Finally there's an end to this crap knwon STARAC 3

the most boring reality TV show ever

Although I DEFINATELY don't like Joseph yet I'm not intersted in Hany nor Hanaa So , this result is ok with me ;

After all he won the CRAP ACADEMY

By the way :

I did not even bother myself watch the prime

samyyyyyyyy

whatever joeeeeeee is the best and the crab is uuuuu and ur jealouse bez he is a star and to maney people like him u dont have to like him others doessss. get the hell out of hear and dont talk some piece of crab u crab.

yesssssssssssssssssss joeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee is the winerrrrrrrrrrrr god bless joe and lebanon and the others that voted for himmmm.

good luck haniiii and hanaaaaaa.

i want to watch the prime at night so badddd. wow

thanks
jessica

CONGRATULATION!!!!!!

I love u Joseph, specially after the Prime #15, and the song El Tannoura, you were magnificant.

Good luck in your future, and hope to see your neww CD in the market soon.

ya gama3a kol el-nas 3arfa en elmawdou3 cheat*cheat,wy awelhom lebanese..and all the ppl knows since a week en flouse elmasryn etakhdet le-joseph,and all our votes 4 hany goes to joseph..ya3ny MASR 29% !!!!ANY WAY FROM NOW ON ADINA 3REFNA EL-TITA..GHESH *GHESH WYL HEKAYA BA2ET ADEYA WATANEYA..AND FROM NOW THEY LOST OUR TRUST ON THEM.WY KDA KDA HANY BA2A STAR..WHETHER BA2A ETZALAM FY LEBNAN WY DOESNT GET HIS RIGHTS....3AZYNAK BA2A TGELNA YA HANY YA STAR YA AHLA STAR..MA3LESH ETZALAMT WYL KOL 3AREF,BAS ENTA KDA KESEBT KOL HAGA,KFAYA ENAK MASRY...THEY CANT UNDERSTAND ENENA HANWARYHOM YA3NY EH TKOUN STAR..MESTANEYINAK FYL-TOURNER...ENTA EL-NEGM ..YA STAR YA AHLA STAR.BENHEBAK AWY AWY AWY:)

Wow finally!!!!

Mabrouk mabrouk Joe and the best of luck...verrryyyyy happy for you!

from tunisie ila josephhhhhhhhhhhhhh
congratulation
your the best and we are happy that you get it
go on joseph
and i hope the tour is very very soon
good bless you joseph
you make your country very very proud of you and the other countrys are proud to

hanaa enti star w hani kaman
w e7na 3arfen eno kan fe ghich
bas ma3lich
netmanalkom etawfi9 nchallah
good luck
i love u hanaa

mabrouk zouzou!!! you deserve to be star !! you're the best alf mabrouk wgood luck to hany and hanae. daymane ghanilna tanoura ya abou zouz!!

Yes i'm so happy Jospeh won he deserved every bit of it he has an amazing voice and personailty. He represented his country well and won the hearts of everyone who watched him. Congratulations Joe I love you, you're awsome. I wish Hany and Hanna the best of luck. Joe is the sar foever and ever go zouzou!

Yay! Joseph won! I love his beautiful voice! He has so much talent! Good luck to all the other
students! Thanks to everyone who voted.

Mabrouk to Joseph, sorry for hana'eh She has beautiful voice always sang the most & hard songs, Hany was a good boy he thought if he works hard & knows his lessons he will be a winner, but he need it more imagination & charisma.

To night FADI looks bit down, our feelings that the LBC has destoy his charisma & sharm. Through a long period FADI he was like a storm everybody loves him but unfortunately the jeaoulousie of his friends& teachers were obvious. Stay strong Dear Fadi do not let them effect you & we are sure of your intelligence & we love so much here in AUSTRALIA.

Our admiration for you FADI will be forever & the best & bright future.

i m sooo happy for joseph, he deserve!! and hanae too , i love her so much and i hope for her a lot of good things !!!
congratulation lebanon :)

THIS IS CRAP. YOU ALL KNOW THAT IT WAS FIXED THERE IS NO WAY THAT JOSEPH GOT ALL THE VOTES.HANAA DESERVED TO WIN. IT WAS FIXED. HANY HAD THE LEAST AMOUNT OF VOTES AND EVERYONE TRYING TO VOTE IN AMERICA GOT RIPPED OFF CAUSE WE COULDN'T VOTE. WE ALL GOT NOT IN SERVICE MESSAGE.MOROCCO RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!1

congratulations joeseph you have made LEBANON PROUD! though i reallllyy love hanaa and she deserved to win very very much....it's ashame she didnt though joe deserved it too..the lbc have made it obvious that he was going to win and he did...

good luck hanaa
wish you all the best hani
love you maya
congratulations joe

Congratulations to Joseph !!!!

