Shrouq shrouq:P She should stay because sje deserves to stay... Nelly and Maysoon donot deserve to stay ..Its very unfair for shrouq if she goes out...
She should stay...
I want shrouq to stay because she deserves it more than nelly ..

Wala 7aram, pleez ppl vote 4 shorroq as she is our only hope, if she makes through in the academy ash will be a huge voice 4 all gulf and arab gurls. she is our huge role model, plez vote 4 her!!!!

I reaaaaaaally expected this nomination
if maysoun got z public
Nelly will leave ( as all the khalijee candinate will vote to Sherouk n maybe z morocon gurlz too)
If Sherouk got z public maysoun will leave

i didn't expect to say that...but go nelly and maysoun:P:P shorouq is cute but nelly and maysoun did better than shorouq in the evaluation specialy nelly.

Shadi

tany ya maysoon? =////

7aram begad leh hya nominee? she is improving!!!!

occ:SHady who r u voting for?

Hello everybody,
well Nelly & Maysoun got 3 chances to do better but they didnt! sorry but Shorouq also deserves another chance so she has to stay. Good luck for all of them.

Shorouq desreves to stay it's not fair that she's the second Bahrainy student to leave in a short period of time after Khaled who was unjustly out of the show, I'm going to vote for her and so will my friends. Nelly and Maysoon already had their chances and this is the third time they've been nominated so one of them has to go, it's not about their characters or looks but they didn't do well in the evaluation.

to be honest guys even if nelly or mayssoun tried to improve still they r very far from the others.
another thing and to be also honest with u the three girls are very weak and are the weakest among the others.
i m lebanese and i dont see nelly as a star,tina has good voice only in english as for carlo and dany of curse they r not that good compared to joseph.shaza has the best voice among the girls in addition to marwa if she works harder on her voice.as for the guys,imad has good voice but has to work more on it,carlo and dany too.

i will vote for nelly and maysoun, ok egyptian:p

Shadi

ok shady if u vote for maysoon too i will vote for nelly.

It was so predictable that Nelly and Maysoon would be nominated. It would be very unfair for Shurooq if she has to leave. Nelly and Maysoon got already their chances, its time that one the girls leaves. I personally think that the teachers want to get ride of Maysoon and Nelly.
They are realy weak compared with other girls from the academy!!
It's time they start working seriously!!!!!!!!!

What the presenter (her name escapes me at this moment) did to Nelly & Maysoun was very mean. she made them think they were safe, when infact they weren't. lol 7aram I felt bad for both of them. They looked like they were kids in a candy store when they were told to go in the other room, both of them thinking they were safe & then BAM! she brings them back & tells them they're both nominated. Don't get me wrong, they both deserved to get nominated bas wallahy that was mean of them to do it that way.

Once again, Maysoun is gonna get the public vote, Nelly is gonna get the student's votes & Shourouq is unfortuately going back to where she came from. I hope i'm wrong though. Either Maysoun or Nelly deserve to leave not Shourouq because like you guy's said, They both had the chance to improve & they didn't.

HARAMM YAA....

they have 2 gave them a chance this jury...maison & nelly did it better wallaa than shorooq.

anyway why is ahmed not been nomineted he did a shit job :S.

GOO MAISOON KIK THEM OUT hahaha JUST LIKE RYM from STAR ACADEMY 3 ...

MISS NOMINEE 2 hahaha..

a.D ;)

MR.PERFECT,

i lik ur idea of ms nominee 2 looooooooooool haha funny!!!!:):)

please please please vote for maysooon
please.... vote for her... the teachers are mean..what did maysoon do to be nominated please vote for her.

