This week’s nominees …


Nominees... Bachar and Mohammad Khalwai

This week two nominees are two guys, Saudi Mohammad Khalawi and Kuwaiti Bachar Shatti...

This is the third time Mohammad Khalawi is a nominee while it is only the second time for Bachar Shatti.

Who do you think will leave the academy this week?

137 Comments
  1. iman | March 16, 2004 8:13 PM

    OO BABY Bachar is nominee!!!!

    Go Khalawi!!


    I love Ahmad OOH BABY I miss You!!

    iman
  1. عاشقة بشار وصوفي | March 16, 2004 8:54 PM

    أنا أحب بشار وأنا رااااااااااااااح أصوت له

    عاشقة بشار وصوفي
  1. عاشقة بشار وصوفي | March 16, 2004 8:56 PM

    شبااااااااااب تتوقعون منو اللي راح يغادر الأكاديمية؟؟؟؟
    أنا أتوقع خلاوي

    عاشقة بشار وصوفي
  1. reem | March 16, 2004 10:04 PM

    WoW this is the greatest nomination ever after bashar and sophia's nomination two weeks ago..I hope khalawi will win this coz he deserves this more than bashar..first coz his voice is ok and he is a gentleman and he was ahmad's best friends and ahmad said that if khalawi stayed its like he stayed ..plus he is the only one who is not teasing bahaa 24/7 like attieh and bashar who are gonna explode from jealousy coz she has the best voice and hasnt been nominated yet and nshala she will never be..goodluck khalawi...we love you ahmaddddddddddddddddddd and we miss you we will never forget you ever...looking forward to see you in two weeks in the final prime...

    reem
  1. Ahbal | March 16, 2004 10:17 PM

    I would like to see both Bashar and Khalawy goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo :)

    If life would be fair, then Bahaa or Atieh would be the winners.... But since life is not and Saudi Amir Walid Bin Talal owns 49% of LBC and the whole Saudi kingdom gets to vote free.. then Khalawy will stay and win.... Lets remember that there is no guarantee that the results they show us are the real results.. we would not know what happens behind the scenes and what games are played...
    Enjoy the songs and the fun.. Make your favorite your star and don't worry about who they pick. If we support the ones we love by byung their albums, that is all they want from us :)

    Ahbal
  1. Suha | March 16, 2004 10:30 PM

    Listen guys let me put it this way....who got better voice of course Bashar....who's more cool...of course Bashar...who's more talented with instruments....of course bashar...Bashar was able to do a song for him which was good becasue he have experience in it...do you think that khalawi would be able to do a song for himself??
    Anyways I vote for Bashar cuz he's the best...he has a great personality!!!! Go BASHAR

    Suha
  1. lalous | March 16, 2004 10:52 PM

    Finally someone agrees with me Thank u so much AhBAL for ur comment.........but still let's see who got more money saudi's or kuwait's and yeah it would be so fair if Bahaa wins cause she really deserves it and the proof is she hasnt been nominated not even once.......and for everyone that keeps on saying khalawie acts more like a grown up than attieh and bashar well definitely he is 26 and they are 21--5years is a difference......anyways i care less who wins b/w the two but i prefer bashar just because of Khalawi and saudi's money ....ahmad lost...

    lalous
  1. giselle | March 16, 2004 11:41 PM

    If all of you are serious and seriously want Khalawi to stay, that is just ridiculous. bachar is soooo much better. do you actually listen when they sing????i guess not if you think khalawi should stay!!! and ahmad is gone...i miss him too but i know he won't mind if bachar stays>GOOOO Bachar

    giselle
  1. Yara | March 17, 2004 12:20 AM

    GOOOOOOOOO BACHARNO!!! I have liked Bashar the best from the beginning, and I feel he deserves to stay now! come on, what is wrong with everyone? Khalawy has no voice at all, and if you watched the prime last week you will see that they did not even have him sing in the song about lebnan!! that says something! I like Baahat and Attieh too, and I wouldn't mind if they won, but I will be very disappointed if Bashar leaves before Khalawy!! But again, the Saudis have the money, and sadly money sometimes wins!! But please don't say Khalawy has a better voice or personality, because that is just wrong!I vote for Bashar now and always, never Khalawy!!!

