i can't stand him.he thinks he's funny when he's really not.and he is always against haitham(my favorite)

i don't like him.. he's really against the palestinan constentant maybe cuz it has to do with politics..
leave politics aside... he's soo unfair...

duuuuhhh !!

he is a pathetic and creep

i think his great cz he says the trueth his good judge

I hate ziad so much.

i dont wish to make even a comment about this guy, its not worth my time.

I think Ziad has some good comments but sometimes he's OVER!! sometimes he thinks he's funny when he's really not but other wise...he's good!!

all the negative coments posted about him are soo true!! when ppl laugh at his retardedjokes, he tends to repeat them, and did anyone else notice that he tries to be as funny as the host, ayman, but it doesn't work!!

OH MAN...I CAN'T STAND HIM...can't stand his voice...can't stand anything about him...I don't even know why the hell they brought him this yr! He tries 2 be a Simon Cowell..but it ain't working! He needs 2 go home! (fumes comin' out of my head lol)

hes too harsh! i dont care if hes truthful (though hes not) he cant tell a good voice from a bad one!

he think that he is funny, but its not!!!!!
o my god!!!!!
he is not himself!!!!

sarah from the Netherland

nana i have to agree with u i like the guy also and hes the judge he has studied music all his life and he is telling the truth but sometimes he can be mean like he was with ayman the guy that is the talk host on the show that pissed me off because if i was ayman who i love so much i would of walked off but when he talks to the singers he is right sometimes and no one is racist so give ti a break people d***

superstar3 is boring

oh please!don't tell me no one is racist cuz fadia sure is she is always saying bad comments about haitham and the same thing about ammar last year.she always has something about the palestinians.she never even said 1 bad thing about nancy and she's not always perfect.but i can't stand fadia or ziad but i like the other 2.
iraqi noor u r totally right because ziad is trying 2 be like simon cowell

come on guys..give 'em a break...sure he's really silly sometimes..and tries to be simon cowell...but pleeeeease...dont turn it politics now ..is it a hobby some people relate everything to politics...it gives me a headache!!!I don know maybe he doesn't meen to be so cruel..but not that seriously!!

I think Superstar was great before Mr. Perfect (Ziad) appeared onto the screens of every home in the Middle East!!!!! I think he nothing compared to elias al rahbanee... I dont think that adding him to the judges did anything!!!!

Ziad is being so rude... I think he was broght up a society where they made him think HE IS perfect... But unfortuanity he IS NOT!!! I think he is just making comments and idiot remarks just so he can show that he understands in music....

I reapeat... He is being so RUDE in the way he is talking to the contestants... Let him look at Elias Rahbane & Abdullah & fadia!!! and learn from them before he even say a word!!!!

Even if he understands in music.. I dont think he has the right to say remarks that emmbarse the contestants.. At least he must say his stupid remarks not on TV!!!

We need to inform future tv about this useless man!! He thinks he is the HEAD of the Juries!!! He is not!!!

Zeid,

u gusy say that they are racist all of u guys are racist all u guys is is haitham just because his palistinian dont u guys think that there are other people out there also and fadia did say bad comments to nancy and to every other person and so did ziad zeina used to love the tunis girl that just left asma he didnt like nancy is that also being racist ??? this has nothing to do with the freaking politics u guys put politics in it thats why i hate watching super star cuz no one listens to voices people look at what country they are from and its not fair because like lebanon is this small country that barley has people in it and people are barley living at this time but every opne else is able to vote and they are way bigger in population then lebanon and i dont thibnk votes are fair in anyway me i love all the contestens smala 3alyon ma ashtaron kill wahad momayaz bi sawto i hate this racisim wlo its too much no one is racist and plus let the judges be racist what if they are ?? huh its not like they are picking whos out or in and if they were why hasnt any lebanese person won? or reached the top two u guys want someone to win vote dont blame the judges and zida thats just how he is and always have been if u knew him before just get used to it ignore him just like every one in super star dose and haytham isnt even listening to him why are u guys fliping out just relax u love someone vote dont say anyone is racist haram wlo 3anjad haram

i hate ziad,i've always hated ziad,and i always will hate ziad.
because its exactly like zeid hreish said he says these silly things to make it seem like he knows about music.or he's tring to be like simon because simon it what makes the show (american idol)and he's tring to make superstar better by being like simon, he wish in my oppinion the person who makes the show is ayman the host because he's being his self and not being totaly fake like "some ppl" (and pure heart, were not the racests, we are just sayin the truth about what's going on in superstar and its the truth whether u want to admit it or not.)

i dont like him. he thinks he's soo funny
omg cant stand him

hes really good because he tells the truth about Haitham which is that HE IS RUBBISH.

That is the truth and u all need 2 open up your eyes and see his GAYNESS because i homestly cant understand how you all can like haitham . I CANT STAND HIM AND HE IS A DISGRACE TO PALESTINE!

listen ribena, keep ur rude comments to ur self cuz if i was to say everything i got to say, i bet u wont be happy either. but i got common sence, and i know better than to say crap like that cuz no matter what happens, i still respect peoples oppinion, and i believe everyone's eyes are already open and seen 4 thamselfs they dont need u to tell them what to do. just cuz thats ur oppinion doesnt mean everyone needs to go along with u.

