hey bashar is gr8
so is mohameddd 3atteya
actully i like mohamed more but that dznt mean that bashar was the bestttttttttttt 2!
i think they're both now stars
but the final was on 2 main things voting and luck(and 3atteya had more luck coz maybe more ppl liked him)anyway they're all stars
AND AGAIN NO 1 INSULTS 3ATTEYA OR MOHAMED B4 ANY1 POSTS HIS OPINION
I MAY HACK UR COMPUTER IF U DO!!!
ESPPECIALLLY 3ATTEYA DNT INSULT!

I thought (and more ppl) that Bachar would B the Star, coz the others were always talking about him.
I'm very glad that Attieh is the Star.
If Bachar was the Star, then was Kuwait thinkin' that they r always the best.

I'm an egyptian girl , i like both of them but i voted 4 bashar i think he deserves 2 be a star cuz i like his voice more than ateyah but actually ateyah is gr8!
And im very proud of our Egyptian STAR!!

Bachar has got a gr8 voice...that's true,
but I hate his attitude.
That is why he shouldn't B the Star.

the truth AHMED SHOULD OF BEEN THE STAR
but when he left i wanted Attieh to win but i knew bashar deserved it more im glad attiehs the star
AHMED U R THE REAL STAR
GOO ATTIEH IM GLAD U WON
BASHAR IF U WERNT AROUND SOFIA all the time maybe i would of liked u but i realy realy like your voice and your song
AHMED PLEASE COME AND VISIT AMERICA EVERYONE IS WAITING FOR U OHH AND ATIEH AND BAHA and KHLOWI PEOPLE WANT TO SEE U TO COME PLEASE COME

TO THE QUESTION DO I THINK BASHAR WOULD HAVE BEEN A BETTER STAR AS MUCH AS I HATE HIM AND SOFIA HE HAS A NICER VOICE YES I DO THINK HE WOULD BE A BETTER STAR

AAAAAAAAAAH... BACHAR..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BAcHAR DESERVES TO WIN NOT ATTIEH...

OH My GoD... HIS VOICE IS SO BEAUTIFUL..!!!

Goooooo BACHAR.. YOU ARE THE STAR..

I LOVE YOU.. !!!!!!!!!!

WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO... BACHAR....

BACHAR IS THE STAR...

I LOVE YOU..!! HABIBIE

Goooo BACHAR

BACHARNOOOO 4-Sho

BACHARNOOOO BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO
BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO
BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO BACHARNOOO

HAAAI AMAL.. GEKKIE..

HOW ARE YOU DUsHi..?
BACHAR IS THE BEST..!! OF NiE DaNg..!!

I SEE YOU 2 MORROW.. LOvE YoU GuRl

KiSsEsSs FrOm Me.. MwaHhH

I agree with amy 100%! ahmad should of been the star, but aftr he left atteih was next!

Both of them are colown ...Nd non of them desearve to be a star.....I think Ahmad Al-sherif deserve to be the star

YES AHMED SHOULD BE THE STAR
HIS THE BEST AND ALLWAYS WILL BE
BUT BAShAR DOSE HAVE A NICE VOICE
AMANI YOUR SOOO IN LOVE WITH BASHAR LOL HIS UGLY BUT IT TRUE HIS GOT A NICE VOICE I DIDNT LIKE HIM WHEN HE WAS AROUND SOFIA I HATE HER
GOOD LUCK TO ALLL OFF THEM I LOVE AHMED
AMANI DONT BE SAD BASHAR IS STILL THE STAR THEY ALL R WINNERS

Of course Ahmad Al-Sheref is the star

No Attiah ...No Bashar deserve to be the star ....AHMAD is the real star....