    Yara
  1. Suha | March 17, 2004 3:39 AM


    Bashar is the most talented of all....please guys vote for him!!! cuz he defentely have better voice than khalawy and this is exactly what we're suppose to vote on for someone who have the voice..so it's defenetly Bahsar!! GOO BASHAR

    Suha
  1. nazoo | March 17, 2004 9:38 AM

    i want bashar to leave hehehehehehe
    hate him

    nazoo
  1. Diana | March 17, 2004 12:48 PM

    This is for Imad:
    Bashar ....

    Diana
  1. Mona | March 17, 2004 1:01 PM

    HEY BOYZ and GIRLS,
    THE WHOLE THING IS A WASTE OF TIME !!!
    THEY SHOULD CALL IT "RATS" ACADEMY" :P
    JUST READ THE WORD BACKWARDS ....hehehe
    At the Prime, I will go to sleep.

    I love myself and Samsoom very much and I hate everyone else so don't forget to Vote for me MONA !!!! yes yes yessssss

    Mona
  1. SANA | March 17, 2004 1:33 PM

    I VOTE FOR THE BEST OF ACADEMY BACHAR STARAC

    SANA
  1. fatima | March 17, 2004 1:34 PM

    JE VOTE POUR LE MEILLEUR DE TOUS BACHAR STARAC

    fatima
  1. amal | March 17, 2004 1:35 PM

    JJEEEE VVVVVOOOTE POUR BACHAR STARAC

    amal
  1. k.s.a girl | March 17, 2004 4:41 PM

    vote 4 khalawi it's now or never law 9oot wa7ed min kol a7ad inshalla 7ayfooz yestahel els3odi a5lag o 9oot o 5efat dam yalla howa yesta7eg yalla ya hoooo erfa3 elsama3a o vote 3ashan khalawi
    yalla ya nas yalla (i know i'm getting so excited)lol

    k.s.a girl
  1. LAMYAA | March 17, 2004 5:13 PM

    I LOVE KAHALWI AND BASHAR BOTH OF THEM DESERVE TO STAY. BUT PLEASE SHABAB DON'T BE RUDE WITH THEM BCZ SOME COMMENTS MADE ME ANGRY, SOME PEOPLE WHO DON'T KNOW NOTHING IN ARTS BEGAN TALKING AND TALKING BLABLABLA WITHOUT ANY RIGHTS OR ARGUMENTS. PLEASE KEEP YOURSELF THEIR, IN ACADEMY AND JUDGE YOURSELF MAY BE U WILL LEAVE AT THE FIRST WEEK.SO PLEASE BE COMPREHENSIBLE AND PUT NICE COMMENTS TO SUPPORT THEM. GO KHALAWI I ADORE U TOO MUCH.
    LAMYAA FROM MOROCCO

    LAMYAA
  1. iman | March 17, 2004 7:40 PM

    sorry but I Hate Bachar

    iman
  1. Eve | March 17, 2004 7:48 PM

    kalawi&ahmad&bahaa r the best they have the best voices so please all lebanon vote for kalawi, he has the strongest voice and he is gentleman i vote for u kalawi

    Eve
  1. nidine 4m kuwait | March 17, 2004 7:53 PM

    vote for basharno
    oh i hate u ahmad have u heard him(he told kalawi and baha that he hope two of them in the final)he is selfish !!
    i know that bashar is nervous but he has a butiful voice vote for him!!

    nidine 4m kuwait
  1. rania | March 17, 2004 7:54 PM

    BACHAR!!!!!! I LOVE YOU!! go bachar! booo khalawi! bachar! bachar! bachar! bachar! i want khalawi to leave, and if it's true that his dad's paying people to vote for him, then he's so cheap!
    *B*A*C*H*A*R*

    rania
  1. rania | March 17, 2004 8:00 PM

    and yara, and every one with bachar, I LOVE YOU TOO! bachar is the best and deserves to win. he's good at acting, singing...so GO BACHAR!! he's so cute! and nidine 4m kuwait i totally agree with you about ahmad. and bachar has a beautiful voice!
    bacharno, bacharno, shookran al macacroona! i love ateyha too! and bahaa!

