weres Cairo is that in eygypt???
can sameone please that went to the lebanon one tell what happened thank you!!!
i love ahmad i hate atti3 soooooooooo much bashars ok

Yes, Cairo is in Egypt. I saw this concert on TV, it was on the news. There was like twenty-five thousand ppl there or some thing.

loooool seriously u got me laughin at "Let me start by saying that last Friday my dream came true" i mean if that was ur dream in life let me tell u that u have no life gee i mean really to go see a bunch of losers try to sing that's pittiful and i feel sorry for u i mean if bruno was in the show it would be worth watchin...
ps:u'll go very far in life (notice the sarcasm)

THE BEST IN CAIRO CONCERT ARE :
** AHMED - BACHAR - ATTIA - BAHAA

OF COURSE BECAUSE :
AHMED BAHAA BACHAR HAVE THE BEST VOICE
AND ATTIA IS IN EGYPT
IN HIS COUNTRY
** AHMED AND BAHAA AND BACHAR ARE THE BEST IN TUNISIA
** BACHAR AHMED BAHAA AND ATTIA ARE THE BEST IN KUWEIT
** AHMED BACHAR BAHAA ARE THE BEST IN DUBAI

BYE

Gees you people !! the concert was great and they all rocked !! and whoever didn't like them or don't know where the heck is cairo, mind ur own business !! i voted for attiah like 100 times but when i met bashar in person i've got to say he is so adorable !!! good luck to u all .

PEOPLE rELAX

malaak>> I HEARD THAT IN THE KWAITE THE ALL HATED IT BECAUSE THE CROWD WAS SOO bORED AND THEY WERE NOT SAYING ANYTHING IS THAT TRUE?? AND THAT THE CONCERT IN EYGPT AND TUNISIA WERE THE BEST AND SFAX WAS GOOD TO
AND ahmed IS THE BEST ATTIA GOOD TO
IM FROM SYDNEY AUSTRALIA TO I AGREE WITH YOU BRING THE STARS HERE PLESSSSSSSSSSSE

AND TO THE FREAK THAT DOSNT LIKE THE STARS GO TO HELL

Ahmad is thr bast in the all concerts ..efter him come Baha, Khalawi After them the remining others come

Asslan ma3roof wi meen gheer ma tooghooloo inah the best of the best is Ahmad Alsheref

The most distinguish one in all concerts either in Tunisia or Kuwait or Dubi or Safakis or Abu Dhabi or excendria is Ahmad Alsheref...he was the most distenguish person and the most popularity in all these countries and Am sure, if he go to the other countries like Bahrain, Oman ,Moroco, Yeman, Jordan, Syria, Lebonon, Iraq ,Qater and all Arab countries he will be the most one been loved more than any one of the other candidaties

our request from LBC and Waleg is to make for Ahmad and Khalawi a special dueto and to produce for both of them the video clip and their albums....plz..we insist in our request seriously

i wanna tell u that ahmed is only cute and after u saw him in real life he looked terrible!!!
and by the waay i wanna tell that loser who is saying thatt the rest r kemalet 3adad that 3atteyaa is the best and that he is not kemalat 3adad at all and that ahmed is the 1!aand that he is kemalat 3adad lel banat not for the guys!!
3atteyaaaaaaaa u r the besssssssst we adoooooooore u heere in canada and u r the most distinguiesh everywhere and that i saw about 20 ppl on tv insulting u for not being a maannnn!
u aalll go to heelll while 3atteya will staaaaaaay the star no mmatter wut u do or wut the shit u saaaay!!!
gooo 3aaaaaaaaatteya 4evaaaaaaa!!!!
we all adore u here in canadaa!
and by the waay i wanna know when will the next conceert be coz know i haave alot of friends is the aarab world coz i wanted 2 know every step they take!
so i waanna know wheere will the conceert be!!i already saw the tape of the concert in egypt coz magda sent me that!!

liike every1 said DNT MAKE A SCENE IF URSELFS U LOSERS!!!
P.S:LOOK AT THE EMAILS OF THOSE LOSER U'LL FIND SM1 WHOSE NAME IS 3AGL GEEDN LOOK AT HIS EMAIL PLZ!
AND U JAWAHIR,LEARN HOW TO WRITE THEN COME AND OPEN UR DIRTY MOUTH!!
ALL THE LOSERS DNT EVEN KNOW HOW TO WRITE THEY JUST SEARCHED IN A DIC. AND CAME WRITING THOSE SENT. WITHOUT EVEN KNOWING!!!

hey sarah im with you i think its the same person

and you u r all losers and u just change ur names i mean look at the time!! you say you saw 20 ppl on tv insulting him lOL THEN ITS NOT 1 PERSON WHO HATES HIM ITS MANY,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

I DONT HATE HIM BUT AHMADS BETTER THEN HE'LL EVER BE............

THIS WHAT YOU SAY

and by the waay i wanna tell that loser who is saying thatt the rest r kemalet 3adad that 3atteyaa is the best and that he is not kemalat 3adad at all and that ahmed is the 1!aand that he is kemalat 3adad lel banat not for the guys!!............................

WHAT AHMAD DID NOTHING LOL HAHAHAHH YOUR SOOO STUPID IF YOUR GOING TO SAY SAMETHING KNOW WHAT YOUR TALKING ABOUT OK AND IM A GUY..