AHMED THE STAR AHMED THE STAR
I love Ahmed
ahmed u should be the star i love u

bashar i love u to u have a gorges voice how could attiah the monkey win and not u

Ahmed i cryied soo much when u left u should be the star i love ahmed and bashar

Every one of us know that nobody in star academy is complete and real like Ahmad Al-sheref ...so , Ahmad is the one who deserve to be the star of the academy ...the others are good but not as good as Ahmad

that was my sister samantha before i dont really like bashar

soooo true AHMED SHOULD OF BEEN the star
my sister wanted attih to get it but ireally wanted bashar AHMED MORE OF COURSE

I LOVE U AHMED I LOVE BASHAR
MY SISTER LOVES U ATTIH

Go east ..go west ...Ahmad is the best

i really like u Zakaria
AHMED IS THE BEST I LIKE EVERYONE THAT AGREES
WITH ME
GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO AHMED
AHMED I LOVE U FOR EVER

i liked ahnmed so much & i cried when he left the academy but i love attiah & about who 's better attiah or bachar ofcouuuuuuuurssssssssse attiah cuz he's a polite kind-hearted person not rude like bachar anyway i hate bachar & sofia & if the voting was between ahmed & attiah i would ve voted 4 neither of them cuz both of them are the best

من غير ما نضحك على نفوسنا000000بصراحه احمد هو الستار ومن غير مجادل000وخير الكلام ما قل ودل

omg alllllll AUSTRALIA CRYIED WHEN AHMED LEFT
but im really happy that Attieh won not bashar his got a nice voice but him and sofia are so stupid and anoying together
GOOO AHMED U WILL ALWAYS BE THE STAR I WISH i coULD of voted for you but know one knew how we all love you AHMED

IM ITALIAN I LOVE YOUR SHOW STAR ACDEMY
BUT IM SOOOOOOO UNGRY THAT AHMED DIDNT WIN
im happpy that bashar didnt came 1st but AHMED should have won i love u ahmed i dont underatnd what anyone is saying but i love ahmed so much
i hope to see them i live in america in LA almost everyone watchs the show you should have seen alll the people getting ungry when ahmed left all my friend my mum my dad my best friedn his a guy his from moroco criey
alot of people cried THE HAPPIEST DAY OF MY LIFE WAS WHEN BASHAR DIDNT WIN I WAS SOO HAPPY BUT STILL AHMED SHOULD HAVE WON IM HAPPI U BOUGHT AHMED TO STAY FOR A WEEK I DONT REAALY LIKE ATTIAH BUT HIS BETTER THEN BASHAR ANYWAY I THINK THAT IF IT WAS REALLY UP TO THE PEOPLE AHMED WOULD HAVE WON AND IF WE COULD VOTE FROM AMERICA AHMED WOULD OF WON
WE LOVE YOU AHMED SOOOOOOOO MUCHHH

i think that the whole star academy show was fab! bachar..is a gr8 student..and i think he could've been much better...i think his rude attitude is the thing that let him down..and every day life..he used to say that attieh didn't know how to sing...that kind of pissed me off...'cause he acts so nice to attieh but he says other stuff behind his back..ok he has the voice..knows how to have fun and is a good player..but without attieh in star academy no one would have watched the show!! he spiced the show and i gave it this gr8 touch...with his sense of humour, acting and ofcourse his voice...and to the rest (14) u are all stars..no matter how bad they r or good..they have their fans..good work everyone and congratulation to attieh!!! u deserve the best!!!

i think that the whole star academy show was fab! bachar..is a gr8 student..and i think he could've been much better...i think his rude attitude is the thing that let him down..and every day life..he used to say that attieh didn't know how to sing...that kind of pissed me off...'cause he acts so nice to attieh but he says other stuff behind his back..ok he has the voice..knows how to have fun and is a good player..but without attieh in star academy no one would have watched the show!! he spiced the show and i gave it this gr8 touch...with his sense of humour, acting and ofcourse his voice...and to the rest (14) u are all stars..no matter how bad they r or good..they have their fans..good work everyone and congratulation to attieh!!! u deserve the best!!!

i think that the whole star academy show was fab! bachar..is a gr8 student..and i think he could've been much better...i think his rude attitude is the thing that let him down..and every day life..he used to say that attieh didn't know how to sing...that kind of pissed me off...'cause he acts so nice to attieh but he says other stuff behind his back..ok he has the voice..knows how to have fun and is a good player..but without attieh in star academy no one would have watched the show!! he spiced the show and i gave it this gr8 touch...with his sense of humour, acting and ofcourse his voice...and to the rest (14) u are all stars..no matter how bad they r or good..they have their fans..good work everyone and congratulation to attieh!!! u deserve the best!!!