TO RIBENA

FIRST HAITHAM IS NOT RABISH ..IT IS YOU THAT CAMES FROM THE RABISH ,
WE ALL PALESTINIAN LOVE AND LIKE HIM AND DO NOT NEED YOU TELL US ANY THING .OK STOP ABOUT HIM .. AND WE ALL THE TIME EVERRY WHERE AND ALWAYS WILL VOTE TO HIM INSIDE PALESTINE AND OUT SIDE IT ALL OVER THE WORLD HE GOT'S TELL NOW THE HIGHEST VOTEING .. GO HAITHAM ..AND ZEID IS NOT BAD .. HE KNOWS THAT HAITHAM WILL STAY TO THE END SO HE IS TELLING HIM TO DO BEST IN THE FUTURE.

ribena,

u need 2 shut your mouth and stop talkin crap about haitham.the only reason ur sayin that is cuz the person u want 2 win doesn't have the most votes and ur just jealous.so keep ur retarded comments 2 yourself.

I just want to mention that all those guys is super Star are good. I am not Lebanese but I think that Ziad or Fadia’s comments are not from Rasism point of view. Ziad was really hard on Nancy one time. Everybody in that situation wants people to follow his comments. If they don’t he will be little pissed. If Ziad and Fadia were against Haitham, we would’ve not saw him to the finals. Haitham has a nice voice but he gets exited where they wanna train him not to. I think Ziad is hammering on him because he wants him to be better. I sometimes don’t like the way Ziad make comments. Generally, you need somebody that is harsh like Simon. Elias is very mild . Abdallah and Fadia are more professional in the way they comment. I think that fadia and Abdallah are the best.

and whether haitham jumps up or blowes a kiss thats by business who i want to win,he doesnt have to be like fadl shaker for me to like him. so mind ur own business open up ur eyes to the fact that ppl have different oppionions.

GO GHADEER

THANKE YOU FOR EVERY THING AND PALESTINIAN PPL WITH YOU AND WILL BE HERE FOR YOU ..

so many bad comments about this guy!

ok first of all ppl... dont look at it in a racist way... look at the contestants.. HATHEYM has thee nicest voice... and he`s soo cute on stage.. even if he blows kisses and jumps up and down thats just the way he is.. and i love that bout him... besides he`s only 19 he`s not in he`s 30s or 40s for him to be jumping up and down like (fadel shaker, ragheb and assii) even tho i love them.. he`s himself THATS WHAT EVERYONE SHOULD UNDERSTAND even the judges .. they cant change a person.. soo if they have rude comments about hathyem they should keep it to themselves..
and i think the only reason they always mention what he does is cause there is nothing to say about him..!! so they just say shitty comments!! but who cares what stupid ppl say.. hathem is the only one on superstar that amuses me when im watching.. the rest r also amazing. but hathem has a speacial personality that everyone loves.. whether ur plastinine or not!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
soo vote hathem ppllll ... he makes an awesome superstar......
OH and if hathem becomes [popular) which INSHALLal he will ... i dont think he`ll be jumping up and down when he`s old and even if he ... its soo cute.. like look at tony hania.. i seriosely love this guy now.. and he`s what in he`s late 60s.. and he jumps lol... blows kisses... ;)

HATHEYM WAAA bass
we love u habibiiiiiiiiii
and we will always vote for uuu
keep doing what ur doing ... muahhh

I CANT STAND HIM ,,,, I HATE HIS COMMENTS HE HURTS THE CANADATIES,,, and his not funny at all,,,, and specially the last prime when he told haitham he made three mistake,,, he send it in very very mean way ,,,, i cant stand him,,, min wein jabouli yeh ??

Heyyyy
what can i saaaaaaaaay ZIAD BOTROOS U SUCK!!1 WORD honestly you have no manners and think ure better than all,when ure not,go fix ure face and ure look and the way u talk before giving bad comments about ppl that are so better than u!!lek khara 3alek min fo2 la ta7et w min wara la edam!!!!!Inshallah el kil eli bi superstar iyta3mook kharahon !!!roo7 t3alam el adab w ba3den ta3a i7ke,hope ziad reads this message so he can eat shit for once!!!

oh my god ,,, u guys u dont need all this ,, first i'm lebanese and i have fan club for haitham i dont care about the nationalty but i like haitham and i think his very cute and sweetheart,,,, it dosent matter where are u from guys,,, its superstar we support the one we like and we dont care about anyother things,,, everyone in this world have his/her own opnion so lets just dont care and support the one we like and not care about any one who post messages about haitham or anyone else ,,, and as u see guys i had post my opnion about zaid and as i said i just cant stand him ,,,,, he soo mean ,,,, thanks

.... does everyone realize how every opinion topic ends with a fight, and people being mean to each other ? why ? why cant people respect what other people think ..... everyone has to accept the fact that people have different tastes. if you're not mature enough to accept this then maybe you shouldn't be commenting on this topic. using bad words doesnt make you strong, it makes u look stupid.
later.
oh and i like ziad . i think he's honest . thats always a good thing

I do not Like Haitham not because of where he comes from but I feel like he comes across as a tryhard I do not know I hope he does not win, I hope the Iraqi guy wins if not Nancy or shahd.ZIAD can be lame but at least he is not a suckup like some of the other judges.

umm.. I think Ziad is ok not bad but sometimes when he gives some one an advice and that person doesnot do he gets really mad and thats something negative about him

no one could beleive how much i hate this a*s hole, he doesn't have to (sharshe7) the candidates on tv or yetfalsah, he could talk to them back stage and just point out their positive points on air.! fu*k him!

