seem to be the kind, she doesn't seem to like making an argument. Such a tayooba. She doesn't deserve it. I really do feel for her at times.

just someone,
I too really miss Dany :( He was such a great guy.

can I just remind everyone that this is just a game!!!
To Commen sense, for your information, I do think before I write, and if I remember correctly it was tina who once asked amal why she walks the way she does. Also, amel is pathetic. Even after ahmed has dissed her constantly she still makes her feelings for him obvious, by comparing him and her to romeo and juliet.
Marwa may be childish, slightly overweight, loud, but At least she has the guy!!! I will admit she has gotten a little annoying and I think it is just because people keep bringing down her self-esteem, and she is only 18. I think the word evil is a liitle over-rated in this case, and it would be used more appropriately for someone like Tina, the know-it-all, or Shaza, the snob.

Does anyone know where I can see the entire sms from this past sunday because I don't have the 24 hour channel?

hi all, i'm glad that dany left. he was not bad but he's not as talented as the other students.
Tina is active but she has a very annoying voice, if you listen to her you will get a headache i don't like her she thinks she is the best. i love everybody else. but i hope that this is the last season of star academy, it's getting boring. i only watch the end now.
i hate carlo he thinks he's all that

ARE YOU PEOPLE LISTENING TO YOURSELVES... MARWA is a lot better than that AMEL!.. Amel cant accept the fact that ahmed only likes her as a friend .. and marwa was just telling a joke to amel when she was washing ahmeds face.. marwa cried not because of amel and ahmed getting lovebirds, its because no one gave her flowers and all the fans gave everyone except marwa ( POOR GIRL ) ..

GO AHMED
GO 2ama7
go MARWA
GO TINA!

*** [ Comments is Fully DELETED because of the use of dirty words ] ***

amel is making her self ridiculous ,singing to ahmed that horrible song, wering short trouser to attract him ,cleaning his face and if he asked her to clean his legs she will do,just to win the votes of khaligys.hope she will leave soon,i hate her and her ugly voice

OH my God. Come on Girls. You are insulting the contestants left & right. Some comments in here are really rude. No one should make fun of anyone because of their looks & even their weight. It's not nice. Each contestant is trying their best. They each have their own personalities & they are going through enormous stress. C'mon instead of saying she's fat, she's ugly ect...simply just say I prefer her voice, her talent, over the other & simply give your opinion in a nice way. Let's keep this site pleasant.

i didnt say anything rude in my comment i dont kno why it got deleted lol

but anyway if anyone is watching nagham now then they can see how marwa clings to ahmed

i agree with u nacuty but i get mad when people act very childish and immature like amel does

anyway can anyone tell me y theyre not showing amels song as much as mohammeds?

why is tina singing her evaluation in english again?? cant she sing arabic?

and marwa is the childish and immature one rayhana not amel

A person who laughs at others when they cry does not deserve to be me friend. i am not honored to have friends like them "ashrar"

Can someone please tell me if there was any sms for marwa and ahmad together? please please please I miised it

i meant "my friend" and not "me friend"
spelling mistake

salut tt le monde
au lieu de critiquer les stars encourages les c est un programme international et il faut quand soit tous unis
et bonne chanse pour eux tousssss

to laur

marwa & ahmad got many sms, the same song "a7la sona2y"

what happened to the evaluation? why has nobody song 2day is monday!

and how come everyone got presents except amel its not fair!

and shaza is sooooo annoying and so is tina!!

How did the students do on their evaluation today and who do you think will be nominated based on the evaluation?

day after day, Shaza keeps losing its nerves ,becoming very bosy and rude . If anything going against her is her negative attitude ..

The best is Marwa , but the academy seem to ignore her and concentrating mainly of Shaza and Tina ..

Amal is so talented and tayooba,just raw3a.Her voice is so special.Great Charisma.I loved her song.Why people have to insult every year Khalijis candidates??

Go Azzuz
Go Ahmed
Go Ali

Amal will win this year.Nshallah.