Joanne why don't you watch your mouth eh! You're prolly some 10 year old who doesn't know what she's talking about! Sofia is GREAT, she is ADORABLE she's so BEAUTIFUL and she has a LOVELY VOICE, get over it, she is PERFECT! And your just jealous of her! So how about you stop bad-mouthing her, you don't even know her in real life! So Back off! LEave her alone! SHES AMAZING! AND SHE HAS SOOOO MANY FANS ALL AROUND THE WORLD!

3attia better then bashar ..
i love ahmadi so much.. and i hate this bashar
mabrooook 3attia

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

the subject is bashar better than 3ateya and why not ahmed
ahmed has the worest voice i heard and he has only a nice face
but 3ateya and bashar are both great kind,have great voice,funny
but ahmed is the worest voice i cant know why he still till that day
all of u say that ahmed is the star but why didnt u vote for him
goooooooooooooooo 3ateya
goooooooooooooooo bashar
good luck both u r both a stars for me

AHMAD U R THE REAL STAR .
WE LOVE U .

No bashar....... No attieh .................. AHMAD-AL-SHERIF IS THE ONLY STAR like most of the people think...
Love you barcha barcha barcha....................
P:S:AHMAD HAS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL VOICE NOT ONLY THE MOST BEAUTIFUL FACE.......

sure bashar must be the winner cause his voice is wonderful.
i like him sosososososososososososo much he's the best and not 3tiye.
he doesn't deserve to be a star . i prefer any student of the other 15 but not 3tiya

ALL MOHAMMAD ATTIEH'S FANS.
I am sorry to say this but he had played a foolish fool on all of you by Tese funny tricks on the academy wich have made you VOTE for him.
HAVE YOU ALL EVER SEEN A SINGER LIKE HIM AND HIS PERSONALITY?
a SINGER SHOULD BE RESPECTFUL AND SERIOUS ANYWHERE HE GO SO PEOPLE SHOULD TREAT HIM THE SAME.

thats me joanne and katie agrees

im glad attiah won
not bashar my mum WAS really upset because the truth is bashar had the nicest voice
I THINK SOFIA HAD A NICE VOICE BUT YES SHE WASN'T GOOD AT THE END SHE WAS CUTE AT THE START
I LOVE AHMED EL- SHILEF SOOOOOOOO MUCH why did he gooooo omg i was soo upset Ahmed was the best
GOOD LUCK TO ALL OF THEM
I MISS STAR ACDEMY
I MISS AHMED
AND I AGREE WITH SOMEONE WHO SAID IF ATTIH WASNT AT STAR ACDEMY IT WOULDNT OF BEEN AS GOOD EVEN WHEN AHMED LEFT FOR 2 WEEKS IT WASNT AS GOOD THEY ALL MAKE IT GOOD

dose anyone now what the 8 people from staracdemy r up 2 im soo lost im from america i know nothing about them anymore are they together what are they doing??? please if anyone knows tell me i LOVE AHMED
r they in lebanon were are they???
please tell me

To answer the question, no I do not believe that Bashar would have been a better Star. Mohammed Attieh is the real star and I am glad he won. Secondly, I would like to say to the stupid girls who are in love with Ahmad, that he doesn't deserve to be a star. He is good looking, we all have realized that but it is not enough to be a star, he doesn't have the talent that Attieh has. Go Attieh, you are the best!

AHMED IS GOOD LOOKING AND HAS TALENT (SAHAR) HOW DARE U CALL US STUPID ITS NOT ONLY THE GIRLS THAT LIKE HIM SOOO MANY GUYS LOVE HIM TO
ATTIEH IS NOT THE BEST HIS VOICE IS SHIT THE ONLY REASON HE WON IS BEACSE SAUIDA VOTED FOR HIM SOOO DID WE AMERICA BECAUSE HE LIKES AHMED ALOT
AHMED IS THE STAR

we live in Australia and we love staracdmey
WE LOVE AHMED THE MOST THEN ATTIA SO WERE HAPPI ABOUT THE WINNER EVEN THOUGH IT SHOULD OF BEEN AHMED
WE WILL TELL YOU WAT EVERYONE THINKS ABOUT EVERYONE HERE

AHMED- everyone LOVES hIM EVERYONE EVEN PEople WhO DONT SPEak ARABIC OLD YOUNG People every age

bashar- WE LOVE HIS VOICE BUT we all HATE HIM MY MUM LIKES HIM 2nd BEST AFTER AHMED