    rania
  1. راكان | March 17, 2004 8:43 PM

    السلام عليكم


    النومنيز حسب القوانين مفترضا أن يكون حسب التالي

    - آداء الطلاب في الحصص
    - آدائهم في البرايم
    - آدائهم في الاختبار الأسبوعي
    -سلوكياتهم

    الزعيم مقارنة بالمتبقين تقيمه كاتالي

    - الحصص:2-1 نظرا لانضباته واجتهاده حتى في الحصص التي هو ضعيف فيهاكحصة عايدة واليسار , واذا لاحظتوا بعد الفحص وفي حصة الفوكليست قالت مدام ماري أن الخلاوي الوحيد الذي مستواه في تحسن دائم ام الآخرون فيتفاوتون , بالرغم من ذالك اختارته نومني ؟؟؟؟؟؟

    البرايم:1 من هنا لفبوه زملائه بالزعيم , حيث أن خطأه الوحيد هو أن نفسه أحيانا قصير وهذا ينطبق على جميع الطلاب , عدا ذالك فهو لا يخطئ او ينشز ابدا في البرايم , وبشهادة المناقفان وديع و ميشيل

    الفحص الاسبوعي:2-3 نعم , أخطأ ونسى كوبليه في الفحص قبل الأخير , ونعم بان عليه بعض التوتر في الفحص الأخير , لكن كما كان واضحا لنا جميعا أن ىدائه لم يكن أسوأبأي مقياس من بهاء او عطية ؟؟؟؟؟

    السلوكيات:1 أعتقد أن هذا الموضوع لا يحتاج الى تعليق , فسلوكياته أخلاقه بشهادة جميع الأساتذة والطلاب والمشاهدن لا يعلى عليها

    وهناك أيضا عامل الموهبة الموسيقية , تذكرون في النصف الأول للبرنامج عندما كان على الطلاب تأليف أغاني الفحص, فألف الزعيم العديد من الأغاني وألألحان لنفسه وزملائه , فمن هذا المنطلق , حيث أنه يؤلف ويلحن ويجيد استخدام آلات موسيقية , العود والقيتار والأورج , لا يقارن بأحد من الطلبة به سوى بشار

    اذا كيف يتفق جميع الأساتذة أنه نومني ؟؟؟؟؟

    , اتضح لنا نوايا الأساتذة والمقيمين على البرنامج , هدفهم:

    - المال

    - تقديم ستار عربي يتمتع بأخلاق غربية, والحمدلله هذا لا يتواجد في الخلاوي,

    لايخفى عليكم ان القائمون على البرنامج عرب بلا عروبة ويريدون تقديم ستار عربي لا يتمتع بالعروبة أيضا , ومن المتبقين افرب شخص بهذه المواصفات هي بهاء حيث انها امرأة عربيية تتحدث الفرنسية ولا تمانع في لبس الألبسة الفاضحة وهذه ما يعتقدونه مودرن او حضاري ؟؟
    والدليل تركيزهم عليها ومديحهم لهاالذي يتحدى المنطق والواقع انها لم تختير نومني رغم اخطائها المتكررة, فمع احترامي لمحبيها , صوتها جيد لكن لا تفارن من ناحية الآداء والموهبة بالآخرين

    ,انا متأكد اذا بقى الزعيم , ومهما فعل الأسبوع القادم سوف يستمروا في اختياره نومني

    لذا أطلب من جميع محبييه حفظ كرامته وحفظ أموالهم , فهو ستار دون البرنامج وسينجح رغم أنف عبدة الغرب

