i think they both have no talent or stage talent...
who agrees

I think that they were invited to one of SA primes. Their song was horrible. In particular, the guy must do something else in his life than singing...

PS. Merci Marcella, saches que ça me fait énormément plaisir d'interagir avec une personne aussi cultivée que tu l'es:)

I agree with you libangirl:)

i like the songs melody and some of the words even though its kind of weird but i think bushra should stick to acting too

stop it u guys the song is amazing and i love it and they are both talnted so shat your mouth and stop talking to people in a bad way u guys are hrabal

Well, I think your making a big deal attacking the song. The song is AWESOME and its got a melody and a tune to it. If doesn't attract a bunch of people who doesn't seem to listen to the lyrics of the song. At least the song is dedicated to children and offspring! There's a huge value of this song, Bushra proved she has vocal capabilities and Esseily is so creative. So H.A.R, Walid and LibanGirl appreciate that there's other people who like the song and don't go babbling injustice stuff.

I JUST WISH THEY HAD RUBY DANCING IN THIS SONG AND CLIP TOO :) WOW THAT WOULD BE HEAVEN :)

ok, MOI.... u really ARE wierd..... ya, so i thought that when they came to SA, the guy seemed to have probs singing... like when he went to the lower notes... it seemed like he was struggling... personally, i dont like the song... but it doesnt mean it sux... it just means that its not my style, and i dont wanna go insulting them, cuz i wouldnt want people insulting my hard work :P

I like the song!

the song is gr8 and awesome so stop it you guys
and by the way we always hear the song bcoz its nice that's the answer if you wanted to know why

gr8 song guys keep that work

I think both Mahmoud El Iseli and Bushra are not good singers, they even don't follow the notes of the songs. That's why oussamma el- Rehbani says when he was evaluating the prime in starac. they must not sing and disturb our ears !

Oh come on... the song is MMMMMMMMMAGNIFICENT !! Her voice is sooo nice; it reminds me of Zizi !! i dont really like Mahmoud's part but its still nice :D :D Actually its one of my fav's now :D Amazingly... Boushra's terrific in acting, as well !!

i dont understand why waleg u r making a big deal out of it. If the song wasnt succesfull they wouldnt bring them in staracademy and the song is really gr8 and includes new words i mean it has a new idea yala take care all

hopeless please talk about every thing excpet that racional called osama isn't he the same one who doesn't know who is abdulmajeed abdullah isn't he the same one said to hesham if you win 10000000000000 you will not make it but hesham did it I am sure he is not happy and as he says tarrrrrrrrrrarrrrrm tarrrrrrrrrarrrm

hi to all,

i believe that we should not listen to these two singers because they are not educated well to sing and they are not telling the song with love and passion as haifa wehbe do . they should retired both.

loooooooooooooooool smart good one i used to likw him too but not anymore he reminds me of my teachers in school who used to prefer some students and ........ the others looooooooooooooool

Whatever this the trouth have you seen someone raising their hands for four months nomineeing some students(you know what I mean) and then some get angry when the trouth is mentioned.

Common guys don't reminds me with those black days

Smart please leave me alone I am already on black list you know what I mean

THE song is gr8.it is very nice.this is my opinion.

I LIKE THIS SONG

do u think if those two called singers came to staracademy are talented and they r great u r totally wrong
when they entered the stage of starac mahmoud said yalla yalla yalla
ka ano 3am bi bi3 batata shou hal maskhra!!!!!!
teneh shi badal ma both of u saying yakhdou they r saying yaGHHHHHHHHHdoouuuu and hal shi 3ata ousama el rehbeneh which is HIGHLY EXPERT IN REAL ART comment on it
mesh el mafroud kamen ya3rfo yelfzo?
lol
they r stupid both of them
did u see them in miss egypt
yiiiii shou hal habal

Mahmoud El Essaily is a talented young singer.
His song "magnouna" is very funny. And try to pay attention to the lyrics. Do not forget that he wrote the lyrics, did the music and everything. He's studying communication in the Ameican University in Cairo.

hey tony i agree with u mahmoud el esaily put a lot of effort in the song, and it did turn out funny and good, lets just stop critizing the two singers and wish them luck, with the new song..
tony i sendedd you an email, write backkk...

hey plz close ur mouthes!u don't have the right to say that tabat w nabat is repulsive plz !and even bouchra and ma7moud cos both of them were brilliant in performing it!i am advising the envious people not to talk about it and to stop hurting the others by trivial comments !laila frm morocco,tetouan

Hi to all my frds!!!!
I really like this song.. i think that its different from all the other songs..also their voices are not bad at all!!

hi , did anyone of you ask himself what Mahmoud El Iseli and Bushra did in tunisia ? Some articles to both of them were published in "Al-hadath" and they were talking about lebanon. they said that lebanon is not a good country and it's not democratic. they insulted lebanon and its people. they even insulted the lebanese former prime minister Rafik
hariri. I think they are bad and we are all arabs-united together and every arabian shoul love lebanon. these two make discrimination and abuse between arabs. we shoul not encourage them to sing & we should not listen to such .........!

