this is terrible..well the lost 1 viewer...now i have no reason to watch star academy...samer was the best and now he is gone...good luck samer.i love you

we will miss you samer so muchhhhhhhhhhh

i meant to say THEY instead of the

NOOOOOOOOOOOO
BRING BACK SAMER I LOVE HIM
IM SOOOO SAD I WANT SAMER BACK
SAMER 7ABIBEEEEEE

DOES HE DO THIS??? REALLY???I CAN'T BELIEVE IT??PLS ANY NEWS ABOUT WHAT HAPPEND??

Samer , be sure you are better than Gazawy

and we will miss you

It was really a nice good bye from you

This is so sad!
I really liked him!

I like Bashar G too, but Samert's voice to me was closer to my heart.

we will miss u Samer+

SAMER!!!!!!

i was surprised it was a close one!
hopefully samer will come back when the people vote for 4 candidates to come bak

WE LOVE YOU SAMER!
u are a star in out hearts!

i can't belive samer is out how , i like u samer i like ur voice , ur my best star , god with u
samer ur the berst

hey everyone plz who r the top 3?

I think that each one was great in his way... But of course Sammer had better voice... I wish that he could stay... Hard luck!!! Good luck to Bahsar G.. Probably he is out next week!!!

ITS A SHAME!!!
well it's obvious why samer is out...khaliji people vote more..but it was a close call..

But seriously samers voice is soooo much better...we;ll miss him...

there was no top 3

Hi guys,
this is really not fair, Samer is a way better than Bashar.G, why always the good voices have to leave the academy it should be the opposite other ways there is no meaning for this academy show at all.
NONNNNNNNNNNN SENSEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!???????
I like Samers voice.

No top 3 this week!

yea why no top 3 and that was the best prime

THATS A BIG SHAME!!!!
i cant watch the program anymore i hate them they took the best Now samer will be out and see the things in lebanon He is the best and this is cant be true i dont know what to say plz just understand how that feels i hate that program I WANT SAMER BACK!!!!!!!
U STILL THE BEST!!!!

Congratulation for Bashar !!!
When I saw him wearing ""shmakh" at the end of the prime, my heart started beating !
his mom was carrying the Jordanian flag but LBC camera men avoided showing it many times ! shame on you LBC
Bashar voice will improve with time...he is hard working
Go Go Bashar...all Jordanian in USA with you !

2eltellkoun hayde killa wsayit w matami3a. 2enno katia a7san bi ktir, sita wala arwa3a. Samer ken refi3a ras lebnen, ken misel l chab l lebnene l tamou7, weyn mkhalyin katia, kelna ttafa2na ma 7ada ysawetlo, bass l 2akid enno ra7 teb2a la ekhir 4 bel academy. Allah ykhalila watit beyt l 7arake!!!!! kachaftellkoun l le3abe. Ya Ghazi feghali... dare from the consequeces??!!!!!!???!!

What a shame.
I cried <-- that's how much I love Samer.
He should've stayed, but I'm proud of Lebanon, it's the first time I see a Lebanese get a high percentage.
Samer was loved by many, did you see the audience?
They were all like ''SAMEr! SAMER! SAMER''
I loved how he sang in the ending and I wish him the best in life and I hope he will be a part of the tour.
I love youuuuuuu Samer!

Samer we Bass wel baqiya khaas!!!

+ I was very happy to see Salma :], beautiful as always.
And also I was happy to see the guy from superstar 1, and the girl from tea time!
And also, Lamita Frangieh and Aline!!

yes......samar is out, i alwayes hated this weird guy, he is sicooooo

Rana...what was lamita and alian doing in the prime

Samer is oik but i love Bachar more. im sooooo happy. i was scared and it was so close it kept on going up and i was yelling keep going Bachar and it did. YES!!!!!!!!

what's going on with quaisi,i mean the weird bashar al quaisi?????????????please don;t tell me that weird guy is staying!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lecia they were in the audience. :]

+Bashar Q isn't staying Olivia.