He is the best of the best, and he's the only one who deserves to win. For all of you jealous people saying that there was cheating for Joseph to win, you just have to clean your ears and listen to his magnificient voice, and you should know that from all around the world, and not only the arabic world, people are voting for Joseph and only Joseph. I am shocked that he only got 55% because he was supposed to get at least 99%. So maybe LBC cheated in the favor of Hani and Hanaa, and gave them a percentage so they won't be sad.

Joseph, a lebanese, won and he is the real star. Accept it and stop inventing stories. Be happy and proud to have such a star in the arab world.

Love U Joseph...

this was a horrible cheatting!how come egypt is 70 million all were voting like crazy,more then voting to 3ateya by far,,how come we take only 28%
and kast 3 days we were getting thank u 4 voting to josef when we voted to hany!!!no 1 helped us,,egypt is in shock!!!!

JAIMY FROM CAANNDA

lol i agree with u and those ppl who is saying that there were cheating they need to zip there mouyh there is no cheating they knowwww howwww nicee joeeeeeeeeeeeeee voice is.

thanks for all the ppl that voted for joeeee

lebanon is the best and were proud thanks to all the countries that voted for joeeeeeeeee he is the best congratulationnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn.

The prime was too obviouse that josef will win,fire works were prepared in batron,pple in batron were more than too much while in egypt and maghreb were shooting pple in a room very few,reportage about josef was too abviouse that he is the star!hilda asking him what r u going to do after the prime(celebrate),hilda saying that lebanon is not small country,any way we all have proof on our mobiles that thay replied by thank u 4 voting to josef but we voted to HANY!!!WHAT ELSE IS A PROOF?!!!!!!

LOOK..I LIKE JOSIEF AND ALL..BUT U CAN'T DENY THAT THE RESULTS WERE STRONGLY MANIPULATED..HERE IN EGYPT WE VOTED 4 HANY AND THEY SEND US A MSG SAYING THANK U 4 VOTING 2 JOSEIF..EVERY ONR HERE WAS VOTING LIKE CRAZY..WE HAVE ATLEAST 20 MILLION VOTES..SO JOSEF CAN'T HAVE WON FAIRLY..NOTE THAT JOSEF IS LEBANESE..ROLA IS LEBANESE...Z STAFF R LEBANESE AND LBC IS Z SAME..SO IT'S OBVUOS WE WERE CHEATED FOLKS..GOOD LUCK 2 ALL...

plz we need help we egyptians!!we were cheated like crazy,how come after hany getting 55% infront of fadi and shaima,fadi that won khalifa 70% and shaima that won reem,this prooves how hany is strong!then hany gets in the final only 28% is it normal,egypt is 70 million all voting like crazy to hany,plz hany mom do something!all egypt was carying not because hany didnt win because it was realy unfair,we were getting msg (thank u 4 voting to josef)while we r voting to hany,UNFAIR

LIKE I SAID BEFORE, LEBANESE PPL ARE ALL OVER THE WORLD NOT ONLY IN LEBANON.AND U HEARD KHALEEFA ASKING HIS FANS TO VOTE FOR JOSEPH..JUST BECAUSE UR MAD UR SAYING ITS CHEATING.IF IT WAS CHEATING THE FIRST YEAR MOHAMED 3ATEYA WOULDVE NOT WON AND THE SECOND YEAR HISHAM WOULDVE NOT WON.AND DONT BE MAD CAUSE HANI IS A STAR TOO. I WANTED HIM TO WIN SO HELL GET THE MONEY TO BUY HIS MOM A HOUSE ....AND 7ARAM HIS DAD PASSED AWAY LAST YEAR.IM SURE HES GOING TO HAVE THAT MONEY CAUSE HE A STAR NOW...GOOD LUCK TO HIM AND TO HANAA

even the camera in the prime was on josef all the time,giving him more songs,actualy he was treeted as the star before being the star!!all reportage concentrating on how great josef is,fire works prepared,hany was in shock didnt know that his votes went to josef and that we used to send 20 or 30 msg but nothing appears only josef,all egyptian programs annonced that cheating of lbc

