WTF Fadi at NO 1 and Hanna at NO 4 this doesnt make sense I think it should be the other way around.

Bilal, I totally agree with ur comment, and so does EVERYBODY else. ... unless they're as blind as the "academy jugdes".
what can u do?...i Gotta go now, Maya is singing with the 4 cats, i'll see u all after the prime...I hope Chayma stays..bye guys

Hi
Mabroooooooook to Fadi.
I am sure he is now happy.He is been wanting to travel and go out from the academy since forever.

Anyway since I don't have the 24 channel and the dailies(I stopped watching the dailies from some time) I cannot judge if the names put are in the top five are the rightest chioces.
Someone who watches the 24 channel care to elaborate honestly if they have seen that Fadi works the hardest among the students mentioned in this week??
Not that I doubt the judges choices.I just wanna read some honest opinions about the subject

Yasse

i expected hany to be the 1st his evaluation was more than gr8888888888 keep it up hani

i just think that the jugments are NOT FAIR

Fadi number1?? WTF.. I can't believe this

come on , the prime didnt finish? can someone tell me who left the academy and what vas the public vote??
I couldnt see the prime today, I have a problem with my satelite

OMG Lou I had the same problem I didnt even watch it and Iam dying to know the result who got out and what were the percentages and who voted for who???

what the hell who is mohammed shoukri what does she means that stupid Chiama by mohammed shoukri??? I hate her
Chaima= anania, intihazia, mehssada... evil

Mohammed.F left because of Chaima for the people who don't know the result yet

Come on, be realistic people, they're not going to put Hani for the third time in 1st place. There going to give that chance to others. It was expected for Fadi to get to the first place eventually. During each prime he was climbing the top 5. I don't watch the Dailies or 24/7 but Fadi appeals to the audience and he has a certain style that most people like, it is obvious that he is also appealing to the judges.

can someone explain whats going on
what did cahyma say about mohamed who
and who left
i need to know
im in school andcan wait 3 hours to see it at home
hurry pleez
lool

M.Fahd is out.. he wanted it, he got it.
Glad Chayma is back.. the prime was okey, just fine. Rami Ayash is cute, 4 Cats ( any 4 cute girls can do what they're doing ).. Baha2 looked good, her song is cute.
Top 5 ...u all know! totally unfair. I like Fadi, I'm happy for him, but hey, it's still unfair to leave out Hanna, and few others who r much better than fadi.
Is Hanaa ever gonna be # 1??? I don't know 'bout that..we'll c.
Reportage about Maya was misleading.
One more thing, I think the camera man+director read all our comments about him, coz they're putting more butterflies, more hearts, and all kinds of stuff, they're focusing on Maya more than anybody else ( not that I have anything against her) AND in M.Jackson tableau, we couldn't see anything but the smoke and the birds or whatever effect that was.
they hate us, that's what i think :-)

I think they all deserve to be in top 5 but i don't know what is khalifa doing in there it's not like he perticipates in in any of his classes

Fadi doesnt deserve top 1 just to show you the discrimination especially against Hana and Chaima!beautiful voices!HANA be the top 1 next week,i hope the judges will clean their ears and listen next time,i am glad Maya isnt top 5 because she sings horrible.
Chaima should be on the top 5 not a nominee!yeah tell me she cant dance or act well Maya can dance and act but she cant sing yet she got the number 1 spot.Give me a break.
Joseph Hana Hani Khalifa well earned but Fadi no,HANI sang the best he should be top 1 this week but yes i dont think they would put him top 1 3 times although this is how its suppose to be the best wins but they want to give everyone their chance?ha bull!Give Hana her break then give the people with actual voices the top 1

I am quite happy with this prime, the top 5 was okay..but I really wanted hanaa to reach first, well theres always next week, I'm happy for zou zou but he has to concentrate a little more..reem has been distracting him so much..I really am starting to dislike her soo much..oh and maya..wow I shoudn't even start..

shamia and mama mohamed shoukri is mohamed ibrahim his name is mohammed ibrahim shoukri and shoukri is his last name okey i am sorry that you'll can't watch because you'll are missing out alot in the academy

go fadi u deserve every thing, u rock, u r da best

To all the guys

Hana will be the top one next week.
So don't worry about her.