AHMAD I THINK YOUR THE BEST

I WENT TO THE CONCERT IN EYGPT MOST PEOPLE THERE ARE IN LOVE WITH AHMAD LOL GIRLS AND GUYS THEY LIKE THEM ALL IT WAS A GREAT CONCERT THE MOST LOVED PEOPLE ARE AHMAD FIRST THEN ATTI3 AND BASHAR AND BAHAA......

luv attia u r the best

I just have a question for people who voted to Attiya because he is funny, What do you expect from him to do? making albumes full of jokes??? or between each 2 songs he sings on the stage , he has to tell you some jokes or shake his waist as he used to do in the academy???
If this what do you want so I just want to congratulate you to have another Sha3ban 3bd Alraheem or Issam Karika cause those are the best representer for comic singing
attiah is not deserve to be the winner ..He just run around the academy like crazy people. so he is not deserve to be a star he should be a crazy and go to the mental hospital...and he doesn't win because of his popularity, he just win because the voting was free through MELODY HITS channel and all the silly ones who love Attiah were voting thousand of times because of the free voting, other wise they will not vote for him especially Egyptians who are poor

هذا كلام منقول عن واحد مصري عن الموضوع اللي عند احمد الشريف

بصراحه انا انسان مصري و احب اقول ان مش كل المصريين

بتحب محمد عطيه لاننا نعرف الفن الحقيقي ونعرف من اللى يستحق.,… عطيه ما بينفعش يكون ستار 000عشان هو كده على بعضه مصخره في مصخره … و صراحه عار على الفن ان واحد يفوز زي عطيه … وانا بصراحه كنت اتابع البرنامج عشان احمد الشريف لانه فعلا فنان و يستحق لقب الستار اما الخيبه عطيه فهو اذا كان عندنا في مصر فهو ما بينفعش الا للادوار الكومبرس و المهيطه 000والمصيبه انه يحاول يقلد الفنان العظيم عادل امام وهو اصلا ما بيوصلش لظفر منه00000وانا زعلت اوي يوم لما خرجوا احمد الشريف 000وانا احب اقولك يا احمد اننا احنا هنا
في مصر كلنا بنحبك

وانا اقول وازيد على الكلام :
انسان عنده كرامه على عكس عطيه اللى دايما يهين نفسه وينزل من كرامته ويتذلل ,وفي ذاك اليوم اللي طلع نومني راح يبكي للاساتذه عشان بس يرضوا عنه 000وصراحه احمد من غير ما يطلعوه ستار هو اصلا ستار وما محتاج لاحد ويكفيه حب الناس الصادق ليه 000اما اللى يهين من نفسه وينزل من احترامه فهو انسان ذليل وما يستحق محبة او حتى احترام الناس له

وكمان انا اوافقكم في الرأي اللى قالوا ان بهاء ما تستحق تكون المرتبه الثالثه 000 يعنى هذا الشي ما يقبله لا العقل ولا المنطق 000معقوله ان بهاء تكون قبل أحمد والخلاوي في حين احنا كلنا عارفين ان هم اعلى منها واحسن منها في جميع النواحي 00هي بس عندها الصوت والشكل الجميل 000بالاضافه الى كذه خلوها تغني في الحفله النهائيه وما خلوا الاخرين يغنوا بالرغم من انهم هم متقدمين عنها في جميع النواحي ،بس عشان يكيدوهم بيها لما يقدروها بالرغم من انها اخس منهم لكن عشان بس تعرف تنافق مثل عطيه خلوها الثالثه اما عن بشار فهو انسان موهوب وصاحب ثقافه فنيه عاليه لكن اسلوبه ومزاجه السئ هو اللى جعل الناس ينفروا منه بالاضافه انه فنان من الاصل ولحن لمطربيين كبار معروفين امثال نبيل شعيل وغيرهم يعني من المفروض ما يخلوا يشترك في برامج المبتدئيين لانه هو خلاص متعمق في الفن واكيد حيكون عنده خبره بالفن اكثر منهم 000وبصراحه اللى كانوا يستحقوا المرتبه الاولى هم أحمد والخلاوي لانهم متساويين في القوه والمرتبه الثانيه بشار مثل ما هو والمرتبه الثالثه سنتيا او برونو والمرتبه الرابعه عطيه لانه يعرف يمثل والمرتبه الخامسه بهاء لان صوتها حلو000اما يحطوا ناس الاوائل لانهم يذللوا انفسهم للاساتذه فهذا ظلم واحنا ما نقبل بالظلم00000000

احمد ستار مهما كان
بدليل خلص البرنامج من زمان والى الآن مازال الناس يتحدثون عن احمد الشريف
واللي بيقهر الناس الحاقدين على احمد يقولوا انوا احمد اكثر معجبينه من البنات لأنوا هو وسيم
طيب شو فيها انوا اكثر معجبينه من البنات عيب يعني
اكيد لأ
لأنوا عمالقة الفن في العالم كلوا اكثر معجبينهم من النساء مثل عبد الحليم حافظ
محمد عبده ، عمرو دياب
كاظم الساهر وائل كفوري راغب علامة عاصي الحلاني
خالد عبد الرحمن راشد الماجد عبد المجيد عبدالله
سؤال ؟
هل كون ان اكثر جمهورهم من الفتيات افقدهم شئ من نجوميتهم ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟
او هل انقص شئ من اصواتهم ومواهبهم الفنية ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟
الجواب : اكيد لأ
وعلى فكرة الفتيات لهم ذوق كبير جدا في الفن
ولا يعتمدوا ابدا على شكل الفنان
فشرف كبير جدا للفنان ان يكون القسم الأكبر من جمهوره من الفتيات
وهذه نعمة من الله اعطاها لأحمد ما له يد فيها انه هو وسييم
مين قال ان احمد الشريف فقط عنده معجابين من البنات ... انا اقول ان احمد جمع بين محبة البنات والشباب والاطفال والكبار ...انا بنفسي اشوف كيف في بيتنا وبيوت زملائي يشجعوه بشده وفي المدرسة كمان ( مع العلم اننا احنا مجموعة اصدقاء مختلفين المزاج والاذواق ومن مختلف الدول من السعودية وقطروالاردن وسوياوفلسطين والامارات) وكنا نتابع البرنامج بس عشان احمد وبرونو والخلاوي.....وصراحة احمد انسان صاحب شخصية رفيعة وذوق فني مرهف وهو ايضا من اصحاب الشخصيات القويه اللى استطاع يثبت فنه بصدق واخلاص لدرجة انه خلانا نعيش اجوائه وخلانا نفرح معه ونحزن معه....عكس ناس اللي دايما يحاولوا يظهروا نفسهم ، لكن بصراحه ما كان لصالحهم ،كان ضدهم
ومن اللي يقول بان احمد كان يعتمد على شكله ...بصراحه هذا الكلام مو صح ...بالعكس هو اكثر واحد تواضعا وطيبتا ورزانة على الرغم من وسامته...يعني بصراحه اي واحد في مكانه كان حيغتر لكن هو اثبت لنا العكس لجليل اخلاقه .....ويعني بصراحه ومن غير فضاضه لمعجبن بشار ، صراحة لو كان بشار بشكل احمد ووسامة احمد لكان اغتر بنفسه ونفش ريشه مثل الطاووس ( لكن الله ستر). وكمان كان هناك في شخصيات تستحق انها تنذكر الى جانب احمد مثل برونو والخلاوي وامين ويوسف ، اللى من غير ما يظهروا نفوسهم هم ظاهرين ومكانتهم محفوظه ،،ما يستخفوا بدمهم على ثقله ولا يركضوا في ارجاء الاكاديميه مثل المجانين ولا يعملوا حركات القرود مثل بشار وعطي
وعلى فكرة كل الطلاب عدا محمد الخلاوي كانوا حاسدين احمد على حب البنات له بالذات عطيه اللي مايحبه الإ الأطفال مع احترامي وكأنه كان يقدم لهم مسلسل اطفال لمدة اربعة اشهر فتعلقوا به جدا
وبشار اللي مايحبه الإ الكويتيون
فقط وليس جميعهم
بس احمد كانت جميع الفئات العمريه تحبه
فالى الأمام يا احمد