    راكان
  1. soso | March 17, 2004 11:59 PM

    if kalwie's dad is paying people money to vote for him , that mean there cheating and kalwie should leave because , he doesnt even have a good voice or nothing you know when kalwie won last prime not ahmed because his dad payed for him and ahmed had to stay not kalwie and if his dad keeps paying money it means that kalwie is winning so every one vote for bacher so that kalwie gets out. and remmber thais he doesnt even have a good voice and there cheating so everyone vote for bacher

    soso
  1. dark | March 18, 2004 12:40 AM

    i hate them both & i wish they kick them out soon
    sophia ,bruno were the best
    all the rest .......are bad

    dark
  1. fadwa | March 18, 2004 1:52 AM

    guys this isn't an attitude contest its MUSIC ... so obviously bashar is the best!!!! come on!! who cares if khalawi is ahmed's best friend, how old r u guys? who cares if khalawi is more behaved!!
    bashar is gr888 he sings very well, he has 3 tones, the one he likes best the fadl shaker one and the high lebanese pitch he sang in (3al 3ain) and the one he sang with diana haddad in (law yes2aloni) ... he can litrally play any song on the piano, he's so good in playing the guitar, he's so nice to attiya and most imp. of all, he's sofia's lover!!!!
    ISN'T THIS A MUSIC CONTEST??? THE GUY IS GR8

    fadwa
  1. UaE4EvEr | March 18, 2004 2:36 AM

    LeeSh Ho 3ala Kaifkum enah oboo 5alawee YerShe enaS ebaizatah 3eeeeeeeeeb 3leekum yal lebnaneyeen ,, leesh me7tereen lenkum ma3ndkum baizaat how Rude walah .. Go Go 5alaweeeeeeee o 7arah 3leeeeeekum yal 5yaaaaaaaas ..
    GO GO 5alawee You Are the Best :)

    UaE4EvEr
  1. UaE4EvEr | March 18, 2004 2:41 AM

    UaE Vote 4 5alawee Coz he DeSerVeS 2 Stay .. His VoiCe is very Very Nice and he is gentleman .. Love You 5alawee and GooDLuCK :)

    UaE4EvEr
  1. UaE4EvEr | March 18, 2004 3:01 AM

    Go EaSt Go WesT KhaLaWi Is The BeSt WeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeW

    UaE4EvEr
  1. SharJaWeYah | March 18, 2004 3:30 AM

    Inshalah khalawee bayfoooz lenah yeste7eg el Fooz :-) o lah fe 7aD gaal >> who cares if khalawi is more behaved!! >> hashay leh qeemah yalee mat3arfeen eselook .. khalawee deserves 2 win

    SharJaWeYah
  1. QaTaR | March 18, 2004 3:41 AM

    تصوتو لمييييييييييييييييييين لمحمد تصوتو لمييييييييييييين لمحمد
    الصراحه محمد يستاهل يتم في الاكاديمية و يفوز بلقب ستار أكاديمي .... كلنا نحبك يامحمد خلاوي و بالتوفيق نحبــــــــك موووووووووووووووووت

    QaTaR
  1. LanDaneYah | March 18, 2004 3:46 AM

    My Vote 2 Mohammed khalawi bcoz he is better than Bashar..
    and my friends will vote 2 khalwi 2 ..
    we love you Mohammed K

    khalawi Khalawi Khalawi Khalawi

    LanDaneYah
  1. giselle | March 18, 2004 4:04 AM

    Gooooo Bachar!!!!he definitely deserves to stay more than Khalawi. Why? b/c his voice is much much much better.... he's nicer and who cares if he is not as gentelman as khalawi, he still is a gentleman, he just knows how to have fun....and most of all he DOES NOT CHEAT!!!!! go bachar!!!! i agree completely with yara!!!Bachar is the BEST!!!!

    giselle
  1. Manar | March 18, 2004 10:26 AM

    Bashar is the best . we vote for bashar
    Bashar will be the winner
    we love you Bashar so much

    Manar
  1. Yazan | March 18, 2004 10:58 AM

    البقاء للافضل وخلاوي هو الافضل
    هل سمعتم قول الشاعر :

    ستبدي لك الايام ماكنت جاهلا***وياتيك بالاخبار من لم تزودي

    المقصود بالخبر الذي لم تزود به هو الخلاوي ....

    وعدنا البرايم ان شاء الله

    Yazan
  1. k.s.a girl | March 18, 2004 11:06 AM

    come on guys who told u that khalawi is cheating ,his dad is not paying anyone 2 vote 4 him , and btw he's not that rich he comes from an average family ,it's all romurs it's silly that u believe it , stop saying bad stuff about khalawi .

    k.s.a girl
  1. Yazan | March 18, 2004 11:09 AM

    if you think of the behavior of the students from the first time of the starAcadmy you will find your self in the front of the most important fact which is " Khalawiii Alzaeeeem" the Best in every thing...

