What a bullshi*t.....tina????

whats with SHAZA ya allah...

are they blind?? i thought they put her in the first place & then i saw tinas face :S:S

what ever she will win at least..im sure

she sang the BAGHDAD song so nice ..

GOO SHAZAA

marwa deserves to be up there along with shada... they both have strong voices..

shada should be in the top one not tina and ahmed first of all they both don't sing arabic good second of all i swear they don't know how to sing english good either.

yuck tina on the top carlo should be there instead

istill dont understand why they shatha 's not top1 this week?? why??
its so obvious that they re ignoring her
:(

go shatha, y were wounderful today

BAGHDAD

why re they ignoring shatha????? its so obvious!!
the girl was wounderful last prime & this prime more then gr8

idont get it

Ahmad really did not desereved to be in the top 4. Their are better voices in the academy then him, e.g. Amal, Marwa, Shada and even dany who now left us :(((((. Amal sang very well, when Michel was playing on the and Shada did well when she sang Baghdad :), I was estoniched by both girls. Imad and Carlo are both good.

Good Luck to Dany!!!

Faysal. ( Shadi I judged on talen ;))

talent*

Tina deserves to be top1. She's amazing on the stage and her performance in the last prime was fantastic.
But I can't understand why Ahmed is between them and Shada and Mohammed are out of Top4. Marwa couldn't be between top4 because Madam Mery choosed her as a nominee this week.

wow dats gr8 3azouz iz back!but sorry 4 dany!
plz cud any1 tell me the percentage of the results.my lbc and nagham are scrambled

Hi bayan
Ali got 55% something
Aziz 40% something
dany the rest
azoz got chosen by his friend 7 to azoz and 3 dani

hey ppl stop being behind ahmad.he rily deserves mo da tina.tina is da worst in da academy.

meza
thnx alot!!!!!!!!!

Tina is waaaaaaay overrated. She really isn't that great. As a matter of fact, her voice is annoying. How come Mohammed 2amma7 wasn't in the top 4???

Good luck, Danny you were such a great sport and I admire you very much for it. Congratualtions Ali, I was struggling to vote for him and luckily I sent an SMS md thank goodness he won. Azooz welcome back, you deserve all the best.

ana men maughreb...i like alot tina..she is a star...she sings very good and her singing of london bridge was amazing....Go Tina hopefully more number ones to come for you

Go Tina Tina Tina Tina....you are so good...you truly deserve to be number one
i love tina

poor dany im gona miss him inshallah all is gona work out for him can sum1 plz tell me who is the 3rd person who voted for dany my lbc and nagham channels r also scrambled and ahmad and tina didnt deserve to be in top4 dats for sure emad and carlo yah im happy abt it best of luck danyyy

OK WAS THIS A CRAP PRIME OR IS IT JUST ME?

i mean look who once again dominated...tina tina tina tina shada shada shada shada shada...far out! all night these two girls were on stage...while girls like AMAL only sang a few words and then was finally allowed to sing her song right at the end...just to commnet that AMALS song, that she created, is absoloutely BEAUTIFUL!!!! omg i want it on CD!!!!she sang it very well and she was bursting with emotion and love...dont you agree with me? seriously AMAL should get more stage time...they don't lets her shine...also she looked marvelous today in her blue dress ...ashame we didnt see her much...ALSO AYOUB????/ WHAT happened to him...i mean hello hes a contestant to, doesnt he atleast deserve to sing a few words????? omg i don't know about anyone else but i am absolutely sick from Tina and Shaza!!!!! I want AMAL, MARWA and AYOUB to atleast have a fair share,,,,this is unbelievable I SWEAR...also this prime was bad...no good tableaus and the same people sang over and over again!

also the top 4????? where is Mohammad Ahmah and Amal Alanbari???? these two people are creating their own songs and are working hard but it obviously doesnt count, does it??

Frankly Amel is the prettiest of all and her song was beautiful and her voice is great and she has a beautiful soul ...WELL DONE AMAL...keep it up

GO AMAL GO MORROCO
Rachel from Lebanon/Australia

gooood sooo soooo good song amal entee fanana ya beet wallahe go go go
amal and ama7 and shaza a7san sweet on strac gamda a7'er 7aga...........and marwa and ahmad toz amal and shaza the dest

I'm so sad to know that Dany left. He was such a lovely person. I wish him all the best :)

Comments on the Top 4:
4) Ahmed
Don't get me wrong, I like this guy. But he is not that talented in comparison to others in the Academy. He is highly over-rated and the Academy focuses on him more than the other students. The only reason being is, the story of the love triangle. It's the big buzz that everyone is speaking about. Let's face it without him there would be no big story that would keep people interested in Star Academy. Therefore, he is more about entertainment than talent.