Why would a program based in lebanon discriminate against Hana and Chyma and be biased toward Fadi.
Fadi is palestinian after all.With all due respect to everyone here if we wanna be realistic about it and made politics a part in this discussion then the lebanese perfernce will be toward Hana,Joseph and others more than fadi.

Aout Hana maybe elissar is the one behing her not being top one.Fadi has shown improvement in all teachers classes though I bet/am sure he is not any of the teachers' favotite.
Wadee3 may like hanna most.Elissar likes maya.
Gab likes Khalifa and all the teachers like Hani(he was top one twice)but maybe all agreed to give Fadi a gift at improving in each class admitedly he may not be the best in them.
Its all about improvment and appeal with the teachers.I am sure if Hana got better in dancing class and after her performance in the prime today she will be the next top one.

Yasse

Yasse and Katie,

Well put, I could not agree more. For those of you who are worried about Hana, she will be number one very soon if not next week. I mean she just started coming out of her shell. Great voice, one of my favorite actually.

As far as Fadi is concerned, he has been working hard, he acts and has the star look. He is very charismatic and he has been very helpful towards everybody, he did a great job tonight, everybody likes him and has an amazing and loyal fans who adore him.
So you bet your ass he deserves it.

And to Dandoonah, What is your problem with Fadi, where the hell are you from?? you want to talk about discrimination. Let me tell you that the Palestinian people have been discriminated at more than any race of people in this world. No body would have been able to put up with it as much as we have, so before you make stupid comments like that you need to know what you are saying because that is a very sensitive topic and I do not care how much time you spend on this site, I used to respect your opinion until now.
You always had mixed feelings, but what did he get that is different than so many students who have been number one or got something that they did not deserve or is it that because he is Palestinian?? Give it a rest and give credit when it is due, after all, the teachers are the ones who are ones who know what they talking about!!

To Johnnie
How are you doing
Its been a time since I last heard from you.
In a matter of a fact I just talked about you with Mona.

Anyway
Everyone is entitled to his own opinion when it comes to who deserves the top one more.Nothing wrong with that.
dandooneh felt that others deserve more no problem
all the people she mentioned are excellent and are great candidates to fill the number one slot as well.
But I doubt that a lebanese program will
exactly be biased to fadi who holds a palestinian watheeqa and given the palestinians general treatment in lebanon.I don't understand how the program can be biased toward fadi and discrimantory towards chyma and Hana.
Hell I am sure if we ask the general lebanese public.Hana and Chyma will most probably be more prefered and beloved by the audeince compared with Fadi.Man I dislike bringing politics in to star academy discussion but your comment about discrimination brought this up.

Anyway
all take care
Yasse

fady u deserve it baby
go on and be the best
we all love u in palestine
goo fady good

To Yasse,
Good to hear from you, It's been a while, any way I appreciate your comments and support.
It's frustrating to hear crap just because something did not go the way sombody hoped. Believe me I hate politics as well.
No one is taking credit from anybody. Chaima was bad during the last evaluation 40 sec, not good enough despite the voice, no acting no dancing. Hana needs to improve in those areas also. It a talent show not just a singing show. Hani already won twice, Joseph only once and that was last week.
Any way stay in touch
take care
J

Hey Johnnie
Don't worry

Yes
Chaya's nomination was pretty much expected to me.
Don't you guys tell it ain't fair.The teachers gave her countless of times to give more in other fields and not be completely dependant on her voice(great/beautiful). Wadee3 always keeps repeating how a beautiful voice she has but lacks the expressions and whatnot and Gab obviously does not see her that good in acting.Elissar,we all understand Elissar.

I am happy she returned.She has a great voice already if she worked on the other areas.she'll be in the top five very soon.I am sure its easier for her than the others because already mashallah she has a nice voice.she has a chance now.
she is good.Let her stay more focused and she'll be in the top five.i am sure that the teachers will notice her effort.