    I voted for Alzaeeeeeeeem.........
    Je vote pour Al-Zaeeeeeem......
    Voté por Alzaem..............
    Ich wählte für Alzaem.........
    Ho votato per Alzaem..........
    私はAlzaem のために投票した.........

    in all of the languges of the world I vote for Al-zaeeeem.

    الوعـــــــــد البرايم انشاء الله

    Yazan
  1. q8_cHiC | March 18, 2004 11:32 AM

    kHaLawi HaS BeeN a NoMinEEe FaR 2 ManY TiMeZz..WeLl aTLeaSt mOrE ThaN basHaR, iTz oBviOuS iTz TiMe 4 HiM 2 LeaVe!!!! i vOtE 4 7aBeeeBi BasHaR..!! He HaZzz 2 wiN La2aNa BiDooN BasHar BiL aCaDemY ... iTz DEFINETLY nOt GoInG 2 bE tHa SaME!!! baShAr iS mY beSt aNd BasHar is THE BEST!!
    Luv u!! =*

    q8_cHiC
  1. Kaify Kuwaity!! | March 18, 2004 11:40 AM

    Some of you seriously think khalawy should stay? For those who want him to stay (i can't imagine why though) i think his dad has sent you some $'s too eh? Anyway to serious matters now.. whats up with you UAE girl saying the lebanese are jealous of saudias money?? how old r u? 5? 7? so rude.. but then again thats what you expect from that part of the region. Bahaà has an amazing voice!! Attiya has a wonderful personality and a great voice! bashar well he has both attributes from the latter and plus he plays different kinds of instruments.. now whos the ugly duckling that does NOT have anything in common with his "friends" ? u got it :) so I would say Bashar stays on board because he deserves it, plain and simple. No hard feelings khalawy .. but it's the survival of the fittest, not the richest.

    Kaify Kuwaity!!
  1. Manal | March 18, 2004 12:03 PM

    I think Khalawi should win. I loved Ahmad, and he was Ahmad's best friend.
    Also, who said that Saudi's can vote for free? Thats just a load of BS that people make up as an excuse when the person they like gets voted out. People, check your facts please. Saudi Arabia is one of the richest Arab countries, but they don’t own Nescafe or LBC. And its not Khalawi's fault that people make up such fake rumors about him and his country.

    Manal
  1. manaal m | March 18, 2004 1:56 PM

    am reallllly happy for the first time my dream came to true BASHAR AND KHALAWI ARE THE NOMINEES,THANKS ROULA.I want bashar to stay because he got a better voice than khalawi.but my ACTUAL STAR IS MOHAMMAD ATTIEH. AMINE(I MISS UR EYES)AHMAD(I MISS UR SMILE).KHALAWI SHOULD LEAVE THIS WEEK.

    manaal m
  1. Yara | March 18, 2004 2:14 PM

    Thank You very very much Kaify from Kuwait! You are absolutely right. For the UAE girl who said Lebanese are jealous of Saudi's money, that is just disgusting and rude to say. Please don't insult me or any other lebanese again. We would never be jealous of their money, but the Lebanese just don't like people who cheat. It is not rumors either; it is a known fact that a Saudi Arabian owns 49% of LBC. We know no more than that, nothing about what goes on behind the scenes. NO hard feelings towards anyone, but I feel if you stop and listen to Bashar and Khalawy you will see that Bashar has the better voice and better ability for music. Go Basharno!!! If all goes well, the true winner this week should be you!!