3) Carlo
Great voice but a not such a great attitude at time. He needs to sort himself out. But there is no question about it, he does have such a great voice. Good to see him up there.

2) Imad (Yes!!!!)
He too has a great voice. He doesn't get a lot to do on the live shows but, he makes the most of what he has got. Nice character. I am so happy for him. He's one of my favourites, if you hadn't worked that out.
I liked him from the very first prime. I also liked Marwa and Shada - beautiful strong voices. But where are they on the list?

1)Tina (?!?)
Niether Marwa nor Shada were on the list! Last week, everyone was speaking about Shada and her performance - saying how amazing she was. But, last week, everyone was also speaking about Tina and her performance - unfortunately, many of which were negative.
Therefore, I'm not too sure where the common sense lies here. (puzzled*)
Don't get me wrong, I like Tina, but the "London Bridge" performance was a little dreadful. It seemed too desperate. I thought she could have actually got away with speaking the words instead of singing them.
I hope the next time, it would be a song that she can sing and show off her vocals. Because that song did no justice for here.

omg whats wrong with them?? shaza deserved to be top 1 much more than tina, shes been amazing since the beginning and last prime she was awesome, on top of that she smacked the evaluation like anything! and i cant believe amal and mohammad aren't in it too.

Hi every one,

Today prime wasn’t great compared to the previous prime. Shaza deserves to be the one who gets Top 1, to be honest Shaza’s voice is the greatest voice in this season and she deserves to be on the top every week. Last week she wasn’t there and this week I just don’t understand why Tina????????? Please don’t get me wrong I like this girl but her voice is not the best “Shaza, Marwa and Amal their voices are way better than Tina. But we know that star Academy is not fair all the time. The one they like “I mean Madam Rola likes will win the top!!!
Dany hard luck…I wish you all the best your voice is amazing… it is way better than Ali, Ahmad and even Carol…but it is a game “your existence in the Academy will affect their dole Tina thus they have to eliminate you to give their dole a better chance to shine and win!!!

Dany you are a star and you sing better than most students.

Shaza is the STAR…. Go Shaza I and my friends and many people Arabic people in Canada are with you.

Please it is a friendly comment and I don’t mean to offence anyone but this is my opinion

Rosi

Tina seems to have a severe nasal problem.. she often has to take a deep breath .. but she is a good "Show" girl .

My top 4 for this week would have been-

1. Shaza(oh come on she sang beautifully last week I recorded it and listened like 50 times). She always sings perfectly.

2. Tina (she also did very well last week and is a hard worker).

3. Ayoub (he did great last week with his solo and spanish song).

4. Mohammad (I personally would put this guy in just about every weeks top 4, and he did great).

I totally agree with those who think Shaza should have been top 1 this week. To add insult to injury, she was completely bumped off the top 4. I guess there must be a reason for overlooking her. Ahmed shouldn't be in the top 4 this week at all, and although Tina had it coming, because of all the vast efforts she exerts to outdo herself and she did do well in the London Bridge tableau (a bit out of breath, but still ok), but she could've gotten it any other week. Shaza's time was definitely now and it's totally unfair that she was completely ignored after two incredible primes and a the best evaluation of the whole lot.
I totally believe she's the one to beat this year. The girl's got incredible talent and dedication that should carry her the full distance.

AMAL is very smart , she tries to improve her performance every prime. GOOD LUCK AMAL we want another starac like rajaa (X FACTOR) AND hanaa .. keepp on .. WE LOVE YOU

ALLEZ LES MAAGHREBENS BOSSEZ

Mohamed kammah not in the top 4? what ? whaaaaaaaaaaaaat? did you see his evaluation this week? this man is amazing. Also shazaa? i was dreaming and day dreaming about her song with fodel last week and her amazing singing. marwa should also be inthere. carlooo nooooooooo and ahmed nooooooooo. carlo is overated also and i am pretty sure he has connections and thats why he is still in the academy because the boy doesnt know how to sing arabic

The top 4 this week were a little ridiculous. Not what expected at all.