I DONT UNDERSTAND THE MSISS LEBANON THERE NOTHING BAD IN IT??? I DONT UNDERSTAND WHATS HAPPENING WALEG WHY CANT WE GO IN TO MISS LEABNON

For all Attiah fans ...
see in his topic in April Archive..most of the people there hate him..and see how much of his comments are very few in comparing with Ahmad Alsheref comments...and see in Ahmad topice ..most the people love him accept few while poor Attiah most of the people hate him accept few..even the Egyption people hate Attiah..hhhhhh

u r right Zahir...and not only Attiah who got few comments...also Bashar got few comments and most of the comment in Bashar topic are represent people who hate Bashar while they all love Ahmad ...therefore waleg site change the topic from Bashar Alshatti to Ahmad Alsheref bcoz Ahmad is the one who has most popularity..of course bcoz Ahmad is the best of the best...

sofia is from moroco and sarah why are you saying sorry you forgiven i dont know what you have done i think bashar and ahmad are kool
and the concert in cario sounds so good i wish i went how many people were ther i heard there was over 25 thousound is that true?

El_Kaws THAT GIRL IS BACK LOSER I Was at the concert to they were not just screaming attieh they were also screaming ahmd and the girls addmiti it were all screaming ahmad

luck: I know they're loved everywhere and believe me it wasn't Attiyah >>>only<<<who got cheers and whatnot, everyone of them did...But for all the losers who keep on belittling Attiyah for Ahmad's sake: shut up.

Uhh, U GET OVER IT and realize that the world does not revolve around the precious Ahmad and there are actually ppl who love Attiyah and the other stars...Grow up, child.

And for the MILLIONTH time I did not say that NO ONE cheered for Ahmad...Good God are u ppl dumb???? He has millions of fans, I KNOW THAT...BUt what u should know is that the others stars have fans too, ESPECIALLY ATTIYAH.

hey both of u stopppp
ppl cheeered 4 every single candidate!!!!
every1 was so happppppppy to c them in real life
stop insulting each other coa that will make no good
3atteya is loved everywhere
so is ahmed we 3atteya fans love ahmed soo muchh and we love bachar soo much too
and i think ahmed fans too
so stopp pleaaaaaaaaaaase!
the concert was gr8 i have to admit that and they were all so cute
and by the way 3atteya is much cuter in real life!
i had a pro with ahmed's trousers!
but he looked gr8 too!
hope we know what happened in the othe concert
p.s:its again those who dnt think who just change the names!!
i think alooot aloot of problems r happening between us who didnt do anything bec of u so its time to start thinking or even wait a while untill u write the post with a new name!
nadin again dnt say anything bad about egypt...
ppl have different tastes and some like karika and sha3ban abd el reheem alover the world!
i dnt totally agree with that but i must respect them!
3atteya is not like them...it is said that he is like amr diab
and when u come to name the singers in egypt dnt only say sha3ban or karika
name also abdelhaleem and omu kalthoum and the other great egyptian singers
masr balad el phan as all those candidates said!!!!
and others too!

lets not fight anymore lets all agree that even though ahmad is loved more and u stuid one person dont wana admit it that ahmad and attieh have the same nummber off fans and are loved the same are u happy
nooooooooowww lets get over everything in the past and all be friends now LETS ALL SAY SORRRY
IM SORRY FOR SAYING THE TRUTH NOW ITS ATTIEH FAN ATTMIT IT AND SAY SORRYYYYYYYYYYY

Of course Ahmad is the best..go go Ahmad

اللى يشجع احمد يهتم بالمظهرواللى يشجع عطيه يهتم بالطرفه وخفة الدم واللى يشجع بشار يهتم بالصوت هذه هى الحقيقه احمد يحظى اغلب المشجعين مع انى لست من معجبيه بسبب شكله وغالبية مشجعيه من البنات هذه حقيقه انا لاانكر ان صوته جميل ولكن ينقصه الكثير حتى يصبح مطرب محترف خاصة انه يعانى من مشاكل فى اللفظ ويؤدى لونين اوثلاثه من الغناء فقط بالنسبه لعطيه فهواضعفهم من ناحية الغناء بل حتى اضعف من متاسبقين خرجو من المراحل الاولى ولكن مواهبه الكوميديه هى المحرك الاساسى للاكاديميه لااحد ينكر ذلك واعيدها خفت دم وليس هبل كما يدعى البعض فعطيه بنظرى اذكى شخص بالاكاديميه بشار صوت جميل اجاده لللهجات العربيه اجده للطبقات يؤدى معظم الالوان الغنائيه ملحن ولكن عيبه الوحيد المزاجيه وسرعة الغضب لكل منهم جمهور غفير واحيانا مشترك اذا سالتمونى عن افضل صوت واداء جوابى هو بشار واذا اردتم جمال ورزانه احمد واذا اردتم خفة دم عطيه وكلهم محبوبين لكن المشكله ليست بهم المشكله بنا الجمهور عموما المستقبل كفيل بمن فعلا يستحق اللقب وسنرى ذلك