Yasse

I think the discrimination was more about discrimination towards the females within the academy and not especially about nationality. Seeing as it's usually a majority of males in the top 5, the person who made the statement has a point. One should always try to distinguish between the different types of discrimination rather then to assume always that it's one of nationality. Sexism is a legitimate argument under the circumstances. Nonetheless i can't say that the girls are doing a good job of representing themselves in the best light.

top 5 is not bout da best voices but bout max. improvement. compare fadi in da 1st week with da fadi dat he is now.he's da 1 who improved da most.in da classes, hes workin hard. in da evaluation, he dares. in da prime,he makes his presence felt.
fadi is not da best. but give da guy a break. i mean he's been makin alot of progress lately n he definitely deserves 2 b top 1.

congrats fadi.

yaaay .... go go go fadiiii....we love u & we dont care what others say ...u deserved it.... Thank u yasse & jonnie for the support...keep it up

how does this silly fadi in top .. what the hell with the teachers?? don't they see his rubish voice ,, he just all the time be out the tones and almost (Ynashiz)...he is bas in Arabic singing as well as English ....as well as he is bad in acting , dancing and everthing ...why they still stand him in the show ...he must be nominee for his bad appearnce ...he has nothing related to the talent ...i will loose my temper from that unfair teachers who just will plan to keep him with that silly hani till the final 8 ....

at least in starc 1 and 2 , the teachers just keep the best ones to join the final 8 ,, even there were the best 9 in starc1 even though the order of the students were not fair such as Ahmadsherif deserve to be number one more than attia ,,,and amany deserve to be numnber one more than Hisham but at least the best 8 stay till the end ...while this silly starc3 will keep the worst ones till the final 8 such as fadi and hani rather than wajdi or walid ( who just withdrawal from the show bcoz the unfair treatment in the academy,, as well as unfair top5 in each week) or Mokha,,, and they will keep Maya till the final despite that she is 'not deserve that at all and 4 sure they will get ride of either Reem or Rakia these weeks before the final 8....this is really unfair and very bad game ,,,therefore the khaligi people use to not waste anny penny for that dirty game

i think that fady and hany aren't deserve their place in the top .. they must be nominated rather than being in the top ... really unfair

I didn't hate in whole my life someone as the same as Fadi, Bashar qaissi, Hani , Bashar Shatti and Fahad al-Zaid.... they are the most terrible ones who make the show so disgusting espacially alshatti and Fadi who are totally stupid a nd sucker ..

fady must be nomineee , not in the top as well as Rakia, hani and maya ,, they are the worst ones ...why they use to nominate reem and moh'd ibrahim all the time and am sure that reem and Moha'd ibrahim are the nominess for next week despite that there are many ones who are really bad as the same as fadi, rakia , maya and hani ..I can't stand this unfair top each week ...what the hell with the teachers??? are they blid ?!! how they put fadi number one he is the worst one i ever seen even Ahmad Al-Sherif who is the best in whoe starac1,2&3 but he didn't get number one in the top bcoz of that unfair teachers and that ugly Rola Sa3d...and now Ahmad Alsherif is number one in his success above all starc studnets and superstar candidates ...this dirty Fadi will do nothing later in art media ,, he will just add more sucks as the same as the sucker singers like Jad Shuiri, haifa, Marwa, Ruby ....etc....., and i just want to know what hani or maya or...etc will offer later , the answer is nothing except more sucks and dirts to the arabic art, they will not serve the arbic art nicely ...i hope the teachers must release their mistake of keeping someone like fadi or maya or hani or shukri....etc...this is the most unfair starc , i ever seen

the worst ones are Moh'd Ibrahim, fady and Hany...why they still there in the academy ..at least moh'd fahad has a star style and has acceptable voice and carizma and can dance amazing !! ..... i can't emagin any one of them in the final 8 bcoz really no one of them really deserve to be with the final 8

I think that it is not nescessary to keep 4 girls and 4 boys till the final bcoz the remaing 5 girls are really good while the boys are not good at all except Joeseph, khalifa as well as mokha and wajdi but they had already leave ...

it is not important to keep the number of girls equal to the number of bous bcoz this is about talent and only the best ones must join the final 8 even if all of them are girls and only two or three boys with them bcoz the reamaing boys are totallyaren't deserve to be with the final and the good ones just leave such like walid , wajdi ..etc

i suggest to LBC that they put 4 girls ain the final 8 and 2 boys who are Joeseph and khalifa and the other two could let the people and the audiance to vote for two of the boys to join the students for the tour and i hope they will be wajdi and walid or Mokha...bcoz as u said the remainig 5 boys are not deserve to be with the final 8 ecxept Gozeif , khalifa and alittile bit Mohammad Ibrahim ...while I can't agree to keep fadi or that girly hany till the final ..it will be unfair !