    Yara
  1. junz | March 18, 2004 3:04 PM

    6ab3an kil ily gala kaify kwaity sa7 ... and i thank all of those who voted for bashar .. at least we know 100% that he's not cheating in anyways .. and i vote for him with all my heart becuz he truly deserves to stay .. i think anyone out of bashar or attiyah or bahaa2 deserve to win except for khalawi .. i dont like his voice at all i dont even believe his voice is that good from the first time i listened to it .. and he cant even do the shami lahja rite ... and i dont see how the people say he's a gentleman oo maba3rif shoo ... did any of u see how much he fites in the gym class when he loses ... since a long time i've seen his childish behaviour .. but then again it doesnt matter about the persoonality .. what truly matters is the voice i just wanted to make a point on how "ungentleman" and childish he is :D .. i have many other points against hiM ... but who cares its the VOICE .. :D

    junz
  1. k.s.a girl | March 18, 2004 5:10 PM

    what's the problem with u guys?? how many times do i have 2 say that khalawi's dad is not paying any1 2 vote 4 his son , the ppl r voting 4 him coz 1. he has a wonderful personality 2.great voice 3.he plays on different kinds of instrumens(oud , guitar,and piano)so please just stop saying bad stuff about khalawi , i hate bashar 2 death but i didn't say bad stuff about him or start spredding romurs , and kaify kuwaity i think u already know that kuwait is a rich country and they can vote 2 bashar non stop , anywayz i'm not voting 4 khalawi coz it's better 4 him 2 leave and i think that most of the saudi's agree with me coz if he wins u'll start saying that he won by cheating bla bla bla , but he'll still be a star in our hearts .

    k.s.a girl
  1. Kaify Kuwaity! | March 18, 2004 5:57 PM

    Ur welcome Yara and thanks Junz :)

    I hope Bashar wins tomorrow, i really do because he deserves to win .. if and when for some unfortunate reason i.e an "invisible hand" intervenes and he doesn't win, well, atleast we will all know why. I wish the best for the remaining three after this friday.. and better luck next time for the ousted students because they were all stars in their own unique way .. though i hoped from the start that it could've been a cleaner competition in terms of voting (people who get to vote for free whilst others don't and this is a fact because i have saudi friends who told me this). I am however very optimisic because i remember when ahmad and khalawy were up against each other .. khalawy won by a scratch and ahmad was by far better than khalawy.. and knowing Bashar has a respectable # of fans who like him for his "voice" and his "talents" i think he has a gr8 chance of winning Inshalah. I apologise to khalawy's fans about how i described khalawy. I respect him as a contestant no doubt.. but some people here say things that are just flat out disrespectful and insulting so emotions run high. Lets all not get carried away and start insulting each other .. whatever the outcome!
    TC

    Kaify Kuwaity!
  1. rasha | March 18, 2004 6:09 PM

    بيشو يا بعيد عمري بتمنى انو انتي تكون ستار بشار ما طليء بهاء ;)

    rasha
  1. Kaify Kuwaity! | March 18, 2004 6:22 PM

    K.S.A girl .. "i hate bashar 2 death" hmm... tawni ga3id agool hal kalam mala da3i .. lakin may5alif hatha rayich wintay 7urah feeh ihwa s3oody o min deertich.. bas kalamich laman itgoleen kuwait is rich o what not is irrelevant cuz we still have to pay for the votes and not everything is a conspiracy o " u hate khalawy so stop spreading rumors " and so on .. and ana ma gilt khalawy 3enda floos wela faqeer o ma ihimny hal shay at all .. kilina 3indina 5air o il 7imdila .. ily gilta ina il s3oodiya fat7a il ta9weet for free o hal kalam yay min s3oodiyeen 7ail rab3i and as far as i'm concerned thats all i need to know .. o mithil ma gilt atmanah bashar ifooz inshalah la`ana ihwa o il a7san..o mala da3i for you, me or anyone who uses this forum to use obscenity o nijra7 ba3ath.. Kuwaitiyeen, S3oodiyeen, Libnaniyeen, Tunisiyeen, Ma9riyeen, hehe ta3abt wana agool "yeen o yeen" wallah ma tiswa ina inghali6 3ala ba3ath :)

    Kaify Kuwaity!
  1. meera | March 18, 2004 8:27 PM

    فديييييييييييييييت الخلاوي انا

    اصوت لاحلى واحد الخلاوي

    meera
  1. لولو | March 18, 2004 8:28 PM

    صوتي لافضل واحد

    بشاردو

    لولو


 
« Elissa and the four remaining students | Main | People’s Most Common Fears »