I went to Cairo concert in EGYPT on friday 14/05/04 it was great, 28.000 people was there screaming the name of Attieh, when he appeaared on stage,Guys and girls and families and children and mothers and old people was trying to had good positions before the begening just to see Attieh, and when he appeared they screamed his name A LOT and congratulated him, he was so cute in realty and he was so stylish too, He had to intrupt the screams to thank the spectators and to talk to them.
Of course he is the star, we don't need to proove it, we can not keep our eyes away of him on the stage,he is very hyper, he can make very good atmosphere people singing and dancing, he can make it like a fire, he has the same style of Amr Diab,he attract the eyes of the spectators he has very high presence on stage in his 20 years old, we wanted the concert never end, and to see Attiah more, Bashar was good too, he had good presence, and he has good chemistry with Attieh, they understand each other without words,Ahmed was good too but he is a little bit calm i think he should be a little bit hyper on stage and interreact with the spectators more than that,he had a good looking but he need to be more enthousistic on the stage , but he 's good too.
we loved them all, Hisham abbas was their interducing them on stage,it was very nice to see Yasser with them too and joined them in singing in the concert and interduce them, the concert was showing on Channel (1) in the Egyptian TV last saturday, and i recoerded it on a tape,
and they showed a summery of their visit in Alexandria in country club next friday on CHANNEL (1), by the way Summaya and Mira was joinning them in their trip to Egypt and they went and stayed with them in Alexandria country clup and their trip to Cairo, and they showed us how was their days from they arrived Cairo airport till teir trip to Alex by Bus,Soumaya and mira were dancing in the Bus, then they arrived to Alex, Attiah and Yasser were waiting for them with their families, Attiah and his family was standing beside the bus waiting to Hug Bashar and they took a lot of picture Bashar and Attiah 's family who was waiting to welcoming Bashar , Attieh was waiting his collegues with his family in the club, so was Yasser, Attieh was in Egypt with his family in TANTA (HIS CITY) before they arrival to EGYPT, Attieh & Bashhar cheched in thier room together, and so were the other candidates, and they were (Attieh and Bashar)were jocking as usual in the coridors of the club, we remeberd the academy when we saw them jocking and kidding in the coridors with their bodyguards, we really missed them and we miss the academy days, they had their lunch after the check in , and they (the 11 candidates) were singing and dancing around the swimming pool and after the were jocking together and joined Yasser's and Attieh's familes, then the guys went to change their clothes then they jumped in the swiming pool in laughing and jocking, they had a great time together in Alexandria, they made us remember the academy days.
after that they had the concert at night at the same club, and their was 20 thousand people waiting and sceaming Attieh 's name, the next day they were in Cairo.
we will never see star academy team like that again , by the way they love each others very much, we will never find 16 candidates like them again , may be it will be more organized in the futur but they will never like that 16 candidates and their spirit and their love toward each other, and never will be great like (STAR ACADEMY 1) and u will see, the 16 candidates and their spirit together were like a MERICALE wich will never be repeated or come again, and u will see
I think after that tour they should make their own band together like THE BEATELES in the 60'S , because they are great together and they had a lot of fans around the world who love them, and each one of them has his style and his taste, like Attiah 's style or Bachar style or Ahmed, Or Bahaa, each one has his style, his caracter, and his fans.
we wish them all the luck, they are together like a MERICALE,they r the originales all the other STAR ACADEMY in the future would be a silly copy of them.
they r a Mericale, wish u all the luck .

ALL THE BAD THINGS ABOUT ATTIEH U HAVE TOLD NADIN AND OTHER PE0PLE IS WRONG AND IF ATTIEH IS NOT A STAR ATTIEH IS THE BEST OF THE REST AND MELODY WAS NOT FREE IN VOTING AND IF EGYPT DONT LOVE ATTIEH WHY THEY VOTE FOR HIM BEC.he is a real starAND EGYPTIAN.WHY R JEALOUS FROM HIM AND EGYPTIANS ARE NOT POOR UR THE POOR ONE, EGYPT HYA EL 3MLTKO AND ALL THE REAL EGYPTIANS LOVE 3ATTIEH SO PLZ THE STUPID JEALOUS EGYPTIIANS DONT TALK AS UR ALL THE EGYPTIANS TALK ABOUT UR SELF ONLY AND IF U SAID BAD THING FROM NOW TILL THE END OF THE HUMINITY ATTIEH IS THE STAR AND HIS THE ONE WHO WON DIE WITH SORROW(MOTO B'3ZKO)

im sorry for getting angry but i want to know who delted my message please tell

and why you delete it for???

dear Sarah , dear El-KAWS, dear Magda

YOU R ALL RIGHT , Attiah is the 1st Star of star Academy, it 's the fact, whatever sami and the other jealous children r saying, they r just kids, and very jealous, simply because Ahmed didn't want to win and he wanted to leave and back home, simply he didn't want to be the star or do more effort to be the star, so why u wanted him to be the star, he didn't want to, Attieh was the opposite he didn't sleep for some night to prepare to the evaluation and he spend some nights studying vocalise alone till the morning, so he deserves to be the STAR,AND GOD MADE HIM REACH HIS GOAL, BE SURE THAT GOD IS FAIR,
TO NADINE :by the way the voting was free in Egypt, contrarly EGYPT has not an SMS number from the begining.
- Egyptians are not poor people, we made our son (Attieh) win against all the gulf, tell me what did u do for ur star AHMED, ???
- ONLY U LIKE HIS GOOD LOOKING AND SCREAMING, BUT U DIDN'T WANT TO PAY TO SAVE HIM, POOR PEOPLE, U R CRYING NOW THAT UR STAR LOST, PLUS u blaming ur selves by insulting the real star.u r realy funny what u do, but whatever u say or whatever u do, it' s a fact that ATTIAH IS THE THE STAR AND U WILL SEE WHAT HE IS GOING TO DO IN SINGING AND ACTING IN THE FUTURE IN THE ARAB WORLD BECAUSE HE 'S VERY VERY CREATIVE AND VERY INTELLIGENT.
but Ahmed is the 5 th one.
-Egypt and Attieh 'S fan made attieh the star, (the younger candidate in the academy)AND VOTED FOR HIM, what did u do for Ahmed if he realy has the the largest numbers of fans as said??????????
U ONLY SCREAMING WHEN U SEE HIM, IT'S VERY GERLY AND CHILDISH.
ATTIEH'S FANS R A LOT ALL AROUND THE WORLD, WE DON'T NEED TO PROOVE IT, BECAUSE HE 'S THE STAR ,
DIE BY UR JEALOSY.