Oh Come On !!! This nomination thing is not based on talent, its based on money, the guys running the show are taking advantage of egyptians , they know that no matter what egyptians will always vote for their own and they represent the largest number of people voting, so they're basically milking the cow ( in this case maysoon, but don't get me wrong !! ) until they can switch to another egyptian, I bet that the next time they nominate someone after maysoon is kicked out,it'll be sally or mohammed.And guys, plz don't tell me that I think its a conspiracy theory or something that we egyptians have , ITS JUST MONEY !! that the academy is thinking of

Nominees were expected; even though both Nelly and Maysoun improved vocally slightly. However, Shurouq was a catastrophe. Her voice is horrible, honestly speaking. I am Khaleeji and that does not mean I should vote for Shurouq, that is called stupedity. You vote for the candidate that has star qualities even if they were nominated before. I personally want Maysoun and Nelly back; at least they are trying & have got some star qualities.

I assume Maysoun will be brought back by audience, and Nelly by students. I personally will vote for Maysoun and encourage all Khaleejis to vote for her too as she is capable of improving.

URGENT URGENT URGENT

Do you guys know the name of singer and song of evaluation of the girls? The ones Maysoun, Sally, Amel, Marwa sang? I want to download it but find dificulties identifying the singer and song.

hey, does anyone know whose going to sing in the show. thanks..

am with shrouq n Nelly ..ya rab ohma efoozoon.. yalla ya 5aleej o yallah ya lebnan keep voting.. i hope all the best for both..

hey leila ^_^ its massari , jawad and darine hadchiti

hii i am ingi go go go maysoon yala ba2a kolo vote 4 maysoun egypt egypt egypt with u 3ala fecra maysoun 7aterga3 bel gomhour w nelly 7aterga3 be as7abha w shourouk 7atrawa7 bye bye ingi from alexandria

ba j'crois que shourok ki vas quitter le programe cette semaine meme si je veux bien qu'elle reste encore par ce que vraiment elle merite par apport aux autre nominées mais dommege c'est comme ça le jeu. 3id mobarak enfaite pour tt les meufs et les mec de bled.aller ciao.......

Ok... I knew 100% that Shorooq will be nominated, because she was terrible in the exam. Who knew that Nelly and Maysoon will be nominated again? Actually, Maysoon laughed again, and Nelly sang like she had a cold. Anyway, if Shorooq leaves, it'll be for the better. She could always get more training outside the academy. It won't be the same without her, but it wont be the end of the world if she leaves. ;)

i love maysoon and who ever hate her is stupid.
masr is with maysoon forever!!!!!!!!!!!

shrouq wiill come back....actually this is a very hard compettion..becase the coutries egypt, kaleeg, and lebeenon..are high in votes..i don't know who will come back..its hard..but even tho i don't like maysoon..i am gonna vote for her..according to her ability and talents..comparing her to her fellow nominess..she is better that both of themm..i rlly like shourouq..but her voive is the weakest in the academy..i think..i want nelly out..b.c she had her chances..i want maysoon out tooo..but if she was to come back..then she has the capiblty to get far with her nice voice..but nelly and shrouq won't .thats wut i think

i dont its prettttyy harddd..

good luck..at least this is only a game..

who is the guests this week in star academy?
please someone reply

Egyptian they saif they're
MASSAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARI
DARINNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNE HADCHETE
JAD ALI ( NEVER HEARD OF HIM)
GOOOOOOOOOOOO MAYSOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUN

Honestly I don't care about any of them. I want Nelly or Maysoon to go first because I am tired of them taking up the nominee song. Shurooq also is not good. All of you who say Maysoon is good are bias towards egyptians(same with those who think Nelly is good). Whoever of them goes this week really doesn't matter. They are all bad. Not to mention none of them are interesting r fun to watch. Shurooq is silent whereas Nelly seems to have the sad idea that she is actually good. Maysoon also is just annoying and NEEDS to be out. But I agree completely Luna. It was a little cruel to tell them they were safe and then bring them back out.

Listen people all three of them are bad, none of them sang well. Not compared to the others anyways. Doesn't matter they are all going out in the next month.

I meant the nominees, not all of them lol.