CONGRATS LEBANON THOUGH HANAA IS MY STAR...im lebanese and i love joe but hanaa is fantastic and walla hazim she deserved it alot. i was hoping a girl will win this year..oh well they were all great...LOVing HANAA...cant wait to next season of star academy already....

well..some body explain why every time we vote 4 hany they send us a msg thanking us 4 voting 2 josef..if it was fair.egyptians would win every year..mated7akoosh 3la nafsoko..you know it..u wanted a lebanese 2 win so it happened..this is z first time a libanese make it 2 a final.i affirm he is talanted..but the votes decide..we voted..but we were deceived into voting 4 josef..ANY ANSWER ME..EXPLAIN..

HEY MESSENGER,

walah i agree with you but only GOD knows its not in our hands to save those women and children. most of us on here are just regular citizens who have gone through that or is experiencing it still. the people you should be mad at are the so called big guys. like saudia arabia who supports star academy financially to the fullest. allah yahdihom and bless those that are suffering everyday. they are always in my thoughts and i wish i could do something about it.

I like josef but hany was top 1 for 3 times never happened,very kind,nice voice,not acting on any 1,caring for every1,very frank and saying that he doesnt have money now while he was rich before!very happy of being in the academy,very polite.all egypt was proud of him and voted like crazzyy,,colleges,schools,clubs all voted hany more than atteya by far and over that we get msg thank u 4 voting to josef while we r voting to hany ya gam3a,what would u feel after all that when we find hany 28%

LOL GUYS IT IS SO OBVIOUS....
people okay we know you love JOE (so do i) but it is obvious that it has been all planned......
i am lebanese and i am admitting it.....I LOVE ZOU ZOU SO SO SO SO MUCH AND HANAA TOO and hani BUT there was cheating and thats obvious...

Evidence:
- the camera focused on joe mostly in the prime

- the fireworks were already made beforehand.. the lebanese people won't waste their money on them if they didn't know who the winner was

- he sang most in the prime even though HANAA and Hani both have great voices

- joe was given the most attention

- Hilda already had her script made..when she siad that LEBANON is not a small country

- when each of the finalists had a reportage about them JOES one was longer and they kept saying "can joe raise the name of lebanon", and all this stuff.

- even in the dailies the camera was always on joe

- the teachers knew he was going to win from lebanon because (especially gaby)they kept telling him to focus on your work and try harder, when he got carried away with REEM...

--------------------------------------------
SO IT HAS ALL BEEN PLANNED...hani would have beat both of them but the LBC are not going to let Egypt win twice...ALSO IF JOE DIDN'T WIN THEN THE LBC WILL LOSE MANY VIEWERS AND WOULD HAVE BECOME VERY UNPOPOULAR..meaning the next season won't succeed..and the LBC will lose money..

SO WELL DONE JOE HE DESERVED IT though i would have liked to see him win FAIRLY
AND PEOPLE DON'T SAY THAT THERE WASN'T CHEATING JUST BECAUSE YOU LOVE JOE...becuase i love him and im admitting it

GOOD LUCK HANAAAA!
AND HANI

who told u that the camera was on joe all the time he had the least number of songs in this prime while hanaa had the most then hani and plz stop "el kossa" topic that ur dicussing here and in melody joe is loved by millions of people not only in lebanon or in the arab world but even outside it iam egyptian and i swear thatme and a lot of my friends here voted 4 joe it is not a war it is only a game and about the fire works in batroun and people gathering in this large number i donot see anything suspicious in it batroun is joe's hometown and they were going to celebrate him even if he didnot win bec they see him as the star that is all and lebanon u r sooooo lucky 4 having joe .. good luck for ra2ya hani wajdy hana fedo and to all the other students they r a;; stars

THERE WAS CHEATING ITS OBVIOUS AND THATS IT/

Yes I think the show did alot of cheating this year but what can you do? That's the way rula works. Congrats to Joseph bc he does have a nice voice. What was really weird is that they refused to show Reem's face in any of the videos. What the hell is that about. Reem is so beautiful and sweet they should have respect for her! Damn rula.