dear magda and dandoun.. how can a person from tunisia with its 7 million and who voted for ahmad only 1000 times coz they do not have a direct line and the internatinal line is expensive and all the time busy win ... the votes shows that ahmad is the most popular coz they came from outside tunisia and people vote for him coz he is the real star we all know this .he has the charisme voice personality ..
attiah won coz he is from egypt .. i was told that many people voted for him though they do not watch the programm .well i suppose u know that .. we all know who is the real star and who should have won .. bashar is also good ha has a nice voice .so the best is ahmad then bashar then boubou ...attiah has no voice but he is an actor a good one many artists advised him to choose acting coz he has a weak voice .
it is stupid to fight about this coz everybody knows that especially here in lebanon .
i like attiah as an actor but many people hated him coz he had a title he does not deserve.. i really hope that ahmad work as much as attiah coz succeess is not easy

If you want to hear the whole Star Acadmey CD, go to the link below:

http://search.cartserver.com/search/search.cgi?cartid=s-1334&category=details&maxhits=1&keywords=3200&go=GO!

dear Sarah , dear El-KAWS, dear Magda

YOU R ALL RIGHT , Attiah is the 1st Star of star Academy, it 's the fact, whatever sami and the other jealous children r saying, they r just kids, and very jealous, simply because Ahmed didn't want to win and he wanted to leave and back home, simply he didn't want to be the star or do more effort to be the star, so why u wanted him to be the star, he didn't want to, Attieh was the opposite he didn't sleep for some night to prepare to the evaluation and he spend some nights studying vocalise alone till the morning, so he deserves to be the STAR,AND GOD MADE HIM REACH HIS GOAL, BE SURE THAT GOD IS FAIR,

TO NADINE :
by the way the voting was NOT free in Egypt, THE OPPISIT IS TRUE, EGYPT has not an SMS number from the begining, THEN WE HAD TO VOTE WITH VERY EXPENSIVE CALL COAST.
- Egyptians are not poor people, we made our son (Attieh) win against all the gulf, tell me what did u do for ur star AHMED, ???
- ONLY U LIKE HIS GOOD LOOKING AND SCREAMING, BUT U DIDN'T WANT TO PAY TO SAVE HIM, POOR PEOPLE, U R CRYING NOW THAT UR STAR LOST, PLUS u blaming ur selves by insulting the real star.u r realy funny what u do, but whatever u say or whatever u do, it' s a fact that ATTIAH IS THE THE STAR AND U WILL SEE WHAT HE IS GOING TO DO IN SINGING AND ACTING IN THE FUTURE IN THE ARAB WORLD BECAUSE HE 'S VERY VERY CREATIVE AND VERY INTELLIGENT.
but Ahmed is the 5 th one.
-Egypt and Attieh 'S fan made attieh the star, (the younger candidate in the academy)AND VOTED FOR HIM, what did u do for Ahmed if he realy has the the largest numbers of fans as said??????????
U ONLY SCREAMING WHEN U SEE HIM, IT'S VERY GERLY AND CHILDISH.
ATTIEH'S FANS R A LOT ALL AROUND THE WORLD, WE DON'T NEED TO PROOVE IT, BECAUSE HE 'S THE STAR ,
U WILL NEVER CHANGE THIS FACT.

Posted by Dandoun at May 24, 2004 03:54 PM

Dandoun i think you first message was tite PLEASE BE NICER but its ok because you said sorry and i cant br bothed fighting i think there is sameone in here who is more then on name but they can do what they want i don CARE UNless they say samething BAD about ahmad then this will start agin

and im SORRY As well for being RUDE to samepeopl i still think that that 1 attieh fan is still here but its ok ill get over it

magda i think its good your trying to stop the fights and i think that star acdmey was not fare it made same countries freee same no i think star acdmey from the start should of let everyone VOTE for free sooooo EVERYONE HAS A SAY not just the people with money THATS HOW AHMAD GOT OUT (im TALKING ABOUT MOHMD K AND BASHAR) BUT I LOVE THEM BOTH STILL monny your right its over LET ALL BE FRENDS

AHMAD I LOVE

Dear all WALEG VISITORS,

CLARIFICATION

Just i want to clarufy it again for the 3 rd time that:

THE VOTING WAS NOT FREE IN EGYPT, THE OPPISIT IS TRUE, EGYPT has not an SMS number from the begining of STAR ACADEMY, THEN WE HAD TO VOTE WITH VERY EXPENSIVE CALL COAST,
meaning more expensive than other countries.

it's just for ur information.

Let's be freinds all.

HAVE A NICE DAY.

Egyption people vote for Attiah not bcoz he is the best but bcoz he is Egyption and represent their country ,,,so people stop cheating,,,,,we all know that Ahmad is the most popular one amaong all the candidates from all Arab,America, Austuralia countries not onle from his own country..isn't it...GO GO AHMAD

For all ones who just want to stop fight, I want to say that waleg site is published to let people express their opinions, so feel free to your say opinion without saying bad words......but still that Attiah's fans are the ones who want to stop fight...u know why ???...bcoz they are not know how to defense of attiah..and they don't have any thing to say or to proof..bcoz they know from deep inside of them that Attiah is not deserve to win and there are not any reason to let him win over the real compititiors(Khalawi,AHMAD and BASHAR)...bcoz all of us even Attiah's fans know the fact that Attiah must come after AHMAD,BASHAR AND KHALAWY in the top 5 bcoz they are better than him.....so Attiah'fans don't have any proof to say..therefore they just want to stop fight..is n't it...hhhhhh

plz tell me if Egypt ch1 will repeate the the concert and the report abaut star academy bcoz I didn't watch it plz tell me ..i want to see the report and the concert....