Ya7ya from Kuweit

amel is the bessssssst i love her so much i want her to win win win!! inshallah she will be the star its time a moroccan one look at last year hana came second this year morocco will be no1!! wooo

but i just need to say:: marwa stop crying please ur annoying everyone ur sticking to ahmed to much and the way u treat amel is disgusting shes like ur sister and ur so rude to her!

i love ayoub, emad, mohammed, carlo and i used to like azooz but he has completely changed!

go amel ur the best [and shaza too but since she went to dinner with fadel she thinks shes too important]

my top 8::
amel, mohammed, emad, shaza, ayoubi [HES SO CUTE I LOVE HIM], carlo, marwa and tina

*** To Bambusha and shaza,

Please solve your personal issues outside the site otherwise we will have to ban you from commenting in the future.

KEEP your comments relative to the article subject.

Thank you.

i need to ask ppl on here::

who likes amel and who likes marwa - its like a war between the two!!

[ Please keep your comments short ... Very long comments will be deleted ]

I like Marwa...She's sweet, pretty, and has a great voice.

I like Marwa too. She's a sweetheart, and isn't evil! I really believe she will win!

i think marwa is putting her head in the dirt by showing her jealousy of amel.She was shaking with jealousy.Everybody noticed this.Iha ve already warned marwa to get rid of that guy who is playing a dirty game with the 2 girls.Marwa concentrate on your evalif you want to progress,otherwise you'll lose our votes.

Can any body tell me how to vote from Canada & United States, the same thing for sending SMS, Also what is the mailing address of Star Acedemy to send letters of gits???? Thank You . . .

SMS's today weren't that nice . . . wasn't fare for Tina & Marwa (from the few ones that I watched). . . I don't get it why would some people like to offend others . . . impose ideas of love stories on the students!!!!
How about writting nice things, funny (but polite) comments . . . words that encourages every single student to show their best side & talents!!!!
It is o.k. that sometimes they fight (though I rather not watch them fighting). . . they are humans . . . most of the times they reconcile.
Obviously Sally was nervous because of the evaluation, that is why she had fights with Tina & Shatha . . . not because she hates them really!!!
Let the students in peace & Enjoy life & the show in better ways.

Sally shaza and tina problem about little sympa,
Well, shaza and sally are the mistaken ones.
Sally was under pressure all the day b/c of the evaluation which is quite logic why she is nervous. Shaza shouldnt tell sally u have to clean sympa i mean emad is responsible for the cleanin stuff but this doesnt mean he is the one who should clean all the academy . same here , shaza if u feel symba isnt clean , wash him. I didnt like it when shaza told sally enty 2alelet el adab guys u r on real t.v u shouldnt say such things. but thanks god , At the end they got over it in the sms night when someone asked sally what do u think of shaza? she told them my biggest sister and she is so sensitive and i respect her .
my prediction of this week nominees:
1.Ali
2.Abdelaziz
3.Sally
If they're 4 :
add marwa on them.
But i hope neither marwa or sally are nominees.
my top4 this week should be :
1.shaza or carlo
2.tina
3.mouhammed or emad
4.Sally or amel.
about dany :
I cried when he went out . It was really touching i mean he is the best voice in the academy after shaza mmouhammed and carlo. abdul aziz and ali are much less than him. he should be in top8 or 9 whatever it is going to be cuz he desrves it

shaza,

If you continue to post long comments, you will be BANNED!

amel amel amel amel amel is the best

marwa is so annoying she needs to leave she gets on everybodies nerves!

anyway is anyone watching amel modelling for the camera guy? how STUNNING does she look!

azooz is sooo hot i love him too!

and can anyone tell me how the evaluations went today? who was the best and the worst and who do u think will be nominated??

OMYGOD i just saw on sms on lbc nagham that amel forgot her words in her evaluation AGAIN!! please tell me this isnt true pls pls pls i dont want her to be nominated pleaaaaaaase somebody tell me!!!!!!

OMG PLEASE NO amal cant be nomineee please guys noooooooooo

how was amals evaluation??????

PLEASE SOMEONE TELL ME HOW WAS AMALS EVALUATION?????

hi, i totally agree with shaza that shadha made a huge mistake by callimg sally names on T.V i mean sally who's the younger didn't call her names although she was really nervous ,how come shaza say that?!!!!!!
any way, i want 2 know if ur prediction about the nominees was based on the eval coz i haven't seen it or it's just in general coz many expected her a nominee last week but dany did much worse so she didn't becom a nominee.plz reply.thnx

marwa marwa marwa...so talented and beautiful...voice is good and sings very well...marwa star inshallah