special mabroooooooooook from oman to lebanon to josef and i knew that he will be the winner and he deserve it wallah ,i wish him all the best ......shayma looked so cute and beauty yesterday she was amazing and i love her so much and i love tunisian so much .....i am to shayma's
parents that u r lucky to have a wonderfull daughter......hana ya hana wht i can tell u is only one thing is u have to be natural like josef than u can win not acting ya hilwa i really dont like your attiude even if u have nice voice .....dont be jealous from shayma coz she is more better and pretty than uuuuuuuu.mabrooooooook ya josef and all oman and gulf love u .......if u go east or west shayma ,reem and josef are the best

I am sick and tired of all these losers of people saying nothing that really matter...Personally, I am ashamed of people who are still complaining, move on and get a life.
If it was Hanaa or Hani that had won, no one would have made of that a big deal..now give us a break, the guy won because he is smart,cute, talanted, and he deserved it...
If Lbc was cheating then Maya, the golden child of the Academy would have won the title..I would not have been mad, because I love her but personally, Joseph was way better than all of them in the academy..Good luck to the two others, they are also star but it would be nice and FAIR if the country that organizes all this program finally has one of his son win the title...Now you guys think Lebanese don't know how to sing, then too bad go listen to Fayruz, Magida El roumi and Wadeh El Safi...and also Melhem Zein who was supposed to be the winner of Super Star but never won..now please, tell me who is wellknow he or the other stupid lady that won/
And as for cheating, why no one said anything last year, when Amani was supposed to win and she did not...People always have a big mouth when it comes to the lebanese people succeeding...Too BAD, jOSEPH IS THE WINNER AND YOU GUYS WHO ARE PISSED ABOUT IT CAN CHUCK ON IT...ALL NIGHT, ALL YEAR FOR ALL I CARE...YOU ARE SICK...
LBC ROCKS, SO DOES MADAME ROULA, SO DOES HILDA, SO DOES ALL THE INSTRUCTORS, SO DOES LEBANON, SO DO ALL THE 9 GOING ON THE TOUR AND SO DOES EBEN LUBNAN, EBEN EL BATRONE, AND STAR ACADEMY 3...NO ONE OTHER THAN JOSEPH ATTIEH.....ABUL ZOUZZZZZ

please stop saying it was cheating because he is labaness coz we gulf we supported josef more than hany and hana.......so who ever say that its better to close his mouth

plz does anyone know the name of the song and the singer of the song zouzozu sang in the prime 4 maya???

Anyway

Mabrook Joseph

I dunno what to believe anymore about student voting.

If Fadi truley lost to Khalifa ,They should have shown the result .That would be only be fair to Fadi by the way.Getting up his hopes to 67% and then crushing him the next week to 9% is a very very dirty.Its some sort of revenge.

He is obviously still shocked and sadened.They ought be truthful from the start.by the way that was like the highest result ever after Hishams wooping 80% or higher.
He obviously looked very tired,dissappoind and he seemd downright forced to attend the prime.
Chaima did not look ok either.

about the lebanese girl who talked about the voting.You raised some pretty good arguments
Especially, the whole mofraka3at thing.

Yasse

Joseph has a beautiful voice. No matter what u r going to say about him. It is over. He is the winner. You Egyptians, you could spend the rest of your lifetime babbling, but it ain't getting you nowhere. So, open you ears and listen to their voices again, you might get a glimpse of the truth. "HOPEFULLY"

My best wishes to Joseph, Hanny and Hanna and CONGRATULATIONS to everyone of them.

TO EGYPTIAN GIRL
U R SUCH A LOOSER
U SUPPORTED JOE ,WHILE IF U HAVE GOT EYES U SHOULD HAVE SEEN HOW HANY WORKED HARD , HE IS PREFECT ,I WANT TO TELL THAT EACH TIME I HEAR HIM HE REMINDS ME WITH WALEED TAWEFEEK VOICE.
PLEASE CHANGE YOUR NICKNAME COZ I AM ASHAMMED THAT U R EGYPTIAN DIDN'T U HEAR AMR 2DEAB OR MOHAMOUD SA3D TALK ABOUT THAT DECENT TALENTED HANY.

joe you are the best .. congrats ,, you have the voice of a real star!!! you really deserved it

To Yasse

We do feel very sad for FADI > As you mention regarding FADI he does look crushed by the whole institution.