I love them all but I love Ahmad most of them bcoz he is talent ,handsame, has great voice, has great personality

However, i Love the three tunisian candidates so much: Ahmad, Sumaya , Baha and I also love the saudi Khalawi so much....and I like the strong relation ship between tunisian candidaties..it is really strong and real ..while the other candidaties are not tight togrther...for Example: Yasser and Attiah fro Egypt but they are not together...Nisreen and Myriam from Syria and also are not together..Mira, Laila Brono and cyntia from Lebonon but are not together(except Cyntia and Brono)...Sofia and Ameen are from Moroco and also are not together...khalawi, Bashar, Youseef from the Gulf and also are not together.......while beautiful Ahmad is always help Baha and Sumaya and always motive it them as he is their bigger brother..and Am sure that he will always help Sumaya and Baha as if they are his sisters....I love u Ahmad so much ...take care honey

Uhhh, seriously u can't be dumber than that...

Why is every Attiya fan "the same person changing his name"??? PROVE IT, dumbass. U just don't wanna admit that Attiyah has fans...As I said b4, not everyone has to LOVE ur precious Ahmed and Bashar...As far as I am concerned, I think they're crap and the most boring stars ever...They only sing, other than that they are lame and dull.

And I am being rude because u ppl are 100000000 times ruder...Ur always saying Attiyah sucks and has no fans when in fact u don't know anything...All u say is non sense and excuses cuz Ahmad and Bashar lost...FACE IT: Attiyah is the star, but Bashar is the sad runner up and Ahmed is 5th place, which means that Khalawi, Bahaa2, and Bashar, PLUS Attiyah have fans more than him...

If anyone has to stop being rude, it's everyone here.

El_Kaws i proved it many TIMES im not sayingf your the one LOSER LEARN HOW TO READ
and ahmad coming 5th dosnt MEAN ANYTHING SEE MAYBE IF YOU USED YOUR STUPID BRAIN you would understand that if ahmad was with others he might of won TRUE FACT AND there was one attieh fans as diffrent names why you DEFFENDING THAT PERSON LOSER
and you SHUT UP DONT BE RUDE AND TELL OTHER TO SHUT UP AND IF YOU COULD READ WITCH YOU CANT YOU WOULD OF SEEN THAT I PROVIED ALOT AND THAT I SAID SORRY FOR BEING RUDE THEN A DUMB ASS MEANING YOU COMES ON AND STARTS BEING RUDE Again

and do you think i reallly wanted bashar to win attieh NO WAY all im saying IS MAYBE SAMEPEOPLE LIKE ATTIEH 2nd 3ed AFTER THERE FAVORITE SO THEN THEY VOTE FOR HIM SEE IT DOSNT MAKE HIM THE MOST FANSSSSSSSS STUPId
OR AND DONT YOU SAY ITS EXCUSESS COZ ITS THE TRUTH

YOUR THE ONE WHO SHOULD GET OVER ITTTTTT

AND PLEASE READ THIS CAREFULLY AND UNDERSTAND WHAT IM SAYING B4 SAY SAMETHING YOU DONT EVEN KNOW WHAT YOUR TALKING ABOUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

AHMAD I LOVE YOU

ahmad=most fans like him 1st TRUTH
attieh = samemight like him 2nd BUT I DIDNT VOTE still thats why he won MAYBE IF HE WAS WITH MOHD K TELL ME HE WOULD OF WON OR AHMAD I DONT THINK SOOOOOOOOOOO