they make me laugh ...how Fadi is number 1 while hanna2 is number 4 and Shaima is nominee ..this is really doesn't make sence !! the academy this year doesn't appreceate the good voices such as Shaima, Hana2, Joeseph( he must be number 1 for the second week rather than that silly fadi) even hani doesn't deserve to be asslan with the top students , he is not talent at all ...the judges are really blind...I afraid that they will keep ignoring the best voices as they did before with Ahmad sherif and baha and then let another attia or abu el hish to win ...LBC is always in the same raw of cheating

they put fadi in the top1 as if he merical student and they will give him a trip as a gift for his sucks... as if they want to tell the students to be more suckers in order to put u in the top 1..this top is really doesn't make sense..4 what they put fadi as top1.. i think there asr serious problem with the teachers eyes and ears ,,can't they see the guy can't sing at all , can't act , ....etc

i think there is discrimination in treating the students as the same as what happened in starc1 when they didn't treat ahmad sherif and cyntia and brono..etc in suitabl way while just use to focus on what happend to attia , and what the hell happend with bashar and sofia ,,,etc.... and in starc2 when they just focus on zizi new style and katia new hair and her stupid story with al-Qaisssi while ignoring the others and ignore hisham and didn't enter him in the top excepte once,,, the same thing happened this year when they use to put hani and maya each time in the top even if they don't deserve ...and now they enter that silly fadi in the top despite he is poor in every thing ...why this discrimination against the great voice and hard work students just like Ahmad sherif, Hanaa, shaima....Really UNFAIR

Johnnie my opinion about Fadi not deserving to be number 1 isnt because he is palestinian because there are others who deserve it WAY MORE. And there is nothing sensitive about saying Fadi doesnt deserve the top 1 lol,what's sensitive about that? we all have opinions learn to accept them.
Just because you are Fadi's uncle or whatever doesnt mean you have to defend him at every chance,and why only mention me? There are many here that are agreeing that Fadi doesnt deserve it,this is discrimination. Palestine has nothing to do with why Fadi doesnt deserve to be top 1,you are twisting up things for sympathy,how sad.
Yasse Fadi is a Lebanese to LBC and anyway he lives in Lebanon and has many friends and fans and he has a love triangle with Maya LBC's favorite and Viviane,so its obvious why they would give him extra treatment to get money and ratings!its obvious

why the teachers give a chance to fady to enter the top and now be number 1 while they didn't give that chance to reem despite she did very well when sang with wajdi ( JAM JAM) in the evaluation as well as she did very well in that week when walid leave .......the teachers just put reem as nominee and now put shaima as nominee despite that both of them are thousand of times bettere than that stupid fadi or maya..... and I don't know 4 what all the teachers like Hany,,, he is not good in any of the classes except dancing class...despite that they put him twice in the top 1 ... the guy is not talent at all ,,,and all his capabilities are limited ,,even he has no apperance and no carizma... can't u see how he disapperead when someone come to visit them ,,he has no reaction at all and he just keep calm bcoz he is fraid to be asked to sing while his voice is ugly to let sber reba3i or Ramy 3iass or who ever to lestin at him , he just use to do that silly acting each time when the singers come to the academy ( Mashhhad feen el-Shantah)....this guy is really silly ,,, and has nothing to offer or add to the academy atmosphere ..He is a real kombarss ...i hope that the teachers opened their eyes and ears to know how to judge in correct way , not puting the most dump students in the top !!

welcome back khalifa to the top 5!

the nomination must be amoung moh'd Ibrahim, Fadi, rakia, hany or maya ,,otherwise it will be unfair

yes, your right but also reem..but I don't think fadi yet,probably the week after.

i love u haniiiiiiiiiiiiiii
u deserve to be number 1 in the top 5
ur evaluation is very good
u r the best
go hani go hani go hani
go hani go hani go hani go hani
i love onlyyyyyyy
haniiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
jousef
hani u r rock
go hani go hani

i love u hani hani u r the best
i love u hannnnnnnnnnnnniiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
hani deserve 2 be number 1 in top 5
and he deserve to be with the last 8
and fadi doesnt deserve to be number 1 he may be number 5 not 1
go hani go hani go hani u r the best u & jousef