I cried my eyes out for Samer...I voted so, so many times for him but LBC wants him to leave so what can we do ? I LOVE SAMER WITH ALL MY HEART, THE REAL STAR OF STAR ACADEMY BALA SHAK...BRING SAMER BACK, HE WAS THE ANGEL OF THE ACADEMY...THE ONLY DECENT, RESPECTFUL, MATURE, KIND-HEARTED, UNSELFISH HUMAN BEING IN THE ACADEMY...WALLAH SAMER BYIRFA3 EL RASS...THANK YOU FOR BEING YOU SAMER AND LETTING US WATCH YOU FOR 3 MONTHS IT WAS AN HONOR. BEST OF LUCK IN ALL YOU DO HABEEBEE

Yeah i cried to and ur right with everything he was our angel 4 three mouth the best 3 mouth in the academy!!!!1 i already miss him i wish that the could bring him back or that he is of the 8.....I liked him from the 1 prime and will always like him it doesent matter that hes out he still the BEST but the thing is i will miss him........I hope u can be a very famous artist i want to see ur cute face and hear ur good voice more i wish u the best
SAMER IS THE BEST!!!!!!

ma3lesh ya samer bs best of luck in yr college enta ensan mo7taram w testahel kol 7'er
mabrouk ya bashar enta kaman ensan kwayes awy
al 7a2ee2a sa3b al wa7ed ye2ol meen aly star la2enohom kolohom kwayeseen rabena yewaf2hom gamee3an we7na k masreyeen ma3aky ya zizi w lw 7ad tany kesb hanefra7lo akeed i love amani ,bashar g ,hesham ,ahmed h w karia awy rabena ma3a al gamee3
w 7aram bashar al Q da yo3od da damo te2eel awy may7'alo samer yo3od 3alashan kaman al white flag :(

sorry asdy katia 3'alta matba3eya :)

Why couldnt Katia leave!
I miss Samer already im gonna cry, actually im already crying!
i have like no reason to watch the show now!
Maybe they will bring Samer back!they better they brought that ugly singing machine Bashar G. back!
I love you Samer i hope you do well in the future

i think the final four will be

1 amani
2 ahmed
3 zizi
4 hisham

i dont think that it would be unfair for another egyptian to win, if mohammed attiya didn't win then zizi disearve to be the star of the academy. There is also a good chance that katia would be in the last four i'm sure who she gonna replace.

sorry i'm NOT* sure who she will replace out of the four.

SAUDI ARABIA WOULD LIKE TO CONGRATULATE JORDAN FOR THE SLASHING VICTORY,, ANYWAYS I LIKE SAMER , HARD LUCK LEBANON BUT YOU STILL HAVE KATIA , AND EVENTHOUGH I DONT REALLY LIKE HER FOR WHAT SHE DID TO BASHAR Q BUT GOOD LUCK.

Good luck to Samer...congratulations Bachar...
I was very happy to see Selma in the prime, I wish they'll bring her back to stay instead of BachrQ. I hope next week Amani will be the nominee, She has a beautiful voice but anoying......I can't stand her anymore.
Selma, and Hisham are the best....

Katia will replace Amani...I want the last four to Hisham, Zizi, Ahmad, and Katia...

I am so happy because samer is out of the academy because I hate samer so much he is so ugly and boring. I was so happy because BasharQ's mom came and I also happy for Bashar Q because he was singing with them and he lokked so cute as he always does I love Bashar Q sooooooooooooooooooooooooo much he is the cutiest one in the academy I love him. I am happy for Bashar G because he stayed he is so nice. I tink the final four will be

amanie

zizi

Katia

ahmed i want amnie to be the star because she is the best one in the academy her voice is realy good. or if not amanie maybe zizi becasue she is kind of good I like her now because she staring talking so much to Bashar Q and he feels comfortalbe with her amanie and hisham now. and I al so happy about that. Adhra. I al forom Iraq. I live in America.in MIchigan.