الى الأخ واحد
احب اقول لك ان بشار مايستاهل يمسك مايك
ويستاهل انو يطلع من الأكاديمية من بدري
بس مجاملة مدري واسطة خلتوا يقعد طول هذي المدة
تدري ليش :
لأن انت قاعد تقارن احمد الشريف اللي لسه موهوب واول مرة يغني
مع واحد صار له سنتين يدرس فن ومع كذا ما يعرف
حاجة حتى كتابة النوتة ما يعرف يكتب النوت الموسيقية
احمد الشريف كان الوحيد اللي ما يفلط في كتابة النوت الموسيقية
صراحة مالها داعي دراست بشار وكمان سمعت ان عبد الله القعود يقول انه شاف بشار من قبل اربع سنين من استديو لأستديو
ومع ذلك لم نرى من بشار ذالك المستوى الرائع بل قورن بالهواة تعرف ايش هو السبب ؟
لأن اصلا بشار ما عنده صوت واضح مثل ما قال له اوسامة الرحباني : انت لسه فكرت الصوت لسه ما بعد بلشت عندك
وكمان نطقه للحروف مش مضبوط مثل حرف اللام ماينطقه زين
ومين قال ان بشار يعرف يغني كل الأغاني ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟
مثلا ما اعطوه ابدا يغني لعبد الحليم حافظ على المسرح
ولا اعطوه اغنية لكاظم الساهر
ولا غنى مع امير الغناء العربي هاني شاكر
ولا غنى لوحده مع عبد الله بالخير
ولا اعطوه اغنية لجورج وسوف
عشان كل هذه الأغاني تحتاج الى صوت قوي
وبشار صوته جدااا ضعيف
بس يعطوه يغني جبلي لأنه كان يضخم صوته ومكان يغني بصوت أصلي كان يغني بصوت مستعار
وهذه الحقيقة اللي ما احد يقدر ينكرها والله صوت عطيه احلى من صوت بشار
واصلا عيب على بشار انه ينشز او حتى يغلط بحكم خبرته الطويييلة في الفن والمفروض اصلا ما يقبلوه في البرنامج لأنه برنامج هواة اللي مالهم خبرة
وكمان الكوتيين هم يفتخرون فيه بصرااحة انا ماشفت انه قدم اي مستوىيدعو للفخر بس ينتقد ويتمسخر على اصحابه بدون حياء مثل ليلى بهاء عطية
وعلى فكرة الناس ماانتبهت لبشار الا بس بسبب حكايته مع صوفيا وصداقته مع عطيه
وكبر دليل هو شريط ستار اكادييمي اللي طالع صوته مو حلو وقال ملحن ومؤلف قال ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟ يعني اغنيته اللي الفها ولحنها مالها داعي مثل ما قال اوسامة الرحباني بس احساس مافي صوت ولا اداء واصلا بشار ما يقارن بعطية لأن محمد عطية في التأليف والتلحين اكبر بكثير من بشار مثل لما الف اغنية النومينية صراحة محمد عطية مبدع وملحن وممثل يعني بشار حتى في التمثيل مو ذاك الزود مو مقنع
ويعني ماشاء الله على احمد الشريف والخلاوي وبهاء ومحمد عطيه انهم يقدمون مثل هذه المستويات والتقدم في اربعة اشهر فقط
وكيف تقول ان اللي يحب احمد يحبه عشان مظهره
يا اخي ان الله جميل يحب الجمال يعني احمد ما لو يد في حب الناس له وكمان احمد ما كان الوسيم الوحيد كان برونو احلى من احمد بكثيييير وامين كمان كان جميييل بالمرة ماشفنا يعني الناس حبوهم كثيير والسبب هو ان اصواتهم كانت مو حلوة وكان التوب في الصوت بدون منازع هو احمد الشريف وبهاء الكافي اللي ما احد يقدر ينكر هذه الحقيقة
ولو ما كان احمد الشريف هو التوب في الصوت ما كان غنى مع امير الغناء العربي هاني شاكر
يعني بمختصر العبارة صوت احمد قوي وجميل وراكز واداء احمد على المسرح اداء باهر وواثق من نفسه واكبر دليل هي اغنية راجع يتعمر لبنان باريت ترجع وتشوفها فرق شاسع بين اداء احمد الراكز المتزنواداء بشار
كمان دليل على ان احمد اقوى واجمل صوت في الأكاديمية يوم غنوا ميدلي العين عندما قال اسامة الرحباني: انا اتفاجئت يا احمد ما عرفتك يعني ما شاء الله صوت جميل وقوي
هذه اكبر شهادة لأحمد
وكمان بشار محبوب فقط من الشعب الكويتي وليس جميعهم
يعني ليش الحسد والغيرة من احمد الشريف ومحمدعطيه سبحان الله الله معطيهم الشعبية الكبيرة عند الناس
وان شاء الله سوف يثبتون للناس مواهبهم وسوف يبرزون كنجوم عالميين ومحترفين كمان عطية في مجال التمثيل والفن الإستعراضي واحمد الشريف في الغناء العربي الأصيل
وعلى فكرة لو ما كان احمد الشريف احسن صوت واقوى صوت ما كانوا قارنوا احمد الشريف بملحم زين
وعلى فكرة في سوبر ستار كان مرعي سرحال صوت قوي ويمكن في مستوى قوة صوت ملحم زين لكنه طلع من بدري وليس له معجبين لأن شكله مو حلو لكن ملحم زين جمع بين جمال الصوت وجمال الشكل مثل احمد الشريف يعني ما تا خذوها حجة ان اكثر جمهورهم من البنات وشئ طبيعي ان اكثر جمهور اي فنان في العالم من البنات لأن نسبة البنات في العالم الآن ضعف نسبة الرجال فهذا طبيعي وما هو عيب ابدا لهم نفس الجمهور المضاهف من الشباب ولكن البنات زودوها شوي
واللي يحب احمد الشريف مو يحب المظهر ابدا لأ
ولكن هو قبول من رب العالمين
يعني مهما كان الفنان موهوب وصوتوا حلو وشكله حلو اذا ما كان عنده قبول او كاريزماوالطلة الحلوة ابدا ما راح ينجح
وهذا الشئ ما يصنعه الفنان ولكن هذا من الله
واقول ان اللقب لا يصنع فنان ولكن الفنان هو الذي يصنع اللقب

ان المصيبه انهم
ما يقلدوا البرامج الاجنبه بالطريقه الصح اولا لجنة التحكيم في سوبر ستار ولجنة الاساتذه في ستار اكاديمي ما يعرفوا يقيموا ولايقدروا الشخص الموهوب على عكس مثيلاتها في البرامج الاجنبيه يعرفوا يعطوا كل واحد حقه والمرتبه اللى يستحقها واكبر مثال على صدق كلامي ان برونو لم يُقدر حق قدره في ستار اكاديمي العرب بينما نجد انه قُدٍر وعُبِر في ستار اكاديمي العالمي ، كما انه ورد في مقالة خاصة في صفحه من صفحات احد مجلات الفن الامريكيه وقد ورد نصيا:" بأن أحمد الشريف هو الموهبه النابعه من الشرق بالرغم من انه حديث العهد بالفن الا انه استطاع ان يثبت سيطه وان يدخل قلوب المعجبين من مختلف الفئات العمريه ومن مختلف دول العالم بما فيهم امريكا على الرغم من ان غنائه شرقي بحت الا انه استطاع ان يمثل العرب بأحسن صوره"، هذا دليل على مدى تفوق الاجانب في هذا المجال وعلى مدى قصور البرامج العربيه في تقدير الفنانين الموهوبين الحقيقيين من عامة الناس
وتعليق على اللي يحكي ويقول انو احمد اكتر محبينه من البنات
في مرة جابوا برنامج صغار كبار على المستقبل ففي المدرسة اطفال كتيير لابسين بندانة فسألتهم المذيعة ليش هيك لابسين
فأجاب الطلاب :متل احمد الشريف لأن صوتو حلو
يعني هو احمد الشريف معجبينو كتار متل اي فنان
متل كاظم الساهر انا بحبوا كتييير لكن البنات بزودوها كتيير مش شوي مع اي فنان
وشو بدنا بالفنان اللي مابيحبوا غير الرجال ؟؟؟؟؟
شو الفرق يعني بين المرأة والرجل ؟
يعني انا بشوف انو كلو جمهور
وكمان اللي بيقول ان اللي يحب احمد الشريف بيحبوا مشان مظهروا بقول لك يا أخي
احنا الحين بزمن شو ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟
احنا الحين بزمن المظاهر
وبشار بحياتو لو شو مابيعمل ماراح يوصل لمستوى صوت احمد الشريف او حتى مظهره
وبس سؤالللكويتين