Tina
I'm not sure why or how the london bridge performance was the main trigger of Tina getting to the top 1 this week. I personally thought it was awful and even painful to watch. I think maybe the popularity of the song (especially that it's a recent song from the west) is what made the performance so appealing to some people. But in reality, Tina was out of breath most of the time and it almost felt like she was speaking the words rather than singing them, and at times maybe even shouting them. That performance didn't deserve top 1 stand in comparison to Shaza'z performance in "my way" last prime.
Don't get me wrong, i love Tina as a person and she is one of the people i love to watch on the dailies. But in all honesty, her voice needs a lot of improvment if she wants to make it in the arab world musical industry. The girl has so much trouble singing in arabic, more so than anyone else in the academy this year. Even though she tries her best (and i greatly respect that) her voice just never suits arabic singing and she is always out of breath. Her effrt is appreciated of course, but this is an arab star academy after all, knowing how to sing well in arabic is kind of a requirement lol.

Imad
This guy is amazing. His voice is good and sometimes even great. He still needs to work more on it when he is singing low notes but still he seems to have it under good control. However, his character is probably the most appealing thing about him. He shows just the right emotions when singing, he doesnt over do it (like Tina) or under do it (like Ali and azouz). His charisma just shines wherever he is and he really knows how to put his character into good use whether by being creative in evaluations or by just his interactions with others. He knows how to critique other right without being rude and at the same time while giving them the right advice. Totally unselfish.

Carlo
I hated him in the begining. He was just rude and very isolated from the rest. His voice is amazing nonetheless. True, he sounds so much better when he sings in english but his arabic singing is still under control and he is improving very well in it. Also, his character has been slowly changing week by week. He is moreintegrated with the group now and seems to even bring more fun into the academy. He is also becoming a gentleman with the girls (shocker isn't it? lol)

Ahmed
He confuses me, seriously. Sometimes he is really good and other times he is really just awful. He is trying his best to improve but im not really seeing any change. I really dont know but i seriously can't see any change from like 2 weeks ago and now. He is still singing the same way, sometimes off key...sometimes just flat with no emotions...others actually really good. I dont mind him getting to top 4 but the fact that he is been in top 4 in 3 consecutive weeks while others who deserve it more (at least in my opinion: Shaza, mohamad, marwa) have been totally pushed to the side..i find that just very troubling and it's almost making me dislike him through no fault of his own.

AMAL AMAL all the way
what a beautiful song!!!!!!!!!
omg i wasnt expecting it
wow

go amal love from lebanon

Hey Guyz!!

this is crazy...... i just wanna ask both of you in this comment, DO YOU THINK AHMED IS BETTER THAN SHAZA, MOHAMMED OR AYOUB? actually i don't know wat happening there? coz they are always choice ahmed in top 4 so wat abaout the others? is he good that much? i don't think so!!! ahmed he don't deserve to be in top 4 more than the others.. but i have to say he is luckyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy!

Hey All

Did someone of you remember my mesage 2 weeks ago when I said that Dany who has the best voice in Starac 4 will go out soon...If you want to know whay Shatha is not in top 4 it is because the next week she will be in the 1st place ( the 1st place is as a ball every week is in the hands of someone ).
For Ammah he will be in 3rd or 4tht place.

i wonder if top 4 or joke 4 !!!!!!
where r marwa ,shadha,amel 'n' mo7amed in [ chairs game ]
2nd job the average of voters r dork cuz dany who deserves to stay not 3ali [what a joke]
profs r dunmy cuz they must nominate a7mad [I 4get they can't cuz he's a don juan of serial
but a zero wn he sings arabic]Imane 'n' Dany r better but profs considered them bitter.
plz fans save your money some they don't deserve to stay.
ma3'ribin boy said 3emad will b the star

hi guys
HILDA mota7ayeza isin't true?

amal should be in top 4 hello why is ahmed in it wats he good at..

thes section name must be:
unfair top4
or down4

no another comments

Ahmed again in top 4.Is the jury blind to pick up this nothing guy among top 4 students!!I can't believe that!! Where are mohamed, amal shatha ..?? ithink there 's somethiong unfair in that choice.Starac 4 is a total failure.Im not goinhg to waste my money voting on people who don't deserve a place in the top 4 ha ha....