This was totally expected and the outcome is almost predictable like all previous weeks. My personal hope though - and I am Egyptian - is for Maysoun to leave. I hate what this is doing to the girl's moral....Nelly's too, but I'll talk about Maysoun first. She has a voice, but as Wadie said last week, having a nice voice alone is not enough. Maysoun needs formal training before she tries to sing in public again. She obviously has absolutely no clue and her ears need serious training. Nelly has training, but has serious trouble belting out an Arabic song. She can go out and sing English or French without any trouble whatsoever. She really gave it her best shot this week, but fell short compared to the stronger candidates like Shaza, Marwa, Imane and Amal. Shorouq, like Maysoun, has no fighting chance at the moment and should consider formal training if she would like to become a singer one day in the future, but for now she's really much weaker than the rest. Who should win is a toss up....all three are on equal footing and will all be eliminated shortly. Who will win....well, I have a strong feeling Maysoun and Nelly will be unpacking their luggage one more time this week, but will certainly find themselves in the same unfortunate position a short week later.

YOU GUYS LETS STOP THIS CHAIN AND VOTE FOR SHUROUQ SO ONE OF THEM (NELLY & MAYSOUN) CAN FINALLY FINALLY LEAVE!!! COME ON DONT YOU THINK ITS GETTING BORING AND IF THEY STAY ONE OF THEM WILL BECOME A NOMINEE AGAIN NEXT WEEK PROBABLY EVEN BOTH OF THEM AGAIN. LETS JUST STOP THIS NOW AND VOTE FOR SHUROUQ SO EITHER NELLY OR MAYSOUN CAN HOPEFULLY LEAVE

Finally, the nomination is fair. We all know that Nelly and Maisoun deserve to be nominees but Shoroug is without any doubt the worst female student to ever be in star academy, in addition to the level of ugliness that she has, her voice is worse than a dog barking. What was funny is that she cried after she knew that she was a nominee, for god's sake, don't these people look at the miror or hear them selves singing. SHE IS HORRIBLE. And lately, she is acting cool kissing and hugging guys.....

HAPPY NEW YEAR 2007!!!!! BEST WISHES FROM US HERE IN CANADA TO ALL OF U OUT THERE, ENJOY IT!!!! OK, I JUST WANNA SAY TO Shoroug_the_donkey that her comments were a little bit mean and unnecessary, i dont think Shrouk is ugly but anyway all 3 nominees deserve it but Shrouk should stay since Nelly and Maysoon got 2 opportunities to improve and they still were among the weakest so thats it let the luckiest 2 win ciao xoxo

ALL THE PEOPLE WHO SAY BAD THINGS ABOUT MAYSOON NEEDS TO STOP!!!

sara from egypt

ken i bet ur from bahrain so ur saying that so shrouq can win..but guess what? the egyptians and lebanese will never give up on voting for their children

sara from egypt

Maysooon all the way!! I am going to vote for Maysoon! She is the only one I admire in the academy, walla, she is soo funny!

EVERYONE VOTE FOR MAYSOON!

The only reason I vote for Maysoon because she reminds me so much of my love Reem Ghazali! God, I miss her so much,

hi every1 this is my 1st time posting :)
i live in australia and i watched the daily show this morning, at 3.30 am lol
and i have 2 agree with every 1 who said the way that maysoon and nelly were told they were nominees this week AGAIN!! was mean...
even though they might have deserved 2 be nominees they shouldn't have been tricked like that...
well we never knw wat will happen in star ac so we're gonna have 2 wait till the prime 2 see who will leave us this week..
it was nice posting lol
talk 2 u all later
cya tc :)

Goo Maysoon.

shoroq has all my respect...but she cant sing thats it!!