We hope FADI will not join the tour because these people caused him a lots of harm, but if he went with them he will be facing a lots of problems as emotional etc............... & his proformance is going to be average.

We are very much worry about FADI, he didn't get what he deserves.

We love you Fadi , you are one an a million(ASEEL)

You "EGYPT-HANY-EGYPT",
Let me make this clear for you.
If you scroll up, you'll see that even people from Oman, Gulf, Tunise..etc voted for Joseph. If i were you, i would accept the fact that he deserve to be in the 1st place. "TRUTH HURTS"

And in the end, it's not the Rank that counts. It's what you achieve afterwards.
So, BEST OF LUCK 4, Joseph, Hany, Hanna, Maya, Fady.........etc (Especially LEBANON).

May God Bless All Of You

PPL PPL GET OVER IT FACE THE REALITY JOE WON AND IF U SAY THERE WAS CHEATING FROM NOW TILL THE NEXT TEN YRS WE DONT CARE ALL WE KNOW THAT JOE IS #1. GOD U GUYS ARE SO JEALOUS I DONT KNOW WHY EVEN THOUGH IM LEBANESE I WOULDVE NOT CRYED LIKE THAT IF HANI WON.

Congradulations to the best star JOSEPH ATTIEH,because from the first prime when zozo went to stage he looked like a star and i wish that we will see him soon with his great musics and good luck to you joseph because you deserve it and you are the best.

listen too who ever is not happy with joe here in USA we all voted for goe even in iraq everyone did.me and my family callede like 1000 times sooo he did win fair ok and im happy for him

Congradulations again to ZOZO because he had made us very proud and good luck to the best star that is the man of my dreams.

It was clear from the begining that LBC were planning this year for Lebanon to win. I notice that all my messages and voting for hanaa were not displayed 99% of joseph were displayed so that to discourage the morocaans and the egyptian. It is 100% sure that Joseph did not won by votes but by LBC cheeting. There is now were that he won by votes no way. LBC were aiming from the begning for winner to be from lebanon to please its people, but it is not correct by cheeting. I do agree that he has nice voice but he did not win. LBC be fair and stop your cheating.

Egyptian Girl,

I don't know the name of the song but i think you can wait for a few days until it's posted in www.6arab.com

This way you can figure out the name of the song and you can download it as well =)

CONGRATULATIONS LEBANON.
CONGRATULATIONS JOSEPH.
REALY IT IS THE FIRT TIME THAT THE WINNER OF STARAC IS A REAL ARTIST.
BEST OF LUCK FOR:Hana,Chayma,Wajdi,Hani,Khalifa,Maya,Rim,Fadi,Rakia.

Joseph deserved to win, and he did win it hands down. The people who have voted to him were not all Lebanese, as a matter of fact, most voters were non-lebanese. SO if this is the case then the cheating accusations and all that crap that most on this forum have been blabbing about is false. Dont be sore loosers, the first 2 years of star academy didnt see a lebanese person win, even thou it is a lebanese show, and the director is Lebanese. So the crap comments of him winning because he is Lebanese are trully ridiculous, and I am sure the person who said that hasnt heard Joseph's voice. Remember that there are more than 10 million Lebanese all over the world, not only the 4 million inside Lebanon. So all in all, Well Done Joseph, you are a Champion.

I think the game was not fair from the beginning, LBC planned everything and this is exactly why Waleed decided to quit! he felt that LBC was manipulating! and did not want to continue in this dishonest environment! honest people like him cannot live in such places or with such people! i think he was right after all, and it was the best decision he has ever made!

On the other hand, Joseph was a Phenomenon, he was a chnace for LBC to finally present a Lebanese winner! he had the voice and the good manners. he lacked nothing but the majority of votes! the only missing thing was to guarantee that Lebanese will vote for him, which is not something they would easily do as we all know!
I love Joe and i was happy for him, but i still have my doubts regarding the votes!

People will start saying you have no evidence, yes you're right! but i am not holding a gun at your heads to believe what i am saying! we aren't trying to solve a twisted crime! we're here to share our thoughts and opinions. And this is exactly what i am doing right now!
I am just expressing my feelings, and you cannot do anything about it!

Finally, i want to wish Joe happiness, best of luck and success