Baha- she nice go a nice voice older people like her

attieh- AFTER AHMED LEFT ALL THE YOUNG PEOPLE WANTED HIM TO WIN HIS GOT OLD FANS LIKE GRANPARENTS

SOFIA- EVERYONE HATES HER EVERYONE SHE USE TO HAVE FANS I DONT KNOW Y EVERYONE STARTED TO HATE HER

MUHHMED K- HIS A GOOD MAN OLDER PEOLE LIKED HIM AFTER AHMED THEN WHEN AHMED LEFT ALL AHMED FANS HATED HIM THEN WHEN BASHAR WON THE LIKED HIM AND HATED BASHAR VERY STARNG

BRUNO- HE WAS A KIND MAN

THE HARDEST THING FOR PEOPLE IN AUSTRALIA WAS WHEN AHMED LEFT EVERYONE I KNOW WAS SOOOO ANGRY

THE BEST THING WAS WHEN ATTIEH WON THEY ALL STARTED TO HATE BASHAR AT THE END FOR SAME STRANGE REASON

AHMED WAS ALWAYS THE FAVOURITE THEN ATTIEH BAHHA TO LOTS OF PEOPLE LIKe HER AHMED ALLLLLLL THE GIRLS AND GUYS LIKED HIM FROM THE AGES 2 to about 28 he had lost of older fans to

anyway no we dont think bashar would have been a better star

i think that Ahmad must won because he have all the charactrics to be star but after ahmed leave i think BAsher deserve to be a star than atieh &i think he will be a big star in fufure

HEY Do KNOW PREVENT IS THERE SOMEONE OR IT PERHAPS COMING FRIDAY SOMETHING ON LBC?

GREETINGS

Am agree with u Amanda ..The singer must be respectful not moving like a kid like Attiah........

But I disagree with sahar in that Attiah is more talent than Ahmad ....Of course u r wrong bcoz AHMAD is the most talent person in the academy

And I disappointed from your attitude dondon ...bcoz u r really wrong...And AHMAD has a nicer voice I ever heard .......even ahmad has abeautiful voice even more than the singers who are singing with Ahmad like Hani Shaker, Ehab Tofeeq, Ba AL-Khair....and many others

and 4 u dondon , who told u that we are not voting 4 Ahmad ...we vote 4 him but we not cheating like ATTIAH & BASHAR fans who are voting freely through web sites and sms ...Despite the voting was free ,Bashr didn't win bcoz of his rudness ...Attiah win not bcoz the people love him but bcoz the people hate Bashar and find Attiah better than Bashar but not the best over Ahmad

Alfn khassar kteer lma tla3o Ahmad min Star Academy bcoz Alfn need some one like Ahmad to be valid ....while many other singers are Keemalit 3dad....

We All love u Ahmad

Why Waleg site put that Bashar is have been a better "Star" than Mohammad Attieh and why not put AHMAD AL-SHEREF is better "Star" than Mohammad Attieh or the best over the others

Surly Ahmad is the one who really deserve to be the star and win the title of star academy

Fo this reason , we all insist in letting Ahmad the star of the academy and no one else....

we all with u AHMAD AL-SHEREF

we want Ahmad to be the star ...not Attiah and not bashar to be the star because non of them deserve to be the star in comparison with Ahmad and Khalawi...

The all public choose the best who are AHMAD AL-SHIREF

Ahmad Alsheref is the best of the best

AHmad is the star ..go Ahmad ..we all love u truly and votting 4 u truly bcoz u r true ,we r true with u ...not cheting like Attiah and Bashar fans

Go Ahmad.... Go Ahmad....Go Ahmad....

احنا نطالب موقع الوالج والال بي سي بتعيين احمد ستار للاكاديميه0000ونطالبهم بان يتداركوا الغش والخداع اللي حصل في عملية التصويت 000وان عطيه وبشار ما يستحقوا يبقوا للاخير ولا يستحق عطيه لقب الستار 0000لان احمد هو الستار الحقيقي بشهادة الاغلبيه0000

Ahmad ..we hope that u open this site and see how the people love u and respect u ......U r great person...

السبب اللى جعل الاغلبيه يحبوا أحمد الشريف هو ان احمد انسان قبل ما يكون فنان 0000وانه صادق قبل ما يكون ناطق0000وان خلقه جميل بالرغم من وجهه الوسيم000000وانه عالي من غير مايكون مُتعالي