I HATE THIS JUDGE LET HIM GO TO HEELLLL

PALESTINE KHAWA HE HATES PALESTINE

1)Ziad is not acting like professional.
2) He is so rude to all contestant not to just one or two or five.
3)He can catch some of the mistakes they do which i agree with him, but he does not have to be so rude on air. He can mention these comments behind stage.
4) He has a lot to learn. I hope he start acting like Elias, Qaoud, And Fadia.
5) Ayman Qassouni probably the best talk show host I ever seen on an arab TV. I am impressd with him. I wish I have such a talent. Yet we see dislikes from Ziad to Ayman. And I bet every one like Ayman. Why not Ziad? Why all the contestantlike Ayman but not Ziad?
6) Ziad is boring with his jokes. I hope he recognizes that one day. I doubt it though. He is Dum.
7) He is trying to show that he knows better. But in fact he knows shit.
8) IF he wants to be fair he should say not only the bad things they do, but also the good things they do. Which never did. Any student needs to be praized when he does something right. Ziad does not recognize that.
9) He is a drawback to the show.He is always negative. Hi bad comments is alwyas diappointing to the contestant.
10) The big big super star TONI HANNA did not agree with his comments. That will put a seal on him.

His stupid un clear comments caused the most lovely voices to go out of programm, the two tunisen girls and the morocan guy. Ziad you are not cute and you are acting and harming the candidates. stopppppppppppppppppppppppp!!!!!

you guys.. were arabs.. we should repect each other and have manners.. we dont neeed to swear at eachothers..
everyone has his/or her own opinion,.....
and even tho i never lived in the arabic world.. i no that arabs are known for there respect....
soo common guys... plzz dont fightt...
GOO HATHEMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM&& AHMADD
i love uuuu tooo

Ziad Butros... I LOVE YOU
HE IS THE BEST JUDGE :)

I LOVE HIS COMMENTS, I LOVE HIS WAY
I LOVE everything about him...

im with you seniora i like him alot he is direct about his words and he knows what hes talkign about its not like hes lieing hes just saying whats on his mind and its soo true

I think that Fadia is more prejudice than Ziad. She is always giving haitham a negative comment on top of a good one that she throws as nothing. She gives all the others highest marks or is easier on them with her comments. I think Ziad is almost as difficult as her, but she is the worst especiallywhen it comes to Haitham, she can never just say, Haitham you were wonderful...

you are racist je vous deteste hatim is the best il est le prince du monde arab va te faire foutre ok

WOW! and i thought i was the only one that hated him.(im not even a drop in the bucket)

je deteste les paletiniens, et tout le monde qu'ils le supportent. ils ont detruient notre pays , vas tu faire foutre

I have nothing against him he's just a judge nd nothing else !
plzz guys i missed the last superstar extraaaaaa :§
can I have a breif resume ?!?!?!

To the person who disagreed with the politics comments don't criticize people for no reason. People don't like to exaggerate just for the fun of it. When something involved racism and politics people often feel it because we all wish racism doesn't exist so trust me no one would exaggerate abt it. And the thing about haytham is sooo true. Haytham is so great - warm personality, unique voice, nice presentation. So how come they pick on minor things when everything the guy does is almost perfect. Please the other day when ziad found nothing to make look bad he picked on the kiss. It's cause the voice was amazing n stupid Ziad found nothing to comment on. Listen guys I'm lebanese and I still agree with u that those judges tend to have a thing for palestinians. Like last year in several occasions Elias sort of ignored 3ammar (who was my fav! i love him) When 3ammar's turn came Elias would say these stupid stories of his and not actually comment on 3ammar's presentations which were always stunning. But oh no they used to praise that Ayman sometimes for no reason. N ya guys think about it how could ayman win who came from Libya which is far from the middle east, headquarters of the show. The guy also stood in the dangers zone few times while 3ammar who's palestinian and had everyone love him didnt win. Btw, 3ammar never stood in the dangers zone!! So ya ladies n gents, it's all politics. N please keep in mind that in ayman's case, the Libya trip was right before the last episode of Superstar. The contestants visited other arab countries but tell me if they met the president when they went to Syria or when they went to Jordan, but they sure met the president when they went to Libya. Am gonna leave the rest to u ppl cause ur wise enuf. When u figure it out, please keep in mind that we cant let this happen again public opinion in the arab world just keeps being controlled by politics so VOTE FOR HAITHAM and prove to them that we can choose who DESERVES IT AND THT'S HAITHAM!!

iysalim ilsanik ya perla.