Talal we missed you common it is long time Malika how are you I like whatever you like

who is H.A.R.??????????
are you insane to post such a comment, there are plenty of songs every day with no lyrics or music and u pointed on the BEST song and write these words
shame on you
just you cant stand any egyptian success

Tunisian_girl did they say that really? Do you have a proof or any links?? or you're just a grudgey little girlie who just hate Egyptians??

Yes,ithink you're right Rania they all can't stand any Egyptian sucess and for you Tunisiangirl you're just lying Mahmoud and Bouchra haven't said a word of what you have claimed,if they think so they wouldn't have at least gone to Lebanon and sung there!!! Anyway the song has some really good vibe and amazingly new lyrics so it's a total winner and the rest who doesn't admit that are liars

i'm not agree with you. i like the songs and the singers are good

Dear RAYES & LoooL

actually, you can buy "al-hadath" magazine and see their photos and their claims. issue number 107- April 2005.
they said their estimates and claims after their visit to lebanon and the participation in star academy !

I am really honest , it's only a clarification !

N.B: i love egypt and the egyptians also

The girl is cute though and has a wonderful voice. The guy isn't much.
Un salut libanais pour walid :)

the song is nice bas on play back not on stage..coz as they sang it in da prime ahmad and zizi were far better then boushra and mahmood osayle

I think the song is very good and so different from all the new songs we listen to everyday, atleast this song doesn't sound like all the other new songs we listen to everyday, it has a special and unique rythm to it. I particullarly like the guy's voice and the way he sings. I must admit thought that i have only heard the song at the prime and have been listening to the prime version ever since.

Ossamma EL Rahbani is the biggest jerk among all! he's not the one to decide whether they sing good or not. You know what he is? He's a maniac of Jazz Songs and Whitney Houston and he's like waiting from the candidates to perform similary!! Well, guess what? ITS ARABIC SINGING, TECHNIQUES DIFFER.

+ Ossamma El Rahbani has no right to critisize SINGERS, ALREADY ARTISTS! just he has to stick to the candidates with his stupid meaningless contradictive comments. Ya3ni suppose Mahmoud or Bushra were watching the show and hear his misjudging?? 3eib 3aleih! BTW, there's a proof that he hates Egyptians: After ZiZi left he started off doing these harsh comments because she was away and another thing u should ALL ask yourself: "WHY HE DIDN'T CRITISIZE HAIFA WAHBI? THE SO-CALLED ARTIST" ????

OMAR - JORDAN

loooool tunisian girl u really made me laugh looooool i know ppl who know mahmoud elesseily and they say that he s very decent and btw he s at the AUC the american university in cairo. he would never say that or bouchra why would they say that aslan looool anyway good one looool egyptians love lebanon btw

it doesnt make sense so that s why ppl u dont have to beleive anything u read and sometimes u watch either lool
take care alll
bye

the song is a very good one bouchra has a nice voice but she only needs more practice and training it is her first song but i think that mahmoud is not as good as bouchra in singing he is better in composing i heard that he is the one who wrote the words and composed it if it is right so he is a great composer because the lyrics and the melody are gr8

hey to all my friends malika happy hassan tony marcella siham walid moi samir lulu nunu 7amzah nassimo etc.
i liked the song, its cooolllllll

I think that this song is gr88888888..even if there voices are horrible but the song is really god job...

Dear OMAR,

Sure you don't understand arts and culture because you don't know who is OUSSAMA el REHBANI in lebanon, he is the most educated and he is the son of the huge person "MANSOUR EL REHBANI" . i am sure that you don't know also who is "MANSOUR EL REHBANI", because you are ignorant.

who said their voices r horrible !!! the song ( including their voices )is sooooooo nice !! ;)

the song fazi3aaaaa di my best song asslan ma7adesh ye2dar ye2oul 7aga begad ... homa el etnen wahmeyinn

r u kidding???!!! i LOVE this song! it is soo good! the melody is great, their voices are great, ugh this song is sooo good!!lol..i know i repeated that but its true.

I love the song, the melody and their voices r gr8, so please stop insulting them, it's u r right not to like the song but it's not a reason to be rude.

i think they r both cute and i love their song i dnt get it y most of u ppl dnt like it whats so bad bout it bil3ax its nice

THE SONG ROCKS !