hey all,2zay 2mma7,shaza&marwa werent in the top 4!!!!!!!!!!!!bgd homma to7fa 2wy w talented ...i dont think 2n a7med deserves 2 stay in the academy 2ktar mn kda .....LOVE U 3MAD, 2AMMA7,SHAZA&MARWA w REALLY DANY kan 27la voice fl gus in the academy(good luck) bgd ana msh fahma 2h 2ly by7sal momkn 2y 7d y2olly fe eh!!!!!!!!!!!

i was very disapointed with this prime i belive tina did not deserve to be top1 because there are more deserving people like marwa kamah shada and she dont even sing that well the black eye peas would be disapointed with the londen bridg performance

i wanna say something ppl ok this is getting to the point wat the hell is going on has ahmed lol imad looooool tina ok but no way first.1.ok shatha i dnt get y they r not putting her on top wallah i dnt y is it because of her looks or her age.Ahmed is there because of the look he has 4 me i dnt think he is good lookin wat the hell is happening.Imad is there cuz of hes looks cuz no way he has better voice than shatha.OMG PPL R U BLIND SHATHA BENT IL IRAQ deserves it all wallah.

here we go again wit dat shiiitttt ppl jus jealous cuz egys alwayz win stop bein jealous mayne cuz u kno we gon win

U guys really need to shut up. Tina is a great candidate. She is really talented. I know shaza also deserved to be in the top 4 but the teachers didnt out her. They have to have some reason. Ahmad doesnt deserve top 4. This was my opinion for top 4

4. Mohammed
3. Imad
2.Shaza
1. Tina

I think the teachers are being fair though. They understand about talent more then u guys. So u shouldnt be talkin at all!!! o and for the ppl who said that they only gave it to tina because she is lebanese......... shut the hell up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Some of u even said that they gave tina a trip because she is lebanese. So what. They gave amal and ayoub a trip. They gave Imad 5000 dollars for him to buy clothes. All lebanese ppl are being treated equally with every one else.. This prime was really good

I like Tina, Carlo, Shaza, Sally, Imad, Ayoub, and Amal. I like every one else too but not as much as these ppl.

Good luck Dany

Put yourselves in Ali's shoes and you'll know what's it like to be ignored by the teachers. And most imporatnt, Ahmed worked hard and that's why he's in the Top 4, you reject Khaleeji students like every year and if somebody insults one of your people you go nuts! Just grow up and leave him alone unless if you're jealous of his popularity and he's not like Carlo the snob. Mohamed seems to be going backwards because of his love for Tina.

I've been watching this this year's star academy from the start and here's my impression about this year's group:
-Mohammed: a musical genius with a great voice (best male voice, imo) and a cool, if slightly bland/introverted, character.
-Sally: the best dancer of the group, by far. Her problems are lack of self confidence and an average voice.
-Marwa: great voice in the high registers, average every where else. She has the mannerisms of a 5 year old and no character to speak of.
-Amal: a quiet, dignified and sentimental girl with an above average voice. To my eyes, she's the best looking girl in the academy!
-Tina: there seems to be a desire to make Tina the star this year, even if that means shoving her into our faces 10 times per prime! She's a delicat, seemingly smart person, but I find her voice annoying, like it's a cross between a male/female voice, and her dancing is average at best.
-Shaza: the best voice in the academy, male or female, and a good stage presence, but that's where he talent ends. I also feel she's not the nicest person to have around (she enjoyed the "authority" she was given over Marwa's diet a little bit too much imo!)
-Imad: a very cool guy with a very decent voice and a cleaning freak! Would make some lucky girl a great husband, lol :)
-Ahmed: I feel he's a little boy in a big man's body in every thing he says or does. That's probably why he's more compatible with Marwa than Amal :) He sings like he's in the middle of a yawn, which, in turn, makes me want to yawn when I hear him! Should've been gone LONG ago!
-Azouz: Another man child, but better voice than Ahmed (though still average). He has curious effiminate mannerisms, especially when trying to be funny, that don't do him any favors.
-Ali: decent voice, but zero stage presence. He can also play the lute, which is a plus.
-Ayoub: funny and kind-hearted guy. Good on the guitar and has a decent voice.
-Danny: too bad this guy left! Great voice (right up there with Mohamed), great stage presence and an all around talented guy. Too bad his nerves got the best of him during the evaluations..

My pick for the winner this year? Ding..ding...ding..ding.... Mohamed Kammah!

Oops, forgot Carlo, but for a good reason; he didn't leave any impression on me! All I have to say about his is that he has a decent voice and sings reasonably well both in arabic and english.