hi samer..u r good guy and wish u best of luck in ur life and plz mail me if ucan i m simon from egypt..bye

noooo bring back samer!!!!!!!!!!!!
i wont samer!!!!!!!!
SAMER SAMER SAMER

ITS NOT FAIR!!!!!
no need to watch star acadmey any more khalas ba7 ya star academy its a waste of time watching it now

I really don't care who wins, i used to like Salma but since she is gone, i don't like the academy at all. I totally wish Amani the worst of luck, she freaks me out when i see her, you know Star Academy isn't only seen by adults, there are little kids and I'am sure they're having nightmares when they see Amani. Did you see when she was crying( as usual) and Bashar Q. and Hisham were talkin to her, about her personality. Hisham then said that he thinks the audience most like Salma's personality. She said " Salma,la" and then Bashar Q. said Salma is very(Rakza)and then she said, Salma is ( Rakza) because she is old. Well, my point here is that Amani first said no and the no and then she said ya, because she is older. Amani is very jeolous of Salma........... Amani is the biggest loser ever!!!!! AHH..... i have to turn off the TV Amani is on

Tony I agree with you, I didn't like Amani because she is boring, crying all the time, and I hated her when she talked about Selma, I felt that she was happy that Selma was out. This Show is not only about the voice but also about personality...and Selma has the best personality....I love Selma...Vive Selma la belle Algerienne..

Why do u all hate Amani?? she is a nice person!! i agree that she has an old style but she's nice!! Maybe she is jeolous of Salma! but its normal in such programs, do u think that anyone of them loves the others,I dont think so!! except for Samer who is a greaaat person and who cant hate anyone!!
Anyway, im really disapointed! i would like that Samer stay!! But i know that he will not win !! this year, it will be either Ahmed H or Hesham!!

Dounia ..... Are you the Dounia that i used to know who used to come to the gulf every summer ???

well i will be watching it soon due to the time difference. i am happy that bashar stayed, he deserves to stay. hard luck samer.

but i would like to comment to a person by the nick TUNIS. why do you say lebanon is a boring country. i dont believe you have been to lebanon you moron. second are you jealous of lebanon? i am not being bias but i dont like people to put my country down.

good luck samer and bashar keep on working hard, you never know what life hides. fame is not enough, look at MOHAMMAD 3TEYE? he has disappeared.

love you ahmad, hisham great funny guy, katia go girl go, amani stop your drama, it is 2005, no more black and white movies, hahahahahaha zizi eh da kolo eh da kolo,Gnaaaaaaaaaaan

see ya

am not lebanese but i got to say that Samer was a very nice polite person and lebanon should make a good asset of him ..

on thursday , the lebanase night , he portrayed lebanon in a very natural and nice way ..

wish him good luck

A Tunis!!
Lah yahdik!!! wach nta labés??? if u love Amani, u can say the most beautiful things abt her, but plz stop insulltin the others!! wht are u sayin in ur comments wont help her at all, on the contrary, u are just givin a bad image of the tunisians!!!

I'm so sad for Samer but I'm so proud of his 47%.It is very good for a lebanese.
Well I think that Katia will stay 2 weeks more.LBC doesn't want to get out two lebanese in two weeks.So Bashar G will get out next week face Hicham or Zizi.

To Paris/ algiers:
Moi je pense que les nominees de cette semaine seraient Bashar et Katia!! et apparemment elle n'aura aucune chance devant lui!! Sinon, Tu sais la starac est devenue vraiment ennuyeuse !! On connait deja les 4 finalistes et c clair aussi que le gagnant serait soit Hesham soit Ahmed Hussein!!

No need to insult the country Tunis, because the people don't reflect the country, look at Baha and Ahmad al sherif they were gtreat!!! Amani suck!! she is not natural,she is dramatic, and cry all the time. even if she is jealous of selma it's a show,....Selma loved everybody and helped them all...she was the mother, the sister and the friend to all the Student. She is fun, and serious at the same time. I love Selma, we will miss her..Inchallah Amani will be out soon so I can watch the show again....