Dandooneh,

I like people to be fair, and you have been consistantly on Fadi and Maya's case for a long time and I never responded to you because I did not care, but now you got on my nervous because you never want to give credit to anybody hardly.
What's wrong with Fadi getting number one for once. I mean he has improved for the past 9 weeks in every category and all the students and teachers like him. Some of the others have not improved and it shows. I mean other than Hana, no one else deseved it. Hani got it twice and Joseph got it last week. Chaima is not doing what they want her to do, voice is not enough and her eval was not good and very short. Rakiya's haveing a hard time being there. So other than Hana it was fair.
This has nothing to do with sympathy and please do not play mind games with me, I'll run circles around you. Pay attention and be nice. Or more like be fair. Fadi already has an amazing popularity world wide and the recoginition as well as the contacts to do what ever he wants. This is about being fair for once, because despite the improvements you do not give credit. You are fixated on the Maya thing. You are entitled to your opinion, but why does it have to
be so negative all the time. Can't you enjoy the show without offending anybody who is involved in the show? I mean everybody!!

Fady's good but hes not as good as Joseph!

but mabrouk fady and joseph!

hey guys u should accept everything in starac, wajdi being out, moukha refusal of doing his evaluation, and the teachers choices for the top 5.
the teachers are the ones who are expert in singing and dancing and are the ones who can realize the improvements of the students so do not give ur suggestions abt who should be in top 5 and whose not.
do not hate chaima cos she didnt choose moukha,do not hate rym cos she kicked many students out, do not hate fady cos he is top1,do not hate the teachers cos they didnt choose hanaa to be number one this week, this is ridiculous guys.
u saw what happened between zizi and amani's fans.
accept each student as he is, just vote for the one u like and never hate the others. do not hate khalifa for being black do not hate fadi cos he is palestian, do not hate rym if u used to hate her sister salma, do not hate rakia for her way of dressing and etc etc etc

johinne
dandoosh likes walid she thinks he is the best but she hates fady
but the poor girl forgot that both of them are palestinian ....
the thing is walid sucks in dancing, acting and he is the king of nachaz as osamah alrahbani said once but bcoz he said that he's jordanian she thinks he's better than anyone....

by the way the stupid freak is jordanian that's why she hates fady ...!! u got my point.
she always say that this show is not about nationality but she is a big lier ...
i never wanted to replay to her coz in my life i don't deal with 2 faced people but she needs to get kicked in the head maybe she will wake up for a while ..

go fady we love ...all the palestinian are proud of you..

who is dandoosh, and why her name is sound giy name.

so she is strik about palastines, i love palastines people, the one hot is fady, he is great acting and have sexy voice that i ever heard.

To Aline,

That is exactly my point. like or love and support whom you want, no need to hate and insult everybody else. They have come a long way.
Enjoy the show and have fun. Focus on funny things instead of stupid things that have no meaning and it's nothing but a waste of time. Have a positive on everything in the show and in life as well.

To Yasse, and to just someone,

Joseph's voice is better than Fadi's no doubt. Joseph has an amazing voice actually and I like listening to him. But I also like Fadi's voice and the fact that he can sing different types of music in Arabic and in English.

To Nado,
I agree with everything you said, well put.

No descrimination in Star Academy No 3.
All the teachers are fair.
It is Great Show.
FADI he's a Star ALL over.
(Strong Voice,Sense of humour, Maturity,A real Man,Galant,Intelligent,Personality)
A Person with all these gifts has to be a star.
We Love FADI GO......................to the top.

If we could vote for the 10 contestants now i think this will be the results:
1_reem 20%
2_hani 16%
3_hana 12%
4_khalifa 11%
5_chayma 10%
6_rakya 9%
7_joseph 7%
8_moh'd 6%
9_maya 5%
10_fadi 4%

Well but i hope :
1. reem
2. chayma
3. hana
4. hani
5. joseph
6. fadi
7. rakya
8. maya
9. khalifa
10. moh'd i

by the way...reem is da best

Shadi