يعني لو احمد الشريف كان كويتي شو كنتو عملتو ؟
الجواب : كنتوا توجتوا بدون تردد ملك الغناء العربي

looooooooooool

omar+nadin+shadi+saaed=all of them a one stupid guy

to 007:
ur avery biiiiiiiiig stupid
becouse ur know it is the true
and u can not say that
ahmad and attiy are the best

dear Dandoun you didnt say it b4 it was el kaws thhat was saying it nOT YOU

il be frineds because i dont care
ahmad is the best

did u see the program on LBC thursday with osama rahabani ? he talked about staracademy .what did he say about ahmad ?????

sorry dondon i didnt mean anything,add me on msn if u want 2!

wow!alot of fights about the star
but mohamed atteh star mahma sar
keef bet2olo heyak we hwa el aw7ad el ra7 yeshar lel sob7 le ye2ady a7la ma 3endoh!
ana ra7 be7bak 7abeeby mahma y2olo la2inak enta 2akdar wa7d beha el lakab!
go mohamed u r the best!

to poor liar .. u have a good name but if u changed it to poor jeoulous it would be better .coz it is clear u are angry and joulous .u must be a very ugly and sad person .attiah is also ugly with no respect to the egyptian always lying and making people at he academy laughing at him and his bad smell .
and i know poor liar u are some of the few posted before but with a different name .i hate attiah coz he disgraced u egypt .i live in dubai and people here are asking me if all egyptians are that dirty and sneaky .LBC should have chosen a better one to represent us .
we have in egypt people as handsome as ahmad ,we have people with beautiful voices like him .egypt is the centre of the arab art so why did they choose that silly boy attiah .

by the way i am not only defending 3atteya coz i am egyptian but bec i believe he is the star in my eyes and in others too

sherren YOU GOT To ADDMIT THAT AFTER AHMAD ATTIEHS THE BEST

ATTIA is in miss Libanon
I hope that AHMED came too
AHMED MYRIAM BAHAA BACHAR ARE THE BEST
BYE

magda im trying to be nice NO AGFTER AHMAD ATTIEH THE BEST LOL
i want ahmad and others to go to miss lebanon too I HOPE NADINE WINS BUT NO ITS GOING TO BE A LIE just like star acdmey SO PROBLY SAMEONE LIKE SANDRA WIL WIN LOL JOKING

ahmad the best

i'm egyptian and i'm proud of that .it hurts when i listen to people saying they liked tunisia and tunisian people through baha and ahmad . i also liked tunisia and the tunisian when i was watching baha and ahmad .. they have geat personality especially ahmad he is loyal honest and a man really .. he does not cry to get the sympathy of people he does not talk behind people's back like attiah the hypocrit did .when i started watching the program i was ready to support attiah but after i saw him saying bad things about people behind their back ,being a servant to the teachers ,making the clown i lost any respect for him ..i do not like him as a person and of course he has no charisme or voice .i feel he cheated us the egyptian.. he did not represent us nicely .he just wanted to get the money .
well i hope there will be a better egyptian in staracademy 2.coz we hve thousands of real artists in egypt .lbc should have shosen carefully .sorry for saying that but it is the truth we should not lie coz attiah is from our country .i laugh at people who say he has a heart of gold ... are they blind or what ..they can't tell when a person is acting ???

yes no body can act for 4 months this is why we all know the true character of attiah ..some people just lie to them selves .i'm trying to say that not all egyptians are like attiah we are not hypocrits ,dirty or sneaky .the egyptians are great people with great civilisation .they do not lie, humiliate themselves for money .in dubai all the egyptian are disgusted from attiah .we should not support someone only coz he is from oir country dandoun he gave bad idea about us .

hiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii everybody ...i'm egyptian...i'm 18 years old.....plz plz plz plz plz plz plz vote for hadi aswad if u are a real egyptian so plz let's vote 4 him

all my comments r so long!lol!
thats not half what i have to say!but i am taking this 4 fun as i said b4 coz 3atteya won they y would i bother myself let the others burn from inside while 3atteya is the winner and the only star
anyway thnx dondon:)u r soo sweet but i think u shouldnt give them much concern for the reasons i wrote there
maybe she was free and she counted how manytimes he took showers!
know what she should also look for the word real and star and sneaky:D

For God's Sake People.. don't you get it..?! is that because he's a kuwaiti and you arabs hate kuwaitis..!? what's with you..!??! Bashar is The staar mahma kaaaaaaaaan.. everyone loves bashar.. he's got the sense of humour and the voice.. my god 3ala el voice, this guy has the spirit of a real star..that doesn't mean that i hate the others.. cuz that's not true.. i like em all, but when it come to this unjustice, i totally disapprove...! i don't mind any other person to be the star other than bashar, but he has to be worth it.. i mean is it because bashar is kuwaiti u all voted to 3a6eya.. my god, in future, attia has to attend openings of new associations or go and sign his album and talk to reporters, u think he can do it..!??!??!? He's a maniac..!! It's a shame that he'll go representing us Arabs in the World BEst next year.. this is what u wanted, have it! they'll be laughing at us..!! he wouldn't be joking for a start cuz he doesn't know their language.. so what's he good at again, other than being a clown..!??! Shame on u ppl.. seriously.. Listen To bashar's voice in the url i have put.. and tell me that 3a6eya is better..!!

superstar o baaaaaaaas

into msh cooool la2ankom bitab3o star academy yukky