Also, while -like I said- I think Mohamed Kammah should win, it looks like the academy is hell-bent on making Tina (or maybe Shaza) the winner this year.

i wanna say dat. i think this year winner should be shatha she has the best voice out there not cuz im iraqi and im saying dis to u guyz la its because did u hear her voice wen she sang da iraqi voice all my family were crying and the funniest bit iz wen my dad and my mum now wants me to get in to star academy enshalla this 1 comeing. anywayzzz ppl my opinion this year should be a girl who should win shatha she has it all all. 4 me ahmad i love him ok i thin he is cool and marwa loves him u can tell she gets jelaous over him and poor amel i love her more than marwaaaaaaaaa walla and she deserves a better guy.Ayub i think my opinion on him he has the best manners and omg and he respects every1 so much thats why i love about him. Carol has an attuide i swear even with his GF wat the hell he just left like bloody talking hes shoes off walla i think he needs to get a life. DANYYYYY ya allah i cnt believe he went out i think it should of been ALI although i looove ali but its not about like its about the truth her guyzzzz. gooood luk DANI ya hayti love u 2 bitez walla.

i wanna say dat. i think this year winner should be shatha she has the best voice out there not cuz im iraqi and im saying dis to u guyz la its because did u hear her voice wen she sang da iraqi voice all my family were crying and the funniest bit iz wen my dad and my mum now wants me to get in to star academy enshalla this 1 comeing. anywayzzz ppl my opinion this year should be a girl who should win shatha she has it all all. 4 me ahmad i love him ok i thin he is cool and marwa loves him u can tell she gets jelaous over him and poor amel i love her more than marwaaaaaaaaa walla and she deserves a better guy.Ayub i think my opinion on him he has the best manners and omg and he respects every1 so much thats why i love about him. Carol has an attuide i swear even with his GF wat the hell he just left like bloody talking hes shoes off walla i think he needs to get a life. DANYYYYY ya allah i cnt believe he went out i think it should of been ALI although i looove ali but its not about like its about the truth her guyzzzz. gooood luk DANI ya hayti love u 2 bitez walla.Ammahhhhhhh omggg he has ya allah such a good voice i think he iz gnna make it to the final him and shatha thats if the 5leeeji ppl wont vote. enshalllla.lool

i totallly agreee guys Tina truely sucks.. her english isnt even good so imagine arabic.. ewwwww ..... shatha deserve to be top and momo toooo... but tina.. comeon she has to go soon

Forgot to say... I totaly agreee that wat the hell is wrong with top 4.

MOMO PLEASE WAKE UP like its not worst losing a great spot in the academy for an ugly girl u deserve prettier and better for u... like please be careful...

amal is really an amazing person but she has to improve somuch her voice but shes amazing! LOVE HER

shatha too her voice is nice but she doesnt really have star quality shes 25 i think its too late to start... but she has the best girls voice

HARAM DANNY:( OMG can anyone tell me how an incredibly talernted person can leave... i wish tina left... or carlo dany deserved to stay but starac want ssomeone who can sell.. and dany is still young for that i guesss

Ahmad DID elvis sooo much better than carlo... and his mom is soooo pretty omgggg and his sister tooo waw

I totally agree tina has this annnoyinggggg voice like it comes from her noise and its freaking annoying shoving it in our face evetryprime like 10 timesss she dont deserve that much

Ayoub WE NEEED TO SEE HIM MORE his voice is improvingg and omg his enligsh was stunning

Ali watever hes gonna leave anyways him and 3azouz... but theyre great pepople but lets face it they wnot make it to the finals...

marwa.. i dont know in the evaluation she was amazing but theyre not giving her songs to show her real talent but please girl lose weight and get a peronsality.. like star quality ZERO

Imed... okay he is freaking hot but voice ZERO ewwww and his dancing moves and annoying and he is impolite and rude and he thinks hes all that like ur hot but thats it

tina please try to be more original girl ur sooo fake and we dont think ur all that so why u so confident.. shouldnt bee

I think dani shouldve stay carlo out....
and the best is momo... he has such a great future... but there gonna ake shatha win cause first year a girl and first tima iraqui... and momo has a future garanty thats wat i think...
Star ac last year was 1000000 million times better than this year they have no starquality even if there talent are a lil more expend.. but were not attached to them as last year and there not so special... as last year
DOnt u agreee guys

Jenny i hate you cause you are ZERO