Nelly she is acting cute to the khalijiis she just hoppin that they take her back in the academy.

but guys 2 have to stay in academy.....
nelly out plss yaaaaaa
nelly thinks she is so good soo gooood becus she is at last lebanise....baby girl u are wrooog its time 2 leave....becuz look guyz 2 times she lose in auditions maisoon wins ;)

GOOOOOO MAISOOOOOOOOOON
GOO
GOO
GOOOO

a.d

SHAZA from academy LOVE HER voice first iraki girl in the academy & so talentet wooww

IRAK 4 EVER (v)

TO 3aziz min kuwait .

YEESS MAN you are so rightttt hahahaa

just like RYM ...

i loved her so much hahaa anyway

a.d

hey guyz any 1 now how old amal is plz plz plz some 1 tell me.. thanx GOOOOOOOOOOOO AMAL

SARA FROM EGYPT
ACTUALLY I AM FROM PALESTINE AND I LOOK MORE ON TALENT RATHER THAN COUNTRY BECAUSE MAYSOON AND NELLY GOT TWO CHANCES AND THEY ARE STILL THERE. THEY SHOULDNT HAVE ANY MORE CHANCES BECAUSE NELLY IS HORRIBLE I DONT KNOW HOW SHE GOT IN TO BEGIN WITH, AND MAYSOON WOULD REALLY BE GOOD IF SHE TRIED A LITTLE HARDER BUT SHUROUQ SHOULD HAVE ANOTHER CHANCE BECAUSE ITS THE FIRST TIME SHES A NOMINEE SEXY NESS I THINK SHES AMALS 19 AMAL OR MARWA SHOULD WIN IN MY OPINION

Plz everyone vote for nelly she deserve to stay
First of all nelly improved alot this time I'm just suprised with the teachers comments

Ahmed didn't do well at all and ali too but he was sick thats why

Goo Goo Nelly I'm with you
And everyone vote for nelly she did much better than the two other

i love mayson very much
and if she leaves it will b very boring
imad and mayson and kamah r the best

Yes I agree with everyone that was a really bad idea tricking them
Nelly and Maysoon thinking they really improved this time and happly running to the safe room thinking there dreams came true before the didn't finish there satisfaction it took a second to broke there hearts

It was very bad
I'm sorry to say if it was hilda or the teachers idea that was a very bad act!

I wish nelly gets the public vote becoz comparing the two nelly did a great job this time instead of nelly ahmed deserved to be nomine

they ar enominatign NELLY so that a lebanese can get out because there are 4 of them and they need to make one get out...
I SWEAR TO GOD I SWEAR TO YOU THAT NELLY DID NOT DESERVE TO BE NOMINATED...I SWEAR!!!!

oh my god..are u guys seroius that massari is going to be performing in the up-coming prime?? i'm sorry im not tryin to be mean or anything.. i live in the states so i was wondering is massari very famous in the middle east?? i like him but he aint got a very good voice really but some of his songs are pretty nice..i met him here hes a nice guy, yet a bit conceited but what can u do..some people when they become a bit famous go crazy haha..so what a great example for the students to have massari (who has no voice) as role model on HOW TO BE A SINGER lol i mean look at massari and wael kfoury..big difference..aint it?? anyhow.. nelly, maysoon and even shurouq will end up leaving very soon and none of them will stay toward the end..lets face it ppl..there are better talents...like shaza..and mohammad qammah and can anyone tell me why sally is still there.. i mean she's so annoying and acts so ghetto for real!!

umm one more ?.. who is jawad? i dont think i ever heard of him..

HEY GUYS

I LIVE IN AUTRALIA AND I JSUT WATCHED the evaluation and i must day NELLY did not deserve to be a nominee and OMG OMG OMG hw slack and mean were they too MAYSOUN and NELLY....first bringing them relief making them so happy and then jsut like that breaking their hearts!!!!! THAT WAS SO SLACK....they could have atleast warned them that even though you are in the safe room you are not safe until the alst second...GOD did they seriously think that was funny?????????...because no one is laughing!

shaza,

PLEASE don't use such 'LooooooooOOOOooong' words otherwise your comment/s will be DELETED!

Same goes for everyone.

Thank you for your understanding.